HypnoPsi
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Aug 31, 2004
- Messages
- 1,422
All that we can ever know exists is our own consciousness. We can't know matter in the same way that we know our "Self". Instead, all we can experience of matter is sensory information appearing in our minds.
Reminising back to the "Must a Skeptic also be an Athiest" thread, it's true that a "total skeptic" would have to abandon all faith in everything and thus be a solipsist, which I doubt is workable for most of us. But no matter how unpalatable some of you skeptics (and/or possibly Atheists) might find it, it requires faith to beleive that matter actually exists "out there" - a faith that might not be well founded given the superstring theorists' ideas about matter actually being the vibrations produced from superstrings or something strange like that.
Now ask yourself about consciousness: have you ever seen/felt a consciousness be born or die? I haven't, and I certainly don't remember being born myself nor have I ever "died" to my recollection. To believe that we came into existence when our bodies were born and will cease to exist when our bodies die requires faith, because we have no personal knowledge of such a change in state being possible.
All we do actually have personal knowledge of is of the "Self" and the "Other" - the sense of "There Is" that is permanently enjoined to the sense of "I Am". In my consciousness, and I'm assuming you're all the same (if you guys even exist
), there is a "conscious field" with a sense of "Self" at the "centre" of it: the "There Is" (existence) and the "I Am" (existing).
Some call that "Other" "God" and some call it "Allah". Another group calls it "Lord Buddha" or "Nirvana" while yet others, who Richard Dawkins wanted to memetically imprint upon us as "Brights", call it the "Flying Spaghetti Monster".
We even "think" and/or "talk" to that sense of "There Is" at night when we're wondering what we'll do tomorrow.... about X. Some people even address that sense of "Other-thing-ness" in the late evening in a personal way by saying "Now I lay me down to sleep..." and "Our Father, who..." in the morning.
Simply put, we have a much more intimate knowledge of both the "Self-thing-ness" and the "Other-thing-ness" than we can ever hope to achieve of any other objects that might appear in our consciousness from "out there".
This means that, ultimately, skepticism and materialistic science is the faith that matter is actually "out there" and is "real". Faith, not knowledge. It's not something directly and intimately experiencable like the "Self-ness" or the "Other-ness" that exists in consciousness.
So, no skeptic is starting from a blank slate, from a default position. Materialism is a belief system - even if it's consistently replicable and reliable that the sun will appear every morning as calculations predict. It's all additional to the default position. It's all additional knowledge that had to be taught explained to someone that they had to personally become convinced is the one real "truth" above all others.
Ultimately skepticism and materialistic science is just another faith like Christianity, Islam, Judaisim, etc., because between the two realities claimed to exist "Consciousness" and the "Material" world we only know with absolute certainty that one of them exists - "Consciousness".
In fact, let's take things even further. By believing in "matter" as primary and consciousness either as secondary/transitory or as an illusion (to whom exactly?) atheists are basically placing their faith in a God, albeit a non-intelligent and determanistic one. But it's still a supernatural God because it's extra to our only known nature - Consciousness.
Atheism isn't like being bald, it's more like wearing a wig.
_
HypnoPsi
Reminising back to the "Must a Skeptic also be an Athiest" thread, it's true that a "total skeptic" would have to abandon all faith in everything and thus be a solipsist, which I doubt is workable for most of us. But no matter how unpalatable some of you skeptics (and/or possibly Atheists) might find it, it requires faith to beleive that matter actually exists "out there" - a faith that might not be well founded given the superstring theorists' ideas about matter actually being the vibrations produced from superstrings or something strange like that.
Now ask yourself about consciousness: have you ever seen/felt a consciousness be born or die? I haven't, and I certainly don't remember being born myself nor have I ever "died" to my recollection. To believe that we came into existence when our bodies were born and will cease to exist when our bodies die requires faith, because we have no personal knowledge of such a change in state being possible.
All we do actually have personal knowledge of is of the "Self" and the "Other" - the sense of "There Is" that is permanently enjoined to the sense of "I Am". In my consciousness, and I'm assuming you're all the same (if you guys even exist
Some call that "Other" "God" and some call it "Allah". Another group calls it "Lord Buddha" or "Nirvana" while yet others, who Richard Dawkins wanted to memetically imprint upon us as "Brights", call it the "Flying Spaghetti Monster".
We even "think" and/or "talk" to that sense of "There Is" at night when we're wondering what we'll do tomorrow.... about X. Some people even address that sense of "Other-thing-ness" in the late evening in a personal way by saying "Now I lay me down to sleep..." and "Our Father, who..." in the morning.
Simply put, we have a much more intimate knowledge of both the "Self-thing-ness" and the "Other-thing-ness" than we can ever hope to achieve of any other objects that might appear in our consciousness from "out there".
This means that, ultimately, skepticism and materialistic science is the faith that matter is actually "out there" and is "real". Faith, not knowledge. It's not something directly and intimately experiencable like the "Self-ness" or the "Other-ness" that exists in consciousness.
So, no skeptic is starting from a blank slate, from a default position. Materialism is a belief system - even if it's consistently replicable and reliable that the sun will appear every morning as calculations predict. It's all additional to the default position. It's all additional knowledge that had to be taught explained to someone that they had to personally become convinced is the one real "truth" above all others.
Ultimately skepticism and materialistic science is just another faith like Christianity, Islam, Judaisim, etc., because between the two realities claimed to exist "Consciousness" and the "Material" world we only know with absolute certainty that one of them exists - "Consciousness".
In fact, let's take things even further. By believing in "matter" as primary and consciousness either as secondary/transitory or as an illusion (to whom exactly?) atheists are basically placing their faith in a God, albeit a non-intelligent and determanistic one. But it's still a supernatural God because it's extra to our only known nature - Consciousness.
Atheism isn't like being bald, it's more like wearing a wig.
_
HypnoPsi
