Multiverse Theory Gaining Ground?

Fudbucker

Philosopher
Joined
Jul 5, 2012
Messages
8,537
I keep coming across statement from physicists like the following:

Observationally, we have learned more and more that we live in a highly special universe—it seems that the “physical laws” of our universe (summarized in the form of standard models of particle physics and cosmology) takes such a special form that if its structure were varied slightly, then there would be no interesting structure in the universe, let alone intelligent life. It is hard to understand this fact unless there are many universes with varying “physical laws,” and we simply happen to emerge in a universe which allows for intelligent life to develop (which seems to require special conditions). With multiple universes, we can understand the “specialness” of our universe precisely as we understand the “specialness” of our planet Earth (e.g. the ideal distance from the sun), which is only one of the many planets out there.
http://quantumfrontiers.com/2014/02/13/making-predictions-in-the-multiverse/

Question: if there's no evidence that other universes actually exist, can't a theist use this type of reasoning to assert "God did it" (since there's no evidence for God either). In other words, how do you argue to a theist that the "specialness" of our universe is better explained by a vast ensemble of other universes than "God did it", if there's no actual evidence that other universes exist?

In the past people here at JREF would complain that arguments that depend on the "specialness" of the universe (the precise values of the physical constants that allow for a universe like ours) are an example of the "sharpshooter fallacy". But I keep reading physicists who keep saying the only way to explain the uniqueness of our universe is by positing a whole bunch of other universes, like the physicist I just quoted. I think these scientists are sophisticated enough to avoid fallacies like that.

Thoughts? Does anyone want to argue that it's all just chance, there's no "specialness", and we shouldn't look to a multiverse (or God, if you're so inclined) to explain it?
 
Sigh. Nomura again. I notice is blog post has no actual predictions (not surprising after his last attempt).

And FFS he's spouting crap comparing the evidence for a multiverse to that for Evolution, consological inflation and the BBT.
:rolleyes:
 
Some people aren't satisfied with the anthropic principle, which is fine I guess, but I don't see how the multiverse theory is any better.
 
The multi-verse comes in handy for explaining the lack of time-machine interferences in -this- universe.
As our past is fixed (history books don't change overnight), what happens way back when never changes, changing the past in -this- universe by someone in this universe isn't possible.
But someone from another universe could have gone back into our history, and altered events which had yet to occur.
Such an alteration would be in our fixed history.
 
The multi-verse comes in handy for explaining the lack of time-machine interferences in -this- universe.

I always liked Larry Niven's theory for that. If time machines can change the past, then the only stable universe is one in which time machines are not invented, and all those time machines randomly changing the past will eventually, randomly, stumble on that universe, at which point, the past never changes again. ;)
 
Its rather odd this thread came up, because i have been pondering lately, that with one Big Bang...one universe...no matter how you slice it...no matter how one can argue that there are trillions of reactions going on in the universe...it all still led to us..from just one Big Bang. One attempt; us...people...brains, creativity...ability to wonder where we came from, why we are here, IF there is a ``why?``, the fact hot burning gas and hundreds of degrees below zero combined, as our parents, to end up making something like us, in one attempt. Eyes, nose, ears, touch, emotions, sex..............
.
Yes, there were many forkings along the way. Something we could not see, at one point, turned into something alive, a long long time ago. And from there one fork went the way of algae, moss, grasses/crops, weeds, flowers, trees, etc. While another forking took us to living and breathing creatures of all types and living in all sorts of places and conditions, adapting to these places and conditions.
Nonetheless, the one Big Bang led to us. Like a pinnacle of creation.
And amazing alone as that is, the Earth provided us with protections, sustanance, and resources, allowing man, in particular, to create and to have things that go far past just simple survivability. (I`ll spare you my list this time).
.
The universe just did not turn into some say more and more intricate soup mix.
.
Very facinating subject for both believers in a god, and atheists alike. At least for those who have an open mind.
.
So in closing, the deal is...i started wondering if rather than just ONE Big Bang causing all this...if instead say there were multiple Big Bangs producing multiple universes. Then maybe one universe DID only create a fancier soup mix. And another universe, amongst the many Big Bangs, was lucky enough to lead to us.
.
But before you jump all over my thoughts...my disclaimer would be that i`m just thinking...and probably will continue to entertain new thoughts til i die.
I do have to say, that...well, even though we can scoff at the Bible, and its authorship, i have never gotten out of my head this one verse that basically says that man will be held without excuse, for not believing in God, by simply observing everything around us.
I picture myself standing before God, and saying...``But, but, but...these pretty smart guys in this one forum i joined, made it out like there really is no magic involved how we got here, and.......`` As the Lord says, ``Go on. Tell me more...i`m fascinated by this...and their thinking. `` Me again: ``Okay, well, there`s also this Stephen Hawking guy...i`m sure you know about him...anyway, i was just wondering what um...a lot of good people believe in his theories and ah...um...........what`s going to happen to him? Lol
 
I don't understand why people think that there is zero evidence for the multiverse, or that no evidence could be found someday. Indeed we are currently looking at the cosmic microwave background with the Planck satellite to see if there is evidence of a "bubble universe collision" and some evidence has been published in support of that. Hawking published "The Grand Design" and talked about how the math looks good and would enjoy traveling far into the future for when we have the technology to test it. I understand that a certain amount of cosmologists and astrophysicists have poopooed the theory saying it's untestable or whatever but I wouldn't throw in the towel over that kind of "philosophical" argument...
 
And oddly, as im submitting my post...is this ad by Chobani, on the Olympics. Did any of you happen to see it? It mentioned and showed all this spectacular stuff regarding our world.
And to think all this happened by no real design other than chance life started, got a simple brain of sorts, and from that point on...whatever could survive, adapt, mutate to improve its position, did so...and explains everything. Or does it. Does that really explain everything? Does it explain pleasure? Thrill? Challenge? Love? Hate? Random thought? Creativity? The intangibles that go beyond the organic.
 
Could the cosmological constants be different? I didn't know that this had actually be advanced/proven yet. I'm stuck at why we'd think they could be different than what they are.

Until this is addressed, shouldn't we assume other universes have the same values as we do?
 
I can't wait for this idea to catch on and the "The multiverse theory means everything is possible in some possible universe, therefore everything is possible in this universe, therefore Woo" apologetics to start.
 
Sigh. Nomura again. I notice is blog post has no actual predictions (not surprising after his last attempt).

And FFS he's spouting crap comparing the evidence for a multiverse to that for Evolution, consological inflation and the BBT.
:rolleyes:

Yes, but he is at Berkeley, which is a top tier university, and he does have published peer reviewed papers, and you're Catsmate, so you need to do better than that.
 
Thanks for raising this important question of whether parallel universes are science or mere speculation! I often hear people assert that it's obviously the latter if parallel universes are unobservable. In my opinion, the question is more subtle.
Most multiverse arguments involve what logicians know as “modus ponens”: that if X implies Y and X is true, then Y must also be true. Specifically, ones argue that if some scientific theory X has enough experimental support for us to take it seriously, then we must take seriously also all its predictions Y, even if these predictions are themselves untestable (involving parallel universes, for example). In other words, ones argues that parallel universes are not a scientific theory, but prediction of certain scientific theories, which are testable if they make additional predictions that we *can* observe. In my book, for example, I argue that there are four implications:

1) Cosmological inflation generically implies Level I multiverse
2) Inflation + string landscape generically implies Level II multiverse
3) Unitary quantum mechanics implies Level III multiverse
4) The Mathematical Universe Hypothesis implies Level IV multiverse

So to argue that some particular type of parallel universes is unscientific, one needs to either make the case that the corresponding implication is incorrect, or that one of the theories (inflation, say) makes no testable predictions and is therefore unscientific.
 
Thanks for raising this important question of whether parallel universes are science or mere speculation! I often hear people assert that it's obviously the latter if parallel universes are unobservable. In my opinion, the question is more subtle.
Most multiverse arguments involve what logicians know as “modus ponens”: that if X implies Y and X is true, then Y must also be true. Specifically, ones argue that if some scientific theory X has enough experimental support for us to take it seriously, then we must take seriously also all its predictions Y, even if these predictions are themselves untestable (involving parallel universes, for example). In other words, ones argues that parallel universes are not a scientific theory, but prediction of certain scientific theories, which are testable if they make additional predictions that we *can* observe. In my book, for example, I argue that there are four implications:

1) Cosmological inflation generically implies Level I multiverse
2) Inflation + string landscape generically implies Level II multiverse
3) Unitary quantum mechanics implies Level III multiverse
4) The Mathematical Universe Hypothesis implies Level IV multiverse

So to argue that some particular type of parallel universes is unscientific, one needs to either make the case that the corresponding implication is incorrect, or that one of the theories (inflation, say) makes no testable predictions and is therefore unscientific.

Do we actually have THE Max Tegmark posting here???
 
Thanks for raising this important question of whether parallel universes are science or mere speculation! I often hear people assert that it's obviously the latter if parallel universes are unobservable. In my opinion, the question is more subtle.
Most multiverse arguments involve what logicians know as “modus ponens”: that if X implies Y and X is true, then Y must also be true. Specifically, ones argue that if some scientific theory X has enough experimental support for us to take it seriously, then we must take seriously also all its predictions Y, even if these predictions are themselves untestable (involving parallel universes, for example). In other words, ones argues that parallel universes are not a scientific theory, but prediction of certain scientific theories, which are testable if they make additional predictions that we *can* observe. In my book, for example, I argue that there are four implications:

1) Cosmological inflation generically implies Level I multiverse
2) Inflation + string landscape generically implies Level II multiverse
3) Unitary quantum mechanics implies Level III multiverse
4) The Mathematical Universe Hypothesis implies Level IV multiverse

So to argue that some particular type of parallel universes is unscientific, one needs to either make the case that the corresponding implication is incorrect, or that one of the theories (inflation, say) makes no testable predictions and is therefore unscientific.

One can't help but notice all the "implies". Is there any direct evidence yet for other universes? Will there ever be?
 
Thanks for raising this important question of whether parallel universes are science or mere speculation! I often hear people assert that it's obviously the latter if parallel universes are unobservable. In my opinion, the question is more subtle.
Most multiverse arguments involve what logicians know as “modus ponens”: that if X implies Y and X is true, then Y must also be true. Specifically, ones argue that if some scientific theory X has enough experimental support for us to take it seriously, then we must take seriously also all its predictions Y, even if these predictions are themselves untestable (involving parallel universes, for example). In other words, ones argues that parallel universes are not a scientific theory, but prediction of certain scientific theories, which are testable if they make additional predictions that we *can* observe. In my book, for example, I argue that there are four implications:

1) Cosmological inflation generically implies Level I multiverse
2) Inflation + string landscape generically implies Level II multiverse
3) Unitary quantum mechanics implies Level III multiverse
4) The Mathematical Universe Hypothesis implies Level IV multiverse

So to argue that some particular type of parallel universes is unscientific, one needs to either make the case that the corresponding implication is incorrect, or that one of the theories (inflation, say) makes no testable predictions and is therefore unscientific.

Is there any reason to believe that these universes, should they exist, would have different cosmological constants?
 
Yes, but he is at Berkeley, which is a top tier university,
Appeal to authority.

and he does have published peer reviewed papers,
Irrelevant. This isn't one of them.

Incidentally, which is more credible: An idea from someone who doesn't know about peer reviewed journals or how to publish in them, so he publishes outside them? Or an idea from someone who not only knows about peer reviewed journals but has actually published in them in the past, but chooses to publish this idea outside of a journal anyway?

If you're going to judge this idea by his history of peer reviewed publication, then I'd say his choice of publication in this case shows that Nomura himself knows this idea has serious flaws and would not pass peer review in its current form.

and you're Catsmate,
Ad hominem.

so you need to do better than that.
Your rebuttal consists of unfortunate implications, bookended by outright logical fallacies. So you need to do better than that.
 
Appeal to authority.


Irrelevant. This isn't one of them.

Incidentally, which is more credible: An idea from someone who doesn't know about peer reviewed journals or how to publish in them, so he publishes outside them? Or an idea from someone who not only knows about peer reviewed journals but has actually published in them in the past, but chooses to publish this idea outside of a journal anyway?

If you're going to judge this idea by his history of peer reviewed publication, then I'd say his choice of publication in this case shows that Nomura himself knows this idea has serious flaws and would not pass peer review in its current form.


Ad hominem.


Your rebuttal consists of unfortunate implications, bookended by outright logical fallacies. So you need to do better than that.

It's perfectly OK to appeal to authorities. A doctor's advice is better than a mechanic's when you're sick, no? Cosmology is a highly specialized field, so yes, statements from physicists are going to count for more.

Anyway, Catsmate had made no argument at all. Just called what he said "crap". So right off the bat, I'm not giving that post a whole lot of credibility.
 
Appeal to authority.


Irrelevant. This isn't one of them.

Incidentally, which is more credible: An idea from someone who doesn't know about peer reviewed journals or how to publish in them, so he publishes outside them? Or an idea from someone who not only knows about peer reviewed journals but has actually published in them in the past, but chooses to publish this idea outside of a journal anyway?

If you're going to judge this idea by his history of peer reviewed publication, then I'd say his choice of publication in this case shows that Nomura himself knows this idea has serious flaws and would not pass peer review in its current form.


Ad hominem.

Also, that's not an ad hominem. That's an implicit argument of the following:

1. I have two statements that contradict each other.
2. One is from a physicist at a top university
3. The other is from Catsmate, who is most likely not a physicist
4. When one's knowledge is minimal in a certain field (say, cosmology), one must appeal to experts who are knowledgeable in that field.
5. There's a high probability Catsmate is less knowledgeable than the author of the article.
6. There's a high probability Catsmate is wrong.

Anyway, that was my thinking.
 
It's perfectly OK to appeal to authorities. A doctor's advice is better than a mechanic's when you're sick, no? Cosmology is a highly specialized field, so yes, statements from physicists are going to count for more.

Your appeal to authority was to point out that Nomura is at Berkeley.

Are you now claiming that the University of California, Berkeley, is equivalent to a highly specialized field, and equivalent to a statement from physicists?

Does it work for other disciplines besides physics? "I'm at Berkeley, so my advocacy of homoepathic remedies outside of peer-reviewed medical journals is probably credible. Because Berkelely. You want a statement from medical doctors? Here's a statement from medical doctors: Berkeley. What more do you need?"
 
Last edited:
Your appeal to authority was to point out that Nomura is at Berkeley.

Are you now claiming that the University of California, Berkeley, is equivalent to a highly specialized field, and equivalent to a statement from physicists?

I'm claiming Berkeley, which is one of the top 20 schools in the world, hires people who are standouts in their field. As such, their opinions carry more weight. A degree from Standford is more valued than a degree from Cal State Chico, wouldn't you agree? Of course you would.

The author of the article may indeed be talking "crap", but as a respected physicist, he's going to get the benefit of the doubt, and Catsmate has to do more than just verbally attack him to change my mind (or any non-idiot's mind).

This is a stupid derail. Do you have something to say about Tegmark's post?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom