Mephisto
Philosopher
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2005
- Messages
- 6,064
Now, is this legal? Someone breaks into an elderly ladies home, at night, in a crime-ridden neighborhood (no saying whether they identified themselves as police officers, or that she could hear/understand that they were), and they're surprised that they're fired upon?
Sounds to me like the lady was within her rights, and the police were a little trigger-happy. Oh, regarding the "drugs found" at the address, make note how the drugs aren't identified as illegal drugs (they could be high blood pressure medication and pain relievers).
92-year-old killed in 'roughest neighborhood in Georgia'
POSTED: 10:19 p.m. EST, November 22, 2006
ATLANTA, Georgia (AP) -- Many people on the run-down northwest Atlanta street where Kathryn Johnston lived fortify their windows with metal bars and arm themselves for protection.
Johnston, 92, was no exception.
Alone in her home, she was waiting with her gun on Tuesday night when a group of plainclothes officers with a warrant knocked down her door in a search for drugs, police said.
She opened fire, wounding three officers, before being shot to death, police said. (Watch niece's fury at police shooting )
Assistant Police Chief Alan Dreher called the killing "tragic and unfortunate" but said the officers were justified in returning fire.
"You don't know who's in the house until you open that door," Dreher said Wednesday. "And once they forced open the door, they were immediately fired upon."
My comment Apparently, they didn't think the inverse might also be true - that the old woman might have been slightly scared about who was trying to gain entrance to her home.
The Rev. Markel Hutchins, a civil rights activist and spokesman for Johnston's family, said he could understand why the elderly woman would arm herself.
"She was afraid," Hutchins said. "This is a horrifying situation in a neighborhood where crime happens often. This incident is a result of a mix-up."
http://www.cnn.com/2006/US/11/22/woman.shot.ap/index.html
Sounds to me like the lady was within her rights, and the police were a little trigger-happy. Oh, regarding the "drugs found" at the address, make note how the drugs aren't identified as illegal drugs (they could be high blood pressure medication and pain relievers).
92-year-old killed in 'roughest neighborhood in Georgia'
POSTED: 10:19 p.m. EST, November 22, 2006
ATLANTA, Georgia (AP) -- Many people on the run-down northwest Atlanta street where Kathryn Johnston lived fortify their windows with metal bars and arm themselves for protection.
Johnston, 92, was no exception.
Alone in her home, she was waiting with her gun on Tuesday night when a group of plainclothes officers with a warrant knocked down her door in a search for drugs, police said.
She opened fire, wounding three officers, before being shot to death, police said. (Watch niece's fury at police shooting )
Assistant Police Chief Alan Dreher called the killing "tragic and unfortunate" but said the officers were justified in returning fire.
"You don't know who's in the house until you open that door," Dreher said Wednesday. "And once they forced open the door, they were immediately fired upon."
My comment Apparently, they didn't think the inverse might also be true - that the old woman might have been slightly scared about who was trying to gain entrance to her home.
The Rev. Markel Hutchins, a civil rights activist and spokesman for Johnston's family, said he could understand why the elderly woman would arm herself.
"She was afraid," Hutchins said. "This is a horrifying situation in a neighborhood where crime happens often. This incident is a result of a mix-up."
http://www.cnn.com/2006/US/11/22/woman.shot.ap/index.html
