timokay
Thinker
- Joined
- Jun 29, 2005
- Messages
- 158
I was in a discussion that derailed a thread, and I hate doing that. Hopefully, the discussion can continue here.
I have been an active member for a short while, but have supported the JREF for many years prior. I am not much of a poster. I usually chime in only when I can address a claimant whom I feel may be able to give some insight as to just why they feel they have experienced a paranormal event. Or when I have a good limerick.
I personally never have experienced the paranormal, and it is my personal opinion that paranormal events can be explained by science, logic and common sense.
Convincing a believer of that, as most people on this board know, is a task. I am very glad that the MDC has become proactive in revealing the criminals who make claims about these "powers", and steal millions from the gullible, uneducated and ill-informed.
All paranormal claims, especially those who receive funds for "services", should be rigorously challenged, without mercy. Taking money for a service that you cannot prove is criminal.
Anyway, I really am a friendly sort when you get to know me.
And now to work.
The thread we have jumped from is here:http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=2363820#post2363820
If someone genuinely believes they have a power, but can provide no evidence, and has nothing but anecdotal evidence and bad science to back them up, then it is counterproductive to start designing a protocol.
I asked JM questions directly from his claims. I specified each claim, and asked specific questions. He has provided NO evidence. Anecdotal evidence is NO evidence. It may be his reason for believing, but it is NOT evidence. I addressed his CLAIMS. Specifically. I made NO generalizations. And I addressed HIS claims, not anyone else.
He provided NO evidence. I addressed his CLAIMS. There is no reason to pull a protocol out of thin air. Maybe I should ask him if he can run a marathon? That's random enough. I am interested in ANY evidence he has to present. Did you see any? Wait, lets see if he can predict the flip of a coin? That will prove.... wait, he never said he could do that.... That's ok, let's try it anyway.
I guess you hope that he will sit in his room and flip away, and then see that he can;t predict the outcome. Is that what you are after? Do you think he will have some great epiphany at that point? Why did you try it yourself? Do you think you will demonstrate the paranormal?
Why do you choose to ignore that he has said that he can make people pick him at a table, he can avoid speeding tickets, he evidently caused the death of someone, but vows to ease up on that one... None of this is up for debate? None of this interests you? It interests me. Because it is his claim.
If they say they can jump 20 feet in the air because of a paranormal ability, I will be right there with a measuring stick. I will address exactly what they say, as carefully as possible. I will offer alternate solutions, and examine the individual for the reasoning they use to determine their claim. I will ask them to provide evidence as to why they think they can do it. And why it is paranormal.
Then I will demand that they do it. And before you roll out the ridiculous marathon analogy yet again, I don't care if they only can do it better than chance, if that is their claim. Under a full moon, in a park, in the dark, in a car, in a bar.... they better be able to do it.
I have been an active member for a short while, but have supported the JREF for many years prior. I am not much of a poster. I usually chime in only when I can address a claimant whom I feel may be able to give some insight as to just why they feel they have experienced a paranormal event. Or when I have a good limerick.
I personally never have experienced the paranormal, and it is my personal opinion that paranormal events can be explained by science, logic and common sense.
Convincing a believer of that, as most people on this board know, is a task. I am very glad that the MDC has become proactive in revealing the criminals who make claims about these "powers", and steal millions from the gullible, uneducated and ill-informed.
All paranormal claims, especially those who receive funds for "services", should be rigorously challenged, without mercy. Taking money for a service that you cannot prove is criminal.
Anyway, I really am a friendly sort when you get to know me.
And now to work.
The thread we have jumped from is here:http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=2363820#post2363820
If someone genuinely believes they have a power, but can provide no evidence, and has nothing but anecdotal evidence and bad science to back them up, then it is counterproductive to start designing a protocol.
Well, let's look at JM.
He genuinely believes he has the ability to affect events around him and he has a lot of personal experience to relate. Okay, call it belief in the paranormal with only anecdoatal evidence to back it up. But I have never heard him offer up bad science as an explanation for his claimed ability. And he has at least attempted to provide evidence - initially to himself before subjecting himself to a public test. How, in this situation is it counterproductive to design a protocol to help him test his ability scientifically.
You have mischaracterised JM because of your obsession with generalising rather than attending to the individual before you.
I asked JM questions directly from his claims. I specified each claim, and asked specific questions. He has provided NO evidence. Anecdotal evidence is NO evidence. It may be his reason for believing, but it is NOT evidence. I addressed his CLAIMS. Specifically. I made NO generalizations. And I addressed HIS claims, not anyone else.
If you are going to challenge the evidence presented by JM, why not help him with a protocol that is likely to produce evidence that is worth considering. It seems to me you are not interested in any evidence he may or may not be able to present because you have already decided, based on your generalizations, that he could not possibly have this ability.
He provided NO evidence. I addressed his CLAIMS. There is no reason to pull a protocol out of thin air. Maybe I should ask him if he can run a marathon? That's random enough. I am interested in ANY evidence he has to present. Did you see any? Wait, lets see if he can predict the flip of a coin? That will prove.... wait, he never said he could do that.... That's ok, let's try it anyway.
I guess you hope that he will sit in his room and flip away, and then see that he can;t predict the outcome. Is that what you are after? Do you think he will have some great epiphany at that point? Why did you try it yourself? Do you think you will demonstrate the paranormal?
Why do you choose to ignore that he has said that he can make people pick him at a table, he can avoid speeding tickets, he evidently caused the death of someone, but vows to ease up on that one... None of this is up for debate? None of this interests you? It interests me. Because it is his claim.
You can't possibly be that thick.I can't believe you still haven't got the point about the man beating his wife.
So you don't think we should help potential claimants by designing protocols which would show them whether or not they have an ability and what exactly that ability is? How exactly are you going to actually challenge them then???
If they say they can jump 20 feet in the air because of a paranormal ability, I will be right there with a measuring stick. I will address exactly what they say, as carefully as possible. I will offer alternate solutions, and examine the individual for the reasoning they use to determine their claim. I will ask them to provide evidence as to why they think they can do it. And why it is paranormal.
Then I will demand that they do it. And before you roll out the ridiculous marathon analogy yet again, I don't care if they only can do it better than chance, if that is their claim. Under a full moon, in a park, in the dark, in a car, in a bar.... they better be able to do it.
Last edited: