StopSylviaBrowne: Shawn Hornbeck Reading

I just saw the good news that the two boys had been found. So, in two different kidnapping cases, Sylvia got them both wrong in opposite ways. Gee...I think Sylvia may just not be a real psychic. :p
 
Just wondering -- are you planning on including a Forum of sorts? It would be interesting to see what people contribute.
 
I just saw the good news that the two boys had been found. So, in two different kidnapping cases, Sylvia got them both wrong in opposite ways. Gee...I think Sylvia may just not be a real psychic. :p
Oh Lisa, you're such a skeptic!

Little nitpick: how about he is alive...
I had considered that. It is accurate, since he was alive when she said he was dead. I don't know. I'll think about it. But thanks!

Nitpick: some of the links on the bottom of the page are hosed.
Doh! Actually, even fixed, those probably won't work for a while. Those sites about Shawn are absolutely swamped right now... Thanks!

Just wondering -- are you planning on including a Forum of sorts? It would be interesting to see what people contribute.
No, I'm not. I think the tone of the site is important to its success, and I think that opening it up to a forum (or to comments on the articles, another thing I considered) would have a negative effect on the site's tone.
 
I posted something about this in a different forum. Good job.

According to a story in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, Shawn Hornbeck's parents spent over $40,000 on psychics. One thing that's odd -- their website said Sylvia Browne did not do a reading for them. They were told she would do a reading for $700, but was too busy. Apparently, they met her on Montel Williams' show later, and forgot to update their site. I had a hard time getting links on their website to work due to the heavy traffic.

Again, nice work on the website. I would love to see Sylvia and all of the other psychic predators go out of business.

There is a reference to their appearance on the Montel Williams website.

montelshow.com/show/?showID=2051

It was on Feb. 26, 2003
 
Last edited:
I know I might be a bit naive and I really apologize about that.

But if someone shows your website to the police, can't they just arrest her? I mean, it's obvious that what she does is crime after crime and ruining people's lives on the way. After all the facts on your site and other places, why no one is doing anything to stop her? Why isn't she in jail? It doesn't make any sense. It's not like there's any doubt about her being a fraud, there are facts everywhere! I don't understand this.
 

Browne told the Akers that it was her vision that Shawn was taken by a "dark-skinned man, he wasn't black -- more like hispanic." She said he had long, black hair that he wore in dreadlocks and was "really tall."

Pfft. The guy was so white and had practically no hair. I doubt he is more than average height too.


can't they just arrest her

Freedom of speech. She can say whatever the heck she wants. I just wish she didn't fleece people the way she does while she is spewing lies.
 
Isn't it against the law if you take money over those lies? I've heard about a lot of frauds that get arrested over things like this, some of them much less dangerous than her.
 
I can say she's lying, because the evidence tells me so. She hasn't fleeced me though, since I don't believe her-because the evidence tells me not to.

If enough people get together that she did fleece, then maybe they can charge her with fraud. Are they willing? Do they have the money she now does to go to court with? Would it be worth her victims to go through that?
 
I had considered that. It is accurate, since he was alive when she said he was dead. I don't know. I'll think about it. But thanks!

I just think the present tense has more punch. The past tense sounds like he might have died since...
 
What about false advertising? Is it illegal in America for an individual to put in an advertisement which cannot be backed up by facts?

RSLancaster
You forgot to put in your tags. That is why I could not find this thread. Please put them in now. Also thanks for your PMs.
 
I posted something about this in a different forum. Good job.
Thanks, ksb.

According to a story in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, Shawn Hornbeck's parents spent over $40,000 on psychics. One thing that's odd -- their website said Sylvia Browne did not do a reading for them. They were told she would do a reading for $700, but was too busy. Apparently, they met her on Montel Williams' show later, and forgot to update their site. I had a hard time getting links on their website to work due to the heavy traffic.
Yes, the Shawn Hornbeck sites have been absolutely swamped.

Again, nice work on the website. I would love to see Sylvia and all of the other psychic predators go out of business.

There is a reference to their appearance on the Montel Williams website.

montelshow.com/show/?showID=2051

It was on Feb. 26, 2003
Thanks for the link.

I know I might be a bit naive and I really apologize about that.

But if someone shows your website to the police, can't they just arrest her? I mean, it's obvious that what she does is crime after crime and ruining people's lives on the way. After all the facts on your site and other places, why no one is doing anything to stop her? Why isn't she in jail? It doesn't make any sense. It's not like there's any doubt about her being a fraud, there are facts everywhere! I don't understand this.
Join the club, DJM.

Luckily, it looks like the JREF is going to be pursuing this angle with people like Browne (see this section of this week's commentary for details.

I for one am anxious to see how it turns out.

Pfft. The guy was so white and had practically no hair. I doubt he is more than average height too.
You might have seen the first pictures. The ones of him in the orange jumpsuit being escorted by police, show a fair amount of hair, and he looks to be taller than the officers.

I just think the present tense has more punch. The past tense sounds like he might have died since...
Understood. Still thinking about it!

What about false advertising? Is it illegal in America for an individual to put in an advertisement which cannot be backed up by facts?
You'd think so. But what exactly does she advertise? And she herself says that she is only right 86% of the time (:rr:), so even if she is wrong for YOUR reading, well, she never said she was always right!

:rm:

RSLancaster
You forgot to put in your tags. That is why I could not find this thread. Please put them in now. Also thanks for your PMs.
done! And, you're welcome.

RSL - You've been mentioned (obliquely) over at MetaFilter.
Nice! Oblique is fine, just get the link right!

The site has been getting lots of mention lately in places where Browne is discussed. Some people in this thread seemed to get a kick out of the site's logo.
 
Well, the legality of fortune telling in the U.S. depends on local laws, and these are usually not enforced. Also, it's pretty easy to interpret the actions as being legal--all Browne has to do is say "for entertainment purposes only" somewhere on her website and she's off the hook, even though this is clearly a lie.

It might be an interesting exercise for a plant to question her on this and see if she'll admit that it is not for entertainment.

As far as all her predictions being wrong, I don't think this is technically illegal. She agreed to do whatever it is she does and she did her best. She doesn't claim 100% success at it. It's like a being a hairdresser--if the client is truly dissatisfied they give the money back, but normally the hairdresser is only asked to do what she/he is trained to do with a reasonable degree of competence and to the best of his/her abilities.
 
<snippage by TjW>
It might be an interesting exercise for a plant to question her on this and see if she'll admit that it is not for entertainment.
<snippage by TjW>

Yes, I'm certain the parents were quite entertained by being told their son was dead.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom