CARINA LANDIN, Swedish Friend of the DEAD

edthedoc

Thinker
Joined
Dec 26, 2002
Messages
163
So she says she can tell whether a diary was used by a man or woman. Smell perhaps? Looks like a cheap magician's trick.
 
That's quite a scaled back claimed from her original. I wonder if she is even embarassed.
 
If a random selection of diaries kept by men and women are presented, I would think one could determine at far better by chance which were kept by a male or female. The appearance of the diary would be a huge clue since they are typcially chosen by the keeper and would reflect gender based preferences. If this test it to be performed, 20 identical diaries should be given to 10 men and 10 women, kept up for some period of time, then submitted for testing.

IXP
 
I don't get it... She will read diaries and then say if it was written by a man or a female. Is she allowed to read in it? If the writer is gay, does that matter? Sounds like an out to me. "Well she is a woman, but her spirit is male".

Why can't she just say the name of the writer and what car he/she drives?
 
She says she doesn't need to read them. And also the diaries have to be from dead people.

I think the way to test it would be to have her blindfolded, to cut back on visual clues. But I doubt we can get 20 diaries that easily...
 
I don't get it... She will read diaries and then say if it was written by a man or a female. Is she allowed to read in it? If the writer is gay, does that matter? Sounds like an out to me. "Well she is a woman, but her spirit is male".

Why can't she just say the name of the writer and what car he/she drives?
You are exactly right. You don't get it. Did you read the post? She says she will NOT read it or look at the handwriting.

IXP
 
You are exactly right. You don't get it. Did you read the post? She says she will NOT read it or look at the handwriting.

IXP

So she will get in contact with the dead person. Ok, so she will have no problem telling us their names and what car they drove. Yeah right...

Oh... I just looked at her previous test and the results. Amazing... Every wrong is actually right. This woman is never wrong, the spirit however is sometimes wrong. She can't say their names and if the spirit show dirty nails it sometimes means she hates dirty nails or she have dirty nails. Carina doesn't know what it means. I am glad Randi didn't agree on this test.

http://www.ruter-ess.nu/carina/tester/egna2005/index.html

In swedish only.
 
She says she doesn't need to read them. And also the diaries have to be from dead people.

I think the way to test it would be to have her blindfolded, to cut back on visual clues. But I doubt we can get 20 diaries that easily...


Any minimally stocked city library would suffice.
In the centuries after Gutenberg's invention people had to keep handwritten paper-based diaries if they wanted to pass on whatever came to their minds.

Like diaries in those days, people today use blogs. Or JREF threads.


Blindfolding would exclude a big chunk of cheating possibilities.


Still, I don't really get the PARANORMAL aspect of this claim. Perhaps Ms. Landin's next communiqué will enlighten the forum members.
 
Carina... Oh... sweet Carina...

She is not a fraud. She does believe in this and seems very sincere. But she is critical like a cheerleader at a football game. "We are losing means they are winning! Yeah!"
 
This is considered a hit: "she shows me red, I don't know if she liked red"

"I see a cirkus show. I don't know if there is a memory about cirkuses or if she liked cirkuses."
 
So she will get in contact with the dead person. Ok, so she will have no problem telling us their names and what car they drove. Yeah right...

Oh... I just looked at her previous test and the results. Amazing... Every wrong is actually right. This woman is never wrong, the spirit however is sometimes wrong. She can't say their names and if the spirit show dirty nails it sometimes means she hates dirty nails or she have dirty nails. Carina doesn't know what it means. I am glad Randi didn't agree on this test.

http://www.ruter-ess.nu/carina/tester/egna2005/index.html

In swedish only.

Any chance you could help us out with a little bit of translation work?
 
Any chance you could help us out with a little bit of translation work?

I am not very good at translation. But I can explain the test a little.

In short. 5 persons brings a thing, something the dead has owned. Say a spoon and the spoon is given to Carina who has no contact with these five persons. Carina contacts her "guide"...

Carina says stuff and a writer writes them down. The notes are handed back to the 5 persons with a colour code. And they pick the note they think is the right one. The setup is ok, with a lot of rules and I don't think any cheating was going on.

This test was done at 4 times and the rules was changed a bit after the first test. They needed to choose the objects better.

The results are really hard to understand. They are often wrong but ends up being right somehow. A LOT of info are right a couple of weeks later after relatives are contacted and sometimes new dead relatives fits the description.

Most stories are like a history book about swedish people from ca 1940-60. There are the old women living on a farm. Intelligent man reading in a library and living in an apartment and perhaps he owns a summer house (A well paid man living in a city and owns a summer house, what are the odds...)

Her stories are not as interesting as the answers given to her later.

Carina says" I think it is a house with a small farm and a small outhouse (?)."

After the person has "checked" the info with relatives that sentence has turned into a perfect description of the house complete with info about what kind of material the house was built of and of course where the house was.

Almost every object was previously owned by someone else. Hmm...

"used a computer" was a hit.

"My mother died 1976, 36 years old"

She used a computer 1976 or even earlier? That was a nice hit...
 
Sounds like the typical psychic set up, where the participants are working to validate the psychic.


I am not very good at translation. But I can explain the test a little.

In short. 5 persons brings a thing, something the dead has owned. Say a spoon and the spoon is given to Carina who has no contact with these five persons. Carina contacts her "guide"...

Carina says stuff and a writer writes them down. The notes are handed back to the 5 persons with a colour code. And they pick the note they think is the right one. The setup is ok, with a lot of rules and I don't think any cheating was going on.

This test was done at 4 times and the rules was changed a bit after the first test. They needed to choose the objects better.

The results are really hard to understand. They are often wrong but ends up being right somehow. A LOT of info are right a couple of weeks later after relatives are contacted and sometimes new dead relatives fits the description.

Most stories are like a history book about swedish people from ca 1940-60. There are the old women living on a farm. Intelligent man reading in a library and living in an apartment and perhaps he owns a summer house (A well paid man living in a city and owns a summer house, what are the odds...)

Her stories are not as interesting as the answers given to her later.

Carina says" I think it is a house with a small farm and a small outhouse (?)."

After the person has "checked" the info with relatives that sentence has turned into a perfect description of the house complete with info about what kind of material the house was built of and of course where the house was.

Almost every object was previously owned by someone else. Hmm...

"used a computer" was a hit.

"My mother died 1976, 36 years old"

She used a computer 1976 or even earlier? That was a nice hit...
 
Is it just me or is this test utterly boring? *Guessing* 50/50 on 20 diaries - what does this achieve? Even in the unlikely event of her getting 16 or more I would still be wondering what it proves. If this woman can speak to the dead why can't she do it 100% of the time and without changing the goalposts to narrow the possibilities to 50/50?
Here is my proposed test for a medium. The medium is presented with a relative of the dead. The medium then produces the full name, date of birth, place of birth, date of death, cause of death, and place of death of the deceased. The deceased will surely know all these details. If the medium cannot do this then he/she is not talking to the deceased. Is this too strict? Why do the dead seem to suddenly forget all important details of their life and become incapable of giving coherent specific answers to questions? The afterlife seems to dull the brain.
 
Last edited:
If this woman can speak to the dead why can't she do it 100% of the time and without changing the goalposts to narrow the possibilities to 50/50?
Supposing it exists, the paranormal works in mysterious ways. If it doesn't conform to our perceptions of how it ought to work, that's just too bad for us. If she says she can do it 80% of the time, that's what she should be tested on. The 50/50 aspect of the test is on purpose.

Here is my proposed test for a medium. The medium is presented with a relative of the dead. The medium then produces the full name, date of birth, place of birth, date of death, cause of death, and place of death of the deceased. The deceased will surely know all these details. If the medium cannot do this then he/she is not talking to the deceased. Is this too strict?
The problem is not its strictness, but that it would require judgement. If the person's real name was John Smith and the medium said it was John Smythe, most people would think that was more of a hit than if the medium said Fred Bloggs. To avoid having to subjectively quantify these things, JREF test protocols normally involve a forced choice, such as the 50/50 choice you allude to. This makes the statistics tractable, and an objective measure of success possible.
 
Supposing it exists, the paranormal works in mysterious ways. If it doesn't conform to our perceptions of how it ought to work, that's just too bad for us. If she says she can do it 80% of the time, that's what she should be tested on. The 50/50 aspect of the test is on purpose.

The problem is not its strictness, but that it would require judgement. If the person's real name was John Smith and the medium said it was John Smythe, most people would think that was more of a hit than if the medium said Fred Bloggs. To avoid having to subjectively quantify these things, JREF test protocols normally involve a forced choice, such as the 50/50 choice you allude to. This makes the statistics tractable, and an objective measure of success possible.


An interesting discussion is going on at www.paranormalt.nu, a forum dealing with the paranormal. (In swedish, so don´t bother.) One of the believers actually posted regarding JREF test procedures, basically saying that of course there can be no discussion or debating over the result, because that way (JREF) avoids objective judgement(!) and independent opinions.

No wonder it is so hard to get people to accept a testresult... How is science ever going to prove anything to these people?
 
Just to clarify: Carina Landin was not the person posting the arguments which I mentioned in my former post, it was another poster on that forum. Carina Landin seems to very honest about the test, nothing about her for me to argue about.
 
Any chance you could help us out with a little bit of translation work?

If y'all want, I'll have a look at doing (some) translation of the page comes the weekend. I had a quick look earlier and can (with some confidence) say it'll be a painful experience, lots of idiosyncratic usage of Swedish is only the beginning.
 
I have been reading here in the forum, and on Carina Landins web about this woman and her claims. I have to say, that for me she seems to be very honest. The TV shows we watch are cut, all "bad" parts are away when it comes to programs, but this women seems to take with those parts also, in a very honest way. Guys,what happens, if she does the test with more than 80%? Before beeing too hard, show us that you can do it on 80%, without cheating! Why not try first, and discuss later? :-)
And if, I only say IF, she does it with more than 80%, how do we explane it then? If it´s with luck, then she absolutely should play in every lottery in the whole world.... :-)
 
I have been reading here in the forum, and on Carina Landins web about this woman and her claims. I have to say, that for me she seems to be very honest. The TV shows we watch are cut, all "bad" parts are away when it comes to programs, but this women seems to take with those parts also, in a very honest way. Guys,what happens, if she does the test with more than 80%? Before beeing too hard, show us that you can do it on 80%, without cheating! Why not try first, and discuss later? :-)
And if, I only say IF, she does it with more than 80%, how do we explane it then? If it´s with luck, then she absolutely should play in every lottery in the whole world.... :-)

Indeed. Feel free to alert her to the existance of the challenge and encourage her to apply. We are always curious to see what reaction such helpful acts get.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom