Dr de Cock says circumcision reduces HIV risk

Last time I read the UNAIDS report they stated they could use another 8billion condoms. How much will mass hygienic circumcisions cost?

IMO The main reason for a boy/man who is not going to be circumcised for religious reasons to opt for this is to have unprotected sex. The exact opposite of what is required until a high efficacy (i.e. similar to that of using a condom correctly) vaccine is developed.

http://www.unaids.org/en/HIV_data/2006GlobalReport/default.asp
 
Doubtless he's a urologist. Either that or he makes wallets that turn into suitcases when you rub them for a while.
 
I wish I was called "Dr of Cock". That's awesome.
 
So there should be solid evidence from the sexually-active Jewish community. Is the AIDS rate lower in Jews practicing non-safe sex?
 
IMO The main reason for a boy/man who is not going to be circumcised for religious reasons to opt for this is to have unprotected sex. The exact opposite of what is required until a high efficacy (i.e. similar to that of using a condom correctly) vaccine is developed.

http://www.unaids.org/en/HIV_data/2006GlobalReport/default.asp

Both studies specifically looked at this issue and found that it wasn't the case - i.e. condom use increased and unprotected sex decreased in both groups.

Linda
 
So there should be solid evidence from the sexually-active Jewish community. Is the AIDS rate lower in Jews practicing non-safe sex?
As I recall, this whole issue came to light because of the observed differences between Moslem and Christian villages in those areas of Africa where both populations are at risk from AIDS. I have even heard, on the radio, suggestions that some Christian fathers get their boys circumcised as a prophylactic measure.

The question about the Jews seems fair but I have never heard anything about them. Circumcision is very common among all Americans so a statistical study directed to Jews might best be performed in Europe. (I recall that the Jewish actor, Paul Michael Glaser - Starsky - did not contract AIDS from his wife, though she had suffered that infection from a blood transfusion.)
 
Both studies specifically looked at this issue and found that it wasn't the case - i.e. condom use increased and unprotected sex decreased in both groups.

Linda

So how does having (or the promise of) your foreskin removed give you greater self control and a more responsible attitude? Or did they all have safe sex practices drummed into them at the same time, as with some of the other studies?

Given that men complain about reduced sensitivity using condoms and circumcision also reduces sensitivity (after the glans has hardened up), I would think it unlikely to be the circumcision that's responsible for the safer sex practices.

Although I guess it could be that the circumcised men's urge for sex increased while they were waiting for their penises to heal and so started using condoms to protect their wounded member and got used to wearing one.
 
So how does having (or the promise of) your foreskin removed give you greater self control and a more responsible attitude? Or did they all have safe sex practices drummed into them at the same time, as with some of the other studies?

Given that men complain about reduced sensitivity using condoms and circumcision also reduces sensitivity (after the glans has hardened up), I would think it unlikely to be the circumcision that's responsible for the safer sex practices.

Although I guess it could be that the circumcised men's urge for sex increased while they were waiting for their penises to heal and so started using condoms to protect their wounded member and got used to wearing one.

Mostly likely the free condoms and the safe sex counselling they received throughout the study period.

Linda
 
I recall that the Jewish actor, Paul Michael Glaser - Starsky - did not contract AIDS from his wife, though she had suffered that infection from a blood transfusion.

HIV is not 100% infectious. One case study doesn't prove the purported phenomenon. In any case, I'll bet anything you like condom use is safer, even if there is a real effect - which I concede is possible, having seen an abstract of the report. There does seem a plausible transmission mechanism in uncircumcised men, but I think it's irresponsible to offer what may be an exaggerated lifeline.

Encouraging condom use would seem to be a more responsible attutude.
 
Linda,

Do you think it will work?

What changes in behavior would there need to be to make it go tits up? E.g. would a 5-10% drop in condom usage wipe it out in the long term?

I just don't see how you could sell it to most men. They need to be told to use condoms to protect themselves and their sexual partners. How then do you add on the bit about circumcision without talking about them engaging in unprotected sex?

All I can think is I'm looking at it from the wrong perspective i.e. from the individual rather than as a population, to see that this is going to be as great as they are pitching it to be.
 
From the Kenyan study the 2 behavioral changes that look concerning are:

Unprotected sexual intercourse with any partner in previous 6 months. Circ.: 51%; Control: 46% in month 24.

This stabilized for the circumcised men, but had a downward trend for the control group during the study period.

Consistent condom use in previous 6 months. Circ.: 36%; Control: 41% in month 24.

Again, this stabilized for the circumcised men, but also stabilized for the control group at a slightly higher level.

I could not see similar differences in the Ugandan study, where after 24 months the two groups were near identical in all behavioral risks considered except alcohol use: Circ.: 51%; Control: 57%.

In the Ugandan study only 1-2% of men admitted to transactional sexual intercourse, which seems very low.
 
Last edited:
HIV is not 100% infectious. One case study doesn't prove the purported phenomenon. In any case, I'll bet anything you like condom use is safer, even if there is a real effect - which I concede is possible, having seen an abstract of the report. There does seem a plausible transmission mechanism in uncircumcised men, but I think it's irresponsible to offer what may be an exaggerated lifeline.

Encouraging condom use would seem to be a more responsible attutude.

I do not understand why it is more responsible to withhold an intervention which now has overwhelmingly demonstrated, in real world situations, that it reduces the acquisition of HIV by more than half.

Linda
 
Linda,

Do you think it will work?

In light of the evidence, what possible justification could I give for thinking that it will not work?

What changes in behavior would there need to be to make it go tits up? E.g. would a 5-10% drop in condom usage wipe it out in the long term?

As far as I can tell, even if all the circumcized men didn't use condoms, it still wouldn't wipe out the effect.

I just don't see how you could sell it to most men. They need to be told to use condoms to protect themselves and their sexual partners. How then do you add on the bit about circumcision without talking about them engaging in unprotected sex?

The fact that they were able to accomplish that in the real world shows that it can be done, even if your imagination fails you as to how.

All I can think is I'm looking at it from the wrong perspective i.e. from the individual rather than as a population, to see that this is going to be as great as they are pitching it to be.

As far as I can tell, some people are unable to overcome their strong negative bias towards circumcision when considering the results of these studies. I don't like it either, but maybe I have more practice with having to accept things that I didn't want to be true?

Linda
 
In light of the evidence, what possible justification could I give for thinking that it will not work?

I don't know, that's why I was asking you:)

As far as I can tell, even if all the circumcized men didn't use condoms, it still wouldn't wipe out the effect.

Both groups in both trials had similar levels of condom usage. I know you’re too smart to be saying that if the circumcised men had not use condoms they’d have been better off than the control group, so could you explain what you mean?

The fact that they were able to accomplish that in the real world shows that it can be done, even if your imagination fails you as to how.

Not quite. There's a difference between being a volunteer in a medical trial and have a procedure presented to you as effective, especially as the procedure in question is a preventative measure - but isn’t really, since you still have to do all the same stuff you did before!

As far as I can tell, some people are unable to overcome their strong negative bias towards circumcision when considering the results of these studies. I don't like it either, but maybe I have more practice with having to accept things that I didn't want to be true?

Linda

My only bias toward what anybody does with their body is that they are allowed to make an informed choice. In the discussion session they were mentioning 100% uptake and performing the circumcision before the boys were sexually active, which could be a very young age in sub-Saharan Africa.

I think promoting circumcision for HIV prevention has huge potential to backfire. As it looks like they will be doing this in the near future, I hope I'm wrong.
 
I don't know, that's why I was asking you:)

Okay. :)

It's taken up in numbers too low to make much of an impact. Because of limited resources, educational resources are eliminated to pay for the program. The circumcisions are not performed under safe conditions by skilled workers and the rate of complications is much higher. Prostitutes give a discount to circumcised men, leading to a higher rate of risky sex among circumcized men.

Both groups in both trials had similar levels of condom usage. I know you’re too smart to be saying that if the circumcised men had not use condoms they’d have been better off than the control group, so could you explain what you mean?

That's exactly what I'm saying. Taking into consideration the rate of condom use found in the study, the risk reduction due to regular condom use, the risk reduction due to circumcision, and the rate of HIV acquisition during the study, even if the circumcized men stopped using condoms altogether, there would still have been fewer cases of HIV acquisition among the circumcized men than there would have been among the uncircumcized men. If the rate of condom use among uncircumcized men was 60 percent and rate among circumcized men was zero, then the rate of HIV acquisition would be equivalent.

My only bias toward what anybody does with their body is that they are allowed to make an informed choice. In the discussion session they were mentioning 100% uptake and performing the circumcision before the boys were sexually active, which could be a very young age in sub-Saharan Africa.

So I take it you would oppose vaccination, as well. ;)

I think promoting circumcision for HIV prevention has huge potential to backfire. As it looks like they will be doing this in the near future, I hope I'm wrong.

Because Africans shouldn't be in any sort of hurry to deal with AIDS, so it's fine to dick around for the next few years?

Linda
 
Okay. :)

It's taken up in numbers too low to make much of an impact. Because of limited resources, educational resources are eliminated to pay for the program. The circumcisions are not performed under safe conditions by skilled workers and the rate of complications is much higher. Prostitutes give a discount to circumcised men, leading to a higher rate of risky sex among circumcized men.

All good points. Well done.:D

Actually, higher education is positively correlated with HIV incidence.

That's exactly what I'm saying. Taking into consideration the rate of condom use found in the study, the risk reduction due to regular condom use, the risk reduction due to circumcision, and the rate of HIV acquisition during the study, even if the circumcized men stopped using condoms altogether, there would still have been fewer cases of HIV acquisition among the circumcized men than there would have been among the uncircumcized men. If the rate of condom use among uncircumcized men was 60 percent and rate among circumcized men was zero, then the rate of HIV acquisition would be equivalent.

Assuming all other factors stay constant. That's a really big assumption.

So I take it you would oppose vaccination, as well. ;)

It would depend on the risks associated with and the effectiveness of the vaccine. They are some diseases that can be vaccinated against that the risks of the vaccines are considered high enough to stop them being used for the general population. Other vaccines are considered not to have a high enough efficacy to make them cost effective. Yet others only work for a limited time period.

However, on the whole I support vaccination.

Because Africans shouldn't be in any sort of hurry to deal with AIDS, so it's fine to dick around for the next few years?

Linda

Is that what you think I'm advocating? I have two main concerns with what the research will lead to:

1) Blanket male circumcision for boys who are too young to make an informed choice.

2) Over a longer term than the studies to date and in real life, i.e. men who are not part of an experimental group with an uncertain outcome, behavioural changes occur that compensate for the increased protection circumcision provides.

I freely admit that (1) is my bias. You appear to be saying studying (2) is "dicking around". I think it is a real and significant risk.
 
I do not understand why it is more responsible to withhold an intervention which now has overwhelmingly demonstrated, in real world situations, that it reduces the acquisition of HIV by more than half.
Because the intervention comes with a cost; one, it might be noted, that will not be borne by the proponents of an envisioned mass-circumcision program in sub-Saharan Africa. Thus, there is a cost-benefit analysis to be made, and if this analysis is to be honest, it must take into account the fact that consistent use of condoms provides better protection (and for both parties involved) than circumcision alone.

Yes, I acknowledge that the prophylactic effects are cumulative, but not without the equation undergoing some changes. Consistent condom use is at least 87% effective in reducing the risk of HIV transmission, and more likely 99% or more. So imagine two subjects; #1 is uncircumcised, #2 is circumcised. Assuming consistent use of condoms, subject #1 enjoys 87-99% protection from HIV infection. Given that the effect of circumcision is moot unless and until the HIV manages to bypass the condoms, subject #2 enjoys 93.5%-99.5% protection. In the overall equation, then, given the consistent use of condoms, the beneficial effect of circumcision drops from the touted 51-53% to at most ~7% and more likely less than 0.5%. Those are markedly less impressive numbers.

As far as I can tell, some people are unable to overcome their strong negative bias towards circumcision when considering the results of these studies. I don't like it either, but maybe I have more practice with having to accept things that I didn't want to be true?
To be blunt, I think the fact that you don't have a foreskin plays a larger role in your thinking on this issue. Imagine that there were research which indicated that amputation of the clitoral hood reduced the risk of HPV transmission by 51-53%. Would you be as quick to support a program of mass FGM for the purpose of reducing occurrence of HPV? Perhaps more importantly, would you personally step forward to undergo such a procedure? Or would you personally prefer to seek alternative means of protection, especially if those had a better rate of return?

Moreover, the controversy regarding this issue does not concern the findings of the studies themselves; it concerns how those findings should inform policy regarding aid to Africa. We have finite resources to apply to attempting to limit, and hopefully reduce, the incidence of HIV/AIDS in Africa. Even taking it as read that the findings of these studies are correct, reducing the transmission rate of HIV will at best slow the spread of HIV/AIDS, not halt it. It is a legitimate question to ask whether the resources necessary to responsibly implement a program of mass MGM in sub-Saharan Africa ("responsibly" in this context meaning that it does not cause greater damage to public health as a result of non-HIV/AIDS-related complications and side-effects than the benefits derived from slowing the spread of HIV/AIDS) might not be better spent otherwise. It is also a legitimate question to wonder whether such a program would provide full disclosure to its prospective subjects (or "clients," if you prefer) regarding the benefits and drawbacks to undergoing such a procedure: Will it be sufficiently emphasized that the procedure provides an extremely limited degree of protection? (Would you play Russian roulette with three chambers loaded?) Will the subjects be fully informed beforehand as to the drawbacks of not having a foreskin?

So I take it you would oppose vaccination, as well.
Not a very good analogy. Male genital mutilation permanently affects the quality of life of the subject to an extent that nobody would accept from a vaccine, especially not one that was at most 53% effective. If someone came out with a vaccine against HIV next year, which was effective 53% of the time, and gave the subject a mild but incurable permanent cough, would any governmental agency approve it? Would we fault anyone who refused to take it, or inflict it on their kids, instead preferring to exercise caution regarding exposure and hope that somebody might come up with something without permanent side-effects a few years down the road?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom