Seen 'The Secret' and want to appear on Oprah?

sophia8

Master Poster
Joined
Oct 28, 2003
Messages
2,457
Just got this email:
The Oprah Winfrey Show presents The Secret

Oprah is hosting a show dedicated to The Secret, tentatively scheduled to air LIVE on January 31st.

In order to capture the real essence of The Secret, Oprah has selected Rhonda Byrne, the producer, as well as four of The Secret's teachers,
including myself. The others are Jack Canfield, Lisa Nichols and Dr. Michael Beckwith. We'll be discussing how the Law of Attraction works and
providing hands on tools that the viewers can use to change their lives in a positive way.

Share this news with everyone you know... Clear your schedule and watch the show... Or better yet, record it and share it over and over with your friends and family. Email Oprah and let her know you want to see more of this type of show on the air... After the show, send a message to Oprah.

We need to make this show a hit (and I know it will be)! We have the opportunity to reach millions with this message, and when it succeeds, it'll literally open the floodgates to change the lives of even more people! The planet is transforming, and you're a part of it--I appreciate you. Do you want to be a guest on Oprah?
Have you seen The Secret or read the book? Has it changed your life for the better? If so, Oprah wants to hear from you. Submit your story to Oprah, but only if you are willing to appear on national television. To your continued wealth and happiness,

James Arthur Ray
President/CEO
James Ray International
Go on, I dares you... I double-dares you! :D

Oh yeah, the website: The Secret. Pile of steaming new age carp....
 
Last edited:
What is the Secret? I fell off the planet for a couple of months, been back for a couple of weeks, and now Oprah is taking over the world. Can some one fill me in?
 
The Secret:

A flashy restatement of the popular New Age "Law of Attraction,"

To wit (or less than a wit): whatever you desire will come to you by believing, imagining, and affirming it's yours and maintaining a positive attitude about obtaining it.

The formula doesn't include the Old Age fuddy-duddy element of hard work and effort to attain your goals, but says it's all in the power of the mind to shape reality on the quantum level.

It's all quite feelgood and 'inpirational' till it just doesn't work. At what time you are simply accused of not having a positive attitude.

For many this formula is a more palatable beleif than praying to a deity to give you what you covet. But it is in the end merely superstition.
 
I had an ongoing exchange of views about 'The Law of Attraction' at The Secret movie's online forum that went on for several months last year and ended up at Joe Vitale's blog before I decided to get on with my life.

This was all before I'd even seen the movie itself. I live in Australia, where the movie wasn't released until fairly recently because of some legal technicality, but I read about the forum, so I decided to join that in the meantime to get some 'lowdown' on the details of the movie.

I got involved in the discussions because the lady who produced the movie, Rhonda Byrne, supposedly was inspired to make it after reading a book called The Science of Getting Rich. This was a book written in 1910 by a Wallace D. Wattles, who was a member of what I believe was called the 'New Thought' movement.

I first read TSOGR in 1985 and I was so impressed by the ideas in the book that I used it as my parenting guide when the first of my children was born soon afterwards. In fact, it became the foundation of my entire parenting philosophy, with very positive results. Now, the thing is, there's no 'law of attraction' mentioned in TSOGR. I didn't even become aware of that idea until probably less than three years ago. My interpretation of Wallace D. Wattles' message was that there's a correlation between our thoughts and our experiences and by deliberately changing our thoughts we can change our experiences. Something I've since demonstrated successfully in my own life. But, the 'mechanics' of how such changes are actually brought about were pretty much irrelevant to me at the time I read TSOGR and probably still are to some degree. Sometimes, 'coincidence' is good enough, no further explanation required.

It turns out that 'The Law of Attraction' is an idea popularised by a Jerry and Esther Hicks, whose worldly wisdom is apparently channelled from a group of 'higher beings' known collectively as Abraham. Hence, their philosophy is usually referred to as 'Abraham-Hicks'.

And, at the movie's forum, the essence of 'The Secret' was constantly presented in terms of the Abraham-Hicks philosophy. Which is what I took exception to.

Essentially, my view was that 'The Law of Attraction' might well be a useful metaphor for the, I believe, well documented correlation between what we think about and what happens to us in our lives, but when people tell me it's a real 'law of the universe' ("Just like gravity", is the usual line), and especially when they bring quantum flapdoodle into it, well, I really don't think so.

Having now watched The Secret myself, I have to say that, once you get past the overdramatic tosh that the movie opens with, it's actually very uplifting. But, not necessarily for the right reasons. It's uplifting in the manner of a technicolour pep rally. There are certainly ideas in the movie that make a lot of sense (to me at least!), but they're absorbed into this hazy generalisation of a 'Law of Attraction' that, like I say, is okay if you want to regard it as a useful metaphor for things you otherwise have no explanation for (although I would have thought "I don't know how this happened", or something like that, would serve as well), but it's not a true explanation for events that may have any one or more of numerous explanations. In my experience, the truth has more to do with how the brain works, rather than how 'the Universe' works.

Unfortunately, 'The Law of Attraction' is usually presented as infallible, it seems, so, as has already been noted, if it doesn't work for somebody, it's that person's fault for not having their vibrations properly aligned or whatever. There was so much of that kind of gobbledygook at the movie's forum, it was extraordinary. It prevents people from looking more closely at why something isn't working and, if there is something in it that does 'work' (as I contend there is), what is it and why does it work?

As somebody who believes in 'the power of the human mind', if that's a reasonable way of putting it, and who practices and promotes 'mind programming techniques', I have to say I find 'The Secret' a pain in the proverbial right now.
 
It is certainly a misnomer to call something a "law" when it shows no reliable reproducibility. An earlier incarnation of it was "The Power of Positive Thinking." I bought into that as a teenage Christian and began to treat prayer as a vending machine. Soon I began to learn that reality is more complex than a servant to hand us anything we covet.

Believers in the Law of Attraction make as many excuses for its faliures to deliver as belivers in prayer do. Whe you get what you desire, it works. When you don't you forget you asked, you blame yourself, or you say the Universe has something better for you.

People who never heard of The Secret, don't pray, and are even Athests and skeptics will tell you of conincidences in their lives when just what they needed dropped out of the blue. The majority of the time though, the blue is unresponsive to our desires.

You need to reach out, grab, and pull it to yourself to fulfill the attraction.

Welcome to the JREF!
 
I had never heard of The Secret, but if you strip away all the mystic new age rubbish, they is actually something in the idea that your attitude changes your luck, or at least your perception of your luck. Research by Richard Wiseman showed that being pessimistic and believing yourself unlucky alters your behaviour in such a way that you do actually have better "luck".
 
I've found myself to be a very lucky person. The worst case senarios I worry over very rarely happen. Things even work out OK when I've had a bout of "wallowing in negativity."
 
It is certainly a misnomer to call something a "law" when it shows no reliable reproducibility. An earlier incarnation of it was "The Power of Positive Thinking." I bought into that as a teenage Christian and began to treat prayer as a vending machine. Soon I began to learn that reality is more complex than a servant to hand us anything we covet.

Believers in the Law of Attraction make as many excuses for its faliures to deliver as belivers in prayer do. Whe you get what you desire, it works. When you don't you forget you asked, you blame yourself, or you say the Universe has something better for you.

People who never heard of The Secret, don't pray, and are even Athests and skeptics will tell you of conincidences in their lives when just what they needed dropped out of the blue. The majority of the time though, the blue is unresponsive to our desires.

You need to reach out, grab, and pull it to yourself to fulfill the attraction.

Welcome to the JREF!


Thanks. I think "reality is more complex" sums it up very neatly.

The 'Law of Attraction' makes it all seem so cut and dried. Do A, get B. It's the law. Yet, my disagreements with its proponents have been mostly about their inability to explain it to me in a way that makes sense. How exactly do I harmonise my vibrations with the object of my desire? What is that? If I'm a magnet, does that mean I'll be walking down the street and the object of my desire will leap out of the shadows at me and stick to my clothing?

I'm not so sure, either, about the use of the word' science' in The Science of Getting Rich. Is it a science? Maybe it depends on what you mean by 'science'. It's a much abused word these days, in my experience.

The version of the book that I first read in 1985 was actually called Financial Success Through Creative Thought. It wasn't until I came onto the internet in 2000 that I discovered it was originally called The Science of Getting Rich and had now reverted to its original title. The version entitled Financial Success Through Creative Thought was, apparently, a one-off edition produced in the 1920s after the author's death. Something like that. I never got the whole story.

Anyway, it's a book that's played a very significant part in my life, but, I would certainly feel more comfortable with it these days if it was still called Financial Success Through Creative Thought, rather than The Science of Getting Rich, for the reasons of the use of the word 'science' and the book's current position in relation to New Age beliefs.

I read The Power of Positive Thinking in the 1980s, after I'd first discovered the whole self-help/self-improvement thing (what I usually refer to as 'personal development' these days) and I was reading those kinds of books one after the other as fast as I could find them.

What I used to believe about 'positive thinking' was that it meant I had to be upbeat and cheerful all the time and that I should be having positive experiences all the time. If I wasn't, I was doing something wrong. Not so, I've since learned (the hard way, as generally seems to be the case with these things!). Positive thinking is more to do with responding in a positive way to whatever our experiences are - good, bad or indifferent. Getting up when you fall down, rather than skipping twinkletoed through life in the manner suggested by such luminaries as Tony Robbins. Somebody I find seriously irritating. Have done for many years, to be honest.

Having said that, 'positive thinking', in my experience, definitely does tend to maximise the good experiences and minimise the bad experiences - but, again, that's more to do with changes in perception than any 'law of attraction'. For example, when you learn to feel better about yourself and more optimistic about the world, you might suddenly decide you'd rather go for a walk in the woods with your kids than sit in the bar with your drinking buddies; and that's a matter of going out of your front door and turning one way and not the other, or whatever. That doesn't take magnetic attraction or quantum mechanics, as far as I'm aware.

Gotta fly now, as Rocky would say. Time for lunch and I'm doing the cooking!
 
What is the Secret? I fell off the planet for a couple of months, been back for a couple of weeks, and now Oprah is taking over the world. Can some one fill me in?

Ugh...I had the distinct misfortune of viewing this at the in-laws home last month. I didn't intend to watch it, but my attempt to escape what can only be described as "What the Bleep"-level inanity was cut short by a pressing need to have me fix the computer in their living room...the same room the TV is in.

I only caught bits and pieces of the movie, but here is the gist of it far as I could discern: think happy and good stuff will happen.

Now, I agree with this from a thoroughly pragmatic viewpoint - if you have a goal, you're more likely to accomplish it if you focus on it with a positive attitude. You're more likely to work harder towards that goal, and to seize opportunities you might not seize if you are obsessed with feeling gloomy.

However, the problem is that the movie didn't focus on that aspect of things. Instead, the impression I got was that these people believed that you could actually manipulate the very fabric of reality around you just by having happy thoughts (even absent any other direct action).

After the movie, my stepmother turned to my wife and said: "You know, that's totally true. Your sister decided two years ago that she would get a PT Cruiser, and she thought positively, and she put it out into the universe, and she got a PT Cruiser."

It was very difficult to bite my tongue and hold back the obvious retort - that she got that ugly honkin' excuse for a car because she worked for it, her credit is good, and their household income is above average.

Sort of a case of missing the forest because you can't see through all those bloody trees!
 
I've since learned (the hard way, as generally seems to be the case with these things!). Positive thinking is more to do with responding in a positive way to whatever our experiences are - good, bad or indifferent. Getting up when you fall down, rather than skipping twinkletoed through life

Precisely!
Ego control of reality is severly limited.
What we can call is our attitude.
 
Can I apply this "power of positive thinking" law to software that I write?

Can I just imagine users doing the right thing with my code, and thus somehow stop them from breaking it?

I guess I'm just too pessimistic to make this work. I'm gonna stick with my current strategy of envisioning users breaking it, clicking in the wrong places, and - working to fix the problems.

While positive thinking is very important, totally ignoring any negatives - pretending that obstacles aren't in your way - is very dangerous.
 
I watched "The Secret" DVD. Well, halfway through anyway. Maybe one day I'll finish the entire DVD.

I'm forgetting the quantum-law-of-attraction-of-the-universe-to-serve-you, and getting the basic message.

"You are what you think of yourself"
 
Oh my. I haven't heard of "The Secret," but my mom and my uncle are both crazy about the "Law of Attraction." When my mom goes on long drives, she listens to the audio books (mostly consisting of some lady with a southern accent giving long answers to stupid questions). She drove me home from our country house once, and played the tapes the whole way. slept most of the way, but when I opened my eyes, my mom assumed I was interested in the Law of Attraction, and proceeded to explain it to me. Great.

At first I figured it was just a symbolic way of looking at things. It makes sense that immersing yourself in things you like would make you happier. But then I actually listened to the details. "When you want something, only think about that thing you want. Don't think about how to get it, just picture yourself having it, and it'll come," she said, and listed every example she could think of (none of which actually demonstrated it, of course). I couldn't believe that she could actually believe that crap. I know what blind optimism can do, and these people have some serious disappointment coming their way.

The worst part is that whenever something upsets my mom, she puts on those damn tapes to feel better. Sooner or later she's going to run into a problem that can't just be ignored, and she'll be screwed. Looking at the other replies here, I see that I'm not the only one who thinks so. I know how nice it is to have a record of someone reassuring you that everything's going to turn out alright - I sometimes listen to Carl Sagan's voice when I'm upset - but at least I realize that this isn't going to solve any problem I have.
 
Having said that, 'positive thinking', in my experience, definitely does tend to maximise the good experiences and minimise the bad experiences - but, again, that's more to do with changes in perception than any 'law of attraction'. For example, when you learn to feel better about yourself and more optimistic about the world, you might suddenly decide you'd rather go for a walk in the woods with your kids than sit in the bar with your drinking buddies; and that's a matter of going out of your front door and turning one way and not the other, or whatever.

What you're describing is very much the theory behind Cognitive Behavioral Therapy which is the most common type of therapy practiced by today's psychologists and has a good success rate. In this respect, your thoughts and how you perceive things really can shape your feelings and experiences.

That being said, the whole "the universe will respond to my positive thoughts" is complete twaddle.
 
Can I apply this "power of positive thinking" law to software that I write?

Can I just imagine users doing the right thing with my code, and thus somehow stop them from breaking it?

Sure, just get a job at Microsoft, that seems to be their modus operandi.

IXP
 
Re: Mom listening to motivational tapes. After you've seen the Veggie Tales movie Jonah, you'll never be able to keep a straight face about motivational tapes again. "You...are a skilled metalworker..." :D

Linkie.
 
This stuff's been around for yonks.

http://psycho-cybernetics.com/

Does it work? Of course it does! Write a similar tome and watch the money roll in.

M.


One of my peeves about this whole New Age wealth movement is all the carpetbagging and 'life coaching" preying on the economically disfranchised with promises of 'abundance,' especially if they will buy the books, tapes, and expensive seminars.

My previous roomate was into The Millionaire Mind and just lost money as a result. Meanwhile the hucksters who sell these illusions keep raking in the bucks from the ignorent who buy into them.

No that the ignorant are merely victims. Greed is the hook.
"The Secret" is getting some flack from other quarters of the New Age movement for it's decidedly and crassly materialistic emphisis. "You can have it all, and therefore be happy."
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom