Does E = MC2 ... Or What?

Iacchus

Unregistered
Joined
Dec 24, 2003
Messages
10,085
From this thread

No. There is a relationship between matter and energy, described by Einstein's equation. Neither is a subset of the other.

You are quite simply wrong.
So, what if you took a number, say the number 2, and divided it in half. You would get 1 + 1 = 2 or, 1 x 2 = 2, correct? So, doesn't this suggest that either half of 2, is a subset of the whole of 2? Sure it does, so long as each half is considered in context with the whole. Hence we can say, 2 = 1 + 1 or, 2 = 1 x 2, correct? So, in what way does this differ with respect to the letter "E," in the equation E = MC2? How does "E" not refer to the whole, and the rest of the equation to the constituent parts thereof? Even if you were to say M = E/C2 or, C2 = E/M, it still shows that both are properties of "E."

So, if you insist on saying I am "quite simply wrong," please tell us how I am wrong or, admit that you have no means of refuting it, please.
__________________

To the Mods: Please understand that I'm trying to illustrate the relationship between matter and energy, and show how the patterns we see in nature occur as a result of the way energy is arranged, which then gives rise to the arrangement of matter. Or, simply put, the arrangement of energy is necessary for the arrangement of matter but, not the other way around.

Perhaps you can see the implications to Max Planck's quote in the other thread? ...

All matter originates and exists only by virtue of a force which brings the particles of an atom to vibration and holds this most minute solar system of the atom together. We must assume behind this force the existence of a conscious and intelligent mind. This mind is the matrix of all matter.
So basically what I'm asking, is there another reality or, spiritual reality if you will, that exists and manifests itself through what we deem the material reality?
 
Last edited:
If you have a coin, is heads a subset of tails, or tails a subset of heads?
 
So, in what way does this differ with respect to the letter "E," in the equation E = MC2? How does "E" not refer to the whole, and the rest of the equation to the constituent parts thereof? Even if you were to say M = E/C2 or, C2 = E/M, it still shows that both are properties of "E."
But by exactly the same argument, you could say that E and C are both "properties" of M, or even that M and E are both "properties" of C. The equation just expresses the relationship between mass and energy.

Perhaps you can see the implications to Max Planck's quote in the other thread?
Ah yes, the thing you claimed he'd said in his Nobel prize acceptance speech. Have you found any reliable evidence that he actually said this yet?

In any case, why not just carry on the argument in the other thread on precisely the same subject? You know, the one you've just linked to?
 
But by exactly the same argument, you could say that E and C are both "properties" of M, or even that M and E are both "properties" of C. The equation just expresses the relationship between mass and energy.
Yes, but by the equations shown, both C and M are derived by the division of E ... which, of course constitues "the whole." I mean, isn't it a fact that everything is comprised of energy?
 
Ah yes, the thing you claimed he'd said in his Nobel prize acceptance speech. Have you found any reliable evidence that he actually said this yet?
No, I in fact did not claim this.
 
No, it isn't.
Well, it seems to be according to Max Planck anyway ... or, whatever he means by "conscious intelligence." Whereas if there is no matter per se', then what are we left with but engergy?
 
No, I in fact did not claim this.
Really?

You claimed that that was what someone else said, then admitted that you couldn't find the quote in any reliable source, and yet you're still using it to base a whole argument on!
 
In any case, why not just carry on the argument in the other thread on precisely the same subject? You know, the one you've just linked to?
Because basically this is the crux of the matter, that hasn't really been addresss, and I felt that it was going to lost and/or not addressed properly in such a lengthy thread.
 
Well, it seems to be according to Max Planck anyway ... or, whatever he means by "conscious intelligence."

Argument from Authority - "If Max Planck said it, it must be true!"

E=MC2 says that matter and energy are the same thing, just organized differently. You can call matter highly organized energy, or call energy highly disorganized matter. Neither one constitutes "the whole", since they're both the same thing.
 
Neither, both are subsets of the coin.
Ah, so you would find it acceptable when tossing a coin for me to call "Coin!" thus ensuring that I win no matter which side shows?
 
Really?

You claimed that that was what someone else said, then admitted that you couldn't find the quote in any reliable source, and yet you're still using it to base a whole argument on!
The quote is one thing. Now, whether or not he gave it during his Nobel acceptance speech is entirely another. I have already agreed that this seems unlikely.
 
Yes, but by the equations shown, both C and M are derived by the division of E ... which, of course constitues "the whole."
Ah, I see. It's the division/multiplication thing that you're hung up on.

OK, let's look at it.

E = M x C2
So M = E divided by C2
This is the same as saying that M = E multiplied by 1/C2
Now let's define a new constant, D, as being equal to 1/C2
We can now write the equation M = E/C2 as:

M = E x D

And the original equation as E = M/D

By your (erroneous) reasoning, this means that energy is a subset of matter.

The equation does not state that either energy or matter are a subset of the other. It just expresses the relationship between them.

Got that?
 
The quote is one thing. Now, whether or not he gave it during his Nobel acceptance speech is entirely another. I have already agreed that this seems unlikely.
So when did he say it?

This is important, Iacchus. If you can't show that he ever actually said it then it's worthless.

Of course, it's worthless anyway as it's purely the opinion of one admittedly religious man, brilliant physicist though he was.
 
Iacchus, the first thing to understand is that the famous E=MC2 is an incomplete equation. I don't have the full one at my finger tips, but there's a gamma factor involved, which scales for the portion of C that you are traveling.
 
Argument from Authority - "If Max Planck said it, it must be true!"
Not in the least.

E=MC2 says that matter and energy are the same thing ...
No it doesn't.

... just organized differently.
No, it shows that everything is organized within the context of energy.

You can call matter highly organized energy, or call energy highly disorganized matter. Neither one constitutes "the whole", since they're both the same thing.
It still doesn't explain how matter begins to structure itself. Where does the information come that tells it how to do this?
 
Not in the least.

No it doesn't.

No, it shows that everything is organized within the context of energy.

It still doesn't explain how matter begins to structure itself. Where does the information come that tells it how to do this?
Iacchus, your post should have said "oh, I see! I was wrong in what I was thinking--thanks ever so much for clearing that up for me!"

You are still wrong in what you are thinking, and it leads to meaningless questions like the last sentence you wrote above.

you are quite simply wrong.
 
No, it shows that everything is organized within the context of energy.

So if I rewrite the equation to M=E/C2 the entire structure of the universe will be changed to organize everything within the context of matter?

E=MC2 or M=E/C2 is the same equation, just written differently. And you have demonstrated that you have no clue what either of them means.
 
Iacchus, your post should have said "oh, I see! I was wrong in what I was thinking--thanks ever so much for clearing that up for me!"

You are still wrong in what you are thinking, and it leads to meaningless questions like the last sentence you wrote above.

you are quite simply wrong.
No, it was the response that Mojo made while I was in the midst of responding to this one that cleared it up for me. But, thanks just the same.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom