New Book on Pearl Harbor Puts Blame on Washington and Exonerates Kimmel

Joined
Sep 25, 2012
Messages
805
Best-selling investigative journalists Anthony Summers and Robbyn Swan's book A Matter of Honor: Pearl Harbor: Betrayal, Blame, and a Family's Quest for Justice (New York: HarperCollins, November 2016) presents new evidence of a massive cover-up and exposes FDR's shameful efforts to make Admiral Kimmel the scapegoat for the attack on Pearl Harbor. Here is some of what three reviewers have said about the book:

“Meticulous, eloquent, and compelling - and hugely readable. The 75th anniversary of the Japanese attack is well served by A Matter of Honor.” -- Simon Winchester, New York Times bestselling author of The Men Who United the States and Pacific

“Anthony Summers’ & Robbyn Swan’s A Matter of Honor is a noble and right-minded portrait of Admiral Kimmel, the scapegoat for Pearl Harbor. The amount of fresh research is deeply impressive. Highly recommended!” -- Douglas Brinkley, author of Rightful Heritage: Franklin D. Roosevelt & the Land of America

“The most comprehensive, accurate and thoroughly researched book of events leading up to the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor ever written. It provides new information never before revealed.” -- Admiral James Lyons, former Commander in Chief U.S. Pacific Fleet
 
Last edited:
Best-selling investigative journalists Anthony Summers and Robbyn Swan's book A Matter of Honor: Pearl Harbor: Betrayal, Blame, and a Family's Quest for Justice (New York: HarperCollins, November 2016) presents new evidence of a massive cover-up and exposes FDR's shameful efforts to make Admiral Kimmel the scapegoat for the attack on Pearl Harbor. Here is some of what three reviewers have said about the book:

“Meticulous, eloquent, and compelling - and hugely readable. The 75th anniversary of the Japanese attack is well served by A Matter of Honor.” -- Simon Winchester, New York Times bestselling author of The Men Who United the States and Pacific

“Anthony Summers’ & Robbyn Swan’s A Matter of Honor is a noble and right-minded portrait of Admiral Kimmel, the scapegoat for Pearl Harbor. The amount of fresh research is deeply impressive. Highly recommended!” -- Douglas Brinkley, author of Rightful Heritage: Franklin D. Roosevelt & the Land of America

“The most comprehensive, accurate and thoroughly researched book of events leading up to the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor ever written. It provides new information never before revealed.” -- Admiral James Lyons, former Commander in Chief U.S. Pacific Fleet

Doesn't appear to support your idea that the President was running a conspiracy to start a war now does it?

Another review:

This evenhanded exposé of the scapegoating of the commander in chief of the Pacific fleet at the time of Pearl Harbor challenges official memory.Adm. Husband Kimmel was roundly blamed for the destruction of the fleet at Pearl Harbor and loss of 2,403 lives on that terrible day of Dec. 7, 1941, but as co-authors Summers and Swan (The Eleventh Day: The Full Story of 9/11, 2011, etc.) show, he was conveniently used to hiding many missteps by his Washington, D.C., superiors. Both Kimmel and the Army’s Hawaiian commander, Lt. Gen. Walter Short, were forced into retirement after the debacle. The subsequent official fact-finding commission (the first of nine), the Roberts Report, blamed them for “dereliction of duty,” and they were charged with having failed to “confer and cooperate” with warnings by Washington leading up to the surprise Japanese attack. Kimmel dedicated the rest of his life to challenging these charges and vindicating his name. The truth, as close as the authors can ascertain, is that the intercepts cracking a Japanese supercode were not adequately shared with Kimmel, although Washington officials assumed that they had been. The key middleman in this failure to pass on valuable intelligence information was Chief of Naval Operations Harold Stark, who was ostensibly Kimmel’s longtime friend yet withheld critical information from him—e.g., the telltale Japanese dispatch of Sept. 24, which requested that Pearl Harbor be divided into special zones for the location of specific kinds of ships. Moreover, Kimmel was out of the loop in knowing about the deterioration of diplomatic negotiations between Japanese representatives and Washington in the final weeks leading to the attack, while the traffic analysts guessed that Japanese heavy carriers (which no one could locate) must be in home waters. In the end, the authors find enough blame, high and low, to go around. A solid demonstration of how an insistence on secrecy proved to be a fatal breakdown as the Japanese attack loomed. A good complement to Steve Twomey’s Countdown to Pearl Harbor (2016).

https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/a-matter-of-honor-anthony-summers/1123517482#/
 
In any case involving humans, I'll take incompetence over grand conspiracy.

A cover-up is a conspiracy.

Conspiring to falsely accuse local commanders and unjustly ruin their careers is a conspiracy.

Summers and Swan allow that it might not just have been incompetence.
 
Doesn't appear to support your idea that the President was running a conspiracy to start a war now does it?

You might read the book first, before you comment on it. I find that's the best way to comment intelligently and credibly about a book--read it first.

FYI, Summers and Swan thoroughly document that FDR was scheming and lying all over the place to get us into the war.
 
Last edited:
You might read the book first, before you comment on it. I find that's the best way to comment intelligently and credibly about a book--read it first.

FYI, Summers and Swan thoroughly document that FDR was scheming and lying all over the place to get us into the war.

What a bastard he was. Pity that Japan and Germany didn't win. That would haveserved him right.
 
Cock up rather than conspiracy.

A cover-up is a conspiracy.

Conspiring to falsely accuse local commanders and unjustly ruin their careers is a conspiracy.

I agree with both views here

The failure to adequately brief the commanders who were going to be at the pointy end of any attack was a cock-up of monumental proportions with similarly monumental consequences.

That several scrambled egg wearers higher up the chain of command chose to get together and make Kimmel and Short scapegoats for Pearl Harbour in order to cover up their own complicity is a conspiracy any way you slice it.

As to whether those up the chain KNOWINGLY withheld this vital information for the purpose of allowing a war to start... no. I don't believe that for a moment.

Sidenote: Its a pity the "121.92-meter mutant fire-breathing lizard-thingy" no longer posts here. He was one of this forum's foremost experts on Pearl Harbor
 
Last edited:
Weird, because the entire west coast of the United States knew an attack was coming at some point. Nobody called Hawaii?

Oh wait, they did.

The pre-war Navy had a lot of communications problems...sort of like today's Navy...

War had been brewing between Japan and the US since before WWI.

But hey, I'm just a guy who reads history books...
 
Weird, because the entire west coast of the United States knew an attack was coming at some point. Nobody called Hawaii?

Oh wait, they did.

The pre-war Navy had a lot of communications problems...sort of like today's Navy...

War had been brewing between Japan and the US since before WWI..

Far too simplistic

There is a slightly collossal difference between knowing that war is brewing, and knowing actual day, date and time of an attack.
 
A cover-up is a conspiracy.

Conspiring to falsely accuse local commanders and unjustly ruin their careers is a conspiracy.

Summers and Swan allow that it might not just have been incompetence.

I'd refer you to #5 of the 7 stages of film production:

Wild Enthusiasm.
Total Confusion.
Utter Despair.
Search for the Guilty.
Persecution of the Innocent.
Promotion of the Incompetent.
Distribution of T-Shirts.

Having been around, the concept of a fall guy in instances of failure does not surprise me in the least. It does not mean that it's right, but it's common to institutions of whatever type that someone will take the weight for a failure, whether they're truly the responsible individual or not.
 
You might read the book first, before you comment on it. I find that's the best way to comment intelligently and credibly about a book--read it first.

FYI, Summers and Swan thoroughly document that FDR was scheming and lying all over the place to get us into the war.

Oh, so quoting a review is not good for you huh? He read it didn't he?

Okay straight question since you have read it - does it support your conspiracy theory - yes or no? Ie he deliberately allowed the Japanese to attack Pearl Harbor and he knew they would do it but he did not inform the commander?

Please quote to us the page and paragraph where Summers and Swan state that.

Can you do that?

Additionally tell us why the guy who did the review said this:

This evenhanded exposé of the scapegoating of the commander in chief of the Pacific fleet at the time of Pearl Harbor challenges official memory.Adm. Husband Kimmel was roundly blamed for the destruction of the fleet at Pearl Harbor and loss of 2,403 lives on that terrible day of Dec. 7, 1941, but as co-authors Summers and Swan (The Eleventh Day: The Full Story of 9/11, 2011, etc.) show, he was conveniently used to hiding many missteps by his Washington, D.C., superiors. Both Kimmel and the Army’s Hawaiian commander, Lt. Gen. Walter Short, were forced into retirement after the debacle. The subsequent official fact-finding commission (the first of nine), the Roberts Report, blamed them for “dereliction of duty,” and they were charged with having failed to “confer and cooperate” with warnings by Washington leading up to the surprise Japanese attack. Kimmel dedicated the rest of his life to challenging these charges and vindicating his name. The truth, as close as the authors can ascertain, is that the intercepts cracking a Japanese supercode were not adequately shared with Kimmel, although Washington officials assumed that they had been. The key middleman in this failure to pass on valuable intelligence information was Chief of Naval Operations Harold Stark, who was ostensibly Kimmel’s longtime friend yet withheld critical information from him—e.g., the telltale Japanese dispatch of Sept. 24, which requested that Pearl Harbor be divided into special zones for the location of specific kinds of ships. Moreover, Kimmel was out of the loop in knowing about the deterioration of diplomatic negotiations between Japanese representatives and Washington in the final weeks leading to the attack, while the traffic analysts guessed that Japanese heavy carriers (which no one could locate) must be in home waters. In the end, the authors find enough blame, high and low, to go around. A solid demonstration of how an insistence on secrecy proved to be a fatal breakdown as the Japanese attack loomed. A good complement to Steve Twomey’s Countdown to Pearl Harbor (2016).

I mean this guy read it why don't you believe what he wrote? .......lol
 
Last edited:
It's as insane as 9/11 being a plot to get us into war with iraq. If we wanted to enter the war against Germany, allowing an attack as far away from Germany as possible seems like a stupid way to do it.

The fact is: lots of things happened, they could have happened differently, and everybody is to blame.
 
Far too simplistic

There is a slightly collossal difference between knowing that war is brewing, and knowing actual day, date and time of an attack.

The War Department sent a cable warning of a possible attack early in the morning, but didn't label (or flag it as urgent) so Kimmel didn't get it until too late. That's as advanced as it got.

They knew the Imperial Fleet had sailed, but the thinking was it was steaming to the Philippines, and part of it was. The Naval folks at the War Department did lag in telling Kimmel important information, but that wasn't because FDR ordered them too. Just the usual incompetence found with this kind of story. Throw in the fact that the Army had the attacking aircraft on their new-fangled RADAR, but assumed the contact was an incoming flight of B-17's, and that a Navy destroyer, USS Ward, had engaged, and sunk a midget submarine a few miles from the entrance to Pearl Harbor at 6:37am yet the commander on duty didn't believe them, and failed to put the base on alert, and you get a string of could-a-should-a-would-a's.
 
A cover-up is a conspiracy.

Conspiring to falsely accuse local commanders and unjustly ruin their careers is a conspiracy.

Summers and Swan allow that it might not just have been incompetence.

I thought we were talking about conspiracy theory. When does a conspiracy become a conspiracy theory? When it's covered up? Does that make the NY Police ticket fixing scandal into a conspiracy or a conspiracy theory? Is there any difference between the cover up of the demolition of the World Trade Center buildings and the cover up of the ticket fixing scandal? Let's get these words straight first.
 
Last edited:
It's as insane as 9/11 being a plot to get us into war with iraq. If we wanted to enter the war against Germany, allowing an attack as far away from Germany as possible seems like a stupid way to do it.

The fact is: lots of things happened, they could have happened differently, and everybody is to blame.

Exactly, and in fact had Roosevelt really wanted an excuse to get involved in the war, he had plenty of incidents to do so without needing to wait on Pearl Harbor.

1941, April 10 - USS Niblack (DD-424) depth charges a German submarine off of Iceland in what is believed to be the first act of war between Germany and the U.S.

April 17 - The German raider Atlantis sinks the Egyptian steamship Zamzam in the south Atlantic. One hundred and fifty Americans are among the passengers rescued.

May 21 - A German U-boat sinks the US freighter Robin Moor.

July 30 - The U.S. river gunboat USS Tutuila (PR-4) is bombed at Chunking, China by Japanese planes.

September 4 - The destroyer USS Greer (DD-145) is attacked but not damaged while tracking a German U-boat 175 miles southwest of Iceland.

September 7 - German air attack in the Gulf of Suez sinks the U.S. merchant ship Steel Seafarer.

September 11 - U.S. Navy ordered to attack any vessel threatening U.S. shipping or ships under U.S. escort.

September 26 - U.S. Navy orders protection of all ships engaged in commerce in U.S. defensive water by patrolling, covering, escorting and by reporting or destroying any German or Italian naval forces encountered.

October 17 - The destroyer USS Kearny (DD-432) is torpedoed and damaged southwest of Iceland.

October 19 - A German U-boat torpedoes and sinks the U.S. merchant ship USS Lehigh off of West Africa.

October 30 - The oiler USS Salinas (AO-19) is torpedoed 700 miles east of Newfoundland. There are no casualties and the ship makes port.

October 31 - The destroyer, USS Ruben James (DD-245) sinks after being torpedoed off of western Iceland. First U.S. Naval vessel lost to enemy action in World War II.

December 3 - Sagadahoc, a U.S. merchant vessel, is torpedoed and sunk in southern Atlantic.
 
Perhaps a bit off-topic, but it's always seemed a bit odd to me that Kimmel and Short were fired after being hit by a surprise attack while MacArthur was caught with his pants down in the Philippines when he already knew about the Pearl Harbor raid.
 
Exactly, and in fact had Roosevelt really wanted an excuse to get involved in the war, he had plenty of incidents to do so without needing to wait on Pearl Harbor.

1941, April 10 - USS Niblack (DD-424) depth charges a German submarine off of Iceland in what is believed to be the first act of war between Germany and the U.S.

April 17 - The German raider Atlantis sinks the Egyptian steamship Zamzam in the south Atlantic. One hundred and fifty Americans are among the passengers rescued.

May 21 - A German U-boat sinks the US freighter Robin Moor.

July 30 - The U.S. river gunboat USS Tutuila (PR-4) is bombed at Chunking, China by Japanese planes.

September 4 - The destroyer USS Greer (DD-145) is attacked but not damaged while tracking a German U-boat 175 miles southwest of Iceland.

September 7 - German air attack in the Gulf of Suez sinks the U.S. merchant ship Steel Seafarer.

September 11 - U.S. Navy ordered to attack any vessel threatening U.S. shipping or ships under U.S. escort.

September 26 - U.S. Navy orders protection of all ships engaged in commerce in U.S. defensive water by patrolling, covering, escorting and by reporting or destroying any German or Italian naval forces encountered.

October 17 - The destroyer USS Kearny (DD-432) is torpedoed and damaged southwest of Iceland.

October 19 - A German U-boat torpedoes and sinks the U.S. merchant ship USS Lehigh off of West Africa.

October 30 - The oiler USS Salinas (AO-19) is torpedoed 700 miles east of Newfoundland. There are no casualties and the ship makes port.

October 31 - The destroyer, USS Ruben James (DD-245) sinks after being torpedoed off of western Iceland. First U.S. Naval vessel lost to enemy action in World War II.

December 3 - Sagadahoc, a U.S. merchant vessel, is torpedoed and sunk in southern Atlantic.

In addition if the Japanese hadn't attack PH the war would still have begun as they attack Guam, US forces in China and Philippines
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom