9/11 New information.

DGM

Skeptic not Atheist
Joined
May 22, 2007
Messages
24,757
Location
West of Northshore MA
A new member in another thread mentioned "new information". As it is off-topic in that thread I figured I'd start a new one.

Is there anything new?
 
This post in paticular stuck me as showing a gross misunderstanding of how the world works.

For example, an incomplete theory is that although the buildings were allegedly built to code, and certified as such by an allegedly impartial official, they were not fit for purpose. Criminal negligence on the part of some or all of those involved in the construction and certification of the building is grounds for a corporate manslaughter or even murder charge.
See Bailey and Nordenson for evidence that supports that theory.

This case was started by the insurance companies that paid out large bucks in claims. They chose to spend more to show the building was defective and ignored what "truthers" claim is obvious demolition. This simple fact is lost on this person when it should be obvious.
 
That is true, if the companies could prove CD, then they could go after the CD guys...
But there are no CD guys. Opinions based on opinions are 911 truth's overwhelming evidence.
 
A new member in another thread mentioned "new information". As it is off-topic in that thread I figured I'd start a new one.

Is there anything new?

May I suggest that there is nothing new beyond kids who see the nonsense for the first time and are persuaded by it for lack of the everyday cynicism that age brings.
 
May I suggest that there is nothing new beyond kids who see the nonsense for the first time and are persuaded by it for lack of the everyday cynicism that age brings.

I haven't see anything new either, apart from the faces regurgitating the memes.
 
What's new there?

Probably nothing. And - until AClark or paloalto makes a claim I'm not going looking.

New member AClark is playing "newbie truther' by regurgitating many of the long dead canards - and employing all the standard "truther debating trickery".

AFAICS AClark has not yet played the truther trick of argumentio by youtubium

...so paloalto probably thinks AClark needs help. ;)

...PA is sort of saying "You've played a lot of tricks there AClark - here's one you missed."
 
You tell me!
Are you making money from LOREAL. Not new, but at least on 15 minutes of BS, in politics, from guys who might think they knowledge they had could stop 911... then why did they fail? Thinking they could have, is kind of admitting they failed...

Nothing new, it is BS about the fact these guys knew two terror suspects were on the planes on 911; and they think they missed stopping something they never knew was coming. So much BS, way too late.

If they thought anything was important about anything they think now, then they failed to act then. It is BS to worry about the fact the CIA was tracking some terrorists, and they happened to be on in the 911 plot, which the CIA never knew was going to happen until after it happened.

Easy to predict the past from the future... kind of sad...

Ali Soufan believes that the terrorist attacks of 9/11 could have been prevented. Believes is the key word; aka, an opinion. Why did he fail?

Yes, your opinion the CIA let 911 happen on purpose is not new, it is BS.

So far no clear cut why this would stop 911. Why can't you produce the what would stop 911 narrative. Gee, if you can codify this, we could stop crime before it happens, like in the movies...
 
Last edited:
This post in paticular stuck me as showing a gross misunderstanding of how the world works.

This case was started by the insurance companies that paid out large bucks in claims. They chose to spend more to show the building was defective and ignored what "truthers" claim is obvious demolition. This simple fact is lost on this person when it should be obvious.


Agreed.

I waded into the NIST report, which was mostly over my head, but the "recommendations" section hinted at poor design. Not incompetent, not negligent, just a lot of cut corners to get the WTC built. NYC had to change building codes to green-light the WTC project.

The twin towers were more works of art than anything, and they'd still be there had Al Qaeda not flown jetliners into them.
 
Seriously? Corners were cut? The union leadership and cement providers would never stand for that. Many of them come from old NY Families.
 
Are you making money from LOREAL. Not new, but at least on 15 minutes of BS, in politics, from guys who might think they knowledge they had could stop 911... then why did they fail? Thinking they could have, is kind of admitting they failed...

Nothing new, it is BS about the fact these guys knew two terror suspects were on the planes on 911; and they think they missed stopping something they never knew was coming. So much BS, way too late.

If they thought anything was important about anything they think now, then they failed to act then. It is BS to worry about the fact the CIA was tracking some terrorists, and they happened to be on in the 911 plot, which the CIA never knew was going to happen until after it happened.

Easy to predict the past from the future... kind of sad...

Ali Soufan believes that the terrorist attacks of 9/11 could have been prevented. Believes is the key word; aka, an opinion. Why did he fail?

Yes, your opinion the CIA let 911 happen on purpose is not new, it is BS.

So far no clear cut why this would stop 911. Why can't you produce the what would stop 911 narrative. Gee, if you can codify this, we could stop crime before it happens, like in the movies...

I think you're being rather harsh here Beachnut. True, we don't know what the FBI would have discovered had they been given access, we don't know if such access would have stopped 9/11, but it certainly might have done. Nawaf al-Hazmi and Khalid al-Mihdhar certainly knew more about the plot than a lot of the others because they were recruited to be pilots for it, until they showed a total inability to learn how to fly, and were replaced. We also know that al-Hazmi at least knew about Atta as they were meeting fairly regularly to co-ordinate things, so the likelihood is that the two had a good knowledge of the attacks. Could the FBI have extracted that information.... we don't know. It might have been enough to cause Al Qaeda pause, perhaps re-evaluating their plans, it might have even lead the FBI to Atta and towards others involved.

Blaming the Agents for not working it out when they didn't have the information to work it out with, is overly harsh. They failed because they were denied information that might have helped them. Yes they might have still failed even with the information, but we'll never know for sure.

Does that equal LIHOP? No, it just equals a messed up system that failed to make sure all the information available was in the hands of those that needed it because two agencies were more interested in play politics than working together to ensure the safety of the US.
 
I think you're being rather harsh .. ensure the safety of the US.

They are harsh on themselves...
I understand.

If they are claiming they could have...
I have a problem with why they did not do more before; if I had a task that was important, or involved risk; I spent extra time solving the problem; why did they not do more? They claim they could have stopped 911, why did they fail. Not harsh, it is their claim they could do it.

i would be harsh on myself

I don't know, did they put in 72 hour weeks on the job? and come on the day off to stay up to speed? I did that for 5 months. And special projects cost me 16 hours days for over a week. Maybe they put in the required time; but how many bad guys were they working?

I understand why they are upset; this is the same way I feel when things go wrong, things I can see when looking back.
The good part is they are not saying they let it happen on purpose... the 911 truth conclusion.
 
Does that equal LIHOP? No, it just equals a messed up system that failed to make sure all the information available was in the hands of those that needed it because two agencies were more interested in play politics than working together to ensure the safety of the US.
That goes to the fundamental error the "both sides" make with MIHOP/LIHOP claims - that is assuming that it could only be via one master plan under single point control.

Utter nonsense.

Lots of LIHOOI must have occurred and near certain bits of LIHOP and MIHOP.

BUT at section/agency/inter-agency levels NOT one overall master plan.

That is what "a messed up system" means.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom