imminent merger of supermassive black holes?

lomiller

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jul 31, 2007
Messages
13,208
And by immanent I mean not sometime in the next million years. If the model is correct it will happen sometime this year!


https://www.science.org/content/article/crash-titans-imminent-merger-giant-black-holes-predicted


The researchers confirmed the month long oscillation in x-ray observations from NASA’s orbiting Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory. If this decreasing trend continues, the black holes, which Jiang says come as close to each other as the Sun is to Pluto, will merge in the next 100 to 300 days, they report in the paper, which has not been peer reviewed.
 

And that oscillation means they currently take just one month to orbit at that distance.
I'm not sure what you mean here.

They've been watching these black holes get closer and closer together and now they've reached the point where it's predicted to happen within a year or less.

I just watched a video on this, I'll look for it.

This link says This could occur as soon as 100 days, or up to three years from now.
The separation between the two black holes was getting more narrow, changing from one light year to one light month within three years of observations.

“Normally, you’d imagine the separation between the binary is still large so that the period shouldn’t change during the observation period,” Yang says. “But this signal is unique. The period just changed so rapidly in time in a way that was never seen before.”

There is an expected light (or x-ray or infrared) show. But interestingly the LIGO which has caught gravitational waves from other black hole mergers won't see these gravitational waves because they will be too large. EDITED TO ADD: I could be mixing memories about the wave detection with LIGO. I watch a lot of science videos. Resolved.

I found the video. I'll post it next after I find the minute to listen to as it covers a lot of space news.
 
Last edited:
1.2 billion light years away.

So there's a possibility that we will see something in the next 100 to 300 days, or maybe a bit more, that happened 1.2 billion years ago.

And....we can see it. Or at least detect it.


Technology is incredible.
 


It's a tad tedious because the astrophysicist (Dr Becky) explains the basics with every bit of sky news. She cites the merger possibly happening between 100 and 300 days. IOW in 2022.

The graph and the specific details on the predicted merger start at ~18:00.

But for a bit longer discussion of Yang's paper on these black holes leading up to the predicted merger it starts at 16:44.


Here's the paper: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2201.11633.pdf
 
Last edited:


It's a tad tedious because the astrophysicist (Dr Becky) explains the basics with every bit of sky news. She cites the merger possibly happening between 100 and 300 days. IOW in 2022.

The graph and the specific details on the predicted merger start at ~18:00.

But for a bit longer discussion of Yang's paper on these black holes leading up to the predicted merger it starts at 16:44.


Here's the paper: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2201.11633.pdf

If you open the video and hover the mouse over the timeline, it pops up a description of the content in each marked section
 
If you open the video and hover the mouse over the timeline, it pops up a description of the content in each marked section

And time stamps are in the description.

I often watch Dr Becky's videos, so I actually already saw this one. Well, I skipped over some of it and just clicked on the time stamps that interested me.

Yeah, she also did mention that the gravitational waves this produces will be too big for LIGO to detect.
 
Thanks for reassuring me my memory was correct, Puppycow.

I should probably have linked to the web site of the video. The menu is described in two different ways.
00:00 - Introduction
00:39 - Spot Jupiter while you can
01:24 - Morning sky planets
01:55 - Crescent moon, Venus & Mars 27/2
02:55 - Venus greatest elongation 20/3
03:33 - JWST update
04:40 - JWST first image!
07:48 - ISS de-orbit
08:58 - IAU collective against satellite constellations
11:23 - Intermediate mass black hole in Andromeda?
16:18 - New Saturn rotation rate study
16:43 - Imminent supermassive black hole merger
22:38 - Brilliant
24:02 - Bloopers
The other way is with pictures of Dr Becky.

I haven't seen her other videos. The speed with which she gets to the point is a tad too slow for my impatient taste. I was looking for something else to watch after I've run out of World Science Festival videos (those are great), Neil Degrasse Tyson's Star Talk, Asimov Memorial Debates, and the Origins videos with Lawrence Krauss and a few other misc videos on Neanderthals (another good topic as new things have been discovered) and mass extinctions.
 
...snip..

Yeah, she also did mention that the gravitational waves this produces will be too big for LIGO to detect.

There is some irony in that - we have built these incredible sensitive sensors, an amazing feat of technology to detect these minute fluctuations and this one comes along which probably could be detected with a bit of cable and 2 tin cans!
 
There is some irony in that - we have built these incredible sensitive sensors, an amazing feat of technology to detect these minute fluctuations and this one comes along which probably could be detected with a bit of cable and 2 tin cans!

Or the accelerometer on an iPhone.

Dave
 
Presumably the gravitational waves have been travelling for 1.2 billion years and will arrive simultaneously with our detection of the actual merger. Given that scientists know they will likely be here soon, and they are expected to be too big for detection by LIGO, is there any other technology available to detect and record them (besides iphones ;))?
 
I'm not sure what you mean here.
I mean that they take a month to orbit each other. I wanted to make that more obvious than the article did. These two huge objects that are at the same distance as the Sun and Pluto take just a single month to orbit each other at the moment.
 
I mean that they take a month to orbit each other. I wanted to make that more obvious than the article did. These two huge objects that are at the same distance as the Sun and Pluto take just a single month to orbit each other at the moment.

Let’s see… Pluto’s orbit is very eccentric between ~30 and ~50AU. Say the black holes are 40AU (~6x10^12 m) from each other orbiting a barycenter directly between them. Assuming a circular orbit to make it easy, they travel pi*40AU every orbit, which only takes one month = 30*24*60*60 = 2.6x10^6 seconds. So they’re moving 6x10^12*pi / 2.6*10^6 = ~7500 km/s = 2.5% of light speed. Now that’s scootin!
 
Presumably the gravitational waves have been travelling for 1.2 billion years and will arrive simultaneously with our detection of the actual merger. Given that scientists know they will likely be here soon, and they are expected to be too big for detection by LIGO, is there any other technology available to detect and record them (besides iphones ;))?

Good question, but I don't know. Dr Becky said no, and she would more about it than me because black holes are what she specializes in.

Wikipedia says you would need a space interferometer.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravitational_wave

800px-The_Gravitational_wave_spectrum_Sources_and_Detectors.jpg



I mean that they take a month to orbit each other. I wanted to make that more obvious than the article did. These two huge objects that are at the same distance as the Sun and Pluto take just a single month to orbit each other at the moment.

And the period is getting faster and faster as they circle into each other. Really amazing stuff.
 
Let’s see… Pluto’s orbit is very eccentric between ~30 and ~50AU. Say the black holes are 40AU (~6x10^12 m) from each other orbiting a barycenter directly between them. Assuming a circular orbit to make it easy, they travel pi*40AU every orbit, which only takes one month = 30*24*60*60 = 2.6x10^6 seconds. So they’re moving 6x10^12*pi / 2.6*10^6 = ~7500 km/s = 2.5% of light speed. Now that’s scootin!

And the party is just getting started!
 
And time stamps are in the description.

I often watch Dr Becky's videos, so I actually already saw this one. Well, I skipped over some of it and just clicked on the time stamps that interested me.

Yeah, she also did mention that the gravitational waves this produces will be too big for LIGO to detect.


I think the issue is that the black holes themselves are so large they that when they merge they will probably be orbiting at distances comparable to the Earth orbits the Sun. Even at near light speed an orbit this long takes 30+ seconds so the wavelength is too long for LIGO to detect.
 
Presumably the gravitational waves have been travelling for 1.2 billion years and will arrive simultaneously with our detection of the actual merger. Given that scientists know they will likely be here soon, and they are expected to be too big for detection by LIGO, is there any other technology available to detect and record them (besides iphones ;))?
Good question, but I don't know. Dr Becky said no, and she would more about it than me because black holes are what she specializes in. ...
Now I can help you! :D

In the video Dr Becky noted we will be able to if we put a LIGO detector in space where the distance between the detectors could be large enough.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunately space based gravity wave detection isn't in the cards for this decade, never mind this year.
 
is there any other technology available to detect and record them (besides iphones ;))?

Presumably every massive object in the universe will record them since gravity interacts with all mass. Whether or not there are any suitable objects that could be measured soon enough with available instruments is beyond me though.
 
Let’s see… Pluto’s orbit is very eccentric between ~30 and ~50AU. Say the black holes are 40AU (~6x10^12 m) from each other orbiting a barycenter directly between them. Assuming a circular orbit to make it easy, they travel pi*40AU every orbit, which only takes one month = 30*24*60*60 = 2.6x10^6 seconds. So they’re moving 6x10^12*pi / 2.6*10^6 = ~7500 km/s = 2.5% of light speed. Now that’s scootin!

The separation between the two black holes was getting more narrow, changing from one light year to one light month within three years of observations.

Wait - they moved together 11/12ths of a light year in three years? So that's ~30%c in radial velocity to add to the 2.5%c of angular velocity.

That's rapid. Is this the fastest massive object(s) ever observed?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom