The Hacking of the American Mind

Skeptical Greg

Agave Wine Connoisseur
Joined
Jul 1, 2002
Messages
21,169
Location
Just past ' Resume Speed ' .
The Hacking of the American Mind:
The Science Behind the Corporate Takeover of Our Bodies and Brains
Robert H. Lustig, M.D

Yes, it's a book, but you can capture the essence of the thesis in this lecture:



Why do investment bankers care whether we are eating carbohydrates or fats?

Fat: The New Health Paradigm

It should be obvious why the pharmaceutical industry is concerned that statins may no longer be golden ticket that it once was.
However, when one door closes, another one opens, and a new drug for the next big self inflicted disease will take up the slack.

The cholesterol and calorie hypotheses are both dead — it is time to focus on the real culprit: insulin resistance


He proposes how the food and tech industries have made us addicted to their products, and provides some compelling science ( IMO ) to back it up.

It is all about dopamine and serotonin.

He discusses how various chemicals ( sugar, drugs )and products ( social media ) trigger dopamine release and create addictions.

Some key points:
1) Reward is not contentment, and pleasure is not happiness
2) Reward is dopamine, and contentment is serotonin
3) Chronic excess reward interferes with contentment
4) Chronic stress drives reward at the expense of contentment
5) Business has intentionally conflated pleasure with happiness,
specifically to get you to buy its junk or engage in hedonistic behaviors
that are profitable to them
6) Government legislation and Supreme Court decisions have made
it easier to buy that junk or engage in those behaviors
7) Individuals and society have become fat, sick, stupid, broke,
addicted, depressed, and most decidedly unhappy

It's hard to look around you and deny that this is happening.

How much do you anticipate returning to these discussions, to see what someone has to say about the intellectual bombshell you just dropped?:D
 
Last edited:
So what's in it for 'them'? That's always the question you need to ask. No answer = no conspiracy.
 
Businesses try very hard to make money!
Consumers are often undereducated fools!
News at eleven.

Not even interesting. Frustrating perhaps, but not interesting.
 
That name looks familiar. Is this the guy who says sugar has magical properties that can violate the calories in vs calories out law?
 

Magic sugar?

He has one thing right, unnecessary/too much sugar is being added to processed foods.

A lot of his stuff sounds quite iffy, but I'm not familiar with it. Corporate conspiracy, no. Consequence of corporate actions sure, Big Pharma has been known to invent diseases (or at least distort them) then promote their products as cures. But an intricately planned CT, :rolleyes:.
 
That name looks familiar. Is this the guy who says sugar has magical properties that can violate the calories in vs calories out law?

I think it does.

Evidence by anecdote time. I was pretty overweight. I weighed about 210 on my not very muscular 5' 8" frame. I ate a lot of junk food. After noticing that I had to pee a lot, I tested my blood sugar. I was diabetic.

I stopped eating high carbohydrate foods in the third week of March. I was pretty fanatic about it. I still ate however much I wanted. I greatly increased my cheese intake, and lots of meat. I never went hungry. I started eating nuts. By the first week in May I weighed 190. By the first week in August, I weighed 175.

I exercised, but not much more than I had previously. I always went to the gym, both before and after the low carb diet. The only thing I did differently was added about a 20 minute walk after dinner if it wasn't raining.

I don't believe in the "calories in, calories out" thing. I tried to lose weight before by cutting calories. It worked, to some extent, but I was always hungry, so the weight came back every time.
 
To address the overall content of the thread, I think it has a conspiratorial tone to it, but in general, I think it contains much truth. I don't think corporations are deliberately "hacking" us to do their bidding, but "their bidding" really is consumption oriented, short term pleasure. Advertising that encourages that sort of behavior really works, so they do it.

I'm not sure this is a "problem" that needs to be solved, or if it's just something that people need to be aware of in their own lives. That way does not result in happiness.
 
I vote for the insulin resistance theory.

Seems the gobs of insulin your pancreas puts out in an attempt to lower your glucose level, act as "insulin like growth factor". It's called "pseudo acromegaly". Seems it's the side effect that all those body builders on steroids get.

The growth factor effect causes bad disks, carpal tunnel, trigger fingers, calcifications, bone lesions, cardiomegaly.myopathy, tendonitis, ligamentopathy, artery lining probs..... I had a list of 45 problems caused by excess "insulin like growth factor".

And it is all genetic, but being synergistic hetrozygosities, hard to pin point the one gene- it's probably several. .
 
Magic sugar?

He has one thing right, unnecessary/too much sugar is being added to processed foods.

A lot of his stuff sounds quite iffy, but I'm not familiar with it. Corporate conspiracy, no. Consequence of corporate actions sure, Big Pharma has been known to invent diseases (or at least distort them) then promote their products as cures. But an intricately planned CT, :rolleyes:.
In the lecture he tries to point out the difference between conspiracy and a plot.

He says there is no collusion ( no conspiracy ), rather the big food companies have the same goal; to make as much money as possible.

There is not as much money in unprocessed, whole foods.

If you have the time, watch the lecture. Let us know which points are ill founded, based on available data.

At 11:59 he says ten well known food conglomerates, control 90% of the worlds food..

Sounds high to me, but 90% of the US food supply doesn't..
 
I think it does.

Evidence by anecdote time. I was pretty overweight. I weighed about 210 on my not very muscular 5' 8" frame. I ate a lot of junk food. After noticing that I had to pee a lot, I tested my blood sugar. I was diabetic.

I stopped eating high carbohydrate foods in the third week of March. I was pretty fanatic about it. I still ate however much I wanted. I greatly increased my cheese intake, and lots of meat. I never went hungry. I started eating nuts. By the first week in May I weighed 190. By the first week in August, I weighed 175.

I exercised, but not much more than I had previously. I always went to the gym, both before and after the low carb diet. The only thing I did differently was added about a 20 minute walk after dinner if it wasn't raining.

I don't believe in the "calories in, calories out" thing. I tried to lose weight before by cutting calories. It worked, to some extent, but I was always hungry, so the weight came back every time.

Fortunately, we don't have to rely on anecdotes:

Reduced-calorie diets result in clinically meaningful weight loss regardless of which macronutrients they emphasize.

http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa0804748#t=article

Significant weight loss was observed with any low-carbohydrate or low-fat diet. Weight loss differences between individual named diets were small. This supports the practice of recommending any diet that a patient will adhere to in order to lose weight.

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/1900510

Several logical consequences of this carbohydrate-insulin model of obesity were recently investigated in a pair of carefully controlled inpatient feeding studies whose results failed to support key model predictions. Therefore, important aspects of carbohydrate-insulin model have been experimentally falsified suggesting that the model is too simplistic. This review describes the current state of the carbohydrate-insulin model and the implications of its recent experimental tests.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28074888

Findings In this randomized clinical trial among 609 overweight adults, weight change over 12 months was not significantly different for participants in the HLF diet group (−5.3 kg) vs the HLC diet group (−6.0 kg), and there was no significant diet-genotype interaction or diet-insulin interaction with 12-month weight loss.

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/2673150?redirect=true

It really is CICO.

Now, it can be argued that certain foods containing refined carbs and sugar being hyper-palatable and high in calories can contribute to overeating, and other foods such as those containing high protein being more satiating can lead to reducing overall calorie consumption when eating ad lib, so some may find a low carb diet easier to adhere to. I think that is what you are saying, but even if true, that doesn't mean CICO is wrong. It is still operating under CICO. You are still losing weight from calorie reduction.

Though in the particular case of Type II Diabetes low carb helps regulate blood sugar in the short term, it is weight loss that seems to be the key to regression.

In conclusion, our study demonstrates that among overweight patients with type 2 diabetes, there was no significant difference in the weight or A1C change in participants after a low-carbohydrate compared with a low-fat diet for 12 months. Participants in both arms achieved an average 3.4% weight reduction but did not reduce A1C. Differences in the short-term effects of each diet were not sustained.

http://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/32/7/1147

xperts like Dr. David Nathan, the director of the diabetes center and clinical research center at Massachusetts General Hospital and a professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School, advise dieting for people with diabetes. But, he said, “when we advise people to be on diets, the major goal is to lose weight.”

What matters the most for controlling diabetes, Dr. Nathan said, “is how much weight you lose.”

https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/16/health/type-2-diabetes-low-carb-diet.html
 
Last edited:
From the article in the OP:

Secondly, although it is true that 80% of the obese population harbour at least one of the diseases of the metabolic syndrome (hypertension, dyslipidaemia, fatty liver disease, and type 2 diabetes), 20% of morbidly obese individuals do not (termed “metabolically healthy obese” or MHO), and have normal life spans[19],[20],[21]. Conversely, up to 40% of normal weight adults harbour the same diseases of the metabolic syndrome, including hypertension, dyslipidaemia, fatty liver disease, and CVD[22],[23]. Thirdly, the secular trend of diabetes in the United States from 1988 to 2012 has demonstrated a 25% increase in prevalence in both the obese and the normal weight population[24]. Thus, obesity, and by inference, caloric balance, does not explain the worldwide pandemic of non-communicable disease. Although obesity is clearly a marker for the pathology, it is clearly not the cause — because normal weight people get metabolic syndrome, too.

This is the anti-QED. He completely ignores that we've known for a decade that Type II has genetic factors, is related to visceral fat, and contains different phenotypes.

In the present study, abdominal obesity defined by WC was associated with significantly higher AI and PWV in diabetic patients; whereas overall obesity defined by BMI did not predict adverse vascular changes in this study population. Abdominal obesity was associated with an adverse effect on blood vessels, independently of age, sex, blood pressure, fasting glucose and BMI. Combination of diabetes mellitus and abdominal obesity, but not overall obesity, was associated with significant deterioration in terms of arterial stiffness parameters.

Findings of the present study concur with recently published data demonstrated stronger association of abdominal obesity than BMI with total mortality among elderly subjects at high risk of cardiovascular disease, particularly among diabetic participants [11]. Additionally, it was shown that the measures of abdominal obesity correlates better than BMI with arterial stiffness evaluated by PWV, and with subclinical atherosclerosis evaluated by C-IMT, in healthy, diabetics and hypertensive subjects [12].

Previous clinical and experimental data show that abdominal adipose tissue can play an important role in the development of diabetes mellitus and it can also increase the risk of cardiovascular and all-cause mortality [13],[14]. Body fat distribution is one of the major determinants of metabolic health, and visceral adiposity has a stronger correlation with metabolic abnormalities and cardiovascular disease than subcutaneous adipose tissue [15]-[17]. Visceral fat is metabolically active and is an important site for adipokines such as adiponectin and leptin, which plays an important role in insulin sensitivity, inflammation, lipid metabolism and atherogenesis. It was shown that low plasma adiponectin levels are significantly correlated with endothelial dysfunction, increased intima media thickness and progression of coronary artery calcification independently of other cardiovascular risk factors [18],[19]. Leptin as well is involved in insulin sensitivity, angiogenesis, vascular and endothelial function [20]. Moreover, novel and traditional cardiovascular risk factors such as asymmetric dimethyl-arginine ADMA levels and LDL-cholesterol are strongly associated with increased arterial stiffness among pre-diabetic subjects [21].

It has been demonstrated that excess body fat, abdominal visceral fat, and larger waist circumference have been associated with accelerated arterial stiffening independently of blood pressure levels, ethnicity and age in older adults [22]. Moreover, both WC and sagittal abdominal diameter (SAD) are associated with subclinical organ damage such as PWV and carotid intima-media thickness and provided information on inflammation, atherosclerosis and arterial stiffness in type 2 diabetic patients [23]. However, it has also been reported that SAD was more independent in predicting arterial stiffness over time, compared with WC, in middle-aged men and women with type 2 diabetes [24], Recently , it has been demonstrated that neck circumference is associated with an increased PWV in hypertensive adults, independent of other metabolic risk factors [25].

https://cardiab.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12933-014-0141-8

Though I regularly defend BMI from people who claim it is "debunked", this is one of those cases where it is misleading, because a large portion of normal BMI people are still overfat, especially centrally.

We found that 29% of subjects classified as lean and 80% of individuals classified as overweight according to BMI had a BF% within the obesity range. Importantly, the levels of cardiometabolic risk factors, such as C-reactive protein, were higher in lean and overweight BMI-classified subjects with BF% within the obesity range (men 4.3±9.2, women 4.9±19.5 mg l−1) as well as in obese BMI-classified individuals (men 4.2±5.5, women 5.1±13.2 mg l−1) compared with lean volunteers with normal body fat amounts (men 0.9±0.5, women 2.1±2.6 mg l−1; P<0.001 for both genders).

https://www.nature.com/articles/ijo2011100

ETA: Also, the "metabolically healthy obesity" notion has been debunked repeatedly.

Metabolically healthy obese individuals had a higher risk of coronary heart disease, cerebrovascular disease, and heart failure than normal weight metabolically healthy individuals. Even individuals who are normal weight can have metabolic abnormalities and similar risks for cardiovascular disease events.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0735109717390502?via=ihub

The increased risk of diabetes in MHO is attributed to the progression to an unhealthier state. "Healthy obesity" is not a permanent situation but a transitory state.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27804254

CONCLUSION:
Compared with metabolically healthy normal-weight individuals, obese persons are at increased risk for adverse long-term outcomes even in the absence of metabolic abnormalities, suggesting that there is no healthy pattern of increased weight.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24297192

Just everything about that paragraph is misleading.
 
Last edited:
It really is CICO.

Now, it can be argued that certain foods containing refined carbs and sugar being hyper-palatable and high in calories can contribute to overeating, and other foods such as those containing high protein being more satiating can lead to reducing overall calorie consumption when eating ad lib, so some may find a low carb diet easier to adhere to. I think that is what you are saying, but even if true, that doesn't mean CICO is wrong.

Since I wasn't counting calories during that period of my life, it is conceivable that I actually significantly reduced my calorie consumption, without being aware of it. I can't rule that out.

What I can say for certain is that I ate a whole bunch of ham, cheese, steak, nuts, pork chops, and chili, whereas before I had eaten a lot sandwiches, pasta, and potato chips, and I lost 20 pounds the first month, without being hungry. Maybe all that cheese really didn't have as many calories as I thought.

I have gone on diets before where I lost a lot of weight by counting calories, but it was a lot of effort, because I was hungry, and the weight came back when some development in my life made me fall off the diet.

As noted, it is entirely anecdotal. Your mileage may vary.

In some sense, if you are right that I must have been cutting calories without realizing it, it really would support some of the OP's contentions. We are surrounded by high carb food that is easy to eat. Go into your local 7-11 and imagine yourself on a low carb diet. It's kind of difficult to eat.

However, I don't buy the somewhat conspiratorial nature of the OP, suggesting that companies steer us toward junk food and away from whole foods because the junk food is more profitable. I think companies are responding to consumer demand. We want food that is simple and cheap. The high shelf life and easy packaging makes high carb food fill those needs very well. You don't need to cook Twinkies, and if you can buy enough for a whole month at a time. (And then do it next week again because you ate the twinkies in a week.)
 
A nice paper that ties all that in together (MetS=Metabolic Syndrome, NWO=Normal Weight Obesity, not New World Order):

Relationship between NWO and metabolic
syndrome(MetS)

There is increased risk for MetS and each one of its
components with NWO. Romero-Corral et al20 demonstrated
that individuals classified as NWO had a prevalence of MetS 4-
fold higher than people also with normal BMI but normal BF %.
NWO adults also had an increased prevalence of dyslipidemia,
DM, hyperglycemia without DM, central obesity and HTN.
When divided by sex, women were particularly affected, as
women in the highest tertile were about 8 times more likely to
have MetS than those in the lowest tertile of BF. This study also
proved that the prevalence of MetS and of its individual
components increased as the BF content increased in men
and women (Figs 2 and 3). After adjusting for sex, age, and race/
ethnicity, body fat was associated with higher odds of having
MetS (OR = 1.11, 95% CI 1.09–1.14, for each % point of BF).

A cohort study from Brazil including 1,222 subjects
between 23 and 25 years old proved the earlier findings that
NWO was associated with MetS and insulin resistance.40 In
this study, NWO was significantly associated with risk for
MetS (OR = 6.83; 95% CI 2.84–16.47) and with the homeostasis
model assessment (HOMA) 2–insulin resistance (OR = 3.81;
95% CI 1.57–9.28), low insulin sensitivity (OR = 3.89; 95% CI
2.39–6.33) and high insulin secretion (OR = 2.17; 95% CI
1.24–3.80). This study also showed significant association
between NWO and some elements of the MetS, such as high
WC (OR = 8.46; 95% CI 5.09–14.04), low HDL cholesterol (OR =
1.65; 95% CI 1.11–2.47) and high triglyceride levels (OR = 1.93;
95% CI 1.02–3.64).

Normal weight with central obesity and prognosis
in coronary artery disease

Increasing central obesity is linked to higher mortality in
adults with or without CHD, even in those with normal BMI.41
Normal weight with central obesity as determined by WC or
WHR in adults with CHD is associated with the highest risk of
mortality,41,42 compared with subjects with normal BMI and
no central obesity and with obese patients by BMI regardless
of their central obesity status. Furthermore, the obesity
paradox, where people with CHD and obesity by BMI have
shown better prognosis than those with normal weight, does
not occur when obesity is determined by the fat distribution.41
While higher BMI relates to better prognosis in CHD patients,
higher WC or WHR is directly related to higher mortality risk.
Those findings may be explained at least in part because BMI
has shown a poor diagnostic accuracy to identify excessive
adiposity in adults with CHD.43 Hence, WC and WHR
measured in CHD patients will better help to stratify and
develop therapeutic guidelines for fat loss.41

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24438734
 
Since I wasn't counting calories during that period of my life, it is conceivable that I actually significantly reduced my calorie consumption, without being aware of it. I can't rule that out.

What I can say for certain is that I ate a whole bunch of ham, cheese, steak, nuts, pork chops, and chili, whereas before I had eaten a lot sandwiches, pasta, and potato chips, and I lost 20 pounds the first month, without being hungry. Maybe all that cheese really didn't have as many calories as I thought.

I have gone on diets before where I lost a lot of weight by counting calories, but it was a lot of effort, because I was hungry, and the weight came back when some development in my life made me fall off the diet.

As noted, it is entirely anecdotal. Your mileage may vary.

In some sense, if you are right that I must have been cutting calories without realizing it, it really would support some of the OP's contentions. We are surrounded by high carb food that is easy to eat. Go into your local 7-11 and imagine yourself on a low carb diet. It's kind of difficult to eat.

However, I don't buy the somewhat conspiratorial nature of the OP, suggesting that companies steer us toward junk food and away from whole foods because the junk food is more profitable. I think companies are responding to consumer demand. We want food that is simple and cheap. The high shelf life and easy packaging makes high carb food fill those needs very well. You don't need to cook Twinkies, and if you can buy enough for a whole month at a time. (And then do it next week again because you ate the twinkies in a week.)

On the other hand, the major food companies definitely do have food scientists working to find the right combinations of hyper-palatable combinations to be enticing, but not satiating. Michael Moss detailed this a few years back in Salt Sugar Fat. I think he was similarly hyperbolic in making the foods sound addictive like narcotics, but there is definitely a lot of research and work going into making foods hyper-palatable, rather than nutritious or promoting a balanced diet, which is definitely due to profit motive.

On the other other hand, does consumer demand have a responsibility? Especially with the calls we see for the various fads, organic, etc. It makes you wonder. On the other other hand, food companies market to children and prey on uninformed consumers and indulge and promote whatever fad or misinformation they can.
 
In the lecture he tries to point out the difference between conspiracy and a plot.

He says there is no collusion ( no conspiracy ), rather the big food companies have the same goal; to make as much money as possible.

Newsflash: That is the goal of all businesses.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom