Firstly I just want to clarify I am a skeptic through and through. In fact it's why I'm starting this thread as I need some help debunking the Ovilus box.
I'm well aware of the well worn arguments against this thing (The 'for entertainment purposes only' disclaimers, the chance of coincidence etc).
I have however read comments on various articles about this machine where people have claimed to have had multiple, direct and correct responses to questions over and over (correctly guessing the items in someone's bag, correctly stating someone's surname when asked twice in a row, correctly stating two different people's age first time).
I'm not a believer in this stuff, and I'll be honest, this kind of stuff scares me as I tend to cling to a rational and material worldview, and I get a little anxious when stuff like this seems to challenge that. Is anyone aware of how the Ovilus works in depth? Is there any logical explanation as to how, outside of coincidence (Which surely can't be the case in the examples above) the ovilus could do this?
Firstly I just want to clarify I am a skeptic through and through. In fact it's why I'm starting this thread as I need some help debunking the Ovilus box.
I'm well aware of the well worn arguments against this thing (The 'for entertainment purposes only' disclaimers, the chance of coincidence etc).
I have however read comments on various articles about this machine where people have claimed to have had multiple, direct and correct responses to questions over and over (correctly guessing the items in someone's bag, correctly stating someone's surname when asked twice in a row, correctly stating two different people's age first time).
I'm not a believer in this stuff, and I'll be honest, this kind of stuff scares me as I tend to cling to a rational and material worldview, and I get a little anxious when stuff like this seems to challenge that. Is anyone aware of how the Ovilus works in depth? Is there any logical explanation as to how, outside of coincidence (Which surely can't be the case in the examples above) the ovilus could do this?
Comments and claims don't mean anything. Evidence is required. No one is providing any so all the comments and claims can be dismissed out of hand until someone provides concrete evidence.
This gadget comes in several models, and some models have several modes. Maybe a certain model in a certain mode answering triple-blind questions in complete sentences in a repeatable scenario would be pretty impressive. I'm guessing none of your anecdotes have done that?
Besides coincidence (and just statistically probable right answers among a mountain of wrong ones, and no one reporting the wrong ones), some results are highly subjective and interpreted by the operator. For example, some ITC gadgets use white noise or radio static. Bursts of white noise sound like 'SsssSSSsS'. A lot of people use these gadgets to ask yes/no questions. And so hear a 'YesSSSSssSSs' just about whenever they want to.
One of my favorite examples is when someone claimed their gadget was answering questions no one but they knew. Turned out, they were asking the box 'Am I wearing a blue shirt' and they were hearing 'YesSSSSSS'. Well, they WERE wearing a blue shirt. Verified!
Some of it is. But this gadget actually can produce whole real words from a pre-loaded database of a couple thousands words. At that point it may actually say "woman". The problematic subjectivity then comes in when interpreting what that answer meant to the question.
Thanks for the replies guys. Does anyone have any links or references to any peer reviewed studies of this stuff if any exist (although according to previous posters they probably don't). Also are there any good peer reviews on the paranormal and 'ghosts' in general anyone can recommend?
Well, there's an iPhone app version available, called the iOvilus. I'm slightly - very slightly - tempted to spend the two bucks to see how this stupid thing works, but thankfully I don't really need to. One of the screenshots gives an example of its output:
The Spirit World said:
I'm
finally
walk
side
Dave
arrived
smell
back
coffee
major
exactly
center
hundred
across
It sounds like an electronic Tarot. I wouldn't surprise me if the 'explanation' for it being a random word generator was that the spirits will guide the interpretation - i.e. only non-skeptics can understand their meaning. Why the spirits are unable to express themselves coherently is a paranormal mystery.
For my money, ouija boards are far more interesting and educational.
Some of it is. But this gadget actually can produce whole real words from a pre-loaded database of a couple thousands words. At that point it may actually say "woman". The problematic subjectivity then comes in when interpreting what that answer meant to the question.
Well, there's an iPhone app version available, called the iOvilus. I'm slightly - very slightly - tempted to spend the two bucks to see how this stupid thing works, but thankfully I don't really need to. One of the screenshots gives an example of its output:
Very convincing. All I can say to that is, "Dave's not here, man."
I would say "Hey thing, you misspelled "black" but yeah I'll have a cup of black coffee - two packets of sugar, please.." If such suddenly appears in front of me, I might rethink things, but I do not expect to need to.
I have however read comments on various articles about this machine where people have claimed to have had multiple, direct and correct responses to questions over and over (correctly guessing the items in someone's bag, correctly stating someone's surname when asked twice in a row, correctly stating two different people's age first time).
The Ovilus is an electronic device that selects a random word from a dictionary of 512 to 2048 words (depending on the model, with some models allowing users to add their own words). When a word is selected, the word appears on the screen and is “spoken” with an electronic voice. A new word appears at irregular intervals, with a new word coming up on average every couple minutes. The claim is that the device can be used by the dead to communication with the living by controlling the device by some means to make certain words from the dictionary appear.
Let’s look at the case where the Ovilus correctly guessed items in someone’s bag. The video is here:
The claim is that Ovilus identified items in the man’s equipment bag. Here are the words given by the Ovilus during the session:
Can you guess the four items identified in the bag?
The claim is those words identified historical trading cards depicting George Washington, Benjamin Franklin, and Paul Revere and an mp3 player in a plastic case, all of which were in his equipment bag. He claims the mp3 player was playing colonial fife and drum music being broadcast through an ES (Energy Speaker) speaker.
Of course the Ovilus didn’t precisely identify those items. How does he match them up? Let’s look at the trading cards first.
George Washington – Cut down a cherry tree and could not tell a “lie”
Benjamin Franklin – Discovered electricity during a thunderstorm flying a key attached to a “kite”
Paul Revere – Gave instructions to place lanterns in a steeple when the British were coming; one if by land, two if by “sea” (which is like the “ocean”)
OK. That’s not an exact match, but with the limited vocabulary available in the Ovilus, that seems like a pretty good match. The man in the video claims the odds it could get three words that matched those three cards in some way are “astronomical”. Are they? We can’t calculate the exact odds, but we can get a rough idea. To do so, we must consider a number of things.
The model used was the Ovilus X, which has 2048 words. The word list is available from the manufacturer here: http://digitaldowsing.com/ovilus-word-list/. I did a quick run through the list and came up with almost 10% of the words matching “Paul Revere” in some way more or less as well as “ocean” does. So each random word would have about a 10% chance of matching one of the cards. Even if we only grant 5% of the words as a possible match, that is still hardly “astronomical”. But, we might think, words like “lie” and “kite” are certainly better matches, so maybe it really is unlikely to have happened by chance.
Next, we have to consider all of the words available. It wasn’t three words that matched three cards. It was 12 words that all had a possibility (of 5-10%) of matching a card. Six of the words (half of them) were simply dismissed as irrelevant to the claim. This practice of remembering the hits and forgetting the misses is called “selection bias”. When we consider all of the words given, the odds are moving far away from “astronomical”.
Also, we don’t know how many times this person has tried this experiment. In the beginning, he claims he “tried using the cards” (whatever that means) the previous year without any success. Whatever the odds are of getting a match to the cards, because the experiment has been done twice, we can double those odds. The odds are starting to look move “even” than “astronomical”.
And he may have conducted many other similar experiments that were not at the same site with no “positive” results and not posted a video for those. Of course, many, many people have probably done experiments with the Ovilus and came up with nothing and never posted a video or otherwise reported it. The fact that typically only interesting or positive results get published is called “publication bias” or “the file drawer effect”. If we consider all of the experiments with the Ovilus that have ever been done, the odds that there will occasionally be a coincidence is not “astronomical” or even “even” but downright “probable”. It would be more surprising of such instances didn’t happen.
But, we may think, perhaps the spirits don’t often communicate via the Ovilus and this happened to be one of those rare “real” cases. Putting aside the total odds (which we shouldn’t do) we still are left with what may appear to be three amazing “hits”. But are they really “hits”?
We have to consider the context of the questions. The experimenter did not ask, “What is in my equipment bag?” He just asks for…anything. The only question he specifically asks related to the claim is for something confirming “Paul Revere” after “kite” which resulted in “however” (which is certainly not a hit). This means that the word could have been matched to anything related to an items in any of his bags, the location, the date of he experiment, etc. He had a packet of fake colonial currency in his bag. Given a different set of random words, those words may have “amazingly” matched those items,
or anything related to the any items he had in any bags
or in his pockets
or in the surrounding area
or the Monmouth Battlefield where the experiment took place
or the George Washington waypoint marker the Ovilus was sitting on
or June 28th (the date of the Battle of Monmouth and date of the experiment)
or anything related to the Battle of Monmouth
or any of the equipment itself
or the man doing the experiment
or the jug of water used as the “trigger object”
or Old Tennet Church where the chimes rang during the session
or…well, you can see where this is going.
The claim is that a spirit is using the Ovilus to select words from the dictionary to communicate something to the experimenter. If I think of words associated with “George Washington” it will be quite a while before I get to “lie”. There are certainly better words to communicate that I am talking about George Washington, even within the limited dictionary of the Ovilus.
The claim is that the spirit wanted to communicate an indication of “Paul Revere” and chose the word “ocean” in reference to “two if by sea”. But if that was the intent, wouldn’t the spirit just use the word “sea” which is in the Ovilus X dictionary? Or if the spirit happened to not find that “sea” was available, perhaps “Paul” which is also in the dictionary. If this were, in fact, a communication from a spirit about the three trading cards, I would be a bit more impressed if it had given the following words (all of which are in the Ovilus X dictionary):
George
Washington
Paul
Reverend
Bend
Frank
Lynn
If not those, there are many other words in Ovilus that the spirit could have chosen that are far more connected to those three men than “ocean, lie, kite”. What is presented as evidence of a paranormal communication fails both ways. If it was a paranormal communication about he cards, we would expect that the words used in the communication would have been more closely related to the cards given the available word choices. And, the words actually presented are not only not unlikely, but even likely to have had some connection to the cards, or something else pattern-matched as relevant, particularly over the course of multiple experiments. Matching data to any possible, and unpredicted, other data is called “retrofitting” or “hindsight bias”.
We also have to consider the words chosen to be in the Ovilus dictionary. The words selected are clearly meant to be words that could be perceived as voices from beyond, including words that:
appear to be answers to questions
have multiple meanings
portend doom and gloom
are related to the paranormal
express difficulty in communication
are very common words, items, or names
are vague, including single letters and numbers
and a few that are odd or uncommon that can be often dismissed, but occasionally can seem uncanny
The specific word list is meant to give the appearance of a voice from beyond and give some responses that are creepy and unnerving.
And of course in the video, the words “rhythm, hidden, glass” are also stretched to their possible associations to match anything else within the vicinity.
The video simply shows random words, selected from a list of words specifically selected to appear as possibly relevant to questions someone might ask of the deceased, and then retrofitted to anything potentially related by stretching interpretations, despite the many better words available that could have matched those relations. It is just random word matching, and not even a very good coincidental matching at that.
The video concludes with a recording of an “EVP” that was not captured by the video recorder. Frankly, I can’t hear the words it claims are said even when I know what I am supposed to be listening for. Hearing random noises as something significant such as a word or phrase is called “auditory pareidolia”. This is not a good example, by any means. And the video shows that what is presented as the EVP in the recording occurs at the point in the video where he acknowledges that there are bells ringing in the Old Tennet Church, not heard on the video. He gave away the secret to the mysterious EVP right in the same video.
If I am hearing anything that sounds suspicious in the video, it is the obviously spurious claims being made up by the video creator.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.