Are God and Jesus the same person?

12AX7

Banned
Joined
Dec 15, 2010
Messages
10,889
Location
Hollywood East
I didn't want to hijack the other thread. So everyone is up to speed thus far:

Nope. God and Jesus are different aspects of one being.

Interesting.

So God (The Father) condemns me, and Jesus (The Son) wants to save me, yet they are one being.

I have both. It isn't necessarily an either or deal.

QFT
Well played, Mal. ;)

Actually, the way it plays out in the Book of Revelation, and various Christian Theology, the Judge is Jesus.
If you are going to make a comment, do a bit more research first, and then remember that even you, as a limited human, can do multiple things.

If one goes along with the Theology, the Omni-present-potent-scient being is going to be even more capable.




Assuming I believe (I do not) Christianity, is the God of the OT and Jesus of the NT the same being?

Also, please explain the God/Son/Holy Ghost thing.
 
Last edited:
I didn't want to hijack the other thread. So everyone is up to speed thus far:

Assuming I believe (I do not) Christianity, is the God of the OT and Jesus of the NT the same being?

Also, please explain the God/Son/Holy Ghost thing.

In confirmation class, we were told that it was a "mystery", and if 'god' wanted us to understand it, it would have made sense...
 
From a historical perspective, the trinity was merely an adaptation christianity made to make the religion more familiar to pagans. But within a christian perspective, I don't believe your question has an answer. If I recall correctly, churches split over the debate about Jesus being/not being a separately addressable entity.
 
From a historical perspective, the trinity was merely an adaptation christianity made to make the religion more familiar to pagans. But within a christian perspective, I don't believe your question has an answer. If I recall correctly, churches split over the debate about Jesus being/not being a separately addressable entity.

I can understand the reasons a church might split over the topic; the two "versions" of God, if one assumes them to be the same, are polar opposite characters from OT to NT.
 
For Jehovah's Witnesses, YHVH (aka God, aka The Father) is a separate entity from Jesus (aka, The Son), and the Holy Spirit (aka Holy Ghost) is merely God's will in action.
 
IAssuming I believe (I do not) Christianity, is the God of the OT and Jesus of the NT the same being?

They're the same being, but not the same person. This is as good an explanation of that apparent contradiction as any.

In confirmation class, we were told that it was a "mystery", and if 'god' wanted us to understand it, it would have made sense...

This is pretty much the standard view. Or excuse, depending on your perspective.

I can understand the reasons a church might split over the topic; the two "versions" of God, if one assumes them to be the same, are polar opposite characters from OT to NT.

Well, the actions and attitudes of the two from one Testament to the next were secondary to the issues and implications raised by Jesus' incarnation as "the Son of God", if indeed they were considered at all.
 
Also, please explain the God/Son/Holy Ghost thing.
I was studying for confirmation into the Episcopal church when I began asking this question. The more the minister tried to give a lame "they are aspects of the same being", the more I thought, "This is codswhallop". That's when I started becoming an atheist.

I mean, is it like the Hulk, or do they have different superpowers or what?
 
I was studying for confirmation into the Episcopal church when I began asking this question. The more the minister tried to give a lame "they are aspects of the same being", the more I thought, "This is codswhallop". That's when I started becoming an atheist.

I mean, is it like the Hulk, or do they have different superpowers or what?

Glad it's not just me then. I've never understood the concept, nor have I ever heard a sensible explanation of it.
 
A long time ago, an older, wider, pinched-faced woman dressed as a penguin, weilding a triangular ruler advised that questions such as this were better left unasked.

Seemed like good advice.
 
OP

Dog Breakfast, who does a lot of formal counterapologetics, offered this recent thread here at JREF, examining the well-foundedness of the Trinity concept:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=266520

In brief compass, there is no necessary contradiction, nor much of an apparent one, but there is a studied looseness in the use of language by promoters of the idea. This may have been a conscious decision originally, with the effect of imparting an air of mystery to the large aromatic brown pile behind the Nicene barn. Alternatively, it solved problems in relatively early Christianity, initially Jesus' authority and later, to allow the "advent of the Holy Spirit" to stand as partial fulfillment of Jesus' broken promise of a prompt personal return.

As to coherence, ordinary human personality, for example, is routinely modeled (and even experienced by people themselves) as a collective of autonomous subpersonalities:

Do I contradict myself? Very well then I contradict meyself. (I am large, I contain multitudes.)

~ Walt Whitman, "Song of Myself"

There's no difficulty at all contructing isomorphisms to the core Nicene doctrine. It follows that the core doctrine isn't contraidctory (with the same confidence that the isomorphisms aren't, which is high since some of them model transparently things that actually exist). There are uncounted variations of the core doctrine, of course, and these can easily contradict each other.
 
Last edited:
By the time you start asking yourself if, or even how, they can be the same person you're deep into the religious woo.

The trinity is just one more aspect of religious nonsense. Why even ask the question?
 
They are the same in one respect. In that they are both equally ludicrous man made myths. Once that is established, who gives a toss for whether they are the same person, notwithstanding the holy spirit, so called because the idea is so full of holes one needs a whisky or two.
 
I can understand the reasons a church might split over the topic; the two "versions" of God, if one assumes them to be the same, are polar opposite characters from OT to NT.

Swift parodied this accurately with his war between the Big Endians and the Little Endians.
 
As I indicated in the other thread.... When I was a young Catholic school lad in the 50s, we were introduced to the Catholic idea of the Trinity.
The Church's position at the time was that The Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit were all each entirely "God", and at the same time separate and distinct individuals.

Even as children we found this a bit difficult, and pressed the priests to explain further.

Invariably, they retreated to the standard Catholic argument... "It's a mystery of faith."

That meant that as a Catholic, you were expected to believe it, even if you didn't understand it.
I have no idea what their position is now... I lost track after they dropped Limbo.
 
They are the same in one respect. In that they are both equally ludicrous man made myths. Once that is established, who gives a toss for whether they are the same person, notwithstanding the holy spirit, so called because the idea is so full of holes one needs a whisky or two.

Agree. I only started this thread because it seemed like Darth Rotor had a good explanation. He has yet to weigh in on this.

Invariably, they retreated to the standard Catholic argument... "It's a mystery of faith."

In other words, they don't understand it either, but can't question it.
 
As I indicated in the other thread.... When I was a young Catholic school lad in the 50s, we were introduced to the Catholic idea of the Trinity.
The Church's position at the time was that The Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit were all each entirely "God", and at the same time separate and distinct individuals.

Even as children we found this a bit difficult, and pressed the priests to explain further.

Invariably, they retreated to the standard Catholic argument... "It's a mystery of faith."

That meant that as a Catholic, you were expected to believe it, even if you didn't understand it.
I have no idea what their position is now... I lost track after they dropped Limbo.

The only mystery is why anyone would believe it.
 
If we pretend the Trinity model is an accurate representation of God's nature, did the Son exist prior to his incarnation, or was God a duality prior to then?

If the former, why did the Son never manifest itself prior to his birth? What was it for? Was it just lingering in the background, waiting for the inevitable downfall of mankind?

If the latter, wouldn't this mean that God had changed?

The only time I've ever seen the subject of the Son's pre-incarnation existence addressed is in Paradise Lost. The answer was as Calvinist as you might expect, leaving no room for the possibility of humans being held responsible for their own actions. Is anyone familiar with any more satisfying answers?
 
If we pretend the Trinity model is an accurate representation of God's nature, did the Son exist prior to his incarnation, or was God a duality prior to then?

If the former, why did the Son never manifest itself prior to his birth? What was it for? Was it just lingering in the background, waiting for the inevitable downfall of mankind?

If the latter, wouldn't this mean that God had changed?

The only time I've ever seen the subject of the Son's pre-incarnation existence addressed is in Paradise Lost. The answer was as Calvinist as you might expect, leaving no room for the possibility of humans being held responsible for their own actions. Is anyone familiar with any more satisfying answers?

IIRC we're not supposed to understand the trinity, it's an aspect of god's nature that he revealed to us (to show his awesomeness) and it's beyond human reason, we just have to accept it on faith.
 
To my understanding, it's all a result of trying to believe that all of the things in the Bible are true, "even the stuff that contradict the other stuff."*

Here is a summary from a fundamentalist website of all the verses of the Bible that, if they are all true, mean that God, Jesus & the Holy Spirit are definitely one God but 3 totally separate beings: http://www.equip.org/articles/the-biblical-basis-of-the-doctrine-of-the-trinity/




*Credit to Ned Flanders of course.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom