Skeptical criticism on Buddhist beliefs and observances.

yrreg

Master Poster
Joined
Nov 24, 2005
Messages
2,420
I like to meet with skeptics here who can tell me how Buddhist doctrines like rebirths and Nirvana cannot stand up to skeptical criticism.

And also the usefulness of meditation, specially that of the Zen school.

yrreg
 
I like to meet with skeptics here who can tell me how Buddhist doctrines like rebirths
There is no proof of previous lifes, the burden of proof is on the buddhists.. not the skeptics

and Nirvana
Depends on which definition you use i guess. If you mean a kind of heaven, then again buddhists would have to provide evidence that the "us" or "me" doens't die with the body, and can be transfered either to another body, or to another place(nirvana, heaven).

Though i have also heard people say "Nirvana" is essentially nothing. Which i guess would be consistent with personality dying with the body. Though that is a matter of the definition of Nirvana.

cannot stand up to skeptical criticism.

And also the usefulness of meditation, specially that of the Zen school.

yrreg
Again, what defintion of meditation do you mean? I would claim that there can be gains from meditation.

As in, with meditation i believe you can be more relaxed, get more energy and stuff like that. But i don't think that is something that can solely be gained from meditation. Different personalities can get that from different actions. Some may get relaxed and gain energy from boxing, others may prefer meditation or prayer.

As for meditation making the brain bigger... or boiling the water out of a piece of wet cloth(as some monks in tibeth does).. that is bunk. As in, brain increase haven't been proven, and the steaming cloths happens for everyone who just sit still with a wet cloth. The reason it is more often noted from the monks in tibeth is because it is much easier to see in the cold weather.. the steam condenses quicker, and also evaporates quicker.

Sincerely
Tobias

Sleepy time now.
 
There is no proof of previous lifes, the burden of proof is on the buddhists.. not the skeptics

No problem, the Buddhists agree with you! Buddhists do not even believe in a soul, so what is there to be reborn?

(Note that some Buddhist denominations, like Tibetan Buddhism, believe in rebirth of the self, and other denominations, like Pure Land, believe in a utopian afterlife. 'Orthodox' Buddhism, however, preaches that there is no self/soul, and that there is no way to know what happens to you after death.

One of my favorite Zen stories is about a man who asks a Zen master what happens to people after they die.

'I have no idea', the master told him.

'What!?', the man explaimed, 'but aren't you supposed to be a Zen master?'

'I am', the master replied, 'but I'm not a dead one.')

Depends on which definition you use i guess. If you mean a kind of heaven, then again buddhists would have to provide evidence that the "us" or "me" doens't die with the body, and can be transfered either to another body, or to another place(nirvana, heaven).

Though i have also heard people say "Nirvana" is essentially nothing. Which i guess would be consistent with personality dying with the body. Though that is a matter of the definition of Nirvana.

In orthodox Buddhism, Nirvana indeed means 'a state of nothingness', a state free of suffering. The goal of a Buddhist is to reach this state in this life! It's called enlightenment.


Again, what defintion of meditation do you mean? I would claim that there can be gains from meditation.

As in, with meditation i believe you can be more relaxed, get more energy and stuff like that. But i don't think that is something that can solely be gained from meditation. Different personalities can get that from different actions. Some may get relaxed and gain energy from boxing, others may prefer meditation or prayer.

As for meditation making the brain bigger... or boiling the water out of a piece of wet cloth(as some monks in tibeth does).. that is bunk. As in, brain increase haven't been proven, and the steaming cloths happens for everyone who just sit still with a wet cloth. The reason it is more often noted from the monks in tibeth is because it is much easier to see in the cold weather.. the steam condenses quicker, and also evaporates quicker.

Meditation without the Dharma does nothing except relax you and decrease stress (which is not a bad thing in and of itself). It's not a 'gateway' to other dimensions, and crystals won't help at all. But through study of the Dharma, and reflecting upon it in meditation, you can gain great wisdom. But there's nothing supernatural about it.

I know a Zen story for this occasion as well! :D

A Zen master returned to the cabin he was sharing with his student. The student was sitting on the floor, in deep meditation.

'What are you doing?', the master asked.

'I'm trying to reach enlightenment', the student replied.

Upon hearing this, the master picked up a rock and a tile and started rubbing them together.

'What are you doing?', the student asked.

'I'm trying to rub this tile until it becomes a mirror', the master replied.

'But, master, you can't just rub a stone against a tile and expect to get a mirror!', the student exclaimed.

'No', the master replied, 'and neither can expect to reach enlightenment through just meditation.'

You can increase your body temperature with meditation, but it can also be done through hard labor or even hypnosis. Nothing supernatural about it.

Sincerely
Tobias

Sleepy time now.

Indeed it is. Or, should've been for a long time now. I guess we're going to have a bad case of the mondays tomorrow ;)

ETA : Note that I'm not a Zen Buddhist, I'm a Theravada Buddhist. I just like Zen stories :)
 
The matter of words.

So far Ryokan is the only Buddhist, unless I am mistaken, among us here in this thread. He calls himself Resident Buddhist.

We all here so far, including Ryokan, use the words: Buddhism, Buddhist.

But Ryokan brings up several kinds of Buddhism, Buddhists:

1. Resident Buddhist
2. Tibetan Buddhism
3. Pure Land Buddhism
4. Orthodox Buddhism
5. Zen Buddhist
6. Theravada Buddhist

And he also brings up the word, Dharma.

So, may I ask him what he understands by rebirths and Nirvana and meditation and Dharma in his kind of Buddhism, which is for himself here that of a Resident Buddhist, and as regards the particular faction thereof, that of Theravada Buddhism.


From my own part, on my stock knowledge, I understand:

1. Rebirths as returns to life after death, like for example when yrreg dies he will come back to life,

2. Nirvana as the end state of a human like Ryokan when he will be released from rebirths and sufferings.

3. Meditation is a process of occupying one's mind with some thoughts in order to reach some insights into life and the universe,

4. Dharma is a collection of teachings in Buddhism.


After we are informed by Ryokan, our Resident Buddhist here, on the words, then we can proceed to exercise our skeptical criticism on the notions and entities represented by the words.

If Ryokan cannot furnish us with the requisite information, then we will have to think of other ways and means and maybe other resource people to obtain the requisite information.

yrreg
 
In orthodox Buddhism, Nirvana indeed means 'a state of nothingness', a state free of suffering. The goal of a Buddhist is to reach this state in this life! It's called enlightenment.

Yeah, it's Iowa. The state of perfect nothingness.....

<ducks to avoid the tomatoes>
 
What's the difference between self and soul, in the context of reincarnation?

They're the same. Buddhism acknowledges neither.

ETA : The reason why the word 'self' is most commonly used in Buddhism is because it does not have the concept of a 'soul', and therefore haven't needed a specialized word for it.
 
So far Ryokan is the only Buddhist, unless I am mistaken, among us here in this thread. He calls himself Resident Buddhist.

In this thread, yes. However, I know there are several Buddhists on this board, of different denominations, and they're all sceptics. As I am. I'm also an atheist.

Resident Buddhist simply means that I'm this forum's resident Buddhist, although highly unofficial. It's not a denomination, just a forum title and nickname I've given myself. It has no meaning at all, please ignore it. I'm a Theravada (The Teachings of the Elders) Buddhist, also called orthodox Buddhism. Theravada follows the teachings of Siddharta Gautama, the Buddha, with little or no influence from local religions.

We all here so far, including Ryokan, use the words: Buddhism, Buddhist.

But Ryokan brings up several kinds of Buddhism, Buddhists:

1. Resident Buddhist
2. Tibetan Buddhism
3. Pure Land Buddhism
4. Orthodox Buddhism
5. Zen Buddhist
6. Theravada Buddhist

Indeed. As Buddhism is more a philosophy than a religion, it has adapted to local religions wherever it spread. So different Buddhists believe different things. However, when I talk about Buddhism in general, I talk about the words of Gautama Buddha. When I say orthodox Buddhism, I mean Theravada. There are numerous other denominations as well, just as there are in most other religions.

And he also brings up the word, Dharma.

Yes, hard to talk about Buddhism without talking about Dharma. This entire discussion would be called a 'Dharma Talk' within Buddhism, and most Buddhists love to participate in Dharma Talks, even if they're sceptical of Buddhism. Or, even if? You learn nothing if you're not sceptical. Even the Buddha himself told us to be sceptical about all things, even to approach Buddhism with sceptical eyes!

Look at the Kalama Sutra, for example. Is this not a guide to scepticism?


From my own part, on my stock knowledge, I understand:

1. Rebirths as returns to life after death, like for example when yrreg dies he will come back to life,

Not according to the Buddha. There is no self that is reborn.

Rebirth and Karma, the universal law of cause and effect, are closely related. It is not yrreg that is reborn, it's his Karma, his actions. If he does good things, those good things will cause a ripple into future generations. Of course, his tiny little life has next to no visible effect, but the more people doing good things the better the future will be. Vice versa for bad deeds.

As someone else on this forum once said : Previous generations didn't reinforce the levees, and this generation suffered for it when the levees broke. Simple cause and effect.

You don't need to be a religious person to see that all your actions have reactions.

2. Nirvana as the end state of a human like Ryokan when he will be released from rebirths and sufferings.

Yes and no, according to your definition of 'rebirth'. The person called Ryokan will cease to exist upon his death. If there's one thing that the Buddha taught, it's the impermanence of all things. Everything will cease to exist one time or another, from the tiniest lifeform to the big universe.

3. Meditation is a process of occupying one's mind with some thoughts in order to reach some insights into life and the universe,

Life, if you mean your own, yes. The universe, absolutely not.

4. Dharma is a collection of teachings in Buddhism.

Yes, Dharma means the teachings of the Buddha.

After we are informed by Ryokan, our Resident Buddhist here, on the words, then we can proceed to exercise our skeptical criticism on the notions and entities represented by the words.

If Ryokan cannot furnish us with the requisite information, then we will have to think of other ways and means and maybe other resource people to obtain the requisite information.

yrreg

Ask away, yrreg, I don't mind answering questions about Buddhism at all, and being sceptical is healthy.

The Buddha in The Dhammapada
All that we are is the result of what we have thought: it is founded on our thoughts, it is made up of our thoughts.
 
First, let's dwell on the self.

I like to be ascertained, dear Ryokan, about the presence of yourself as you write a message to post in this thread before the computer monitor screen and as you type on your keyboard.

When you engage in that activity are you present?

Is that you that is present the self, as in yourself?

Now, I keep reading from you that the self does not exist, there is no self.

Do you mean there is no physical, biological, and personal self that is Ryokan who sits before a computer screen, and types on the keyboard to write messages to post in this thread?

I like to apply skeptical criticism on your statement that the self does not exist, there is no self; but first we have to possess together the same notion of the self.

I have just described the self I am talking about and which I know to be also what I am, a self; in your case you tell me there is no self, it does not exist. Then Ryokan what are you?

So, everyone here, shall we all attend to the existence or non-existence of the self as our first task in doing skeptical criticism on Buddhism, focusing for our purpose on that Buddhism as embraced and practiced by Ryokan.


I have this personal observation that skepticism is applied to paranormal phenomena routinely and extensively, but we can also apply what I might call the canons of skeptical criticism to religion and philosophy, to glean what is of logic and science in these two human activities, and what bereft of all logic and science.

yrreg
 
By self I mean soul. Does that make it clearer?

Did you read the Kalama Sutra?
 
I like to be ascertained, dear Ryokan, about the presence of yourself as you write a message to post in this thread before the computer monitor screen and as you type on your keyboard.

When you engage in that activity are you present?

Is that you that is present the self, as in yourself?

Now, I keep reading from you that the self does not exist, there is no self.

Do you mean there is no physical, biological, and personal self that is Ryokan who sits before a computer screen, and types on the keyboard to write messages to post in this thread?

I like to apply skeptical criticism on your statement that the self does not exist, there is no self; but first we have to possess together the same notion of the self.

I have just described the self I am talking about and which I know to be also what I am, a self; in your case you tell me there is no self, it does not exist. Then Ryokan what are you?

So, everyone here, shall we all attend to the existence or non-existence of the self as our first task in doing skeptical criticism on Buddhism, focusing for our purpose on that Buddhism as embraced and practiced by Ryokan.


I have this personal observation that skepticism is applied to paranormal phenomena routinely and extensively, but we can also apply what I might call the canons of skeptical criticism to religion and philosophy, to glean what is of logic and science in these two human activities, and what bereft of all logic and science.

yrreg

I'm much less of a Buddhist than Ryokan, but I'm a little bit of a Buddhist. I have gone to Zen centers, Theravadan meditation centers, read a lot, and meditated a little (by Buddhist standards). For family reasons, I have adopted Jewish practices, but with a Buddhist attitude. I'm an atheist, and a skeptic.

So I'll give my answers.

When you engage in that activity are you present?

Is that you that is present the self, as in yourself?

One of the things that Buddhism teaches is the artificiality of "you". There is no "you". At this moment, just what is it that is "me". The set of things inside my skin? My awareness? My memories? What is it that is special about "me", that separates "me" from "not me". I had spaghetti tonight. Before I ate it, it wasn't me. As I ate it, some of it passed into my bloodstream, and will be used to build cells, and some will pass through to my toilet. At what point does that spaghetti start being "me".

So I can say that I am typing at my computer, because it makes comprehension easier, but is it true?

But maybe "me" is my mental processes? My thoughts are "me". Well, I just shared my thoughts with you. When you read them, you transformed them and took them into you. Some of them are in your head now. Are you, "me" now? You have my thoughts, but transformed by your own processes.

When I die, will my body be "me"? After it decomposes for a while? When its components turn into daisies? Maybe my thoughts are me, and they stop, don't they? Except that I read the thoughts of the Buddha, or of Groucho Marx, and those thoughts continue. Indeed, parts of those people are continuously recycled by other people, and animals, and plants. It's almost like they are being "reborn" isn't it?
 
Who would agree that, before we even get as far and in-depth as the topics above, Buddhism is in itself a contradiction?

Buddha was not a preacher, did not proclaim hisself a messiah or second coming or whatever. He purported removal of the shackles of isms and schisms to achieve enlightenment.
Now those who "follow" him defy his very words before they've taken another step, eh?

[/first post in years]
*prepares to be flamed into next century*
 
Buddhism from my experience, has got to be the longest lasting philosophy of critical thinking out there. At least, I think Buddha would agree with me. Some of the following practices are a bit too dialectical to be credible with the skeptical community.

The whole idea about "no me" is sort of obvious; buddhists are putting forth the idea that consciousness is mostly imaginary. Now, I'm not much of a buddhist, but I agree with that, unless it can be proven that it is real (I seriously doubt that, though), at which point I'd guess both me and the buddhist would go "hmph," and if it was empirical enough, agree.

Buddhists also happen to think ideas like love are mostly imaginary, and sadness can be stopped, and dissapointment can be turned into something more intelligent. I happen to agree with this too. We tend to take our emotions into a lofty, metaphysical level, just like our idea of consciousness. They are chemical reactions from our evolutionary hericarchy that have survived through the ages, and sometimes they help us, sometimes they don't.

Emotions and consciousness are matter, and are empirical; chemical and electrical emmisions inside our brain. But how we tend to consider them is almost completely imaginary.

That Buddhists have been on the tail of this for so long, I think is a great testament to their critical thinking. It's too bad they've got all these stupid people speaking to the public for them.
 
Who would agree that, before we even get as far and in-depth as the topics above, Buddhism is in itself a contradiction?

Buddha was not a preacher, did not proclaim hisself a messiah or second coming or whatever. He purported removal of the shackles of isms and schisms to achieve enlightenment.
Now those who "follow" him defy his very words before they've taken another step, eh?

[/first post in years]
*prepares to be flamed into next century*

I would totally agree with you, if Buddhism was named after Siddharta Gautama, also called The Buddha.

But it's not.

It's named after the experience all Buddhists seek, that of enlightenment (Buddha = The Awakened/Enlightened One).

Not all Buddhists even follow Gautama Buddha, but follows the idea of enlightenment. Zen is an example of that.
 
I would totally agree with you, if Buddhism was named after Siddharta Gautama, also called The Buddha.

But it's not.

It's named after the experience all Buddhists seek, that of enlightenment (Buddha = The Awakened/Enlightened One).

Not all Buddhists even follow Gautama Buddha, but follows the idea of enlightenment. Zen is an example of that.
The problem therein being how does one define and name such a practice without the use of a "ism". I see.
 
Now those who "follow" him defy his very words before they've taken another step, eh?

[/first post in years]
*prepares to be flamed into next century*

No flames here. But, for those who follow "him", I would agree that they are contradicting what he taught, so it is a contradiction.

For those who follow a body of ideas, originally presented by him, that isn't the case.
 
First critical comment.

The self is the soul, says Ryokan.

Usually in English for the greatest majority of people when self is mentioned it is not routinely understood to be soul, it is understood as the self like in myself, yourself, himself, herself, themselves, yourselves, ourselves: namely, the subject or agent doing or being something in this world where people eat and sleep and work and also make love.

And I find that this reservation of self to the sense of the soul is an obstacle to clear and easy communication for people who do use English as a medium of communication for all purposes of life and work and arts and sciences and philosophies.

Of course if self is used to refer to the soul, then maybe it should be specifically stated that self means soul for a particular speaker or writer and he always understands self that way -- which I would observe to be already obstructive to quick and easy communication.


Anyway, for Ryokan in his kind of Buddhism, the self is to be understood as the soul, and the soul does not exist.

So, who or what is it that is facing the computer screen and typing on the keyboard when Ryokan is writing a message to post in this thread with the use of computer equipment?


yrreg
 
From Ryokan's post #4

Buddhists do not even believe in a soul, so what is there to be reborn?

Also, see his post #9. You just became confused.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom