Skepticism as faith based cult of indoctrination?

HypnoPsi

Graduate Poster
Joined
Aug 31, 2004
Messages
1,422
All that we can ever know exists is our own consciousness. We can't know matter in the same way that we know our "Self". Instead, all we can experience of matter is sensory information appearing in our minds.

Reminising back to the "Must a Skeptic also be an Athiest" thread, it's true that a "total skeptic" would have to abandon all faith in everything and thus be a solipsist, which I doubt is workable for most of us. But no matter how unpalatable some of you skeptics (and/or possibly Atheists) might find it, it requires faith to beleive that matter actually exists "out there" - a faith that might not be well founded given the superstring theorists' ideas about matter actually being the vibrations produced from superstrings or something strange like that.

Now ask yourself about consciousness: have you ever seen/felt a consciousness be born or die? I haven't, and I certainly don't remember being born myself nor have I ever "died" to my recollection. To believe that we came into existence when our bodies were born and will cease to exist when our bodies die requires faith, because we have no personal knowledge of such a change in state being possible.

All we do actually have personal knowledge of is of the "Self" and the "Other" - the sense of "There Is" that is permanently enjoined to the sense of "I Am". In my consciousness, and I'm assuming you're all the same (if you guys even exist :)), there is a "conscious field" with a sense of "Self" at the "centre" of it: the "There Is" (existence) and the "I Am" (existing).

Some call that "Other" "God" and some call it "Allah". Another group calls it "Lord Buddha" or "Nirvana" while yet others, who Richard Dawkins wanted to memetically imprint upon us as "Brights", call it the "Flying Spaghetti Monster".

We even "think" and/or "talk" to that sense of "There Is" at night when we're wondering what we'll do tomorrow.... about X. Some people even address that sense of "Other-thing-ness" in the late evening in a personal way by saying "Now I lay me down to sleep..." and "Our Father, who..." in the morning.

Simply put, we have a much more intimate knowledge of both the "Self-thing-ness" and the "Other-thing-ness" than we can ever hope to achieve of any other objects that might appear in our consciousness from "out there".

This means that, ultimately, skepticism and materialistic science is the faith that matter is actually "out there" and is "real". Faith, not knowledge. It's not something directly and intimately experiencable like the "Self-ness" or the "Other-ness" that exists in consciousness.

So, no skeptic is starting from a blank slate, from a default position. Materialism is a belief system - even if it's consistently replicable and reliable that the sun will appear every morning as calculations predict. It's all additional to the default position. It's all additional knowledge that had to be taught explained to someone that they had to personally become convinced is the one real "truth" above all others.

Ultimately skepticism and materialistic science is just another faith like Christianity, Islam, Judaisim, etc., because between the two realities claimed to exist "Consciousness" and the "Material" world we only know with absolute certainty that one of them exists - "Consciousness".

In fact, let's take things even further. By believing in "matter" as primary and consciousness either as secondary/transitory or as an illusion (to whom exactly?) atheists are basically placing their faith in a God, albeit a non-intelligent and determanistic one. But it's still a supernatural God because it's extra to our only known nature - Consciousness.

Atheism isn't like being bald, it's more like wearing a wig.
_
HypnoPsi
 
First of all, why lump together skepticism and "materialistic science," whatever that is? Who says we must be materialists to be skeptical of either sense or nonsense? What if I've just gone back to my college days and been seduced once again by the pragmatists, thus doubting the existence of matter, and pretty well writing off the existence of consciousness? Must I now tear the epaulets off of my skeptic's uniform and start going to Bible classes? I hope not.

An awful lot of words to come up with the realization that everybody has to believe something. So skeptics believe that the universe, insofar as it exists at all, is rational? Wow! Go figure!
 
I might as well (found I had it filed, heheh):

MRC_Hans' practical test of Solipsism .(tm)
Disclaimer: This experiment might not only bruise your ego, but also your body, so you undertake it entirely at your own risk. I will not be held responsible for any consequences, including, but not limited to, loss of pride, peace of mind, teeth, etc.
1) Find a busy city street.
2) Wait for large aggressive looking male to walk by (generally, the more tattoos, the better).
3) Walk up behind said large aggressive looking male and direct a solid kick at the lower, rear portion of his body.
4) When he turns, tell him: "That was because you mother is so ugly".
5) Observe.
You will now have tangible evidence for the following:
a) You exist physically.
b) At least one other entity exists physically.
c) You and that other entity are in communication, both abstractly and physically.
d) The other entity probably has a mother.
You may conclude that all your observations are, after all, part of an illusion, but the experience should convince you that you had better treat the illusion as reality .
Good luck!
Hans :D
 
If your definition of the world "real" is such that things which have tremendous impact on your life can nevertheless fail to qualify as "real", then your definition of "real" is not a terribly useful one.

If, however, your definition of "real" is such that anything which affects you is necessarily "real", then the question of whether the physical world is "real" or not is trivial. Of course it is.

I consider all of this nonsense of worrying about whether the external world is "real" or not to be a ridiculous waste of time. What we should be worried about is how it works. Whether or not it conforms to some silly and arbitrary metaphysical definition of "real" that some armchair philosopher with too much free-time has dreamed up, is of absolutely no importance.


Dr. Stupid
 
All that we can ever know exists is our own consciousness. We can't know matter in the same way that we know our "Self". Instead, all we can experience of matter is sensory information appearing in our minds.

Reminising back to the "Must a Skeptic also be an Athiest" thread, it's true that a "total skeptic" would have to abandon all faith in everything and thus be a solipsist, which I doubt is workable for most of us. But no matter how unpalatable some of you skeptics (and/or possibly Atheists) might find it, it requires faith to beleive that matter actually exists "out there" - a faith that might not be well founded given the superstring theorists' ideas about matter actually being the vibrations produced from superstrings or something strange like that.

Now ask yourself about consciousness: have you ever seen/felt a consciousness be born or die? I haven't, and I certainly don't remember being born myself nor have I ever "died" to my recollection. To believe that we came into existence when our bodies were born and will cease to exist when our bodies die requires faith, because we have no personal knowledge of such a change in state being possible.

All we do actually have personal knowledge of is of the "Self" and the "Other" - the sense of "There Is" that is permanently enjoined to the sense of "I Am". In my consciousness, and I'm assuming you're all the same (if you guys even exist :)), there is a "conscious field" with a sense of "Self" at the "centre" of it: the "There Is" (existence) and the "I Am" (existing).

Some call that "Other" "God" and some call it "Allah". Another group calls it "Lord Buddha" or "Nirvana" while yet others, who Richard Dawkins wanted to memetically imprint upon us as "Brights", call it the "Flying Spaghetti Monster".

We even "think" and/or "talk" to that sense of "There Is" at night when we're wondering what we'll do tomorrow.... about X. Some people even address that sense of "Other-thing-ness" in the late evening in a personal way by saying "Now I lay me down to sleep..." and "Our Father, who..." in the morning.

Simply put, we have a much more intimate knowledge of both the "Self-thing-ness" and the "Other-thing-ness" than we can ever hope to achieve of any other objects that might appear in our consciousness from "out there".

This means that, ultimately, skepticism and materialistic science is the faith that matter is actually "out there" and is "real". Faith, not knowledge. It's not something directly and intimately experiencable like the "Self-ness" or the "Other-ness" that exists in consciousness.

So, no skeptic is starting from a blank slate, from a default position. Materialism is a belief system - even if it's consistently replicable and reliable that the sun will appear every morning as calculations predict. It's all additional to the default position. It's all additional knowledge that had to be taught explained to someone that they had to personally become convinced is the one real "truth" above all others.

Ultimately skepticism and materialistic science is just another faith like Christianity, Islam, Judaisim, etc., because between the two realities claimed to exist "Consciousness" and the "Material" world we only know with absolute certainty that one of them exists - "Consciousness".

In fact, let's take things even further. By believing in "matter" as primary and consciousness either as secondary/transitory or as an illusion (to whom exactly?) atheists are basically placing their faith in a God, albeit a non-intelligent and determanistic one. But it's still a supernatural God because it's extra to our only known nature - Consciousness.

Atheism isn't like being bald, it's more like wearing a wig.
_
HypnoPsi


On what planet is this freshman dorm room rant even remotely interesting?

"Hey man...how do I know that the color pink to you is the color pink to me?"

"Yeah, dude. It's like, how do we know anything? I mean, are we really just sitting here talking, or are we just figments of some dude's imagination?"

"Dude, that's soooo freakin' deep. Can you pass me the bong, bro?"

Who has time for this kind of babble?
 
Last edited:
Let's go with the often heard claim that Randi is Our Leader and No Skeptic Dare Criticize Him. Here's Shermer's list of cult signs:
  • Veneration of the Leader: Excessive glorification to the point of virtual sainthood or divinity.
    Response: Randi sure takes his share of criticism, especially on this board. I can't think of anyone who doesn't have at least one point of criticism. Randi even encourages that people find flaws - so they can be corrected.

  • Inerrancy of the Leader: Belief that he or she cannot be wrong.
    Response: Randi himself is the very first to admit when he is wrong - as he sometimes is.

  • Omniscience of the Leader: Acceptance of beliefs and pronouncements on virtually all subjects, from the philosophical to the trivial.
    Response: Randi is also the first to admit that he lacks knowledge about something. Hence, his insistence on including experts for the Challenge.

  • Persuasive Techniques: Methods used to recruit new followers and reinforce current beliefs.
    Response: OK, you got me there: Randi does use incredibly persuasive techniques. He insists on evidence. Dang!

  • Hidden Agendas: Potential recruits and the public are not given a full disclosure of the true nature of the group's beliefs and plans.
    Response: On the contrary, skeptics are rather insistent in telling people what skepticism is about. There are no hidden agendas. Say "hidden" to a skeptic, and he will say "show me".

  • Deceit: Recruits and followers are not told everything about the leader and the group's inner circle, particularly flaws or potentially embarrassing events or circumstances.
    Response: JREF is a not-for-profit organization and is therefore subjected to openness. Do we know what Randi has for breakfast? No, we don't. Does it matter? Judging from the pauvre standard of The American Breakfast, I'd rather not know.

  • Financial and/or Sexual Exploitation: Recruits and followers are persuaded to invest in the group, and the leader may develop sexual relations with one or more of the followers.
    Response: While JREF does ask for contributions, it is no different from what any other such organization would do. It takes money to run an organization, and the contributions are asked for, not demanded. Randi himself hates asking people for money - Karl (Schellenberger, Linda's husband), OTOH, is one efficient auctioneer...

  • Absolute Truth: Belief that the leader and/or group has a method of discovering final knowledge on any number of subjects.
    Response: Like other skeptics, Randi believes that the scientific method is so far the best method to describe the natural world. If something better comes along, great.

  • Absolute Morality: Belief that the leader and/or the group have developed a system of right and wrong thought and action applicable to members and nonmembers alike. Those who strictly follow the moral code may become and remain members, those who do not are dismissed or punished.
    Response: There is only "evidence" or "no evidence". Skeptics all over the world have all sorts of morals and political beliefs. Anyone familiar with this forum will know this!

So, no: Skepticsm is not a faith based cult on par with religions like Christianity, Islam, Judaism etc.
 
[derail]

Do we know what Randi has for breakfast? No, we don't. Does it matter? Judging from the pauvre standard of The American Breakfast, I'd rather not know.

Claus,
Tell me you're joking! I love Europe, and I love your insights here, but when a man insults another man's breakfast foods.....watch out!!

You haven't lived until you've eaten eggs over-easy, crispy hash-browns, bacon, sausage, and toast in a greasy roadside diner in the middle of nowhere.

Two words...Yum-my!!! ;)

[/derail]
 
I might as well (found I had it filed, heheh):

MRC_Hans' practical test of Solipsism .(tm)
Disclaimer: This experiment might not only bruise your ego, but also your body, so you undertake it entirely at your own risk. I will not be held responsible for any consequences, including, but not limited to, loss of pride, peace of mind, teeth, etc.
1) Find a busy city street.
2) Wait for large aggressive looking male to walk by (generally, the more tattoos, the better).
3) Walk up behind said large aggressive looking male and direct a solid kick at the lower, rear portion of his body.
4) When he turns, tell him: "That was because you mother is so ugly".
5) Observe.
You will now have tangible evidence for the following:
a) You exist physically.
b) At least one other entity exists physically.
c) You and that other entity are in communication, both abstractly and physically.
d) The other entity probably has a mother.
You may conclude that all your observations are, after all, part of an illusion, but the experience should convince you that you had better treat the illusion as reality .
Good luck!
Hans :D

Or, perform the The Krazy Kat Experiment... ;)
 
First of all, why lump together skepticism and "materialistic science," whatever that is? Who says we must be materialists to be skeptical of either sense or nonsense?
I used the words "materialistic science" in an atheist context though I realise that's obviously not the only way the words can be used.
What if I've just gone back to my college days and been seduced once again by the pragmatists, thus doubting the existence of matter, and pretty well writing off the existence of consciousness? Must I now tear the epaulets off of my skeptic's uniform and start going to Bible classes? I hope not.
That's up to you, but I wouldn't say that going to Bible classes (or Zen classes or Koran classes) is necessary. All I'm saying is that while consciousness is directly experienced - matter is not.
An awful lot of words to come up with the realization that everybody has to believe something. So skeptics believe that the universe, insofar as it exists at all, is rational? Wow! Go figure!
The point isn't so much about "skeptics" in general, as it is more about a specific variety of "skeptic" - "atheists", those who are skeptical as to the existence of "God(s)".

What I'm basically doing is countering the most common assumption(s) that we usually see coming from atheists: one, that 'atheism' as opposed to 'theism' is the default position; two, that the 'belief' in 'God' has to be taught and three, that 'atheism' is not just another faith.

Unless we're talking about Buddhists, then I think, for talking sense, we can agree that atheists (particularly in the western hemisphere) are 'materialistically' orientated in their thinking. Basically meaning they believe "when you're dead, you're dead" and that "the brain produces consciousness".

"Self" can only exist in reference to a sense of "Otherness" - or else all would be considered as "self". To the atheist, not only is that "Self" an illusion but imbuing the sense of "Otherness" in our minds with "Dear God...", "Our Father...", "Lord Buddha...", etc., etc., is actually socially constructed. Atheists believe it is literally taught to us via parents and institutions, etc., and that a no-God state is the original state.

Now, I'm obviously not going to argue that we're not all taught our native languages and the concepts they contain, but I am arguing that when it comes to the real "default position" it is certainly not "atheism".

It is instead the case that our original condition is one of "I Am" and a sense of "Otherness" in relation to that "self". Everything else is secondary or tertiary. We can't know "matter" in the way that we can know "consciousness" - all we have is (selective) sensory experience appearing in consciousness. (Which, notably, doesn't include everything. We don't sense the ultraviolet or infrared, nor do we sense high pitched sound.) We don't have any 'knowledge' of coming into existence or of dying either.

Atheism is considerably more demanding in terms of faith than all the other faiths that abound because it requires it's adherents to believe that what they have direct knowledge of (what they can only have direct knowledge of) is a trick and what they have no direct knowledge of (what they cannot ever have direct knowledge of), matter, is real.
_
HypnoPsi
 
Hypnopsi, I read your post with great interest. It has given me much to think about and it offers me a new perspective on life. By and large I fully agree with what you say however I am perplexed by one point. What colour is the wig ?
A very good question, Lothian. Some people believe its an Elvis wig, but they're just heretics and you shouldn't listen to them. I can catagorically state that it's a plain old grey lawyers wig. No doubt about it at all.
_
HypnoPsi
 
Ghost in the machine, HypnoPsi.

And how does materialism relate to atheism?
 
A very good question, Lothian. Some people believe its an Elvis wig, but they're just heretics and you shouldn't listen to them. I can catagorically state that it's a plain old grey lawyers wig. No doubt about it at all.
_
HypnoPsi
Grey Lawyers wig? I am not sure about this and will have to mullet over. I don’t want toupee lip service to this issue.
 
If Consciousness existed alone and did everything, it would annihilate itself. Existence is contrast.
 
[derail]



Claus,
Tell me you're joking! I love Europe, and I love your insights here, but when a man insults another man's breakfast foods.....watch out!!

You haven't lived until you've eaten eggs over-easy, crispy hash-browns, bacon, sausage, and toast in a greasy roadside diner in the middle of nowhere.

Two words...Yum-my!!! ;)

[/derail]

That's what we feed our pigs with.
 
If your definition of the world "real" is such that things which have tremendous impact on your life can nevertheless fail to qualify as "real", then your definition of "real" is not a terribly useful one.
The external world has verisimilitude and for all intents and purposes can be afforded the status of being "real" on account of being an artifact in conscousness, just like the sense of Self and Otherness.

The important point to note is that, unlike Self and Otherness, the external world is not ever known it is instead comprehended via apperception.
If, however, your definition of "real" is such that anything which affects you is necessarily "real", then the question of whether the physical world is "real" or not is trivial. Of course it is.
Many theoretical physicists (or, at least, the non-theist ones) don't quite like it when esotericists make use of their findings/theories about superstrings and such things. But, equally, all of this stuff about matter being produced by superstring vibrations, much like notes being played on a guitar, is extremely profound. Nobody would deny that. In relation to The Hard Problem of Consciousness that there are many, many things left to be discoverd about ourselves and the universe should not be brushed under the carpet.
I consider all of this nonsense of worrying about whether the external world is "real" or not to be a ridiculous waste of time. What we should be worried about is how it works. Whether or not it conforms to some silly and arbitrary metaphysical definition of "real" that some armchair philosopher with too much free-time has dreamed up, is of absolutely no importance.
In otherwords, we can't explain consciousness in relation to matter no matter how we try so we should just ignore it? Why should we do that when the question is so pertinent to existence? Does a microbiologist and astronomer not want to know everything they can about the lenses they use to percieve the external world? The same thing holds true for that within which the external world is apperceived.

Either way, my point has been specifically about atheism and faith - and that has real "real world" effects, particularly when you consider all of the continual fighting over the separation of "church" and "state". Now, I'm certainly no believer in Creationism, and I don't find the watered-down ideas of Intelligent Design to be much better but I do know one thing: there is a hell of a lot more to behaviour than phenotype and genotype - and it's called psychology.

The Christian backlash in North America against the teaching of evolution in classrooms has occurred with such passion because people are seeing, via the teaching of evolution, a covert - and even overt - attempt to introduce atheism "by the back door". And parading staunch supporters of evolution like Richard Dawkins around like they're clebrities only encourages these concerns. Particularly when evolution is sold as being random and environmentally determined.

This issue, among many others, is deeper to people than simply being a Christian or whatever. I'm an evolutionist and if/when I ever have children, I would certainly want them to be taught evolution in the classroom (or I'd definately teach it to them myself). But I would disagree with the subtle, even subliminal, promotion of "atheism" upon my children, just as an atheist or agnostic would disagree with religion being promoted to their children. (And/or just as someone of one religion would disagree with another religion being promoted to their children.)

Atheism is a religion because in conjunction to it's faith that the so-called "external" world of apperception is independently real, as opposed to the default position which would state that it is phenomenological, atheism has a God - "matter". How so? The answer is simple:

The brain, like nearly all observable 'bodies', is nothing more than the usual ingredients of "matter" - protons, neutrons and electrons (as atoms and moleclues), with plenty more electrons flowing around as 'action potentials' and some electromagnetic radiation thrown in for good luck. Venus and Mars are made of "matter" in a complex state as well. So is my computer; a point not lost on Daniel Dennet who is a strong proponent of Robot consciousness.

So the atheist "God" (matter/universe), might not care about them and might even ensure they cease to exist when the body dies, but it is still a "God", as the entire complex universe, which can only be believed in via faith. And, importantly, you should note that it's a taught faith. It's culturally communicated, with history and tradition.

Given these truths, what right has atheism, above other faiths/religions to have a monopoly on education, justice and social engineering? Clearly none. Possibly even less than other faiths/religions because it is not the 'default position' of Self and Otherness. The North American distinction between Church and State is unworkable unless it is taken to mean that organised "Churches", including those with atheism as a specific agenda, should not wield government power.
_
HypnoPsi
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom