A Hot Knife Through Bullcrap

timokay

Thinker
Joined
Jun 29, 2005
Messages
158
I was in a discussion that derailed a thread, and I hate doing that. Hopefully, the discussion can continue here.

I have been an active member for a short while, but have supported the JREF for many years prior. I am not much of a poster. I usually chime in only when I can address a claimant whom I feel may be able to give some insight as to just why they feel they have experienced a paranormal event. Or when I have a good limerick.

I personally never have experienced the paranormal, and it is my personal opinion that paranormal events can be explained by science, logic and common sense.

Convincing a believer of that, as most people on this board know, is a task. I am very glad that the MDC has become proactive in revealing the criminals who make claims about these "powers", and steal millions from the gullible, uneducated and ill-informed.

All paranormal claims, especially those who receive funds for "services", should be rigorously challenged, without mercy. Taking money for a service that you cannot prove is criminal.

Anyway, I really am a friendly sort when you get to know me.

And now to work.

The thread we have jumped from is here:http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=2363820#post2363820


If someone genuinely believes they have a power, but can provide no evidence, and has nothing but anecdotal evidence and bad science to back them up, then it is counterproductive to start designing a protocol.

Well, let's look at JM.
He genuinely believes he has the ability to affect events around him and he has a lot of personal experience to relate. Okay, call it belief in the paranormal with only anecdoatal evidence to back it up. But I have never heard him offer up bad science as an explanation for his claimed ability. And he has at least attempted to provide evidence - initially to himself before subjecting himself to a public test. How, in this situation is it counterproductive to design a protocol to help him test his ability scientifically.
You have mischaracterised JM because of your obsession with generalising rather than attending to the individual before you.

I asked JM questions directly from his claims. I specified each claim, and asked specific questions. He has provided NO evidence. Anecdotal evidence is NO evidence. It may be his reason for believing, but it is NOT evidence. I addressed his CLAIMS. Specifically. I made NO generalizations. And I addressed HIS claims, not anyone else.

If you are going to challenge the evidence presented by JM, why not help him with a protocol that is likely to produce evidence that is worth considering. It seems to me you are not interested in any evidence he may or may not be able to present because you have already decided, based on your generalizations, that he could not possibly have this ability.

He provided NO evidence. I addressed his CLAIMS. There is no reason to pull a protocol out of thin air. Maybe I should ask him if he can run a marathon? That's random enough. I am interested in ANY evidence he has to present. Did you see any? Wait, lets see if he can predict the flip of a coin? That will prove.... wait, he never said he could do that.... That's ok, let's try it anyway.

I guess you hope that he will sit in his room and flip away, and then see that he can;t predict the outcome. Is that what you are after? Do you think he will have some great epiphany at that point? Why did you try it yourself? Do you think you will demonstrate the paranormal?

Why do you choose to ignore that he has said that he can make people pick him at a table, he can avoid speeding tickets, he evidently caused the death of someone, but vows to ease up on that one... None of this is up for debate? None of this interests you? It interests me. Because it is his claim.

I can't believe you still haven't got the point about the man beating his wife.
You can't possibly be that thick.

So you don't think we should help potential claimants by designing protocols which would show them whether or not they have an ability and what exactly that ability is? How exactly are you going to actually challenge them then???

If they say they can jump 20 feet in the air because of a paranormal ability, I will be right there with a measuring stick. I will address exactly what they say, as carefully as possible. I will offer alternate solutions, and examine the individual for the reasoning they use to determine their claim. I will ask them to provide evidence as to why they think they can do it. And why it is paranormal.

Then I will demand that they do it. And before you roll out the ridiculous marathon analogy yet again, I don't care if they only can do it better than chance, if that is their claim. Under a full moon, in a park, in the dark, in a car, in a bar.... they better be able to do it.
 
Last edited:
I suppose our fellow posters will have to read the last three or four pages of that thread to understand how you have misrepresented it, in my opinion. If they disagree, I am happy to consider it and discuss it further. As it is, though, we're making no headway whatsoever discussing it between the two of us.

So I will wait for other responses.

Anyway, I'm glad you're a friendly sort of person and that your derogatory language is delivered with a well-meaning smile. :)

regards,
BillyJoe
 
I suppose our fellow posters will have to read the last three or four pages of that thread to understand how you have misrepresented it, in my opinion. If they disagree, I am happy to consider it and discuss it further. As it is, though, we're making no headway whatsoever discussing it between the two of us.

So I will wait for other responses.

Anyway, I'm glad you're a friendly sort of person and that your derogatory language is delivered with a well-meaning smile. :)

regards,
BillyJoe

I am not discussing with the fellow posters, I am discussing it with you. What everyone else thinks is not germane to our current discussion, what you say is.

If anyone else wants to add something I am sure that it will help the discussion. Everyone is obviously welcome. I would hope that JM might address my specific concerns towards his claims, but my points are not specific to him.

I made this thread so we would not derail the MDC thread, and I do think we are making headway.

The challenge is to keep it on topic, without drifing off on how bad I hurt your feelings by being direct, and how little I care about how you try to make that an issue.

I don't use smileys to convey a vague message. I try to be clear in my language.
 
timokay,

I believe this discussion is pointless.
Here is why:

A Hot Knife Through Bullcrap
And you want a discussion???

If someone genuinely believes they have a power, but can provide no evidence, and has nothing but anecdotal evidence and bad science to back them up.....
I have already replied: He is trying to produce evidence. He has not used bad science.
But you just repeat the question.

...then it is counterproductive to start designing a protocol.
I have already replied: How do you propose to test his claims without a protocol???
But you just repeat the question.

I asked JM questions directly from his claims. I specified each claim, and asked specific questions. He has provided NO evidence.
How can you possibly provide evidence for something that happened decades ago? :rolleyes:

Anecdotal evidence is NO evidence.
No. It is just poor evidence.

There is no reason to pull a protocol out of thin air.
I have already replied: He was trying to produce evidence. I was trying to help him produce reliable evidence with proper controls by suggesting a protocol.
But you just repeat the question.

Maybe I should ask him if he can run a marathon?
A statement that makes no sense.
If you do not mean it to make sense, please use a smilie (Oh, I'm sorry, you don't use smilies :rolleyes: )

Wait, lets see if he can predict the flip of a coin? That will prove.... wait, he never said he could do that.... That's ok, let's try it anyway.
I have already replied: I did not suggest the coin toss. Someone else did. JM thought he could do it, based on what he has done in the past. He got 100% success. I felt there may have been a problem with the way he was conducting the test so I offered a protocol. His success dropped to 70%.
But you just repeat the question.

I guess you hope that he will sit in his room and flip away, and then see that he can't predict the outcome. Is that what you are after?
I already explained: I already told you that my motives were not as you characterised them. I was not dishonourably setting JM up to fail. And, unlike yourself, I was also not presuming that he would fail. I was trying to help JM discover exactly what it is that he can do in the privacy of his own home before subjecting himself to a public trial.
But you just continue repeat your accusations.

Do you think he will have some great epiphany at that point?
This is an example of what I have pointed out repeatedly to you several times already: You already "know" what will happen before the test is even done. You already "know" he will fail. You already "know" he will offer a thousand excuses. Because that is what you have observed in the past? He is expected to carry your past history on his shoulders. And then you expect him to answer your presumptious questions. Give us a break!

Why did you try it yourself? Do you think you will demonstrate the paranormal?
WHAT?

One of my posts clearly explains my purpose in doing this.
You could not possibly have missed it.

Dan pointed out that it is possible to see "heads" when the coin actually shows "tails", especially when you predict/force "heads". I found that hard to believe. So I decided to test this. I found it was possible to misread the coin in three situations: (1) if the light was poor, (2) if the two sides of the coin were too similar in appearance, (3) if the inspection of the coin is hurried.
Dan was correct. I was wrong. I acknowledged this. I then suggested a change in the protocol to account for this.

But here you are still asking me to explain myself.

Why do you choose to ignore that he has said that he can make people pick him at a table, he can avoid speeding tickets, he evidently caused the death of someone, but vows to ease up on that one... None of this is up for debate? None of this interests you?
Because they happened a looooong time ago.....
How on Earth do you propose he go about proving something that happened three decades ago???

You can't possibly be that thick..
And you want a discussion. :rolleyes:

And before you roll out the ridiculous marathon analogy yet again..
If you really do want to continue this discussion, you can start by proving to me that you understand the point I was making with my story about the marathon.

BillyJoe
 
Last edited:
The challenge is to keep it on topic, without drifing off on how bad I hurt your feelings by being direct, and how little I care about how you try to make that an issue.
Oh please! :D

I don't use smileys to convey a vague message. I try to be clear in my language.
You don't have to use smilies if you don't want to, but you really should try to read them. ;)
 
timokay - I hope you don't mind me saying, but the first part of your post appears naive and confused. You talk of "the paranormal" in your introduction and then seamlessly move onto charlatans and fakers and false claims, as if the latter examples fully comprise the former phenomena.

I personally never have experienced the paranormal, and it is my personal opinion that paranormal events can be explained by science, logic and common sense.

You are implying that you know that science can explain all observed events. This is a very bold statement. People who claim to know everything - skeptic or believer - always argue from positions of ignorance.

Anecdotal evidence is NO evidence

Nonsense. Evidence comes in various forms and can be of variable quality. Anecdotal evidence is poor quality evidence, but it is still evidence.

For the record I happen to agree with many of your later, specific points. I'm of the opinon that there is almost certainly nobody out there who can willfully demonstrate any classic paranormal ability, e.g. telepathy, psychokinesis, remote viewing, precognition, mediumship (I am strongly of the opinion that all mediums, past, present and future, are either fraudulent or deluded) and that testing any old crazy who comes along cannot be a good idea.

My point is, don't be tempted to extrapolate the claims of frauds and fools into a blanket dismissal of everything you deem to be "paranormal".
 
This discussion started here where I said:
Jim_Mich said:
Are there any real-deal possible candidates? I think many people have "border line" paranormal powers. By this I mean that at times they will briefly experience events or do things that just don't seem normally possible, thus it might be considered "paranormal". I've had a number of experiences where I really desperately needed a certain thing to happen; something that was not likely to happen. So I "psyched" myself into absolutely knowing that it would happen. And it did happen. Is this "paranormal"? I don't really know! I do know that I have no desire to "demonstrate" this ability that I've had since about age 7. To me that would be like a laboratory animal under a microscope. I have no desire for such an experience.

I could elaborate on this if any are interested.

Jim_Mich
Jim_Mich" said:
Let’s start at the beginning...

My first experience was in 1st grade. We sat at tables, with four students at each table. When it was time to leave for lunch, recess or the end of the day, we all had to sit quietly at our table with our hands folded and the teacher would randomly choose tables one by one to be dismissed. I had a friend at another table. Many times his table got dismissed sooner than most others including mine. This happened often enough that I noticed it. He bragged that he had “The Power.” I had no idea what he meant so I watched everything he did. I took note that he would sit with his foot titled on edge rather than flat on the floor. I thought, “This must be how he does it.” You must realize I was only 6 or 7 years old. I didn’t know that people can’t have “Super Powers.” After all, my hero was Superman.

So I started sitting with my foot tilted to one side and concentrating on using “my power.” Golly, pretty soon the teacher started choosing my table before my friends table. This was noticeable to both me and my friend, so much so that he accused me of stealing his powers. I was a shy kid and had never told him beforehand that I was trying to use any special power. I had been told about Angels watching over me and I thought maybe the angels were helping me.

Was I influencing the outcome of the teacher’s choice? Maybe she picked tables with the most attentive students? I'll never really know. But this was only the beginning...

Jim_Mich
Jim_Mich" said:
From time to time as I was growing up I tried to influence events. I found that if I could make myself really believe that some event was going to happen then usually events would evolve the way I wanted. Years later I found that religion had nothing to do with it. What was most important was a very strong belief that the event would happen. The belief needs to be so strong that you almost absolutely know it will happen, even though the odds are totally against you.

One time when I was 19 years old I drove across the state to go home with some classmates. We went horseback riding, out across a big hay field just shortly before sunset. I soon realized that I lost my wallet and didn’t have money for gas to get back to school. This was long before credit cards. I knew that I absolutely needed to find my wallet. It was like looking for a needle in a hay field. We all looked for the wallet until dark. The next morning I went back to the hay field which was about 20 acres. I stood at the gate and told myself I would walk straight out into the field and pick up my wallet. I walked out a few paces and doubt filled my mind. I immediately turned and walked back to the gate thinking, “No, I must think positive. I must believe.” It took until about the fifth try before I could make myself believe. Until then I never got beyond about a 100 feet. On that last try I just knew I could do it and I walked out across field straight to my wallet and picked it up. What were the odds of doing that? That is the type of thing I learned I could do. The really hard part each time is making myself really believe I can do it.

Jim_Mich
So let's review what I said. I think that many people have "border line" paranormal powers. I then tried to explained in a little more detail what I meant by saying that at times they will briefly experience events or do things that just don't seem normally possible, thus it might be considered "paranormal". I then said that I'd been using this ability since learning how to do it at a very early age. I learned how to use this ability at an age when superman was my hero and I was too young to know that such abilities are not considered normal.

Reager asked:
Reager said:
Jim_Mich - Have you ever willed yourself to do something that violates the laws of physics?
I searched my memory for any events that might seem to go against laws of physics or science.
Jim_Mich said:
Hmm... I made myeslf believe that mosquitos and deer flies would stop biting me. They seldom bite me now. Other people can be standing next to me swatting them right and left, while only once in a while one will bite me. To do it I decided that it was their instinct to bite and I should not hate them for it. I made a mental pact with all blood sucking insects; if they don't bite me I won't swat and kill them. Just peacefull co-existance!

Jim_Mich
Jim_Mich said:
There have been a few times in my life where an individual caused me much grief and I wished them harm in return. I did nothing except know that I felt they deserved retribution. One man developed cancer and was dead in a few months. Similar events happened to the other individuals. To this day I try to NEVER wish anyone harm.

Jim_Mich
Jim_Mich said:
BillyJoe,
Yes, I'm aware of the studies that show different reasons for mosquitoes not biting. The deer flies stopped biting at the same time. Do the same reasons apply to deer flies?

One time I got very sick with a 106 degree temperature for almost two weeks. My liver enzymes went crazy. You get very sick when your liver quits working properly. The doctors thought I might die. They said it was some rare unknown virus. But through it all I knew beyond any doubt that I would be OK. My fever broke and I went home from the hospital two days later.

One time back when the speed limit was 55 mph I was on the expressway doing about 70 mph when I passed a state trooper hiding under an overpass. I was just passing some semi-trucks so I pulled in front of them and slowed down during which time the trooper lost sight of me. At this point I made myself think very positive that I would not get a speeding ticket. The trooper comes flying up in the left lane and pulls in between my SUV and another SUV in front of me with a similar color. The SUV in front along with the trooper pull over to the side.

Little things like this happen on a somewhat regular basis. Any one incident is not significant. But when you combine them all together then it becomes more than coincidence. It becomes noticeable if you are paying attention, much like my 7 year old grade school friend noticed.

Anyway, enough of this. How would I possibly prove that I'm affecting the outcome of events? I know when I do it and that on those rare times when I can achieve near absolute belief it always works.

I'm sure there are people more deserving of retribution than Sylvia Browne.

Jim_Mich
On the other thread some people made a lot of assumptions about me without looking at what I actually was saying. There was mention of these abilities making me feel more than ordinary.

Let's review. I think everyone has this ability. I don't think I'm anything special. I cannot control every and all events in my life. It's more like a genie or guardian angel supplying a limited number of wishes or requests that can be used on a few occasions when you are in real need of a specific outcome. From experience I know that when I overuse the ability then the results fade into normal results. You might compare it to running a marathon. If your well rested and in shape you know can run it in a certain amount of time. You know ahead of time that you can do it. If you try to run one everyday you will soon fail.

GzuzKryzt asked me to rephrase my statement without using the word "belief."
Jim_Mich said:
... When I can acheive a state of mind where I know that something will happen, feel deep inside that it will happen, have faith that it will happen, have conviction that it will happen, don't doubt that it will happen, then events or circumstances have always evolved as I desire them to do. If I just feel relatively sure that something will happen then it will most like occur, but sometimes it doesn't.

I have absolute conviction that the sun will rise each morning. Of course so does everyone else. When I can make myself have the same feeling concerning something that I want to happen then the result is the same as the sun rising each morning. Of course the event must be logically possible. If the event or desired result is impossible then I cannot have conviction that it will happen. For instance, walking straight out and picking up a wallet in a 20 acre hay field is highly unlikely but it's possible.

Jim_Mich
It was suggested that I try something simple like trying to influence the toss of a coin. It had been years since I'd tried flipping coins. I knew that if my abilities were still working then the coin tossing should work. I chose which side of the coin I wanted then I concentrated on that side turning up. I also forced a certain emotion like feeling as I tossed the coins and let them land on the floor. The first ten tosses were 100% correct. There was talk about maybe I was mistaken. The room is well lighted and my eyesight with my glasses on is very good. There is no change that I was mistaken.

It was then suggested that I try tossing all heads or all tails. I thought that would be pushing the probabilities of the universe too far and decided to try tossing four heads then four tails. As I tossed the coins I realized it was much harder to try to force an outcome that was not my choice, so I returned to the original protocol where I decided a coin side then flipped the coin. I eventually tossed 134 coins and only missed 43 times.
Jim_Mich said:
I tossed 12/1 at beginning. (odds 1 : 315)
I tossed 28/9 after changing to the group toss protocol. (odds 1 : 23)
I tossed 94/33 after changing back. (odds 1 : 394)
I tossed 106/34 excluding group tosses. (odds 1 : 7029)
I tossed 134/43 Total. (odds 1 : 48646)

Full data at http://my.voyager.net/~jrrandall/Misc/Coin Flipping Results.txt

Jim_Mich
Using Visual Basic I wrote a simple computer program to calculate the odds of coin tossing. Anyone may download it from http://my.voyager.net/~jrrandall/Misc/Odds_Calc.exe

After developing a headache (headaches are very rare for me) I decided to again toss coins. The results were about 24 wrong out of 40 tosses thus showing no ability. Later after the headache was gone I tried again to toss coins with only near normal results. The ability to control the outcome of a tossed coin has now faded away. So did I ever have any ability to influence the coin tossing? The pseudoskeptics will say I don't have any abilities and never did. For the moment I've pushed the genie too far with too many coin tosses. I know from past personal experience that the next time I really need and want and believe in a certain outcome of events then the ability will be there again. I also think this ability is there for anyone to use and I'm not a special case. I learned to use this ability when I was very young before I 'learned' that these types of things are just not supposed to be possible. I also know that talking about such "obviously impossible" abilities brings nothing but ridicule, insults and questions about one's sanity.

I see no reason to continue this discussion. The pseudoskeptics will never open their mind to true research into such phenomena because they have already decided that such things are not possible. A true skeptic will recognize that it is impossible to know everything. I think that for all true paranormal phenomena (verse charlatans and cons) there is an actual scientific reason behind them. That reason may involve things that we don't currently understand. If we close our eyes and say such things don't happen then we loose the chance to advance science.

Jim_Mich
 
In a few hours the same can be said for Jim_Mich. Doesn't mean anything.

Both individuals seem to have thrown in the towel for the time being, leaving two unresolved issues:

1) Is Tim thinking cynically or realistically? (Answer: who cares!)
2) Can Jim develop a protocol, pass the test and win the million? (Answer: let the optimists answer this one...)
 
In a few hours the same can be said for Jim_Mich. Doesn't mean anything.

Both individuals seem to have thrown in the towel for the time being, leaving two unresolved issues:

1) Is Tim thinking cynically or realistically? (Answer: who cares!)
2) Can Jim develop a protocol, pass the test and win the million? (Answer: let the optimists answer this one...)
In his own words, timokay started this thread to cut through my "bullcrap" with his "hot knife". Yet he has not added to his opening post. Neither has he posted anywhere else on the forum. This puzzles me. I was wondering if perhaps something has happened to him.

As to your questions:

I think timokay's atitude is dismissive and presumptive. He is not thinking critically or sceptically. He shows continually that he misunderstands what I and Jim are saying and gets defensive and verbally abusive when that is pointed out. He then assumes I'm getting all cut up about him abusing me when, in fact, all I'm doing is shaking my head in bewilderment. This thread was just another example of that.

Jim has conceded defeat on the question of trying to prove his abilities using a coin toss. He has found that his ability to influence coin tosses was limited in two ways.
- Firstly, he is unable to force tosses chosen by someone else (ie he was unable to force all "heads", or alternating series of four "heads" and four "tails"). He can only force tosses he himself chooses. This means he always gets random looking results which, on its face, cannot distinguish between forced and unforced tosses.
- Secondly, his ability fades the more often he uses it. For example his results faded from 100% to 70% and finally 50% (no better than chance) as he continued to try to force tossed coins.
However, I have found Jim to be honest and willing to put his ability to the test and to acknowledge when he has failed. By this, I mean, he has acknowledged he has failed to prove he has his ability through the medium of a coin toss. He obviously will not be applying for the MDC on that basis.
Of course, his claimed ability has not been disproven and, of course, it cannot be. The question was could he prove it by means of a coin toss. The answer is "no". And that is the end of the matter.

But, of course, you could have worked this out or your self if you had read carefully :mad:

regards,
BillyJoe
 
Last edited:
Jim, if I understand your above post correctly, you no longer to intend to take the Million Dollar Challenge as you do not seem to have a claim that could be demonstrated under proper observing conditions. Which is, especially in view of the encouraging statistics that you had posted earlier, disappointing, even if entirely expected.

The ability to control the outcome of a tossed coin has now faded away. So did I ever have any ability to influence the coin tossing? The pseudoskeptics will say I don't have any abilities and never did. For the moment I've pushed the genie too far with too many coin tosses.

Does this mean that you will continue to examine your alleged powers in a critical way, in order to verify their existence and learn more about the way they work and their limits, with the eventual goal of applying for the MDC?

Or does this mean that if proper experimentation disagrees with your beliefs, you reject the former, and to avoid scaring the genie even farther away, you refrain from further confrontation of your beliefs with reality and retreat entirely into the realm of faith?

I know from past personal experience that the next time I really need and want and believe in a certain outcome of events then the ability will be there again.

If this is what you know, then I suggest that you act on it and apply for the JREF challenge today, with any claim that can be achieved via pure luck, for example a dowsing claim. Surely, when you face Randi's skeptical stare, you will really need and want a certain outcome of events - your success in the test - and you have repeatedly claimed that you can make yourself believe the outcome if you really need and want it.

Or is it that the above sentence is just empty words and you actually know no such thing for sure? Or is it simply an arbitrary assertion that is not falsifiable - in other words, if you fail to achieve a certain outcome, it only proves that you didn't really need or want or believe in it?

I also think this ability is there for anyone to use and I'm not a special case.

This is directly contradicted by observation. JREF Million Dollar Challenge remains unclaimed to this day. This says nothing about a hypothetical paranormal phenomenon that would be extremely rare, but it is very strong evidence against common occurrence of paranormal phenomena.

Even very rare and/or difficult (real) abilities can be reproducibly accomplished. Running a marathon not just under 3 hours, but under 2 hours and 10 minutes, is extremely difficult and next to impossible for any random individual. Most people will never be able to do that, many of those who can will never try, many of those who try will never succeed. But because we have 6 and a half billion people on Earth and they are free to try over and over again, even this very difficult accomplishment (which cannot be done with luck alone!) has been demonstrated hundreds of times under proper observing conditions.

Your hypothesis that the alleged ability is there for anyone to use is incosistent with what is observed. Unless you can provide a credible explanation for this inconsistency, I think it is safe to say that your hypothesis has been falsified.
 
Does this mean that you will continue to examine your alleged powers in a critical way, in order to verify their existence and learn more about the way they work and their limits, with the eventual goal of applying for the MDC?

Or does this mean that if proper experimentation disagrees with your beliefs, you reject the former, and to avoid scaring the genie even farther away, you refrain from further confrontation of your beliefs with reality and retreat entirely into the realm of faith?

These are the questions that I'm interested in as well, and I hope Jim comes with some interesting answers.


Of course, his claimed ability has not been disproven and, of course, it cannot be. The question was could he prove it by means of a coin toss. The answer is "no". And that is the end of the matter.

But, of course, you could have worked this out or your self if you had read carefully :mad:

I did read carefully, which is why I as well concluded that the little coin toss experiment was a failure. But thanks for a summery of your reasoning.

I can't to speak for the departed Tim, but I'll try by asking a question: at what point DOES one admit that an individual's claims aren't worth evaluating?

(This, by the way, is why I think the revised MDC is such a step in the right direction. Randi has said; first convince one media source that you have powers; then, convince an academic. And THEN we'll take your claims seriously. Makes sense to me.)

On the other hand, there's a guy who started a thread here recently who claimed to have an idea for perpetual motion machine that just HAD to work. (Sorry, can't find the thread now).

Anyways, a bunch of JREFers smarter than me took this guy and his claims seriously, offered him some honest criticisms, and that was that for a while. But before long this guy comes back with several new diagrams for new devices and pretty soon he's got like 5 diagrams for machines and nobody's really willing to consider any of them because, well, it's pretty clear that he's not taking the criticisms seriously and maybe, just maybe, encouraging him in his delusions is not a valuable way to spend one's time.

On the other hand this is Jim's first paranormal claim as far as I know (hasn't even told his wife, he mentioned) and he definitely deserves a fair shot. Billyjoe has given him more than a that by providing him with protocol ideas that seem appropriate for his alleged power, and when he's back I encourage him to start his own thread with some harder evidence for his [revised and hopefully more specific] claims.
 
I was waiting for timokay to reply.
From http://my.voyager.net/~jrrandall/Misc/Coin Flipping Results.txt02/24/2007 at 9:28 am
02/24/2007 at 9:28 am
Call = H H H H H H H H H T = 10
Toss = T H H H H H T H T H = 4 wrong
Call = T H H H H H H H H H = 10
Toss = H H H H T T H H H H = 3 wrong
Call = T T T T T T T T T T = 10
Toss = T T T T T T T T T H = 1 wrong
Call = T T T T T = 5
Toss = T T T H H = 2 wrong
Note: First coin was a state coin with a minuteman's head.
Session Tosses = 35
Session Wrong = 10

===================================

Total Coins Tossed = 239
Total Coins Wrong = 92
Odds of this = 1:4411
Percent Right = 61.51%

Using Original Protocol Only:
Coins Tossed = 211
Coins Wrong = 82
Odds of this = 1:1350
Percent Right = 61.14%

There were 80 tosses made when under stress and after exhausting the ability.
There were 44 wrong during these 80 tosses.
If these 80 tosses are eliminated from the 211 tosses the results are:
Coins Tossed = 131
Coins Wrong = 38
Odds of this = 1:1176121 (greater than 1:million)
Percent Right = 70.99%

In reply to my emailed question about odds Jeff Wagg wrote, "To answer your question, the odds we're looking for are 1000:1."

In reply to my emailed question whether I would be allowed to flip the coins myself Jeff Wagg wrote, "If you touched them, the question of trickery would come immediately. It would be better if they were flipped by a simple machine or shaken in a can."
I wouldn't characterize the coin flipping as a failure. I know from past (about 43 years worth) of experience that when I need this ability it is there and when I try to use it excessively and don't really need it then it fades. After giving it a rest I tossed 35 flips with only 10 wrong. If I were to do this again it would be 70 tosses with 20 wrong which would be 71.43 percent which has a probability of 1:4543; more than enough to win the challenge.

Many people use this ability all the time. They call it 'praying' and usually direct it to some deity. Many people with strong beliefs get positive results much of the time.

As far as the MDC goes I have mixed feelings about applying. Let's face it, the challenge would be difficult. I tried shaking a coin in a number of different containers to see how the physical 'tossing' might work (without trying to influence the tosses). The coin likes to stay flat in the container and exits the container without much spinning. If I were the JREF I would be more concerned with such a toss than one done by flipping the coin with my thumb the way I normally do. I tried to find a mechanical coin flipper. I don't think any exist except for the one built by the university professor mentioned in the other thread. That mechanical coin flipper tossed coins that landed the same way every time. This is definitely not what we would be looking for. Computer coin flipping programs use 'pseudo' random number algorithms which give a specific number based on the previous number. Only by seeding the sequence with some random number such as the computers clock or by taking a random nth number generated by the computer can a somewhat random number be generated. Even then the number is never purely random just as any mechanical coin tosser would never be purely random. It is my thinking that a true random coin toss can only be accomplished by a human physically flipping the coin and letting it land on a flat carpeted surface to prevent the coin from spinning and/or rolling.

Maybe someone else could flip the coin? This coming weekend I'll be able to experiment with someone else tossing the coin.


Jim_Mich
 
This seems to answer my question. If Jim is willing to continue to experiment with his powers to see if he can come up with a reproducible phenomenon, I'm genuinely impressed. Even more so than with his claim per se. ;)

I tried shaking a coin in a number of different containers to see how the physical 'tossing' might work (without trying to influence the tosses). The coin likes to stay flat in the container and exits the container without much spinning.
...
It is my thinking that a true random coin toss can only be accomplished by a human physically flipping the coin and letting it land on a flat carpeted surface to prevent the coin from spinning and/or rolling.

Let's see if I can offer some tips that might help. The problem with shaking the coin can be neatly resolved: you can try switching from coin tossing to die rolling. If you think about it, die rolling is really the same as coin tossing; the source of randomness is the same, and the only difference is that the object has 6 sides instead of 2. Instead of forcing heads/tails, you can try forcing odd/even numbers. And, most importantly, a die can be easily shaken in a can, which, as per Jeff Wagg's statement, would bring you much closer to applying for the challenge.

If you can achieve good results with dice, consider getting precision dice (the carefully balanced kind for casino use) for further experiments; they are not expensive and an off-the-shelf product that can be purchased by JREF will prevent concerns that the dice are rigged.

Maybe someone else could flip the coin? This coming weekend I'll be able to experiment with someone else tossing the coin.

This would of course be best, but you have said that you may have troubles performing depending on the tossing person (for example you said you couldn't do it with your wife). It might be complicated to seal this potential way out.
 
My point is, don't be tempted to extrapolate the claims of frauds and fools into a blanket dismissal of everything you deem to be "paranormal".

Good point.
 
Last edited:
Jim, this isn't your thread.

This is the thread that was about to hijack your hijack of the Changes to the Challenges thread. What you need to do is send a message to the moderators and ask them to split the original thread at your first post. That way we will have three separate threads: The original Changes thread that will become more active as April 1 approaches, Your challenge thread where we can courteously help you prepare for the challenge or help figure out what is going on, and this thread where we will be yelling at each other saying everybody else is doing it wrong.

To contact the moderators, you can either click the contact us link at the bottom of the page, or find your original post and click the "Report Post" caution sign on the left.
 
I wouldn't characterize the coin flipping as a failure. I know from past (about 43 years worth) of experience that when I need this ability it is there and when I try to use it excessively and don't really need it then it fades. After giving it a rest I tossed 35 flips with only 10 wrong. If I were to do this again it would be 70 tosses with 20 wrong which would be 71.43 percent which has a probability of 1:4543; more than enough to win the challenge.
But then you went to 50% (actually less than 50%)....see below:

After developing a headache (headaches are very rare for me) I decided to again toss coins. The results were about 24 wrong out of 40 tosses thus showing no ability. Later after the headache was gone I tried again to toss coins with only near normal results. The ability to control the outcome of a tossed coin has now faded away.
Anyway, your conclusion is that your ability to force the outcome of a coin toss fades with time. This conclusion is consistent with the results you obtained in the series of trials you conducted (100% -> 70% -> 50%). ON those results, the trial is not a failure but, as it stands, it would not be suitable to win the MDC, in which you would be required to do many more trials than you have done here in order to rule out chance results.

Many people use this ability all the time. They call it 'praying' and usually direct it to some deity. Many people with strong beliefs get positive results much of the time.
Except when it is put to the test, and methodological flaws removed, there is never found to be an effect of prayer.

As far as the MDC goes I have mixed feelings about applying. Let's face it, the challenge would be difficult.
Yes, I guessed it would be difficult - unless that ability turned out to be extraordinary (ie if you had the ability to toss all heads all the time for a large series of tosses). That is why you first had to demonstrate to yourself that you could prove it before you actually went public by applying for the MDC.

Maybe someone else could flip the coin? This coming weekend I'll be able to experiment with someone else tossing the coin.
I thought you had already decided that this doesn't seem to work.
 
I can't to speak for the departed Tim...
Oh, no! And here was I thinking he was just feeling a bit unwell. :D

...but I'll try by asking a question: at what point DOES one admit that an individual's claims aren't worth evaluating?
I think it has to be judged on an individual basis. I can't list all the possible reasons to abandom evaluating a particular person's claims, because so many factors could come into it. For example, if you have someone who cannot even articulate what they can do. Or if you have someone who cannot write a coherent sentence and cannot make it any clearer when asked to explain point by point. Someone who demonstrates clear evidence of a mental disorder. Someone whose claims narrow down to an ability which require so many special conditions to work that there does not seem to be any way at all of testing it.

Also, we should not feel a need to make definite conclusions in all cases. Some claimed abilities just turn out to be untestable. It doesn't necessarily mean they don't exist. Although it probably does mean that they are not very extraordinary abilities. But, having a scientific/sceptical outlook, means being happy to live with uncertainty. Otherwise you are something else - Jim calls such a person a pseudosceptic.
 
The question suggested to me is, "Does a hot knife cut through bullcrap any better than a cold knife?" I mean, bullcrap doesn't really melt at higher temperatures does it? It might even be less effective on extremely dry, hard bullcrap, since heat could slightly soften the metal.

Are there any studies on this?
 
If you can find the bullcrap, then perhaps I will conduct a little experiment with hot and cold knives.

In the mean time I have a couple of song lyrics to ponder:

"You could cut the heat, peel it back, with the wrong side of a knife"

"I could cut my cold breath with a knife"


regards,
BillyJoe
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom