Sue the Homeless

BPSCG

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Mar 27, 2002
Messages
17,539
A high-end antique dealer on the Upper East Side is suing four unnamed homeless people for $1 million on the grounds that they've driven away customers by loitering on the sidewalk in "old, warn, and unsanitary clothing and cardboard boxes and old blankets which they convert into sleeping accommodations."

In addition to money, Karl Kemp & Associates Antiques, located near 69th Street at 833 Madison Ave. near Gucci, Chanel, and Prada, is asking a Manhattan Supreme Court judge to force the homeless defendants to stay at least 100 feet away from the store, according to legal papers filed yesterday.

For more than two years, the papers allege, the homeless have spent "significant amounts of time" obstructing Karl Kemp's storefront window display, "consuming alcoholic beverages from open bottles, performing various bodily functions such as urinating or spitting on the sidewalk, and…verbally harassing or intimidating … prospective customers."

Link.

I checked today's date; it's not April 1.
 
1) 1 Million Dollars

2) Restraining order, requiring they stay 100 feet away.


I'm betting he gets #2.

Any takers?

:)
 
1) 1 Million Dollars

2) Restraining order, requiring they stay 100 feet away.


I'm betting he gets #2.

Any takers?

:)
Any bets on whether he can get a bunch of dazed, drunk, winos to understand they're not allowed to pee on his doorstep any more?

Anybody want to bet on the over/under for how many days it takes before some homeless rights advocacy group sues the store owner?
 
Any bets on whether he can get a bunch of dazed, drunk, winos to understand they're not allowed to pee on his doorstep any more?

Anybody want to bet on the over/under for how many days it takes before some homeless rights advocacy group sues the store owner?

I'll not take either of those bets!

(I only have a couple Told ya so's left, and don't want to loose them all on one thread!


;)
 
Any bets on whether he can get a bunch of dazed, drunk, winos to understand they're not allowed to pee on his doorstep any more?

Anybody want to bet on the over/under for how many days it takes before some homeless rights advocacy group sues the store owner?

After the restraining order, he doesn't have to. It's the police's problem.
 
Well, if the shop owner wins the million dollar lawsuit against the homeless people, I suppose they could always throw the them into Debtor's Prison, then they won't have to worry about the restraining order.
 
One million dollars? Quick, into the Wino Relocation Fund!

Seriously, this thing is just so stupid.
 
These uncouth reprobates will learn not to chase away my business! Sitting on the side of a street like that is disarray… It is disgraceful! I would wager that they only have one or two personal staff each! They should endeavor to make something of themselves, such as inheriting a shipping company or some such. All of this talking about troublesome matters is making me parched. Pedro! Another glass of champagne!
 
Glad we all find that the rights of a tax-paying citizen, who is adding to the citys' income and prestige (presumably), to carry on his business without undue interference (and potential loss to him and the city) are not as important as the rights of others to use the city sidewalks as a restroom (etc.). I am in no way unsupportive of action to help the homeless and I do not believe that a majority of the homeless are in that condition purely through their own fault (and many have no fault at all in it). But.....
 
Glad we all find that the rights of a tax-paying citizen, who is adding to the citys' income and prestige (presumably), to carry on his business without undue interference (and potential loss to him and the city) are not as important as the rights of others to use the city sidewalks as a restroom (etc.). I am in no way unsupportive of action to help the homeless and I do not believe that a majority of the homeless are in that condition purely through their own fault (and many have no fault at all in it). But.....

But suing for a million dollars? That either represents a complete disconnect with reality or a punitive action well out of proportion to the acts and circumstances surrounding them. Can you imagine if a court actually awards monetary damages? They cannot be forced to pay money they do not have, but they can be hounded for years if they try to get a job, get a loan, or pretty much try to engage in mainstream society. Just get a freaking restraining order and be done with it.
 
How much is he going to end up paying in legal fees? Whatever amount it is, I bet if he took half that money and gave it to the homeless people in exhange for them finding somewhere else to "loiter", that they'd probably take him up on it.
 
After the restraining order, he doesn't have to. It's the police's problem.
The more I think about it, the more the restraining order makes sense. If the police don't keep the winos off his front porch, he then has a cause of action against the city for damage to his business. That's where the real money is.

The million dollar lawsuit against the winos, though - I still don't get that. I assume there's a reason there somewhere; I have to assume his lawyer isn't an idiot.
 
Any bets on whether he can get a bunch of dazed, drunk, winos to understand they're not allowed to pee on his doorstep any more?

Anybody want to bet on the over/under for how many days it takes before some homeless rights advocacy group sues the store owner?
When I lived in SF I noticed that a lot of those smaller, older stores, with a recessed entryway, had to install ugly screens or gates to close it off. The stores that didn't do this had homeless bedding down in their entryway at night. It was very filthy come morning time.

With the rents being astronomical in SF, this was just another "tax" of doing business there.

Charlie (go west young man!) Monoxide
 
How much is he going to end up paying in legal fees? Whatever amount it is, I bet if he took half that money and gave it to the homeless people in exhange for them finding somewhere else to "loiter", that they'd probably take him up on it.
But that's improper. You can't just go around giving money to parasites in the hopes that they won't bother you. Wait, what's that? That's how we treat lawyers? Of course. I was talking about lawyers.
 
Are the homeless people in question themselves antiques? He might be able to turn this around to his advantage. Pay em and give them some food and let them spend the day inside the store, in the display window, sitting around on antique furnishings. He'd get publicity, they'd get a warm place to spend the day.
 
This argument is strangely reminiscent of whenever young ladies of a professional persuasion move into an area and the local businesses get understandably upset. Frankly the UK legal system(s) haven't found a way to stop it, just to slowly rotate it from area to area......



ETA: That last bit's not meant to sound rude
 
"...in addition to money, Karl Kemp & Associates Antiques, located near 69th Street at 833 Madison Ave. near Gucci, Chanel, and Prada..."

The Devil Sells Prada. I say piss on his doorstep and be proud!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom