BBC "Trust Me I'm A Doctor" = "Don't I'm a TV Doctor"

stewgreenUK

Student
Joined
Apr 22, 2013
Messages
45
BBC series "Trust Me I'm A Doctor" might as well be called "Don't Trust Me I'm a TV Doctor"
- Is anyone watching this second Dr Michael Moseley series & interested to enter a discussion about it ?

- For although they seem to have admirable motives in debunking the approach of places like the Daily Mail, they seem to then make the same typical mistakes as they try to communicate in the same way.
e.g. ep 1 had small sample sizes, uncontrolled, non blinded tests on varoious topics
but crucially started by apparently validating acupucture as an effectve treatment
with "let's put our presenter, in an fMRI ..hey look how the brain lights up, see it's working" Now although they then mentioned the placebo effect , every acupuncture clinic was jumping on Twitter to say "see proven by science"
There were only about 3 or 4 of us on Twitter saying "oh no"
- The rest of the prog did have some good stuff..
but the problem with that is that it then gives the flawed stuff extra credibility.

ep 2 was talking often about "super foods" ..which I thought was a scientific "no no", as you can't give the public the wrong impression that there are magic solutions to things and that they can carry on as normal otherwise.
Link to TV show : http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b04m0bt4
 
When I checked the internet ..there are no other skeptic discussions on the prog
However I did find that they had asked David Colquhoun to appear, but then changed their minds
"The bad thing was that I was supposed to be recording a piece on acupuncture for Trust Me I’m a Doctor. After talking about it for an hour they cancelled at short notice. The BBC can be rather free with other peoples’ time."
15th April 2014 http://www.dcscience.net/?page_id=6105

Ben Goldacre sometimes picks this stuff up, but is busy off plugging his book
 
Last edited:
spelling Michael Mosley
- also I'll open up a general thread on the one topic the prog covered "resistance starch" cos it is well established but worth a discussion.
 
Unless you want to discuss this as media, you might want to ask the mods to move this thread to Science/Medicine. You'll probably get a better audience for it. (Just hit the report button on the OP and explain what your request.)

It's an interesting topic and I'd like to see further discussion but I'm not able to get the show over here.
 
I'm not watching it on the grounds that a lot of Michael Mosley's output seems to be the same, sweeping conclusions drawn from small badly run trials and Mrs Don doesn't like it when I shout at the TV.

I remember the show (series ?) which led to his unstinting support for intermittent fasting. At one point he was interviewing some guy who was on a severely restricted caloric intake and insisted that this kept him young for his chronological age. His evidence for this is that, at 40, he could balance on one leg for maybe 30 seconds whereas Dr Mosley only managed a few seconds. Well I'm pushing 50 and thanks to a lot of physio on my knees I can stand on one leg for as long as it pleases me and I'm ancient for my age.
 
yes I always planned to put the resistance starch post in Science

- My main post is about media, and I had already noticed theat the Media section is unfortunately in the private section..I will try to get the post moved
 
Yes, one of the sweeping generalisations in ep2 was "Wow I never realised that instant coffee has less caffeine than tea!"
..yep probably cos every other website says that coffee has more (although the ranges overlap, so a strong instant coffee can be a weaker than a weak tea)
I suspect they are getting mixed up with the dry strength cos tea is much lighter so has more caffeine per gramme.

- My Discussion on Resistant Starch is here http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=10293415#post10293415
 
Last edited:
I'm not watching it on the grounds that a lot of Michael Mosley's output seems to be the same, sweeping conclusions drawn from small badly run trials and Mrs Don doesn't like it when I shout at the TV.

I remember the show (series ?) which led to his unstinting support for intermittent fasting. At one point he was interviewing some guy who was on a severely restricted caloric intake and insisted that this kept him young for his chronological age. His evidence for this is that, at 40, he could balance on one leg for maybe 30 seconds whereas Dr Mosley only managed a few seconds. Well I'm pushing 50 and thanks to a lot of physio on my knees I can stand on one leg for as long as it pleases me and I'm ancient for my age.

You should have watched his program with Alice Roberts about gender differences in brain function.

All of us were shouting at the TV. Alice Roberts was less annoying, IIRC. But still too many examples of Betteridge's law.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom