Halton Arp Replacing Big Bang Creationism

jeffreyw

Critical Thinker
Joined
Dec 24, 2014
Messages
343
Location
Cocoa Beach, FL
In this video Halton Arp explains that quasars are ejected from active galactic nuclei or AGNs.

This means that quasars are not at their proposed redshift distance, and also means that redshift of galaxies can be re-interpreted without big bang creationism.

The kinks need to be worked out, but the essence of this understanding is that Big Bang Creationism and all the theory that is based on it is obsolete.

R.I.P. Dr. Arp

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9U-HJGhvN0w
 
Halton Arp was a great scientist who lost it. He refused to preform adequate statistical analysis despite the availability of hundreds of thousands of data sets.

Great man became greatly deluded and totally wrong about QSOs, he engaged in the Texas Sharpshooter and ignored all the data from all the surveys.
 
Sorry, jeff, this idea has long since been discredited. This was nothing more than a few cherry-picked examples of the line of sight to a few quasars being close to the line of sight to more nearby galaxies. Given the number of galaxies and quasars out there, such coincidences are inevitable, but this isn't the case for all quasars, or even an unexpectedly large fraction of them.

It's always exciting to think that you've stumbled upon some discovery that will overturn everything people thought before, but that's rarely the case. Most of the time, it's just a mistake, and that's all this is.
 
"the kinks need to be worked out"? That's a strange way to describe a theory that was pretty weak to begin with, and whose ability to describe data was has been getting worse and worse for 50 years. The kinks were worked out. We now understand why Arp saw galaxies at "discordant redshifts" (in fact we've now seen thousands more of them) and the answer is not "Arp was right" or anything close to it. No kinks in that.
 
"the kinks need to be worked out"? That's a strange way to describe a theory that was pretty weak to begin with, and whose ability to describe data was has been getting worse and worse for 50 years. The kinks were worked out. We now understand why Arp saw galaxies at "discordant redshifts" (in fact we've now seen thousands more of them) and the answer is not "Arp was right" or anything close to it. No kinks in that.

From seeing Jeffrey's posts in his other thread here, I'm guessing "the kinks need to be worked out" means something like "more stuff will need to be made up to support what's been made up to support the original misunderstanding."
 
Actually the history is interesting, Arp catalohued a bunch of disturbed galaxies about the time that QSOs were being figured out. However Arp got it in his head to fabricate a post hoc rationalization for QSOs being ejected from galactic collisions.

And he became obsessed with it. Quite to the wrong side of teh data.
 
In this video Halton Arp explains that quasars are ejected from active galactic nuclei or AGNs
Wrong, jeffreyw: argument by video is not science :jaw-dropp!
What Halton Arp did was look at images of QSO's that were near other galaxies and assert that the closeness meant that they were physically associated despite large differences in red shift. He then went on looking for grouped QSO's in images, selecting the brightest AGN in the image and doing invalid statistics. The Arp objects, QSOs, Statistics thread pointed this out. Halton Arp used invalid "a posteriori" statistics in that he started with the hypothesis that quasars are emitted from Seyfert galaxies and then looked for examples that match his hypothesis :eek:.
For example, see my post on 23rd January 2009
To more clearly see the problem with Arp's methodology consider the following adaption of it:
Look for images of unusual concentrations of quasars relatively near an arbitary empty point such as the center of the concentration (making sure that there is no galaxy that point).
If there are such images then run Arp's probability calculation. You will get the same magntiude of probability since the calculation does not depend on the nature of the central object.
​
Would Arp then conculde that quasars are emitted from empty space?

The "kink" is that Halton Arp was shown to be wrong over the last couple of decades ago with proper statistical analysis of hundreds of thousands of galaxies rather than the tens in Arp's analysis
Critical Examinations of QSO Redshift Periodicities and Associations with Galaxies in Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data (2005)
The authors follow this paper with Evidence against non-cosmological redshifts of QSOs in SDSS data (2008)
Absence of a Periodic Component in Quasar z-Distribution (2010)
 
Last edited:
Halton Arp was a great scientist who lost it. He refused to preform adequate statistical analysis despite the availability of hundreds of thousands of data sets.

Great man became greatly deluded and totally wrong about QSOs, he engaged in the Texas Sharpshooter and ignored all the data from all the surveys.

Well to be fair to Arp when he first presented the theory the data sets did not exist and his idea was as good as any on the origins of quasars. Sadly later as better data came on stream he as you suggested "Lost it" and would not back down

Fortunately he is less remembered for that and more so for his seminal catalog of unusual galaxies, the subjects of which are know as collectively as the "Arp galaxies"
 
In this video Halton Arp explains that quasars are ejected from active galactic nuclei or AGNs.

This means that quasars are not at their proposed redshift distance, and also means that redshift of galaxies can be re-interpreted without big bang creationism.

The kinks need to be worked out, but the essence of this understanding is that Big Bang Creationism and all the theory that is based on it is obsolete.

R.I.P. Dr. Arp

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9U-HJGhvN0w

I used to find Arp's theory plausible. However, I have have one rational objection to it.

If Arp's theory were correct, about half the quasars are coming toward us. Then, they would be recognized as blue shifted objects. There would be highly blue shifted objects found very close in angle to the galaxies. No such objects have been reported.

Some would be detectable as x-ray sources, some as ultraviolet sources,and some blue sources depending on the angle of the objects emission velocity. There should be a whole continuum of blue shifted objects,corresponding to the wide range of red shifted objects. No such continuum of blue shifted objects has been reported.

The opinion of Creationists doesn't matter to me. Although Creationists use Arp's model, his model does not really support YEC. So I prefer to criticize his model rationally. Right now, the major rational objection I can see against his model is that there are no blue shifted objects. Or maybe there are and he took those into account. I haven't found any mention of them.

Does anyone know if Arp found the corresponding blue shifted objects?
 
The kinks need to be worked out, but the essence of this understanding is that Big Bang Creationism and all the theory that is based on it is obsolete.
I used to find Arp's theory plausible. However, I have have one rational objection to it.

If Arp's theory were correct, about half the quasars are coming toward us. Then, they would be recognized as blue shifted objects. There would be highly blue shifted objects found very close in angle to the galaxies. No such objects have been reported.

Some would be detectable as x-ray sources, some as ultraviolet sources,and some blue sources depending on the angle of the objects emission velocity. There should be a whole continuum of blue shifted objects,corresponding to the wide range of red shifted objects. No such continuum of blue shifted objects has been reported.

The opinion of Creationists doesn't matter to me. Although Creationists use Arp's model, his model does not really support YEC. So I prefer to criticize his model rationally. Right now, the major rational objection I can see against his model is that there are no blue shifted objects. Or maybe there are and he took those into account. I haven't found any mention of them.

Does anyone know if Arp found the corresponding blue shifted objects?
I think you're misunderstanding Jeffrey's reference to "Big Bang Creationism." There's no separation there; to Jeffrey, proponents of the BB theory are Creationists. I think it's supposed to be scathing; it really just comes across as a childish strawman, since the methodologies are complete opposites.
 
I used to find Arp's theory plausible. However, I have have one rational objection to it.

If Arp's theory were correct, about half the quasars are coming toward us. Then, they would be recognized as blue shifted objects. There would be highly blue shifted objects found very close in angle to the galaxies. No such objects have been reported.

Some would be detectable as x-ray sources, some as ultraviolet sources,and some blue sources depending on the angle of the objects emission velocity. There should be a whole continuum of blue shifted objects,corresponding to the wide range of red shifted objects. No such continuum of blue shifted objects has been reported.

The opinion of Creationists doesn't matter to me. Although Creationists use Arp's model, his model does not really support YEC. So I prefer to criticize his model rationally. Right now, the major rational objection I can see against his model is that there are no blue shifted objects. Or maybe there are and he took those into account. I haven't found any mention of them.

Does anyone know if Arp found the corresponding blue shifted objects?

Arp tried many ways to say that QSOs had redshifts for reasons other than recessional velocity.

:)
 
I think you're misunderstanding Jeffrey's reference to "Big Bang Creationism." There's no separation there; to Jeffrey, proponents of the BB theory are Creationists. I think it's supposed to be scathing; it really just comes across as a childish strawman, since the methodologies are complete opposites.

Sillygism:

1) I don't care what Creationists think.
2) Jeffrey is a Creationist.
3) Therefore, I don't care what Jeffrey thinks.

I really object to the title of this thread. he title, Big Bang Creationism,
strongly implies that the Big Bang model is a subset of Creationist theory.
Obviously, it is not.

I would love to argue the point. However, I see that you agree with me.
 
Sillygism:

1) I don't care what Creationists think.
2) Jeffrey is a Creationist.
3) Therefore, I don't care what Jeffrey thinks.

I really object to the title of this thread. he title, Big Bang Creationism,
strongly implies that the Big Bang model is a subset of Creationist theory.
Obviously, it is not.

I would love to argue the point. However, I see that you agree with me.

100%. Jeffrey may not be a Creationist in the technical sense, but he is by his methodology.
 
Arp tried many ways to say that QSOs had redshifts for reasons other than recessional velocity.

:)

It doesn't matter. The Hubble constant is not used to calculate the distance to the nearest galaxies. So Arp's theory would explode YEC anyway. Some of the nearest galaxies could be expected to emit 'quasars'. So if Arp is correct, blue shifted objects should be seen emitted from the nearest galaxies

Consider the following example. The Hubble constant has not been used to determine the distance to the Magellanic clouds and Andromeda. Andromeda does show a blue shift, even though it is not a quasar. The distance to these galaxies was determined by both spectroscopic parallax (i.e., the HR diagram) and Cepheid variables. Andromeda is 2.2 MLY away and the nearest Magellanic cloud is a few tens of KLY away. Thus, these galaxies alone show that the stars are more than 6 KY old. Arp has not challenged the distance determination to these galaxies, for instance.

The Hubble constant was used to calculate the distance to the quasars and farthest galaxies. Arp assumes that all methods not related to the Hubble constant are correct. However, Hubble had calculate distance to galaxies up to 60 MLY away in order to 'calibrate' the Hubble constant. The distance to the furthest of these galaxies were determined by galaxy brightness. The nearest were determined by cepheid variables and spectroscopic parallax. So the 'secular' distance to these 'nearby galaxies' is up to 60 MLY. So the universe is at least 60 MLY old regardless of Hubble constant.

The Big Bang model was developed from Hubble's extrapolation of the red shift. Hubble assumed that the red shift was caused by velocity away from the earth. Hubble did not and could not use general relativity theory to extrapolate the data. Hubble did not use any mechanical theory at all. However, Hubble did hypothesize that the universe was at least old as the vast distances signify. So Hubble's interpretation totally contradicts YEC.

The title of this thread seems to imply that Old Earth Creationism is wrong while Young Earth Creationism is correct. However, that is not the case at all.

I do take Arp seriously as a scientist. I am sure that he did not use Geocentric Creationism in his model. Now that this mythology is out of the way:


Andromeda does have a slight blue shift. However, the whole galaxy shows a blue shift, not some object shooting out of it. Andromeda does not have a whole continuum of 'stars' shooting out in all directions, in any case. Recent pictures of the Hubble Space Telescope show Andromeda in breath taking detail. While not every star in Andromeda could be seen, one would expect that a few blue shifted 'quasars' to show up in the picture. I am curious about how Arp explained the absence of blue shifted objects from near by galaxies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom