Bush NSA spies on Americans

Lurker

Illuminator
Joined
May 15, 2002
Messages
4,189
Seen this report? http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20051216/ap_on_go_pr_wh/bush_nsa

That year, following the Sept. 11 attacks, President Bush authorized the NSA to monitor the international phone calls and international e-mails of hundreds — perhaps thousands — of people inside the United States, the Times reported.

Before the program began, the NSA typically limited its domestic surveillance to foreign embassies and missions and obtained court orders for such investigations. Overseas, 5,000 to 7,000 people suspected of terrorist ties are monitored at one time.

Why not go thru the legal process with warrants? Why do it illegally?

Lurker
 
First, it may not be illegal.

Second, it may not be something that a democracy should put up with.

The matters are different. The President MAY have the power to order such intelligence gathering. Certainly, it seems likely to generate a court challenge. Fortunately for Bush, however, his party runs the Congress so oversight of any meaningful degree -- was this wise, was it executed well, was it legal, should it be legal, is it being abused -- will not take place.

Also, few in the public will question it as they should because a). it isn't about them and b). they fear terrorism, so what's the lose of some potentally important Constitutional rights for the reality of security (though the Security may only be a blanket, it will seem better than the mesh of un-checked freedom).

Those who do question it will, ultimately, be accuesed of undermining the President and through him our war against Terrorism and our soldiers in the Field -- lost will be the symbolism of fighting to replace despotic tyranny in Afghanastan and Iraq (secret police, lack of civil rights, lack of rule of law) by employing potentially devestating tactics domestically.

If it isn't illegal, it should be, or at least subject to numerous checks to ensure that it isn't abused. Sadly, this will be yet another tempest in a tea-pot. I hope I'm wrong.
 
I was under the impression that to tap a phone line you needed a warrant?

Lurker
 
You might think so....

When you get into these "national security" findings, it still gets murkey. Hopefully you are right...but don't count on it.
 
First, it may not be illegal.

We can't be sure of that. The article says the Bush admin suspended the practise a year ago because their own legal counsel questioned the legality of it.
Second, it may not be something that a democracy should put up with.
I agree. The degree of percieved threat should inform such decisions.
The matters are different. The President MAY have the power to order such intelligence gathering. Certainly, it seems likely to generate a court challenge. Fortunately for Bush, however, his party runs the Congress so oversight of any meaningful degree -- was this wise, was it executed well, was it legal, should it be legal, is it being abused -- will not take place.

I don't believe you can rightly say meaningful oversight "will not take place". The Republican senators are not monolithic...and the Dem minority has a serious responsibility to keep the White House honest. I doubt they would shirk such an opportunity to throw darts at Bushco.
Also, few in the public will question it as they should because a). it isn't about them and b). they fear terrorism, so what's the lose of some potentally important Constitutional rights for the reality of security (though the Security may only be a blanket, it will seem better than the mesh of un-checked freedom).

True. In past times of war civil liberties have been widely rolled back without much dissent from the American people. Propaganda, disinformation, censorship, and even the overtly racist internment of a target ethnic group has been tolerated. All in the name of national security during wartime.

We at least have a good record of repealing such curtailment of liberties once the threat has passed.
Those who do question it will, ultimately, be accuesed of undermining the President and through him our war against Terrorism and our soldiers in the Field -- lost will be the symbolism of fighting to replace despotic tyranny in Afghanastan and Iraq (secret police, lack of civil rights, lack of rule of law) by employing potentially devestating tactics domestically.

Not really. Reasonable debate that involves offering viable alternatives to the administration's terrorism fighting plans does not undermine the efforts of the troops. Crying that the whole thing is unwinnable; or that our guys are terrorizing women and children in the dark of night; or that we should run away and leave Iraq to disintegrate...these are the actions that undermine the troops and go against the national security of the USA. One must not ever place their own political interests above the general good of the entire nation. This is the mistake of the current leadership of the Democratic party. They have placed themselves in a position to profit from American strategic defeat. In essence Dean has climbed into political bed with the very factions we are at war with.

If it isn't illegal, it should be, or at least subject to numerous checks to ensure that it isn't abused. Sadly, this will be yet another tempest in a tea-pot. I hope I'm wrong.

I agree...but I have the opposite hope...I hope you're right. I can't imagine that much good would come from another investigation. The Plame investigation seems to be off the tracks the same way the "Whitewater" one went. Start looking for evidence of corruption and end up with perjury over a BJ charges....start looking at evidence of outting the CIA agent and you end up with obstruction charges.

George Clooney in "Syriana" said it best...in Washington you are innocent until investigated.

-z
 
Z -- some agreement here :)

But, as an observer, I have to say that -- whether National Security or housing programs -- this Congress (today, dominated by Republicans) has been terriically bad at "oversight."

We may disagree here, but oversight of things like AbuGrab, Gitmo, etc. have been cursory at best.

However, having said that, the fact that there is a battle shapping up in the Senate over the Patriot Act gives me some hope.
 
...
I don't believe you can rightly say meaningful oversight "will not take place". The Republican senators are not monolithic...and the Dem minority has a serious responsibility to keep the White House honest. I doubt they would shirk such an opportunity to throw darts at Bushco.
...
Dems throwing darts is not the same as Congressional oversight. Congressional oversight comes from committee hearings where the executive branch is questioned about its performance, particularly in applying the laws that the Congress makes. The evidence of the last 5 years indicates to me that there will be NO OVERSIGHT from Congress regarding this matter. I hope I'm wrong.
 
Dems throwing darts is not the same as Congressional oversight.
Tomat-o; tom-ah-to
Congressional oversight comes from committee hearings where the executive branch is questioned about its performance, particularly in applying the laws that the Congress makes. The evidence of the last 5 years indicates to me that there will be NO OVERSIGHT from Congress regarding this matter. I hope I'm wrong.

No oversight...that's pretty strong. Here's something that may interest you:
"There is no doubt that this is inappropriate," said Sen. Arlen Specter, R-Pa., chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee. He said there would be hearings early next year and that they would have "a very, very high priority."

So the Chairman of the House Judiciary Committee is promising oversight. Your pessimistic view of the system seems to have been refuted.

-z
 
So the Chairman of the House Judiciary Committee is promising oversight. Your pessimistic view of the system seems to have been refuted.

Promising oversight and actually performing it are two different things. Politicians promise lots of things that they never even intend to deliver. So this promise refutes his 'pessimistic view of the system'...how?
 
Tomat-o; tom-ah-to


No oversight...that's pretty strong. Here's something that may interest you:


So the Chairman of the House Judiciary Committee is promising oversight. Your pessimistic view of the system seems to have been refuted.

-z

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Senate_Report_of_Pre-war_Intelligence_on_Iraq

At the time of the report's release (July 9, 2004), Democratic members of the committee expressed the hope that "phase two" of the investigation, which was to include an assessment of how the Iraqi WMD intelligence was used by senior policymakers, would be completed quickly. Committee Chairman Pat Roberts (R-KS) said of phase two, "It is a priority. I made my commitment and it will get done."

On March 10, 2005, during a question-and-answer session after a speech he had given at the Woodrow Wilson Center, Senator Roberts said of the failure to complete phase two, "[T]hat is basically on the back burner." Senator John D. Rockefeller (D-WV), vice chairman of the Committee, made a statement later that day in which he said, "The Chairman agreed to this investigation and I fully expect him to fulfill his commitment... While the completion of phase two is long overdue, the committee has continued this important work, and I expect that we will finish the review in the very near future."

In a statement regarding the release of the report of the presidential WMD commission on March 31, 2005, Senator Roberts wrote, "I don’t think there should be any doubt that we have now heard it all regarding prewar intelligence. I think that it would be a monumental waste of time to replow this ground any further."

On April 10, 2005, Senators Roberts and Rockefeller appeared together on NBC's Meet the Press program. In response to a question about the completion of phase two of the investigation, Roberts said, "I'm perfectly willing to do it, and that's what we agreed to do, and that door is still open. And I don't want to quarrel with Jay, because we both agreed that we would get it done. But we do have--we have Ambassador Negroponte next week, we have General Mike Hayden next week. We have other hot-spot hearings or other things going on that are very important."

Moderator Tim Russert then asked Senator Rockefeller if he believed phase two would be completed, and he replied, "I hope so. Pat and I have agreed to do it. We've shaken hands on it, and we agreed to do it after the elections so it wouldn't be any sort of sense of a political attack. I mean that was my view; it shouldn't be viewed that way."

On August 2, 2005, Senator Diane Feinstein (D-CA) released the text of a letter she had sent to Senator Roberts, saying, in part, “I am increasingly dismayed by the delay in completing the Committee’s ‘Phase II’ investigation into intelligence prior to the Iraq War... I stand ready to participate in this investigation in any way possible."

On November 1, 2005, Senator Harry Reid (D-NV), the Senate minority leader, invoked a seldom-used provision of the Senate rules to place the body in a closed session. During a three-and-a-half hour discussion, agreement was reached on the creation of a six-member Senate panel to report by November 14 on "the intelligence committee's progress of the phase two review of the prewar intelligence and its schedule for completion."[5]

Phase two of the investgation has not yet been completed.
 
True. In past times of war civil liberties have been widely rolled back without much dissent from the American people. Propaganda, disinformation, censorship, and even the overtly racist internment of a target ethnic group has been tolerated. All in the name of national security during wartime.

We at least have a good record of repealing such curtailment of liberties once the threat has passed.

-z

I'm afraid this current "threat" is one which will never pass.
 
I seem to recall the NSA was doing this anyway through ECHELON.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON

Before the September 11, 2001 attacks and the legislation which followed it, US intelligence agencies were generally prohibited from spying on people inside the US and other western countries' intelligence services generally faced similar restrictions within their own countries. There are allegations, however, that ECHELON and the UKUSA alliance were used to circumvent these restrictions by, for example, having the UK facilities spy on people inside the US and the US facilites spy on people in the UK, with the agencies exchanging data (perhaps even automatically through the ECHELON system without human intervention).
 
Ah the wheels of government grind slowly onward.... So your point is what? That the Congress is slow? Here's another flash for you: Fire is hot.

No, the point is, promises from Republican committee chairmen about their oversight priorities should be taken with a big grain of salt; hgc's concerns are not refuted.

But not to worry...in Washington you're innocent until investigated...so Bushitler is already guilty! You folks should be rather happy I'd think. :rolleyes:

I'd be happy if you could stay away from straw-man arguments when responding to me. But who am I to criticize someone with such stunning skill and logic that he uses "rolleyes" as a debate tactic?

Carry on

-z

I will.
 
No, the point is, promises from Republican committee chairmen about their oversight priorities should be taken with a big grain of salt; hgc's concerns are not refuted.

Well this information about the NSA just came out. Do you expect an inquisitor to be dispatched immediately? You got a promise from the Judiciary Committee Chairman. What more would you have the government do today?
Even a "rush-to-judgement" takes a bit of time you know. :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes:

I'd be happy if you could stay away from straw-man arguments when responding to me. But who am I to criticize someone with such stunning skill and logic that he uses "rolleyes" as a debate tactic?

Sarcasm is not made of straw...but I suppose it's hard to discern on a message board. As for the "rolleyes; well I am a man of many various talents. I am also adept at :dl:
:big:
and :hit:
-z



I bet.

-z
 
Well this information about the NSA just came out. Do you expect an inquisitor to be dispatched immediately? You got a promise from the Judiciary Committee Chairman. What more would you have the government do today?
-z

You are still missing the point. My post showed a past example of a Republican chairman promising to make oversight a priority, only to subsequently drag his heels and call it a "monumental waste of time". hgc's concerns are valid because he, as I, have seen this dog and pony show before. What more would I have the Republican leadership in Congress to today? How about fullfilling its past promises before making new ones?
 
I don't believe you can rightly say meaningful oversight "will not take place". The Republican senators are not monolithic...and the Dem minority has a serious responsibility to keep the White House honest. I doubt they would shirk such an opportunity to throw darts at Bushco.

-z

I missed this the first time through. What are some of the things the Dem minority can do to keep the Bush administration honest? And since it's their "serious responsibility", when they do "throw darts", I can assume you are backing them 100%?
 
I missed this the first time through. What are some of the things the Dem minority can do to keep the Bush administration honest? And since it's their "serious responsibility", when they do "throw darts", I can assume you are backing them 100%?
I'd also like to learn more about this.

What do you mean, Rik, by "throw darts?" Is that meant disparagingly? Is that the appropriate label of any and all Dem criticism of this administration?

What power do Dems have in congress to provide oversight when they don't control the committees or the agenda of either house?
 
Something to consider about Arlen Spector. He almost was denied the chairmanship of Judiciary by the Rep leadership, despite his seniority, due to his pro-choice stance and other quasi-liberal positions. If he throws a wrench into the Alito confirmation, he will be dispatched forthwith. I wonder how much the Rep leadership will let out his leash on illegal domestic spying, if he actually is interested in providing oversight. I predict we'll find out soon if Spector puts greater value on his principles or his chairmanship. And that's no false dilemma.
 
Is it OK to at least be pleased that Mr. Faris was discovered before he found a way to take down the Brooklyn Bridge, or that the fertilizer truck-bomb plot in England was thwarted?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom