Medical and Healthcare phishing

skepticdoc

Critical Thinker
Joined
Jun 30, 2005
Messages
295
Please send me a PM if you are a Physician or are involved in any direct way with human healthcare.

I am a Skeptic Family Physician in the USA and tried to find out if there were other physcians in the Skeptic Forum. It seems that in that Forum there are very few that would acknowledge participation or would want to be identified.

I would like to find out if the situation is different in this Forum.

Thanks
 
Please send me a PM if you are a Physician or are involved in any direct way with human healthcare.

I am a Skeptic Family Physician in the USA and tried to find out if there were other physcians in the Skeptic Forum. It seems that in that Forum there are very few that would acknowledge participation or would want to be identified.

I would like to find out if the situation is different in this Forum.

Thanks

Why did you title your message Healthcare phishing? Do you realize that phishing refers to pretending to be someone or something that you are not in order to gain information?
 
I'm a skeptic nurse practitioner. I have a solo practice in occupational infectious disease. I'm on the prevention side and have had this practice 15 years now.
 
I'm a skeptic nurse practitioner. I have a solo practice in occupational infectious disease. I'm on the prevention side and have had this practice 15 years now.

So- are many practitioners on the opposite side?
 
I'm just curious to find out how many skeptical physicians or healthcare workers have taken the step to participate in skeptical forums.

My personal agenda is to find ways to be honest with my patients when they are in terminal stages and talk about Jesus or whatever.

I started a topic in the Skeptic Forum about practical applications for Evolution (I believe there are none, I believe in Evolution as a tool to describe/explain the biological diversity and one explanation for antibiotic resistance, that is a different thread!!!) and some member made claims that "I was just discussing the opening post with a biologist. After expressing his amazement that a physician -- of all people -- would even ask such a question, he said, "nothing in biology makes sense except in light of evolutionary theory." Does it get any more practical than that? "

My experience in medical list serves is that the majority of physicians are religious and a great deal even believe in/practice prayer, I felt that in the Skeptic Forum the majority of the members are in the "hard" sciences and do not have to get involved in healthcare outside of the personal level. They seem to be isolated from most people that have religious beliefs and have to make decisions for themselves or family members.
 
My personal agenda is to find ways to be honest with my patients when they are in terminal stages and talk about Jesus or whatever.


I'd think that EVERY physician is going to say "anything that makes a terminal person feel better about impending death is good treatment". What do you expect to hear? " Life is tuff, then you die and are disappated to atoms. Get over it. " ?

I suspect that there are a lot of Hospice nurses that profess to believe in an afterlife, if just to make their own job easier. Isn't it better if they have an option to the finality of what they do?

I sure envy those folks with a true faith in an afterlife. It makes what happens here so much less important. Me? I have to make the best of what I've been dealt in one hand.
 
So- are many practitioners on the opposite side?
Oh sure. Actually besides public health practitioners there is almost no one who has a practice like mine. Most infectious disease practitioners treat infected people. I treat people exposed or potentially exposed to infectious diseases.
 
..... After expressing his amazement that a physician -- of all people -- would even ask such a question, he said, "nothing in biology makes sense except in light of evolutionary theory." Does it get any more practical than that? "

My experience in medical list serves is that the majority of physicians are religious and a great deal even believe in/practice prayer, I felt that in the Skeptic Forum the majority of the members are in the "hard" sciences and do not have to get involved in healthcare outside of the personal level. They seem to be isolated from most people that have religious beliefs and have to make decisions for themselves or family members.
You are describing one of the biggest differences between the nursing model and the medical model of care. I happen to work with both models. However, I am an atheist and agree with the statement that the above doc made to you as far as the science and biology involved.

The medical model, and forgive me for grossly oversimplifying a very complex issue, is the practice of treating the disease. The nursing model is the practice of treating the patient.

For example, you can tell a patient what you recommend. I prefer to give them the information and have them decide how they want to proceed. I find most doctors rarely take that approach. They believe the patient wants them to decide. Some patients do. But others appreciate being part of the decision making process.

A specific example was when my Dad was dying of cancer. He had liver metastases and was getting acites from the liver damage. He told the doctor of the discomfort and the doctor offered him a surgical treatment called a Levine shunt. I explained to my Dad the experience my patients in the hospital had had with the shunt and the positive and negative he could expect from it. My Dad decided against the shunt. He died a little over a week later. I was very glad to have been able to offer him the informed choice instead of having a doctor say we can do this for your problem without knowing what the patient really experienced from the procedure.

Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need.

Another example, the more traditional one is the doctor typically diagnoses and orders treatment for a complicated chronic disease while nurses help the patient carry out a complicated treatment plan, educate them about the disease and help them cope.

We benefit from both models of care.
 
Last edited:
To Skeptigirl:

Before I unleash my wrath against you, I need to know a couple of things.

Are you practicing in the USA?

Would you have sent Randi to the undertaker with nursing comfort?

Do you wish to engage in a discussion regarding Medicine and Evolutionary theory? If you do let's start a new thread.
 
To Skeptigirl:

Before I unleash my wrath against you, I need to know a couple of things.

Are you practicing in the USA?

Would you have sent Randi to the undertaker with nursing comfort?

Do you wish to engage in a discussion regarding Medicine and Evolutionary theory? If you do let's start a new thread.
Excuse me? I think you either didn't read my post carefully or you have a warped interpretation of what it says.

Or do you have a chip on your shoulder about nurses?

Yes I practice in the USA. End stage cancer care is hardly relevant to the care given one with an acute MI. And the only comment I made about evolution was in response to your post. I interpreted your friend's comment to be saying that much of today's great advances in medicine are occurring in the field of genetic science. And with that I most certainly agree.

Unleash all the wrath you want. I have the utmost confidence in the competency of my practice.

And I should add my comment to you, How do you resolve your cognitive dissonance regarding your belief in a religion which when examined for validity by the scientific process fails to offer any more credence than any other religion? As in the saying, "when you examine why you reject other religions you'll understand why I reject yours" (paraphrased here).

In addition, how do you resolve the fact that anesthesia alleviates the pain of childbirth, which according to the Bible is the punishment women are supposed to endure for committing the original sin? Anesthesia wasn't in use until more than 1,000 years after Jesus died and isn't consistently used by all "saved" people and it is used by many non-believers. So did God have second thoughts about the pain with childbirth thing or are MDs who provide pain relief for women in labor who aren't "born again" committing sin against God's will?
 
Last edited:
I am neither a physician or a nurse, practitioner or otherwise. I am but a lowly Paramedic and a skepchick. I practice both medical and nursing model dependant upon what my patient needs are. There are times when I have to look them in the eye and tell them if you don't do A, B and C you will die. Then there are times when I hold the hand of a patient that is scared out of their mind and say the Lord's Prayer with them, even if I don't believe.

My job is to get them to the hospital alive, doctors and nurses make them well.


You can argue til you are blue in the face that as skeptics we should be honest with our patients at all times about being honest with terminal patients when they talk about Jesus and stuff, but that's not skepticism, that's atheism.

As a skeptic we can better serve our patients by telling them that we don't always have the answers but for now the best course of healing is through current medical standard of treatment and helping them make an informed decision wherever and whenever we can.




Boo
 
I am neither a physician or a nurse, practitioner or otherwise. I am but a lowly Paramedic and a skepchick. I practice both medical and nursing model dependant upon what my patient needs are. There are times when I have to look them in the eye and tell them if you don't do A, B and C you will die. Then there are times when I hold the hand of a patient that is scared out of their mind and say the Lord's Prayer with them, even if I don't believe.

My job is to get them to the hospital alive, doctors and nurses make them well.


You can argue til you are blue in the face that as skeptics we should be honest with our patients at all times about being honest with terminal patients when they talk about Jesus and stuff, but that's not skepticism, that's atheism.

As a skeptic we can better serve our patients by telling them that we don't always have the answers but for now the best course of healing is through current medical standard of treatment and helping them make an informed decision wherever and whenever we can.




Boo

Great reply!
 
You are describing one of the biggest differences between the nursing model and the medical model of care. I happen to work with both models. However, I am an atheist and agree with the statement that the above doc made to you as far as the science and biology involved.

The medical model, and forgive me for grossly oversimplifying a very complex issue, is the practice of treating the disease. The nursing model is the practice of treating the patient. .

So, what do Doctors do?

What does atheism have to do with Medicine? Do you think that Evolution has anything to do with Medicine?

Doctors want to cure you. They want to give you something to make you better. Sometimes that's not what you need..

So, what is wrong with that?

I think I understand what you are trying to say, but it is not coming out right. I know of Oncologists that create false hopes and "torture" patients with chemo, instead of just arranging for palliative care. Most people want to be "cured", "made better" or just made more comfortable. In the Netherlands some even want to be "put out of their misery" (euthanasia?).

Another example, the more traditional one is the doctor typically diagnoses and orders treatment for a complicated chronic disease while nurses help the patient carry out a complicated treatment plan, educate them about the disease and help them cope.

We benefit from both models of care.

So, who decides the complicated treatment plan? In the USA many physicians just go for the big money and delegate some of the most menial aspects of medical care to nurses, some of these nurses then think they know as much as doctors!

Some doctors perform at the level of nurses and diminish the caliber of the profession. I know of nurses and assistants that realize that there is more to know and then go to Medical School, they make excellent physicians!

If anybody has a "chip on her shoulder" it you, skeptigirl. I would too, if I misrepresented myself in the Forum.

True medical practice involves both prevention and treatment, both have to be based on SCIENCE, not opinion or faith or lack of.
 
I am confused, is this oncology palliative care?
End of life care. My Father had inoperable cancer with liver metastases. Did you think the Levine Shunt had anything to do with treatment of the cancer? No, all Levine shunts do is partially relieve acites and they do a very poor job of that. My Dad asked for some kind of relief for his uncomfortably distended abdomen. It wasn't going to extend his life. In fact it would have taken his last days away recovering from the surgery.

In my many years of nursing I have seen more than one doctor decide offering a worthless treatment was somehow better than offering no treatment. Is this a bad thing? It is a human reaction that is very understandable. But, (again, I'm oversimplifying and giving a black and white version of an issue that really consists of shades of gray), nursing practice isn't focused on offering a cure or treatment as much as it is offering care. From a nurse's viewpoint, assisting a patient with an incurable condition means dealing with the inevitable, not trying as hard to avoid it.

I practice in both fields. I think you may have gotten the impression I was judging one field as better than the other. Absolutely not. They compliment each other.

I think there are many nurses who don't understand that what physicians do is separate from what nurses do. Nurses understand they follow medical orders but underestimate what the nurse contributes independently of the doctor. Nurses make nursing diagnoses often with no recognition of them. They recognize what the patient needs but don't recognize they didn't just assess the patient, they diagnosed the patient.

At the same time there are many doctors who while they recognize nurses are needed, don't recognize that there is a nursing model and a medical model of care. That's why they make a medical diagnosis when a nursing diagnosis is needed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom