Guns and the no-fly list.

Ranb

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jul 25, 2003
Messages
11,492
Location
WA USA
So how exactly does a person end up on the no-fly list? If there are people wanting a new law which would deny a gun purchase to someone on the no-fly list, then a person should be indictable for some felony crime, right? But I suppose there needs to be some way of keeping people like Ted Kennedy and David Cole from walking out of a gun store with a legally purchased firearm.

http://www.cnn.com/2015/12/05/politics/barack-obama-guns-congress/index.html
President Barack Obama said Saturday that it is "insane" that people who are not allowed to fly on planes are allowed to buy guns.

"Right now, people on the No-Fly list can walk into a store and buy a gun. That is insane. If you're too dangerous to board a plane, you're too dangerous, by definition, to buy a gun," he said in his weekly address. "And so I'm calling on Congress to close this loophole, now. We may not be able to prevent every tragedy, but -- at a bare minimum -- we shouldn't be making it so easy for potential terrorists or criminals to get their hands on a gun that they could use against Americans."
I think the word loophole is going to be over-used to the point where it will become meaningless.

Wikipedia does not really say how a person ends up on the USA's no-fly list other than to say it is maintained by the Terrorist Screening Center. I don't suppose that if I end up on the list I'll be informed and allowed to contest it prior to it limiting my ability to travel.

The Huffington Post has an article on the list; http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/07/25/terrorist-watch-list_n_5617599.html but not all the links in the article work for me.
Earlier this week, The Intercept published a 166-page document outlining the government's guidelines for placing people on an expansive network of terror watch lists, including the no-fly list. In their report, Jeremy Scahill and Ryan Devereaux highlighted the extremely vague and loosely defined criteria developed by 19 federal agencies, supposedly to fight terrorism.

Using these criteria, government officials have secretly characterized an unknown number of individuals as threats or potential threats to national security. In 2013 alone, 468,749 watch-list nominations were submitted to the National Counterterrorism Center. It rejected only 1 percent of the recommendations.

Critics say the system is bloated and imprecise, needlessly sweeping up thousands of people while simultaneously failing to catch legitimate threats, like Boston Marathon bomber Tamerlan Tsarnaev.
If this claim is accurate, I don't see Obama scoring any points with rational people when it comes to limiting civil rights to Americans.

At the risk of being called an NRA sycophant, the NRA is not the only group calling this "loophole" a crock of ****. http://www.oregonlive.com/portland/...y_list_appeals_process_un.html#incart_m-rpt-1
People who are placed on the government's no-fly list are denied their constitutional right to due process, because the government's procedures to challenge inclusion on the secretive roster are "wholly ineffective," a federal judge ruled.
How about we indict (thought crimes) the people on the no-fly list and update NICS so that they can't buy a gun from a dealer? Would that make people happy? Would that close the loophole Obama says exists?

Ranb
 
The no-fly list is a mess. Often people end up on it simply because they have the same name as somebody else suspected of terrorism. There is no due process, and presumably this is allowed because airlines are private companies and can refuse service based on arbitrary criteria, as long as those criteria are not designed to discriminate against members of a protected class. The government cannot limit a fundamental right without due process, so simply barring people on the no-fly list from purchasing a gun is not going to pass constitutional muster. I suppose they could distribute the list to gun stores, in the hope that gun stores will refuse to sell to people on the list, but I suspect gun stores wouldn't comply, and it would be unconstitutional to force them.

This is typical Democratic ********. Rather than placing sensible curbs on immigration, which would not only be completely lawful, but also ethical, they instead try to erode the freedoms of their own citizens.
 
I think this is the bill that was shot down in Congress recently. https://www.congress.gov/114/bills/s551/BILLS-114s551is.pdf

It gives the Attorney General rather broad powers to deny a gun transfer.
‘‘The Attorney General may deny the transfer of a firearm under section 922(t)(1)(B)(ii) of this title if the Attorney General—
‘‘(1) determines that the transferee is known (or appropriately suspected) to be or have been engaged in conduct constituting, in preparation for, in aid of, or related to terrorism, or providing material support or resources for terrorism; and ‘‘(2) has a reasonable belief that the prospective transferee may use a firearm in connection with terrorism.
It goes on to give the AG discretionary powers to use NICS to deny a gun transfer to someone he or she feels might be a terrorist. Judging by the statements made by bill supporters, I suppose the AG can simply use the no-fly list and the terror watch list to deny a transfer.

It doesn't actually say anything about the no-fly list other than;
(B) ensure that terrorist watch list records are used in a manner that safeguards privacy and civil liberties protections, in accordance with requirements outlines in Homeland Security Presidential Directive 11 (dated August 27, 17 2004).
And I'm supposed to believe this why?

Ranb
 
The “Terrorist Watch List,” like the “No-Fly List” and other secret government black lists, includes the names of suspects, relatives of suspects, friends of suspects, former college roommates of suspects, and more. No doubt these inclusions are useful for FBI agents and other officials as they search for terrorists and their accomplices, but they are not vetted lists of bad guys.http://www.forbes.com/sites/frankminiter/2015/11/18/did-terrorists-have-a-91-success-rate-with-buying-guns-in-america/

Bolding mine. But sure, seems fair.


Currently it is illegal for a prohibited person to attempt to purchase a firearm. It's a felony, they will go to jail for it(If the government actually decides to prosecute, which bizarrely they often don't.). Will it be a felony for a person to attempt to purchase a firearm because they're on a secret list that they did not know they were on?

Again, seems fair.
 
I've been quick to mock conservatives for their paranoia about the Big Bad Obama coming to take their guns but, when I see something like this, I'm actually a lot more sympathetic to the conservative position. I've heard of serious problems with the no-fly list for years -- often from liberal civil liberties groups. Using it as a basis to deny something the Supreme Court recognizes as a basic right is disturbing.
 
Due process is vital.

Whether it's inmates at Guantanamo, or citizens placed on a no-fly list, it's important to be presented with the evidence that put you there, and a means to defend yourself if wrongfully accused.

Otherwise we have the bastard child of Kafka's "The Trial" and "1984".
 
Will it be a felony for a person to attempt to purchase a firearm because they're on a secret list that they did not know they were on?
I don't think they'll be able to indict a buyer on that.

http://smartgunlaws.org/straw-purchases-policy-summary/

18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(6) prohibits any person:

In connection with the acquisition or attempted acquisition of any firearm or ammunition from a licensed importer, licensed manufacturer, licensed dealer, or licensed collector, knowingly to make any false or fictitious oral or written statement or to furnish or exhibit any false, fictitious, or misrepresented identification, intended or likely to deceive such importer, manufacturer, dealer, or collector with respect to any fact material to the lawfulness of the sale or other disposition of such firearm or ammunition.

Subject to limited exceptions, 18 U.S.C. § 924(a)(1)(A) imposes criminal penalties, such as fines and imprisonment, upon any person who:

Knowingly makes any false statement or representation with respect to the information required by [federal firearms law] to be kept in the records of a person licensed under [federal firearms law] or in applying for any license or exemption or relief from disability under the provisions of [federal firearms law].

Now if the feds give me a heads up on my no-fly list status prior to filling out form 4473 to buy a gun, they might be able to make a case. Also there is nothing on the form 4473 that asks if I'm a terrorist, or the former roommate of one. :)

Ranb
 
Last edited:
The no-fly list is a mess. Often people end up on it simply because they have the same name as somebody else suspected of terrorism. There is no due process, and presumably this is allowed because airlines are private companies and can refuse service based on arbitrary criteria, as long as those criteria are not designed to discriminate against members of a protected class. The government cannot limit a fundamental right without due process, so simply barring people on the no-fly list from purchasing a gun is not going to pass constitutional muster. I suppose they could distribute the list to gun stores, in the hope that gun stores will refuse to sell to people on the list, but I suspect gun stores wouldn't comply, and it would be unconstitutional to force them.
This ^^ pretty much covers it. Obama wants to do an end-run on due process.

"Right now, people on the No-Fly list can walk into a store and buy a gun. That is insane. If you're too dangerous to board a plane, you're too dangerous, by definition, to buy a gun," he said in his weekly address.

What is "insane" is the poorly managed no-fly list itself. What does being on a no-fly list have to do with owning a firearm anyways? The more times I read that quote the more idiotic and scary it sounds.
 
"Don't let a crisis go to waste", so why not use the current one to gut the 1st, 2nd, 4th, and 14th Amendments? It's the Democratic way!
 
http://www.cnn.com/2015/12/07/politics/no-fly-mistakes-cat-stevens-ted-kennedy-john-lewis/index.html

The new initiative is reviving questions about the legality and efficacy of the no-fly list, which has drawn criticism and challenges in court by civil rights groups, including the ACLU.

After losing a key ruling in a recent lawsuit, the federal government in April said it would begin to proactively inform people of their status and create a more transparent system for contesting the designation — a process the ACLU once described as a "Kafkaesque bureaucracy."

While the criteria for adding individuals to the list remains murky, one thing is for sure: it's still a lot easier to get on the list than get off it. Even in clear cases of mistaken identity or clerical blundering, a name can linger in the system for years.

Ranb
 
I know I've already invoked Kafka (and Orwell) in these discussions.

One can imagine where as of a certain date, everyone is on the no-fly list and individuals have to apply for a "Fly Permit" after convincing the bureaucracy that they are NOT terrorists.

Or roaches!
 
I think this could be the issue that leads to a Democratic landslide and taking back Congress. It will separate the rational gun owner from the gun nut. Republicans are hoping they can leverage American's fear of terrorism along with the portrayal of Democrats as weak to help their chances. This issue exposes the Republicans as the party of the NRA and gun nuts.

As an aside, it's (and will be) stomach achingly hilarious to watch the HDS crowd, who want her strung up despite lack of charges whine about "due process".
 
But I suppose there needs to be some way of keeping people like Ted Kennedy and David Cole from walking out of a gun store with a legally purchased firearm.

Well, Ted Kennedy is the only person on the no-fly list that we know actually killed someone.

I guess the real lesson is to never let any Kennedy buy a gun.
 
Or we could become the old Soviet Union. :) Your papers please!

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sponsore...-in-Russia-to-become-a-thing-of-the-past.html
Recently, Ms Melnikova stopped for a coffee before a flight to Italy. She was approached by a police officer, who requested to see her internal passport – Russia’s equivalent of an ID card. When the officer discovered that she had not registered as a resident of Moscow, he hauled her off to the police station. “Without this paper you’re a nobody!” he said.

Ranb
 
I think this could be the issue that leads to a Democratic landslide and taking back Congress.

Oh, I so want to see the Democrats try to make this a general election issue. I really, really do. I mean, it's always been such a winner for them in the past, what could possibly go wrong?
 
Well, Ted Kennedy is the only person on the no-fly list that we know actually killed someone.
Not sure which "we" you are talking about, but I don't think very many people actually know who is on the list until they get stopped at the airport.

I guess the real lesson is to never let any Kennedy buy a gun.
Or a golf club.

Ranb
 
I just find it funny that the same liberals who were (correctly) arguing ten years ago that the no-fly list was a dangerous end run around due process now think that it's a foolproof way to keep guns away from Bad Guys.

And, of course, the same conservatives who called liberals paranoid and said that they "only aid the terrorists" are now trumpeting their concern about civil liberties and due process.

Partisan politics + guns = hyperhypocrisy.
 
I think this could be the issue that leads to a Democratic landslide and taking back Congress.
You think it is a good idea to use a semi-secret list with little due process to restrict civil rights? Or did I misunderstand what you wrote?

As an aside, it's (and will be) stomach achingly hilarious to watch the HDS crowd, who want her strung up despite lack of charges whine about "due process".
HDS? Her who?

Ranb
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom