What happens when New Age nonsense invades medicine?

Jaggy Bunnet

Philosopher
Joined
May 16, 2003
Messages
6,241
People suffer. In this case, a new born baby left severely brain damaged.

http://www.sundaymail.co.uk/news/tm...objectid=18805708&siteid=64736-name_page.html

A few "highlights" from the story:

The midwife "HAMPERED paramedics' attempts to resuscitate the baby, so she could apply olive oil to its feet", "STUCK her finger into the baby's mouth to apply a herbal remedy when a paramedic was giving resuscitation" and also failed "to document numerous clinical details which could have helped in the ongoing care of the baby".

Still the organisation she is a member of "focus on the women and their views are respected". Which sounds fine until they go on to say "Even if the wishes of a mother impair the safety of a birth, we will accept that."

Remember this is the type of nonsense that our future king wants to get into the NHS, never mind that it can do no good and never mind that a few kids might die or be permanently damaged by it, it fits in with his belief system so he will lobby for it (ignoring the fact that this is clearly a political matter which he is meant to stay out of) and attack those who argue for medicine to be based in the 21st, not the 12th, century.

Think the French would lend us a guillotine?
 
No, probably not, especially as it was a French surgeon and gyaecologist who has been an advocate for more natural birthing methods - Michel Odent. His book on it is Birth Reborn What Childbirth Should Be.

I am not condoning this midwife's behaviour in any way and from the article it appears that she made some fundamental and critical errors of judgement, however, generally speaking, there is nothing wrong with home births, or birthing rooms or pools, as long as they are properly managed by trained midwives, nurses, doctors etc.
 
I cannot believe these independent midwives operate without insurance. That's frankly staggering. Yes, I appreciate the cost of the insurance is more than their annual salary. There's a reason for that. It's because the premium is relative to the potential damage and the risk. If the premium is high, that means they are operating in a potentially lethal environment and their actions can be the difference between life and death. To not be accountable via insurance is extraordinary.
 
I cannot believe these independent midwives operate without insurance. That's frankly staggering. Yes, I appreciate the cost of the insurance is more than their annual salary. There's a reason for that. It's because the premium is relative to the potential damage and the risk. If the premium is high, that means they are operating in a potentially lethal environment and their actions can be the difference between life and death. To not be accountable via insurance is extraordinary.

I was also surprised to see that it was legal for them to operate without insurance, but apparently sole traders have been exempt from compulsory insurance requirements since 2004, even though the requirement is being reintroduced for midwifes in the near future.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom