Empirical Evidence vs Reason

Iacchus

Unregistered
Joined
Dec 24, 2003
Messages
10,085
From this thread

Since you have yet to prove that there is a spiritual world, this entire thread is a moot point.
If it's provable to me, then perhaps it's a matter of reasoning it out amongst yourselves?

By the way, what's with all the spam and derailing tactics here? I'm not referring to you in particular Tobias ... Is this typical of most of the threads on this forum or, is it a primary focus on those who tend to maintain alternative views? :confused: If you would like to discuss the difference between empirical evidence and our ability to reason, perhaps we can do so on another thread?

In fact I may as well make the split right here ...
 
Last edited:
From this thread

If it's provable to me, then perhaps it's a matter of reasoning it out amongst yourselves?

By the way, what's with all the spam and derailing tactics here? I'm not referring to you in particular Tobias ... Is this typical of most of the threads on this forum or, is it a primary focus on those who tend to maintain alternative views? :confused: If you would like to discuss the difference between empirical evidence and our ability to reason, perhaps we can do so on another thread?

In fact I may as well make split it off right here ...
Any "reason" that is not based on empirical evidence is suspect. An insane person may "reason" that there are demons in his basement because he has seen their faces in photographs he has taken of the wall. To him, this is pure reason. There are the pictures. There are the faces. What could be more obvious?

The fact that the empirical evidence is against him, meaning no-one but him can see the demons, does not conflict with his reason since he is not concerned with empirical evidence.

Note that this example is based on an actual poster who used to present exactly this "reasoning" on these boards. Do we know anyone else here whose reasoning is not based on empirical evidence?
 
Any empirical evidence that is not maintained by reason does not exist.
That is among the most incorrect things you have ever said. Evidence is totally independant of reason. By your definition, the planet Pluto did not exist until it was discovered, which is totally ludicrous. The evidence was there for many many years before our "reason" uncovered it.
 
From this thread

If it's provable to me, then perhaps it's a matter of reasoning it out amongst yourselves?

By the way, what's with all the spam and derailing tactics here? I'm not referring to you in particular Tobias ... Is this typical of most of the threads on this forum or, is it a primary focus on those who tend to maintain alternative views? :confused: If you would like to discuss the difference between empirical evidence and our ability to reason, perhaps we can do so on another thread?

In fact I may as well make the split right here ...
Spam? What do you mean.
Derailing? This is a science forum, we can't discuss something unless we agree on certain things, like for instance, we both have to agree on teh existance of a spiritual world or not.

Of course we COULD spend a week discussing the aspects of the world and the big bang in correlation to a spriritual world, even if a spiritual world doesn't exist. But most people(me included) would find such an endeavour to be a waste of time. So, before we start discussing the correlation between [some subject] and the spiritual world, then lets first agree on some foundation. For instance, that the spiritual world exists.

Since the scientific consensus is that the spiritual world does not exist, you will have to prove that it does exist to us, for us to feel that any other discussion involving the spiritual world is worth the endeavour.


Why don't you just simply prove to us that the spiritual world is fact, that is a part of the world we live in, and not just an idea you have. Once you have that proven, we can better discuss the implications that will have on the big bang and the expanding universe. And you would most likely have both 1 million dollars, and a nobel price.
 
Kewl. You know (whatever that might mean in your scenario) something is evidence without recourse to reason. Mmmkay. :)
Umm.. yes. Elsewise, what would the term "discover evidence" mean? You cannot discover something that doesn't exist.

How you interpret the evidence is determined by your reasoning and indeed it is inevitable that faulty interpretations will be made. Science is a good, but not perfect tool for weeding out faulty interpretations by subjecting them to testing and independant verification.
 
tricky said:
Any "reason" that is not based on empirical evidence is suspect.

Reason in its pure form (as in logic or mathematics, for example) is not based on empirical evidence.


TobiasTheCommie said:
Derailing? This is a science forum ...

The Religion and Philosophy Forum is a science forum?


TobiasTheCommie said:
Since the scientific consensus is that the spiritual world does not exist, you will have to prove that it does exist to us, for us to feel that any other discussion involving the spiritual world is worth the endeavour.

Any consensus (if there is one, which would be news to me) that the spiritual world does not exist would necessarily not be a scientific one.
 
The Religion and Philosophy Forum is a science forum?
Ah yes, forgot to look at the subforum. My bad, and agreed. I did mean the overall board though. But yes, this is Religion and Philosophy. My bad.

Any consensus (if there is one, which would be news to me) that the spiritual world does not exist would necessarily not be a scientific one.
I'm there are many organisations that have a consensus one way or the other. Not that it really matters if there are.
I don't know if the scientific community have a consensus that God doens't exist. But i do know that they don't have a consensus that God does exist.

But since this is Religion and Philosophy, i guess my entire argument is moot. I don't feel a discussion of this nature is worth anything without scientific backing. But since it is in Religion and Philosophy, and not in the science section, i should just keep my damn dirty fingers out.

Agreed, in this subforum scientific evidence is not required, and i shouldn't require it in the context of Religion of Philosophy.

I appologize to all parties involved, and i'll endeavour to check which section i'm in later.

Sincerely
Tobias
 
That is among the most incorrect things you have ever said. Evidence is totally independant of reason. By your definition, the planet Pluto did not exist until it was discovered, which is totally ludicrous. The evidence was there for many many years before our "reason" uncovered it.
That would be great if you were capable of jumping out of your skin. :D Indeed, how is it possible to know something exists on the outside, unless "you" were looking at it from the inside? There has to be some form of mediator between you and the outside doesn't there? And, what do you think that mediator might be, if not reason?
 
But since this is Religion and Philosophy, i guess my entire argument is moot. I don't feel a discussion of this nature is worth anything without scientific backing. But since it is in Religion and Philosophy, and not in the science section, i should just keep my damn dirty fingers out.
And perhaps this should serve as a reminder to some of the other folks around here too? ... Apology accepted.
 
Reason in its pure form (as in logic or mathematics, for example) is not based on empirical evidence.
True, but I would separate this definition of reason from the scientific definition. Reason in math is more like carefully reading the rules.
 
That would be great if you were capable of jumping out of your skin. :D Indeed, how is it possible to know something exists on the outside, unless "you" were looking at it from the inside? There has to be some form of mediator between you and the outside doesn't there? And, what do you think that mediator might be, if not reason?
What you know or don't know is not relevant to the evidence itself. It would exist even if you didn't. But you are correct that "reason" (I prefer "interpretation") is the bridge beween evidence and understanding. But this again is a personal thing. Some people understand a lot about how brains work, some do not. Some people understand how cosmology works, some do not. Their understanding has no effect on how those things actually work.

But I do not deny that it requires a "mediator" for you to understand it. It was this statement that you made:
Iacchus said:
Any empirical evidence that is not maintained by reason does not exist.
which is so very incorrect that it defies "reason" that a sentient being could ever make such an error.
 
What you know or don't know is not relevant to the evidence itself.
Then why bring it up? Why do I need to know it? Is it supposed to just "lay there," without us doing anything about it? What is the evidence without any purpose?
 
Then why bring it up? Why do I need to know it? Is it supposed to just "lay there," without us doing anything about it? What is the evidence without any purpose?
It is just evidence. It has no more "purpose" than the undiscovered fossils which may someday link major taxonomic groups.

However, if a claim is made that, oh let's say earthworms are related to insects, then that statement is useless unless supported by evidence. THe evidence for such a link could have been lying buried and undiscovered for millions of years prior to the claim. Nothing has changed about the evidence. The only thing that has changed is our knowledge and understanding of it.

I realize that because of your religion, you require a "purpose" for everything. Most of us here are not limited by such narrow interpretations.
 
It's true that this is a religion and philosphy subforum. But when you claim that some deity is necessery or responsible for our existence then you are mixing it with science. And you should be prepared to defend your statements scientifically. If we accept any wild claim regardles of any science at all, we might as well change the subforum to fiction/fantasy.

Reason in its pure form (as in logic or mathematics, for example) is not based on empirical evidence.
True, but I would separate this definition of reason from the scientific definition. Reason in math is more like carefully reading the rules.

I agree with both of you. Logic and math are not based on empirical evidence. But alone they don't tell us anything about the world. I could make mathematically and logically correct equations and arguments but without some empirical evidence they would be pure speculation.
 
Example A:
1. Start with emperical evidence
2. Apply reason
3. Formulate conclusion
3. Support conclusion with 1 and 2
This is where knowledge comes from. It is made of win and good.

Example A, if done properly, works. It is built from the foundation up. It will collapse if you skip a step. It can easily go beyond what was already known, which is why it is called "learning."

Example A in action: Geometric proofs, science, philosophy, Pulitzer prize winning essays, everyday rational thought.

Example B:
1. Start with conclusion
2. Apply reason
3. Add emperical evidence (if you have any)
3. Support conclusion with any combination of 1, 2, and 3
This is a trap. It is made of ass and poo.

Example B does not work. It has no foundation. You can skip steps, and it won't make a difference, because it establishes nothing more than a possibility which existed in the first place. It cannot go beyond what it intended to prove. Because it contains reason and emperical evidence, it is indistinguishable from A if you do not think critically about it.

Example B in action: Studies supporting psi where the misses are ignored, Intelligent Design as it is presented in court, New Age, Kilik's many wonderful links, Gene Ray's Timecube, the theories of David Icke.

Now do you see why people tell you reason and emperical evidence alone don't make something true? Neither one is unreal or false, but either can be easily misused. I don't think I can break this down any more clearly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom