Skeptoid Podcast: Cell phones and airlines

Jeff Wagg

Illuminator
Joined
Sep 24, 2003
Messages
3,125
Location
Chicago
I had the pleasure of listening to Brian's "Cell Phones on Airplanes" podcast.. while on an airplane. And I noticed two cell phones that were turned on during the flight. I know I've accidentally left mine on as well. If there's a threat from an active cell phone, the airlines are doing a terrible job of protecting us from it. I suspect there is no threat.

I did have a thought though. If everyone is listening to iPods, it makes it difficult for the crew to issue orders. However, I think an emergency would be obvious enough that people would notice.

I just wish they didn't lie to us.
 
The pilots are responsible for safely flying and landing an aircraft carrying many dozens of people. I'm not. Although it has not been firmly established that cell phones interfere with avionics, I'll take the aircrew's word for it and respect their wish to not have cell phones on during flight.

FCC's take on it:

http://www.fcc.gov/cgb/consumerfacts/cellonplanes.html

also

http://www.fcc.gov/kidszone/teachersguide/isittrue.pdf

FAA:

http://www.faa.gov/passengers/fly_safe/information/

Consumer Affairs:

http://www.consumeraffairs.com/news04/2006/03/cell_phones_planes.html

The study by Carnegie Mellon University researchers has found that cell phones and other portable electronic devices, like laptops and game-playing devices, can pose dangers to the normal operation of critical electronics on airplanes.

Maybe they're lying, maybe they're not. I think their concerns are genuine.

Aside from those concerns, there is the consideration of common courtesty to other passengers:

http://www.consumeraffairs.com/news04/2005/cell_air2.html

Among reasons poll participants cited for keeping the current cell phone ban in place:

• 78 percent of participants agreed that cell phone use in already-tense, close quarters of an airplane could lead to increased passenger unruliness and interfere with flight attendants' ability to maintain order.
• 78 percent believed that cell phones might distract passengers from hearing life-saving instructions in an emergency.
• 82 percent said cell phones might "make planes uncomfortable and be disruptive" to passengers wishing to read or nap.
• 87 percent were alarmed when informed that pilots have reported many cases of problems with navigational equipment possibly caused by cell phones or other electronic devices turned on in flight.
• 84 percent agreed that it is too soon to lift the ban while the Federal Aviation Administration is still studying whether cell phones interfere with aircraft systems.
 
Last edited:
http://www.tc.faa.gov/its/worldpac/techrpt/ar06-41.pdf

This study provided the first reported characterization of the RF environment in the cabins of commercial airline flights. The key conclusions were that (1) onboard cellular telephone calls were observed in-flight and activity is appreciable; (2) signal activity was observed in the aviation critical frequency bands at field strengths capable on causing interference to onboard avionics; and (3) onboard spectral activity was observed at flight critical phases.

I'm not willing to risk avionics interference by using a cell phone on a flying aircraft.
 
Could you speculate on why there are no restrictions against bringing cell phones on board planes, inside the passenger cabin? Surely this would not be allowed if they were dangerous.
 
Could you speculate on why there are no restrictions against bringing cell phones on board planes, inside the passenger cabin? Surely this would not be allowed if they were dangerous.
No, I can't, but the fact that people are allowed to bring cell phones, pagers, etc. on board does not mean people should be allowed to use them on board, or that there is no valid concern regarding avionics interference.
 
Press release from Carnegie Mellon:

http://www.cmu.edu/PR/releases06/060228_cellphone.html

"We found that the risk posed by these portable devices is higher than previously believed," said Bill Strauss, who recently completed his Ph.D. in EPP at Carnegie Mellon. "These devices can disrupt normal operation of key cockpit instruments, especially Global Positioning System (GPS) receivers, which are increasingly vital for safe landings." Strauss is an expert in aircraft electromagnetic compatibility at the Naval Air Warfare Center in Patuxent River, Md.
 
The IEEE online article:

http://www.spectrum.ieee.org/mar06/3069

In March 2004, acting on a number of reports from general aviation pilots that Samsung SPH-N300 cellphones had caused their GPS receivers to lose satellite lock, NASA issued a technical memorandum that described emissions from this popular phone. It reported that there were emissions in the GPS band capable of causing interference. Disturbingly, though, they were low enough to comply with FCC emissions standards.

Our data and the NASA studies suggest to us that there is a clear and present danger: cellphones can render GPS instrument useless for landings. Clearly, the cause of the problem is that the FCC issues RF emission standards for consumer electronics, conferring only minimally with the FAA and with no formal consideration of the implications of those standards for the aircraft environment. For its part, the FAA relies on the airlines to initiate safety plans and, like other government agencies, defers to the FCC on questions of electromagnetic radiation.

Print version, with charts and graphs.

http://www.spectrum.ieee.org/print/3069

I'll comply with the request to turn 'em off, thanks.
 
Last edited:
Certainly it's pointless to go back & forth like this - For every piece of research I present, you can certainly find an editorial or magazine article refuting it, and vice versa. In any question like this one, where there are interested parties on both sides of the debate, there will be conflicting data published.

Another point I find interesting - that I wish I had included in the podcast - is the FCC's current proposal for allowing cell phone calls on planes. It will install a miniature cell tower on board commercial planes, which will then communicate with ground stations in a way that the FCC likes better. Notice that you'd still be using your normal cell phone. Even this "next generation" proposal concedes that there's no realistic conflict between cell phones and avionics.
 
Certainly it's pointless to go back & forth like this - For every piece of research I present, you can certainly find an editorial or magazine article refuting it, and vice versa. In any question like this one, where there are interested parties on both sides of the debate, there will be conflicting data published.

Another point I find interesting - that I wish I had included in the podcast - is the FCC's current proposal for allowing cell phone calls on planes. It will install a miniature cell tower on board commercial planes, which will then communicate with ground stations in a way that the FCC likes better. Notice that you'd still be using your normal cell phone. Even this "next generation" proposal concedes that there's no realistic conflict between cell phones and avionics.
I don't think it's pointless to discuss different sides of an issue, or to present conflicting research. I do not agree that there is no realistic conflict between cell phones and avionics; to agree to that premise would be to dismiss the valid expert research I've sourced previously.

Even the proposed pico cell solution has its limitations and they have yet to develop and test a system. This isn't a "case closed" question by any means.

Certainly, the ability to use cell phones during flight will benefit business interests in this age of constant contact. Allowing people to use cell phones during flight might also provide them with some convenience. Despite this, until it can be demonstrated that there is no risk to avionics communications, my vote is to keep the cell phones and other devices off. I can accept not using my cell phone use for a few hours. I can't accept the aircraft being flown the wrong way.
 
Last edited:
I prefer cell phones stayed banned because I find people on cell phones annoying. I do not want to hear someone yammer on the entire flight about utter nonsense. It interferes with by normal thought pattern.

It is stupid to ban cell phones on the basis no one will hear life saving announcements. No one listens to those anyway.
 
Pyrrho, the problem is, if cell phones are dangerous, then we're all in grave danger, because people DO leave them on, and if they're on, they're sending and receiving signals.

So, it seems to me, that either we're in danger due to lax regulations, or the current rules are silly (or a misdirection).

I do, however, comply with the cell phone rules (when I remember).
 
Pyrrho, the problem is, if cell phones are dangerous, then we're all in grave danger, because people DO leave them on, and if they're on, they're sending and receiving signals.

So, it seems to me, that either we're in danger due to lax regulations, or the current rules are silly (or a misdirection).

I do, however, comply with the cell phone rules (when I remember).
It's not necessarily an either/or issue, and it is not a given that the rules, even if misguided, are either silly or a misdirection.

The IEEE authors contend that there is in fact a clear and present danger regarding cell phones and GPS instruments. They address the question of whether or not cell phone use has caused or contributed to aviation accidents:

http://www.spectrum.ieee.org/mar06/3069/4

So what about accidents? We can extrapolate by looking at the existence of interference. Beginning in the 1930s, industrial safety pioneer H.W. Heinrich found—across many industries—that the ratio of incidents to accidents is about 300 to 1. Since then, this ratio has been approximately confirmed in a number of studies, including ones by the U.S. Air Force in the early 1970s. If this ratio holds true for the aviation industry, then we would expect PED interference to be a factor in an accident about once every 12 years, if we use the upper boundary for reporting that we described previously. If cellphone use increases dramatically with new regulations, we can expect the risk to rise correspondingly.

They make some rather sensible recommendations on page 5 http://www.spectrum.ieee.org/mar06/3069/5

I stand corrected about the development and testing of pico cell systems--the article states that this has occurred.
 
Last edited:
The mythbusters did a session on cell phones and aircraft. They failed to prove that phones interfere with aircraft. However they said it was plausible.
 
I'm with firecoins.
The principal danger of permitting cellphones on aircraft is that after five hours sitting next to some moron rabbiting on a cellphone, it would be quite understandable if any decent , meek , mild human being tore the bastard's throat out. As no sharp edged tools are permitted, he would have to do so using teeth and a plastic fork, which could be messy.

The day they permit these tools of the Devil to be used is the day I release my patented pocket EMP device for public use. And I don't care if I'm on an Airbus and the flight controls default to DOS 5. Given the choice between listening to boring lackwits on cellphones or falling 33,000 feet in a spiralling plunge to a fiery death, pass me the flamethrower !
 
Last edited:
Not lax regulations. Lax enforcement of regulations.

Well, I was suggesting that since enforcement is lax (how could they know a cell phone in someone's carry on bag was left on?) that a new regulation preventing cell phones from going through airport security would be in order.
 
Good business opportunity for cellphone rental there. Step off the plane, there's a rack of the things in the arrivals hall. Tap in your credit card number to release. Put in your SIM card. Bingo.

Let's face it though- cellphones are no longer phones. They are evolving as we watch. How many phones just make calls?
I loathe the things, but don't expect them to go away.
 
Good business opportunity for cellphone rental there. Step off the plane, there's a rack of the things in the arrivals hall. Tap in your credit card number to release. Put in your SIM card. Bingo.

Let's face it though- cellphones are no longer phones. They are evolving as we watch. How many phones just make calls?
I loathe the things, but don't expect them to go away.

Just an FYI: We don't have SIM cards in the US.

Maybe, the two industries could get together and make the phones safer?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom