An Open Letter To The 9/11 Truth Movement

gumboot

lorcutus.tolere
Joined
Jun 18, 2006
Messages
25,327
Dear 9/11 Truth Movement,

I am writing this letter today to express my deep and sincere gratitude for the positive changes you have made in my life. Before I delve into the incredible way in which you have opened my eyes to reality, let me briefly recount my history, if I may.

Prior to my exposure to the Truth Movement film “9/11 In Plane Site” I had no awareness whatsoever of any conspiracy surrounding 9/11. Indeed, I was oblivious, blind, totally ignorant of the true state of affairs. Like so many fellow humans, I accepted, without reservation, the officially touted account of events. I did not linger on it, or consider further. I took no interest in political happenings after the event.

I was, to put it mildly, in the dark.

And then I saw this film “9/11 In Plane Site”. It opened my horizons to a new vista, a vista populated by a myriad of theories and ideas. But it was another video, “Loose Change 2nd Edition” which truly opened my eyes to the broader field of 9/11 Truth, and it is at the feet of the creators of that film that I humbly lay my offering of gratitude. For in seeking further truth regarding this film, I was led, via the wandering undergrowth-choked paths of the internet, to a seemingly innocent and peaceful forum known commonly as JREF.

Tranquil blue met me at the doorstep. Clean lines and clear text, and quaint emoticons called salutations. Online entities with names as diverse as life itself expressed their thoughts and feelings. I was sucked in, and I entered.

But what I found was something I could not have expected. For beneath the peaceful blue headers of the forum, and across the muted pages of dozens of threads, a war waged. Indeed, a battle of cataclysmic proportions. It was a struggle for the very future of reality as we know it.

I expected to find individuals with avatars and opinions larger than their cranial capacities. I expected to find clever and smug individuals like myself who found the 9/11 Truth Movement “silly” and “amusing”.

Instead I found myself scampering about the ankles of intellectual giants. I found myself face to toe with behemoths of analytical thought and cognitive reasoning. I found myself in the company of scientific and mathematical leviathans.

And over the coming months, as I scampered amongst these colossal figures of integrity and logic, I slowly grew, until I could jump up and brush their knees. And as I grew, I devoured the light that spilled from their minds to fall all about me. I came to the JREF blind, deaf, and mute. They showed me light and colour. They shared sound. They taught me to speak.

Slowly, I too learned to focus my thoughts and gather them accordingly, with a solid foundation of fact and reason, to blast destructive torrents of analysis at weak and frail arguments.

As I grew further still, and began to reach their waists, some even became friends. I gazed in awe as you of the Truth Movement slipped thief-like into their midst, only to be crushed and obliterated under the impact of their thoughts. I found friends, and people of great sensitivity, deep conviction, and razor-sharp wit. A host of entities I can name, whom I know would make me welcome, were I to appear one day at their doorstep, on the far side of the world.

And so I changed. No longer did I swallow blindly what I was shown or told. I learned to turn my skeptical eye against every piece of information slipping into my brain. I learned to seek out information, rather than just passively accept it. I learnt to never present opinion as fact. And I learned to laugh at frustration and blind ignorance, rather than scream at it.

And so I continue to grow, surrounded by these Titanic minds. Speaking boldly, I even envisage the day I shall be able to look these vast Herculean entities directly in the eye as an equal. And were it not for you, the Truth Movement, I would never have stumbled across that innocent, tranquil forum.

And so, from the very bottom of my heart, with the deepest and most sincere, unending gratitude, I thank you for coming into existence and spreading so far the false and unsupported claims you hold so dear.

Yours,
Gumboot
 
heh...I certainly have begun to mine for facts amongst my daily delving of whatever I may be doing. This place rocks.
 
Gumboot,

Whoa. Nicely said, indeed.

(I wish I'd written that!)

Cheers,
Lash
 
And so I continue to grow, surrounded by these Titanic minds. Speaking boldly, I even envisage the day I shall be able to look these vast Herculean entities directly in the eye as an equal.

You're there already. Me, not so much! :D
 
That is one of the best things I have read here in a long time. I see it has already been nominated for the Language Award. I saw that because I was about to nominate it myself.
Make no mistake, whether you feel like it or not, you are one of the giants here as well. You and many of the others who have contributed so much in your short time here have encouraged me to be less of a lurker. I still have a ways to go before I can even reach the toes, as you say. Continue growing, so that I may never catch up.
 
That is one of the best things I have read here in a long time. I see it has already been nominated for the Language Award. I saw that because I was about to nominate it myself.
Make no mistake, whether you feel like it or not, you are one of the giants here as well. You and many of the others who have contributed so much in your short time here have encouraged me to be less of a lurker. I still have a ways to go before I can even reach the toes, as you say. Continue growing, so that I may never catch up.

Seconded wholeheartedly, Gumboot-san.

I just wish I had an area of expertise such as yours that would help me to contribute more deeply, instead of just general knowledge. I was initially skeptical of 9/11 theories thanks in part to an emerging interest in logic, and a diminished interest in woo, but I was glad to find likeminded people gathering here over the past year and doing sterling work like yours, sensei.
 
Do you notice how some in the 'troof' movement have a hate on not just for this particular sub-forum, but for Randi and the JREF as a whole?

Could it be, one wonders, that maybe a sizeable proportion of 'troofers' are also believers in ghosts, ufos, psychic powers and all the other woo stuff?

There are some deep seated psychological problems at play with these people.
 
Thanks everyone for your nice words... :D

I had been thinking recently "what if the Truth movement had never been". What I realised was, certainly I would have lost out, had they never peddled their silly theories far enough that they reached us down here at the proverbial bottom of the world.

JREF has honed my mind in incredible ways, and absent some catastrophic and catalysing event - like a "9/11 Truth Video" the process of finding it would not have occured.

And aside from anything else, c'mon, read some of these threads! You guys are HILARIOUS! If the posts aren't overwhelming me with incredible new information I'm almost choking because I'm laughing so hard.

-Gumboot
 
Do you notice how some in the 'troof' movement have a hate on not just for this particular sub-forum, but for Randi and the JREF as a whole?

Could it be, one wonders, that maybe a sizeable proportion of 'troofers' are also believers in ghosts, ufos, psychic powers and all the other woo stuff?

There are some deep seated psychological problems at play with these people.

Very true, uk_dave. All the ones I've met at other forums (other than here and LC) have been woos in general. Troofism ties in with their desire to feel special and in possession of 'secret knowledge'. To them, skepticism and critical thinking implies the old furphy, 'a closed mind'. To them, logic means having the woo definition of an open mind, which is to swallow any theory, however crazy, so long as it goes against the mainstream.
 
Nice. I experienced the same arriving here a couple of years ago. I think I should thank the homeopaths, though. I was a skeptic before coming here, but grew in awareness and debating abilities. Learned to avoid the traps of futile argument. Learned to ignore silly baiting.

Yeah, this place rocks.

Hans
 
I can't recall how I first came across this site, as I lurked for a long time before joining. I tend to post only here and there, where I feel I might have something to add (oops, maybe this doesn't count...). I do read most of the top threads and tend to follow along even if I don't post.

I agree that the whole site is entertaining and the people fascinating. It seems to me that I probably found the site when researching psychics and cold reading. So, the usual story of frauds and morons leading (unintentionally) to an intellectual enlightenment for me.

Odd how you can really get a sense of being "born again" when you take a sceptical view of the world. Suddenly old thoughts take new directions and ordinary things seem wondrous. However, I think it is the opposite of what christians mean when they talk of being born again. Instead of your world-view contracting to only an invisible sky-daddy and his circle of worshippers, everything opens up. Anything is possible and should be considered - but also everything is to be questioned.

Absence of evidence is no longer used to justify a conclusion, but instead is used as a reason not to make a conclusion. Reality is the new god and data is the new priest. This is no less wondrous a deity and the sermons are more convincing than ever.

Thanks to all on this site for contributing to a truly Amazing place.
 
I think I was always a skeptic, but it took a place like this to begin to teach me how to articulate my position in debates effectively.

Still working on it...
 
Nominated.

And Gum: I, too, find myself doubting every little scrap of information fed to me, now. It's been going on since I discovered CSICOP, which eventually led me here.

ETA: And hopefully I'm the one making you laugh (and choke).
 
Well said, Gumboot. I have Clifford Carnicom to thank - his was the first really nutty website my sister pointed me towards as some "troof" that turned out to be complete nonsense.

I also look at every scrap of info that comes my way with a much keener eye. I've even been getting up well before dawn lately to study Robert T. Carroll's "Becoming a Critical Thinker". I hate feeling ignorant about anything and only wish I had more time to devote to my newly-found appetite for knowledge and analytical skills, including the time it takes to lurk and post here more frequently.

As it is, I rarely have a week when I don't get to tell my husband about some interesting thread, previously unheard of fact, or LOL-worthy comment that I read in here. Gravy, Abby, Delphi, Zenith (I miss you!), Skeptic...and Gumboot!... he knows where I've been when he hears those names. :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom