Debunking the Stundies - March Edition

William Rea

Banned
Joined
Sep 4, 2006
Messages
983
Having enjoyed debunking two of the March "Stundie" Awards Voting Nominations I am starting a thread away from the normal "Stundies" activities to debunk the basis of any nominations that do not stand up to their stated aims.

In the same spirit as the "Stundies" this thread is not restricted to analysing any particular side of the debate in preference over the other but, its content will reflect the nominations put forward in the "Stundies".

I am interested in comments from people who have gone back and reviewed "Stundie" nominations and found the quotes taken completely out of context. This is an opportunity to redress the lack of impartiality of any quotes.

NOTE - I cannot emphasise enough that this thread is not for flamers, if you have nothing to add to the analysis then avoid it. By the same token I will no longer involve myself in any of the "Stundies" threads leaving everyone to have their version of fun as they see fit.

Undoubtedly there are elements who will not welcome this thread and will do everything within their power to disrupt & personalise it and so get it moved out by the Moderation. Time will tell but, I think it's worth the effort.
 
First Debunking March Nomination Number 2

Context of the Nomination cut and pasted from the "Stundies"...

-2-

Nominated by apathoid

[From a no-plane thread...Killtown has trouble understanding the limits of the internet; context provided]


Originally Posted by Why Won't God Heal Amputees
If you watch a normal video (not an internet video) of the plane hitting, you will see that after the plane 'disappears' there is in fact a cloud of shredded plane skin falling downward outside of the building on the same side that it hit.

Originally Posted by Killtown
link to a "normal" video?


=====================================================
Actual context of the posts in the thread cut and pasted from LCF...

Originally Posted by Jarrayo in LCF

Excellent observation Amputees.

Obviously the WTC wall is not a giant solid smooth mass. Strangely in the video, it seems so. Why?

Because this video was recorded by who-knows what camera (could have even been a crappy one, such as a camcorder), I doubt the person who recorded gave the original footage to the person who posted it on the internet, so most likely he recorded it from a TV. After that, he send it to the computer. After that he compressed it by an enormous degree to allow fast internet replay. And after that it was posted on YouTube (or GoogleVideo) where it looses even more resolution. And after that someone made a screen capture of the already crappy footage and in most cases blew up the image to focus on the plane.

If you know about videos and graphics, you'll know that every step of the translation of the recording makes the video loose resolution. So the NPTers are basing their "evidence" on already faulty videos.

Response by Killtown

1) link to a "normal" video?

2) Example?

====================================================

1. Killtown was responding to Jarrayo's post not Amputees as is implied in the nomination.

2. The "normal" video link requested could easily be a link to a bit torrent for the original video, we don't know.

3. However diagreeable Killtown's stance is on WTC his post is neither ignorant nor illogical nor fallacious when seen in its full context.
 
Last edited:
I'm very much more interested in your agreement with David Ray Griffin that "...gravitational energy...is vertical..."

Let's go back to Griffin's quote:
"...gravitational energy, which is vertical..."

When an object is suspended above the ground:
Its position (height) is vertical
The gravitational force acting on it is vertical
Its gravitational potential energy IS NOT VERTICAL

When the object is dropped:
Its displacement is vertical
Its gravitational acceleration (g) is vertical
Its kinetic energy IS NOT VERTICAL

You may as well argue that the object's mass is vertical.

Griffin is mixing up fundamental physics concepts. If he weren't making (or repeating) claims about how the twin towers should have collapsed without the aid of explosives, it would be no big deal. But he is (and he has many avid followers) so it is.

Zdenek Bazant represents energies with vectors in his analysis.

???

This I gotta see. Show us some quotes with citations.

I decided to get out of this thread to stop you all whingeing about me posting in it. :D

So you couldn't find any references to Bazant saying energy was a vector?

Dave

You never finished your expert debunking.
 
Not sure I agree with your claim that Killtown was responding to an intervening post--note the word "normal" in quotes, which Jarroyo never uses. On the other hand, it certainly could be argued that Killtown was asking for a link to a site selling a "normal" video. So I think you're right that this should not have been included in the list.
 
Second Debunking March Nomination Number 11

Nomination cut and pasted from the "Stundies"...

-11-

Nominated by Dave Rogers

[David Ray Griffin discovers that energy is a vector...]


Originally Posted by David Ray Griffin
...gravitational energy, which is vertical...


=====================================================

The paragraph as cut and pasted from....

Morons and Magic: A Reply to George Monbiot

By David Ray Griffin

"At the onset of each tower’s collapse, steel beams were ejected out as far as 600 feet; to believe that these horizontal ejections could be explained by gravitational energy, which is vertical, is to believe in magic."

=======================================================

To defend this one hurts me because Griffin is a Theologian and I am at the very least agnostic but here goes...

1. David Ray Griffin's language is not scientific but its intent is clear.

2. It actually shows a little insight into how Gravitational Potential Energy acts and releases in a vectorial manner.

3. In its correct context it is neither ignorant nor illogical nor fallacious, the man just doesn't have the knowledge of scientific language to express himself. Despite this he clearly shows an understanding of how it works.

4. Other scientists and engineers express energy and conversions in similar terms.
 
Nomination cut and pasted from the "Stundies"...

-11-

Nominated by Dave Rogers

[David Ray Griffin discovers that energy is a vector...]


Originally Posted by David Ray Griffin
...gravitational energy, which is vertical...


=====================================================

The paragraph as cut and pasted from....

Morons and Magic: A Reply to George Monbiot

By David Ray Griffin

"At the onset of each tower’s collapse, steel beams were ejected out as far as 600 feet; to believe that these horizontal ejections could be explained by gravitational energy, which is vertical, is to believe in magic."

=======================================================

To defend this one hurts me because Griffin is a Theologian and I am at the very least agnostic but here goes...

1. David Ray Griffin's language is not scientific but its intent is clear.

2. It actually shows a little insight into how Gravitational Potential Energy acts and releases in a vectorial manner.

3. In its correct context it is neither ignorant nor illogical nor fallacious, the man just doesn't have the knowledge of scientific language to express himself. Despite this he clearly shows an understanding of how it works.

4. Other scientists and engineers express energy and conversions in similar terms.

Let's see that evidence that energy is vectoral? C'mo--you said you had a link. Let's see it...
 
The paragraph as cut and pasted from....

Morons and Magic: A Reply to George Monbiot

By David Ray Griffin

"At the onset of each tower’s collapse, steel beams were ejected out as far as 600 feet; to believe that these horizontal ejections could be explained by gravitational energy, which is vertical, is to believe in magic."

=======================================================

3. In its correct context it is neither ignorant nor illogical nor fallacious, the man just doesn't have the knowledge of scientific language to express himself. Despite this he clearly shows an understanding of how it works.


That's pretty much the definition of ignorant. He's a theologian, presuming to discuss physics at a level where he can claim that other's analyses can be dismissed as "magic", and yet he knows so little of the topic, he cannot even use the correct terminology.

This is aside from his glossing over how a downwardly directed force can result in lateral movement, provided there is some mechanism to redirect the effect of the force. He simply ignores the fact that these particular beams were not acting solely under the influence of gravity, but were also interacting with all of the masses around them.

So, ignorant, and willfully blind. Pure Stundie material.
 
Having enjoyed debunking two of the March "Stundie" Awards Voting Nominations I am starting a thread away from the normal "Stundies" activities to debunk the basis of any nominations that do not stand up to their stated aims.
You seem to be a bright fellow, why don't you start a thread with your analysis of engineering aspects of the building collapses instead of your analysis of a silly quote thread. I'm serious, lay out your thoughts, state your case.
 
This is aside from his glossing over how a downwardly directed force can result in lateral movement, provided there is some mechanism to redirect the effect of the force.

It never ceases to amaze me. You just slated Griffin for NOT saying that and I have been slated in the past for saying just that, but I digress, now I'll have to report myself for posting off topic.
 
It never ceases to amaze me. You just slated Griffin for NOT saying that and I have been slated in the past for saying just that, but I digress, now I'll have to report myself for posting off topic.



Your arguments would carry more weight if you'd link to such examples. Some people in these discussions have misrepresented what was said earlier so often and so badly, that we simply cannot accept such assertions at face value.

Note, I said, "a downwardly directed force can result in lateral movement, provided there is some mechanism to redirect the effect of the force".

Consider a wedge being forced sideways under a weight. The sideways force can produce an upward movement of the weight, as the wedge acts to re-direct the effect of the force. There are losses (due to friction, and whatnot), but the principle is sound.
 
Last edited:
William Rea, this is a good idea for a thread. Context is always good for anybody's quotes, whoever and whatever they are.
 
William Rea, this is a good idea for a thread. Context is always good for anybody's quotes, whoever and whatever they are.



Which is why we encourage people to include links in the Stundies threads. You'll note a startling lack of same in Mr. Rea's posts above, however. I shan't speculate on his motives for failing to include them.
 
1. Killtown was responding to Jarrayo's post not Amputees as is implied in the nomination.

2. The "normal" video link requested could easily be a link to a bit torrent for the original video, we don't know.

3. However diagreeable Killtown's stance is on WTC his post is neither ignorant nor illogical nor fallacious when seen in its full context.
nice try, but nowhere in jarrayos post does the word "normal" appear, killtowns use of it in quotes indicates he is responding to amputees instruction for him to watch a "normal video"

from experience killtown deals exclusiely in youtube, i doubt he was asking for a torrent or any other p2p link
 
Honestly, I'm not a fan of the Stundies, so I don't go there very often.

If someone wants to offer some balance, or an opposing view, or defend or debunk the Stundies, that's fine with me. Not because it's the Stundies and I don't like them, but because that's what happens on just about every other thread in the JREF forum.

starting a thread away from the normal "Stundies" activities to debunk the basis of any nominations that do not stand up to their stated aims.

That sounds like a worthy goal (and a recipe for a lot of argument)...

Good luck ;)
 
nice try, but nowhere in jarrayos post does the word "normal" appear, killtowns use of it in quotes indicates he is responding to amputees instruction for him to watch a "normal video"

from experience killtown deals exclusiely in youtube, i doubt he was asking for a torrent or any other p2p link

Jarrayo is suggesting that the available video being used for analysis has degraded so much that the surface of the building looks smooth. He then goes on to speculate how the degredation might occur implying that there might be an original source video. That original source might be considered the "normal" condition for investigation.

Justifiably Killtown asks how to obtain this "normal" video.

The use of "normal" with the quotation marks indicates a sense of irony in the use of the word. I suggest that the poster is raising a question mark about what a "normal" video might be. To me this positively indicates he is aware that this source may not be available via a normal bit streaming source.

For some reason I cannot see the original post but killtown quoted Jarrayo in his reply so I can only infer he was responding to him/her.
 
Last edited:
Honestly, I'm not a fan of the Stundies, so I don't go there very often.
If someone wants to offer some balance, or an opposing view, or defend or debunk the Stundies, that's fine with me. Not because it's the Stundies and I don't like them, but because that's what happens on just about every other thread in the JREF forum.
That sounds like a worthy goal (and a recipe for a lot of argument)...
Good luck ;)

Thank you for the good wishes, I already suspect I will need them.

I am endeavouring to go legit so to speak so, I will refrain from responding in kind to obnoxious posts. In a way it is a test of myself and the forum to see if it is really possible to engage in a more positive manner.
 
I agree that context should be provided for the Stundies. It's only fair, after all, as Twoofers are regularly castigated for taking quotes out of context.

Of course, this won't reduce the number of nominees that much. There are plenty of in-context outrageous things said by Twoofers every day.
 
"At the onset of each tower’s collapse, steel beams were ejected out as far as 600 feet; to believe that these horizontal ejections could be explained by gravitational energy, which is vertical, is to believe in magic."

=======================================================

To defend this one hurts me because Griffin is a Theologian and I am at the very least agnostic but here goes...

1. David Ray Griffin's language is not scientific but its intent is clear.

Yes. He makes it quite clear that he believes that GPE can contribute ONLY to a vertical force vector.

2. It actually shows a little insight into how Gravitational Potential Energy acts and releases in a vectorial manner.

This statement actually gives us a little insight into how little you understand the concept of GPE. It in no way "releases in a vectorial manner." That makes absolutely no sense. It shows no insight on Griffin's part at all. Everyone knows that gravity makes stuff fall down. His confusion about the physics behind it is embarrassing.

3. In its correct context it is neither ignorant nor illogical nor fallacious, the man just doesn't have the knowledge of scientific language to express himself. Despite this he clearly shows an understanding of how it works.

:yikes: In its full context, it's even clearer that he has NO IDEA how it works. Let's see that again:

"At the onset of each tower’s collapse, steel beams were ejected out as far as 600 feet; to believe that these horizontal ejections could be explained by gravitational energy, which is vertical, is to believe in magic."

He not only vectorializes (it's a word, I swear) energy, but also implies that NONE of the GPE in a collapsing structure can be spent on lateral force components (except by "magic").

Judging by this sentence alone, he is completely inept in the realm of physics.

4. Other scientists and engineers express energy and conversions in similar terms.

So you say. Examples? Found that Bazant quote yet?
 
Jarrayo is suggesting that the available video being used for analysis has degraded so much that the surface of the building looks smooth. He then goes on to speculate how the degredation might occur implying that there might be an original source video. That original source might be considered the "normal" condition for investigation.

Justifiably Killtown asks how to obtain this "normal" video.

The use of "normal" with the quotation marks indicates a sense of irony in the use of the word. I suggest that the poster is raising a question mark about what a "normal" video might be. To me this positively indicates he is aware that this source may not be available via a normal bit streaming source.

For some reason I cannot see the original post but killtown quoted Jarrayo in his reply so I can only infer he was responding to him/her.
i feel his use of "normal" in quotes indicates a direct response to amputees instructing him to find a "normal video" your free to ask to killtown what he meant by it, but i think any "normal" person will take it this way
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom