Matteo Martini
Banned
- Joined
- Dec 6, 2004
- Messages
- 4,561
So, this a new subject, I do not know if it has been around the forum lately but I could not find it.
So, where am I ?
Apparently, you could reply, you are right in front on the computer screen, sit on a chair and you should go to bed.
However, when I ask where exactly am I, you can find some problems ..
You could say that I am where my body is, but, I can reply to you, where exactly ?
I am not in my hand, because if I cut it ( no intention to do it, just let's suppose ), I will still be there, I am not in my legs, not in my chest, etc.
Because men can survive without legs, heart, maybe they could not walk or they will need an artificial heart, but they would still be there.
Then you can say:
1) You are your brain, because this is the part of your body dedicated to thought and because without brain you would be dead
Then, I would ask, the brain is made of billions of neurons and synapses. Which of these synapses and neurons am I ?
Moreover, medical literature quotes cases of people with big parts of their brains damaged by cancer but still being able to talk normally and with no problem recognizing other people.
2) You are your soul
Then, where is my soul and my body interact
3) Your mind is an illusion, existing is an illusion, nobody really exists ..
Then if we ( you and me ) do not really exist, just put your hand on that burning fire, Wow, you are shouting and crying, why if you do not exist ?
So, where am I ?
So, where am I ?
Apparently, you could reply, you are right in front on the computer screen, sit on a chair and you should go to bed.
However, when I ask where exactly am I, you can find some problems ..
You could say that I am where my body is, but, I can reply to you, where exactly ?
I am not in my hand, because if I cut it ( no intention to do it, just let's suppose ), I will still be there, I am not in my legs, not in my chest, etc.
Because men can survive without legs, heart, maybe they could not walk or they will need an artificial heart, but they would still be there.
Then you can say:
1) You are your brain, because this is the part of your body dedicated to thought and because without brain you would be dead
Then, I would ask, the brain is made of billions of neurons and synapses. Which of these synapses and neurons am I ?
Moreover, medical literature quotes cases of people with big parts of their brains damaged by cancer but still being able to talk normally and with no problem recognizing other people.
2) You are your soul
Then, where is my soul and my body interact
3) Your mind is an illusion, existing is an illusion, nobody really exists ..
Then if we ( you and me ) do not really exist, just put your hand on that burning fire, Wow, you are shouting and crying, why if you do not exist ?
So, where am I ?
