Is there a doctor in the house?

RemieV

Philosopher
Joined
Jul 29, 2006
Messages
5,292
Let me start this off with "I am a skeptic." I really am. No joke.

I'm hoping that there is a pharmacist out there who can explain something to me.

The other night, I had a killer headache. I hadn't eaten anything in a while, so, thinking maybe that was the source of the trouble, I had some dinner. Half an hour later, the headache raged on. It was the perfect time to test the power of "Head-On," a homeopathic headache remedy that comes in a tube sort of like a gluestick.

You apply it directly to your forehead. Within seconds, so the ads say, your headache will be gone.

I didn't buy it. But I wanted to write an article on the product saying how it didn't work for the SAPS site. So I dragged myself to the pharmacy down the road and bought some.

I felt awful in the pharmacy. The lights were bright, I was nauseated. My head was killing me, and I wanted to slap the checkout person, who was taking too long. Everything smelled too strongly, and I wanted to bang my head against the walls.

I got back home, perhaps ten minutes later, and applied the gunk directly to my forehead. It burned strangely. I kind of laughed internally, already beginning to phrase the stinging article I'd write about the worthlessness of "Head-On". About thirty seconds after I applied the stuff, I realized my headache was gone.

I shook my head really hard to make sure. It was definitely gone.

So I read the ingredients list, and wrote to thirty pharmacology professors asking if any of the ingredients could possibly cure headaches. I didn't think about it being finals week, so of course no one wrote back.

If there's a doctor out there, I'd love to hear if any of these ingredients can a) be absorbed via forehead and b) cure headaches.

The "active" ingredients are in very very very small amounts, it being a homeopathic treatment. So, undoubtedly, none of them are responsible.

Just in case, they are kali bichromium (6X H.P.U.S.) and bryonia alba (12X H.P.U.S.)

The inactive ingredients, which can be any amount, are:

diazolidinyl urea, ethyl alcohol, iodopropynl butylcarbamate, menthol, menthyl lactate, propylene glycol, sodium stearate, steareth-21, tetrasodium EDTA, triethanolamine water


I am also perfectly willing to admit that eating might be what cured the headache, and the timing just happened to perfectly coincide. It really doesn't *seem* that way, but it's a possibility.

Anyway, how about those ingredients, my phd friends?



Thanks,


Remie
 
All the doctors are asleep now so I'll answer. Nothing applied to the skin could possibly cause it to go away within 30 seconds, unless possibly the act of doing so relaxed you. 30 seconds later the stuff would be slightly absorbed into the top layer of skin and nothing else would've happened beyond that by then. Try doing the same thing with whipped cream next time maybe. That's my uninformed homeopathic advice.
 
A sample size of one doesn't meet my standards.

So your report, while interesting, is not persuasive.

The product contains menthol which does have a physiolologic effect. It is possible the menthol altered the etiology of your headache and it is equally possible the pain relief was unrelated to the product and the timing of your relief was coincidental.
 
All the doctors are asleep now so I'll answer. Nothing applied to the skin could possibly cause it to go away within 30 seconds, unless possibly the act of doing so relaxed you. 30 seconds later the stuff would be slightly absorbed into the top layer of skin and nothing else would've happened beyond that by then. ....
Well, not exactly. Applying menthol to one's forehead does result in fairly rapid inhalation of the chemical compound. And, a few chemicals are absorbed via skin in small amounts. Drugs absorbed via the skin include nicotine, nitroglycerin, scopolamine, clonidine, and fentanyl. But sometimes small amounts can be effective.

Then there is DSMO which is a solvent that can carry drugs more efficiently through the skin. It is a common woo treatment and not anything I'd put in my body but it is efficient in passing through the skin barrier.
 
A sample size of one doesn't meet my standards.

So your report, while interesting, is not persuasive.

The product contains menthol which does have a physiolologic effect. It is possible the menthol altered the etiology of your headache and it is equally possible the pain relief was unrelated to the product and the timing of your relief was coincidental.

I knew that something like this would happen. Where did it sound like I was trying to be persuasive? I'm not saying a sample size of one is worth anything. I'm not even saying that "Head-On" is responsible for curing my headache. I am asking if the drug combination of "Head-On" could possibly have any effect on headaches whatsoever. And I already mentioned the possibility of complete coincidence.

This is not a woo thread, and this is not about anecdotal evidence. I am supplying a backstory for the question, and that's all. Hand to God.

Thank you for the post that addresses the absorption possibilities.
 
It wasn't a personal comment, it was a straightforward one. I was merely articulating the specifics of what your experience indicated. I assumed you already knew it was a likely coincidence from your OP.
 
It used to throw me a bit when doctors use the statement, "I'm not impressed." But now I'm used to the fact it only means they don't think xyz is likely or something to that effect. It doesn't mean they think less of you for asking or even for considering it.
 
1) Patient has headache, caused usually by tense muscles in neck and face, etc.

2) Rubbing/massaging tense muscles usually causes them to relax a bit. Blood flow increases too, further aiding the process.

3) Applying Head-On involves rubbing/massaging it into the skin at the site of pain, namely the tense areas!

4) You could have just as easily rubbed in baby-oil, massage-oil, or even 20W50 grade motor-oil for that matter. It is the method of application that is doing the work, not the product being applied.

5) Placebo testing with other substances would have shown this.

6) PLUS: Menthol causes increased topical blood flow in skin (redness), and there is the psychological effect of "taking some relief action".

7) I hope you didn't pay anything for the Head On crap...
 
I don't think it has anything to do with absorption of ingredients, but rather the local effect of menthol on the skin (similar to placing a cool cloth on your forehead or applying one of those cold patches). Sometimes (often) pain can be relieved simply by providing a counter-stimulus.

Linda
 
I'm not a doctor, or even close, but a headache sufferer.

I had a migraine for a few days, and eventually I ran out of tablets so had to go the the shop. The horror story of the shop sounds familiar :(
Anyway, after about half an hour of getting home I notice the headache is lifting. The only thing different was the fact that I'd been out. I hadn't left the house since it started. This was the beginning of the end for that particular migraine.
I decided it must have been the fresh air that helped, and now if I get a bad head I always attempt to get out, even if it's just into my back garden. I haven't had a full blown migraine since that day...

Just wondering if your trip to the shops did it, instead of the woo drops?
 
The inactive ingredients, which can be any amount, are:

diazolidinyl urea, ethyl alcohol, iodopropynl butylcarbamate, menthol, menthyl lactate, propylene glycol, sodium stearate, steareth-21, tetrasodium EDTA, triethanolamine water
Is this the order in which they are listed on the label? If so, it is surely mislabeled because if diazolidinyl urea were the major component, it would be irritating as hell.
 
Is this the order in which they are listed on the label? If so, it is surely mislabeled because if diazolidinyl urea were the major component, it would be irritating as hell.

Maybe it's not counting the wax base in the inactive ingredients?

If diazolidinyl urea is irritating, then it would make sense that a small amount would provide a counter-stimulant effect. Essentially, the effect may be coming from the inactive ingredients with no effect from the active ingredients. :)

Linda
 
I agree with Zep. Menthol is the same stuff as in BenGay. It irritates the skin, thus increasing the blood flow to the area. Plus, sometimes if I have a mild migraine, a bit of gentle exercise will help it go away.
 
Maybe it's not counting the wax base in the inactive ingredients?

If diazolidinyl urea is irritating, then it would make sense that a small amount would provide a counter-stimulant effect. Essentially, the effect may be coming from the inactive ingredients with no effect from the active ingredients. :)

Linda
It's a good point that it is a solid dosage form. Nonetheless, the order of ingredients on the listing is very important (the standard is listing from highest to lowest concentration). Diazolidinyl urea isn't a mild irritant like menthol, it will peel your skin and cause allergic contact dermatitis.
http://hazmap.nlm.nih.gov/cgi-bin/hazmap_generic?tbl=TblAgents&id=1235

By the way, the ingredients "ethyl alcohol" and "sodium stearate" make a really cheap "stick." There is probably no wax.
 
The homeopathic ingredients count for nothing, given the dilutions. Yet, despite the presence of definitively active ingredients, it is the homeopathic ingredients that get the credit.
They are only speculating that there is enough menthol to act as a counter-irritant, as opposed to a fragrance. While the ingredient list is suspect, it favors the latter (fragrance) interpretation.

As usual, the data in Wiki is questionable.
 
(For the record, not a doctor either.)

Just curious, Remie. You haven't mentioned drinking any water, either with your meal or later. But dehydration, more than hunger, is likely to cause a headache. If you had a glass of water, say, just before or after your trip to the drugstore, that might have had a big effect. Yet it's something you might not have taken note of at the time (you don't have to feel extremely thirsty, to be dehydrated), nor thought important enough to include in your account.

I like to point out to people that Excedrin contains aspirin, acetominophen, and caffeine, so if you take it with a big glass of water, you've taken four of the most effective headache remedies available.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Last edited:
It's a good point that it is a solid dosage form. Nonetheless, the order of ingredients on the listing is very important (the standard is listing from highest to lowest concentration). Diazolidinyl urea isn't a mild irritant like menthol, it will peel your skin and cause allergic contact dermatitis.
http://hazmap.nlm.nih.gov/cgi-bin/hazmap_generic?tbl=TblAgents&id=1235

By the way, the ingredients "ethyl alcohol" and "sodium stearate" make a really cheap "stick." There is probably no wax.

I realize the listing of ingredients is from highest to lowest. I think you are suggesting that the alcohol/fatty acid combination accounts for the "stick", so the diazolidinyl urea must form a large portion of the ingredients (if present)?

I was thinking that they may not include "paraffin" in the ingredient list in something like that, and that the ingredients on the list could all be in small to very small concentration. Maybe the "wax" from the stearate/alcohol helps soften the main base?

If that's not the case, then it does sound like that list can't be accurate.

Linda
 
If that's not the case, then it does sound like that list can't be accurate.

Linda
Yeah, I think further speculation as to contents and possible active ingredients is unwarranted.
 
The order I wrote the ingredients in is indeed the order that they appear in. I feel that I should probably say this again in case it was lost somewhere in the story - I am a skeptic. I am the founder of a skeptical society. The link in my signature will take you to the site.

Yes, I spend money on woo products. I spend it so I can write about them.

No, it didn't work because the stuff was massaged in - it wasn't. Not any more than one massages in lipstick.

My question doesn't have anything to do with where my mind is or the possible psychological effects or whether I drank any water. I promise.

I am aware of how many variables one must take into account when looking at this. I was only asking about the possible efficacy of the ingredients that were listed as inactive.

Thanks to the people who seemed to catch that.

-- Remie
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom