Where am I ?

Joined
Dec 6, 2004
Messages
4,561
So, this a new subject, I do not know if it has been around the forum lately but I could not find it.

So, where am I ?

Apparently, you could reply, you are right in front on the computer screen, sit on a chair and you should go to bed.

However, when I ask where exactly am I, you can find some problems ..

You could say that I am where my body is, but, I can reply to you, where exactly ?

I am not in my hand, because if I cut it ( no intention to do it, just let's suppose ), I will still be there, I am not in my legs, not in my chest, etc.

Because men can survive without legs, heart, maybe they could not walk or they will need an artificial heart, but they would still be there.

Then you can say:

1) You are your brain, because this is the part of your body dedicated to thought and because without brain you would be dead

Then, I would ask, the brain is made of billions of neurons and synapses. Which of these synapses and neurons am I ?
Moreover, medical literature quotes cases of people with big parts of their brains damaged by cancer but still being able to talk normally and with no problem recognizing other people.

2) You are your soul

Then, where is my soul and my body interact

3) Your mind is an illusion, existing is an illusion, nobody really exists ..

Then if we ( you and me ) do not really exist, just put your hand on that burning fire, Wow, you are shouting and crying, why if you do not exist ?

So, where am I ?
 
Matteo Martini said:
So, this a new subject, I do not know if it has been around the forum lately but I could not find it.

So, where am I ?

Apparently, you could reply, you are right in front on the computer screen, sit on a chair and you should go to bed.

However, when I ask where exactly am I, you can find some problems ..

You could say that I am where my body is, but, I can reply to you, where exactly ?

I am not in my hand, because if I cut it ( no intention to do it, just let's suppose ), I will still be there, I am not in my legs, not in my chest, etc.

Because men can survive without legs, heart, maybe they could not walk or they will need an artificial heart, but they would still be there.

Then you can say:

1) You are your brain, because this is the part of your body dedicated to thought and because without brain you would be dead

Then, I would ask, the brain is made of billions of neurons and synapses. Which of these synapses and neurons am I ?
Moreover, medical literature quotes cases of people with big parts of their brains damaged by cancer but still being able to talk normally and with no problem recognizing other people.

2) You are your soul

Then, where is my soul and my body interact

3) Your mind is an illusion, existing is an illusion, nobody really exists ..

Then if we ( you and me ) do not really exist, just put your hand on that burning fire, Wow, you are shouting and crying, why if you do not exist ?

So, where am I ?

You are not IN a neuron. You ARE them. Their effect is cumulative. If I tore out one brain cell at a time, I would eventually notice a change. You (and I) are simply so part of our reality that we are unable to imagine what it is like NOT to exist.

I'm sure there are cases where cancer did not harm a person's functionality. There are also many recorded cases of brain damage doing INCREDIBLE damage to a human's personality. If I were a soul, my personality would never be changed by brain damage.

What method do we use to know that you soul hypothesis is right and my brain hypothesis is wrong?
 
You are not IN a neuron. You ARE them. Their effect is cumulative

This is a weak argument, in my opinion.
I would agree that you could justify memory, facial recognition, learning etc. with neurons but not self-cosciousness.
Self-consciousness is not, in my opinion, something that you can have " a little bit ", either you are self-conscious ( like humans, cats, whales and dogs ) or you are not ( a chair, a computer ).
So, if you tear away the neurons from the memory region, you will probably will not remember things of your past, but you would still know that you exist.
So, how can you isaloate the neurons of self-consciousness ?

What method do we use to know that you soul hypothesis is right and my brain hypothesis is wrong?

Do not start attacking me if I speak about " soul " and " religion", many skeptics do this.
I also never said that the soul hypothesis was right just another one.

On the planet Neptune?

Probably, at this time of night, yes.
 
Matteo Martini said:
This is a weak argument, in my opinion.
I would agree that you could justify memory, facial recognition, learning etc. with neurons but not self-cosciousness.
Self-consciousness is not, in my opinion, something that you can have " a little bit ", either you are self-conscious ( like humans, cats, whales and dogs ) or you are not ( a chair, a computer ).
So, if you tear away the neurons from the memory region, you will probably will not remember things of your past, but you would still know that you exist.
So, how can you isaloate the neurons of self-consciousness ?
Your argument rests upon the unfalsifiable, which unfortunately makes it very, very weak.

Your opinion is that consciouness stems from a soul. Souls are unfalsifiable. There is no way to prove or disprove your hypothesis.

However, KingMerv's argument states that consciousness is cumulative neural action. We may not know for sure if this is the case right now, but his hypothesis is falsifiable, and with increases in medical knowledge, we will be able to see if he is right or wrong. (my guess-- he's right)

Matteo Martini said:
Do not start attacking me if I speak about " soul " and " religion", many skeptics do this.
I also never said that the soul hypothesis was right just another one.
Don't get so defensive. It's a very valid question.

I'll restate it-- How can we test your theory against KingMerv's? How can we find a way to validate or invalidate what you say?

Without a theory of how to test your claim, it gets relegated to the top shelf, where it will sit and gather dust until we have testing protocols for it.
 
Matteo Martini said:

Self-consciousness is not, in my opinion, something that you can have " a little bit ", either you are self-conscious ( like humans, cats, whales and dogs ) or you are not ( a chair, a computer ).
So, if you tear away the neurons from the memory region, you will probably will not remember things of your past, but you would still know that you exist.

I'm curious where exactly you draw the self-concious line.
Is a virus self-consious?
 
Ratman_tf said:
I'm curious where exactly you draw the self-concious line.
Is a virus self-consious?
Good question. I didn't know cats and dogs were self-conscious. If they are, hey, my mistake, I just didn't think we had verified that yet.
 
This is a weak argument, in my opinion.
I would agree that you could justify memory, facial recognition, learning etc. with neurons but not self-cosciousness.
Self-consciousness is not, in my opinion, something that you can have " a little bit ", either you are self-conscious ( like humans, cats, whales and dogs ) or you are not ( a chair, a computer ).
So, if you tear away the neurons from the memory region, you will probably will not remember things of your past, but you would still know that you exist.
So, how can you isaloate the neurons of self-consciousness ?


Indeed you CAN have "a little bit" of consciousness.

For example, you suggest that humans, cats, whales and dogs are self-aware. Well, let's go farther down the evolutionary ladder. How about eagles? Finches? Turtles? Goldfish? Squid? Sponges? Amoeba? Viruses? Prions?

Each step you go down you become less self-aware. Consciousness is not a toggle switch, it is a dimmer switch.

Do not start attacking me if I speak about " soul " and " religion", many skeptics do this.
I also never said that the soul hypothesis was right just another one.


Good answer. I will never attack someone who says they do not know something. However, if you want to convince me of your hypothesis, I would need more information.
 
Re: Re: Where am I ?

H3LL said:
I have no idea, but I know how fast you are moving.
Okay, when I use the expression "lol" I usually mean that something was funny enough to make me involuntarily smile. This made me actually laugh out loud. Bravo.

:clap:
 
OK, before writing again, let me reply to Nex

Nex wrote " I didn't know cats and dogs were self-conscious. If they are, hey, my mistake, I just didn't think we had verified that yet "
I think dogs and cats are self -conscious. Self-conscious being have the ability to " feel " pleasure and pain while non self-coscious do not.
My cat feels pain ( do not quesiton me on how I know that, please ), while a rock do not.

Nex wrote again " Your opinion is that consciouness stems from a soul. Souls are unfalsifiable. There is no way to prove or disprove your hypothesis "
But I never said that I believe that consciouness stems from a soul !!
It is just one hypothesis among the others.
It is funny that you ( and maybe others ) believe that I believe that consciouness stems from a soul even if I never said that.

Just back on track.

I see that the main opinion here is that consciouness stems from a brain, and that is a kind of dimmer switch, which I do not know what it is but I assume it means that self-consciousness can grow from 0 ( rock ) to 5 ( worm ) to 20 ( cat ) to 100 ( human ) or something like that.

Now I will try to disprove this point.

1) If self-consciousness stems from the brain, it is obvious that, the less brain you have, the less self-consciousness you have, right ? No brain, no self-consciousness.
Now, I am not a neurologist but I read something in neurology journals that many parts of the brain are " dedicated " to specific tasks, like motion, memory, facial recognition, etc.
I admit I do not know this in deep.
I also know that, some people having brain cancer or ictuses had some part of their brain damaged sometimes even nearly half of it.
In some cases that person dies, but in other cases the person is still completely conscious, just some of the person functions like motion, sight, memory are impaired.
Now, self-consciousness has nothing to do with motion, sight, memory.
I can think at one person ( a very unlucky one, though ) having sight, hearing, memory abilities severely impaired, he would probably not be able to see, hear, remember things of the past but he would be able to feel that he exists here and now as much as I do ( I do not know if he would like to exist anynore after this, but this is another problem ).
So, maybe it is not the whole brain which stems self-consciousness, but only one part. Which one though ?

2) Let' s think about the neurons and synapsys. Let' s think that their functions about information processing could be replicated using a very sophysticated version of the modern microprocessor.
The function of the neurons is to manage information, is not it?
So, I do not think there is no conceptual obstacle in thinking about replicating them using very sophysticated version of the modern microprocessor ( yet to be built, of course !! )
Then, let' s assume to connect one trillion of those Pentium XIs with cables, will we have built a brain.
Will this machine be self-conscious or not ??
If not, why ?
Because humans are organic and this machine would be made of silicon and metal ?
This should not metter, should it ?
So, let' s assume that we had been able to replicate a brain and that this brain will be self-conscious.
We can add mechanic legs, robotic arms, sensors, camera with voice and facial recognition, it is nothing impossible to think, MIT Artificial Intelligence Labs are already working on this.
My opinion is that this machine will not be self-conscious !!
Maybe we could, ultimately, built a machine that will act like a person, remember, move, recognize people, talk, etc. but it will not feel anything.
I will try to disprove the fact that this machine will be self-conscious.
Take away one microprocessor at time from this machine' s brain.
Will his ( its ) self-consciousness fade away like the HAL in 2001: A space Odissey ?
Then, with one or few microprocessors, will the once fully self-conscious machine still be self-conscious, just a little bit ?
As ratman_tf said: I'm curious where exactly you draw the self-concious line.
I can say the same thing.
Then maybe even the Pentium 4 of this computer is self-conscious, just a little, little, little, little bit ?

Matteo
 
Human minds act they way the do because of all the parts and the way they interact. Because we are trapped in our own minds, we don't know how it feels to be something else. We know we are self aware, but what can we compare that to? We have no way to look outside our own frame of reference.

To ask which part of the brain makes consciousness is like asking which part makes a car go. While the engine provides the power, without the transmission, axles, and wheels there is no way to use that power to put the car in motion. If we were unable to take apart a car to see how it runs and could only remove different parts and see how that removal affects the car's ability to function then it would take a very long time to determine exactly how a car works.

The same may be true of the brain. Perhaps if we were able to slowly remove little pieces of the brain then we would eventually be able to find where the conciousness originates. However, that would be VERY unethical, so all we have is what we learn from people who end up brain damaged from other sources.
 
Matteo Martini said:
OK, before writing again, let me reply to Nex

Nex wrote " I didn't know cats and dogs were self-conscious. If they are, hey, my mistake, I just didn't think we had verified that yet "
I think dogs and cats are self -conscious. Self-conscious being have the ability to " feel " pleasure and pain while non self-coscious do not.
My cat feels pain ( do not quesiton me on how I know that, please ), while a rock do not.

Matteo

So your definition of being self-conscious is to feel physical pain and pleasure? If that capacity is damaged in someone, are they no longer self-conscious?
 
I am reading a book right now entitled "The God Gene".

A couple of the chapters deal with the brain and religious experience. I can't remember specifics but there are parts of the brain which allow you to separate yourself from the rest of the universe. Damaging this spot or stimulating it with drugs/electiricty can cause yourself to feel "at one with the universe". Pretty neat actually. Not a bad book.

Edit: Btw, I really appreciate that you are actually addressing questions directly and trying to use logic to solve them. Some posters can't seem to do that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom