[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

oahuoahu

Thinker
Joined
Feb 27, 2007
Messages
168
Lets just assume hypothetically I live in california and make 100 dollars an hour and I work 8 hours a day monday through friday. Which laws, whether state or federal laws, require that I pay a tax on my labor.



Link them to me or type them out so I can comment. Thank you.
 
Last edited:
The 16th Amendment to the US Constitution gives the government the power to tax income. If you're going to go on about "Freedom to Fascism" and all that tax-protesting nonsense, I'd suggest using the search function. It was discussed here previously.

And, in your hypothetical example, you'd best report your hypothetical income or you'll be put in that hypothetical prison in San Quentin. If you're making that kind of hypothetical income, you can afford to pay your hypothetical taxes.
 
The 16th Amendment to the US Constitution gives the government the power to tax income. If you're going to go on about "Freedom to Fascism" and all that tax-protesting nonsense, I'd suggest using the search function. It was discussed here previously.

And, in your hypothetical example, you'd best report your hypothetical income or you'll be put in that hypothetical prison in San Quentin.



Where you'd be likely to receive some hypothetical love from your hypothetical roommate - Hypothetical Joe.

-Gumboot
 
You could ask Kent Hovind or any of the other tax conspiracy nuts that have been sent to jail for not paying taxes.
 
The 16th Amendment to the US Constitution gives the government the power to tax income.

Yes, the 16th amendment allows the US to form a law.

Just link me the laws that require a california citizen to pay a tax on his labor.
 
Yes, the 16th amendment allows the US to form a law.

Just link me the laws that require a california citizen to pay a tax on his labor.

You can get to this message board but not google? Why should anyone here be doing your work for you?
 
Yes, the 16th amendment allows the US to form a law.

Just link me the laws that require a california citizen to pay a tax on his labor.


what are you trying to get at?
If you work (labor) and are being paid for it, then you are earning INCOME. Thereby, in the grand state of CA, you are taxed on it via STATE And FEDERAL income tax laws.
 
what are you trying to get at?
If you work (labor) and are being paid for it, then you are earning INCOME. Thereby, in the grand state of CA, you are taxed on it via STATE And FEDERAL income tax laws.

Based on the wording of the OP, it seems that he wants US to quote the law so he can debate against it. :jaw-dropp

This could very well prove to make the 911 conspiracy theories look well researched!
 
Last edited:
I'd say the easiest way for you to find out would be to stop paying your taxes for a while, and I am sure the nice judge would be more than happy to list for you all of the statutes that were violated by your non-payment.
 
Yes, the 16th amendment allows the US to form a law.

Just link me the laws that require a california citizen to pay a tax on his labor.


You mean you want a link to the thousands of pages of tax code which were passed by numerous congresses to regulate the way you are taxed?
 
Last edited:
no, he wants to be linked on any tax law that says that he can be taxed on his labor (notice his wording)

So if he "laboring" but not being paid , then how can he be taxed? ( they dont)

however, if his labor is earning him money (INCOME) he can be taxed for that.
 
no, he wants to be linked on any tax law that says that he can be taxed on his labor (notice his wording)

So if he "laboring" but not being paid , then how can he be taxed? ( they dont)

however, if his labor is earning him money (INCOME) he can be taxed for that.

Ah yes I see. I'm glad I don't have to pay a tax every time I mow my lawn or perfrom other free labor. :D
 
Fine I will explain.

Theres income. Income is the gains derived from business; revenues minus costs is income as defined by the constitution.

The 16th amendment allowed the government to levy taxes on all forms of income, which it already had the power to do.

Wages and Salaries are not income, because when you trade labor for money you're trading 100 dollars of labor (1 hour) for 100 dollars of currency. When your labor becomes more valuable you get a raise, or maybe you have an easy job and your labor is less valuable.

If I make 100 dollars an hour and I work 8 hours I have 0 dollars of income, because my labor has value. So I spent 800 dollars of labor (cost) to gain 800 dollars of currency.

800 - 800 = 0

0 income.

Anyway, there are laws that say you have to pay a tax on your business income. That is good income tax that goes to fund mostly our military.
The trick is when we pay income tax on our wage or salary. We are told that wages and salaries are income. Whatever.

Most of the time, i've found laws that say if you are required to file a federal income tax return yo must file a state tax return for [this state] or vice versa, and I can't find the law that says citizen of [this state] must file a federal income tax return.

Even if you HAD to file an income tax return, you would have to use the term income as defined in the IRS tax code, but the IRS tax code never defines the word income in its 55,000+ pages. Until the IRS tax code defines the word income, we use the constitutions definition.
 
Last edited:
no, he wants to be linked on any tax law that says that he can be taxed on his labor (notice his wording)

So if he "laboring" but not being paid , then how can he be taxed? ( they dont)

however, if his labor is earning him money (INCOME) he can be taxed for that.

But he said he is being paid in the OP.
 
Fine I will explain.

Theres income. Income is the gains derived from business; revenues minus costs is income as defined by the constitution.

The 16th amendment allowed the government to levy taxes on income.
Wages and Salaries are not income, because when you trade labor for money you're trading 100 dollars of labor (1 hour) for 100 dollars of currency. When your labor becomes more valuable you get a raise, or maybe you have an easy job and your labor is less valuable.

If I make 100 dollars an hour and I work 8 hours I have 0 dollars of income, because my labor has value.

Anyway, there are laws that say you have to pay a tax on your business income. That is good income tax that goes to fund mostly our military.
The trick is when we pay income tax on our wage or salary. We are told that wages and salaries are income. Whatever.

Most of the time, i've found laws that say if you are required to file a federal income tax return yo must file a state tax return for [this state] or vice versa, and I can't find the law that says citizen of [this state] must file a federal income tax return.

Even if you HAD to file a income tax return, you would have to use the term income as defined in the IRS tax code, but the IRS tax code never defines the word income in its 55,000+ pages. Until the IRS tax code defines the word income, we use the constitutions definition.

Good luck with that.
 
Fine I will explain.

Theres income. Income is the gains derived from business; revenues minus costs is income as defined by the constitution.



Is it?

"revenue" is a business term. It is not applied to individuals. For individuals, the correct term is "income" (not to be confused with "net income" which is profits for a business).

You're getting confused because different terms are used for businesses and individuals.

-Gumboot
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom