Larry Lovage
Thinker
- Joined
- Oct 26, 2006
- Messages
- 220
40 out of 60 would be significant. I don't see that 4 right answers out of 6 could remotely count as significant enough to qualify for the final test.Eight experienced dowsers took part in 6 trials in which they were required to locate a bottle of water in a concealed container from a row of six such containers, the remaining five containing sand. Participants had to locate the water 4 or more times out of the 6 trials in order to pass the test. In line with previous controlled tests of dowsing ability, the results for each individual dowser were below chance expectations.
And surely performance less than chance is no less miraculous than more thanchance. If the dowsers are making the wrong decision from the information they are receiving such that they are moving away from the water instead of towards it, it simply sounds as if the experiment is not as completely rigorously controlled as it would need to be.
Can someone explain this to me? Reading the Million Dollar prize applications, I've frequently been disturbed by what seem to be lacklustre controls over the qualifying demonstrations, such that it begins to look like the psychics' (etc) criticisms of the Randi prize conditions could almost be justified.