Who are the legitimate members of the 9/11 Truth Movement?

David Wong

Graduate Poster
Joined
Sep 9, 2006
Messages
1,773
In another thread...

Ron. why waste time on people like Ace and Fetzer, who even the truth movement have rejected. It's pointless.

This comes up frequently, when debunkers hold up (for example) Judy Wood and the Star Wars beam weapon for ridicule, some 9/11 conspiracist will declare that we're intentionally targeting the silliest factions of the movement and ignoring the serious, intelligent ones. In this instance, Ron replied indicating that it was impossible to discern which theories and proponents were still "in" among the 9/11 truth movement and which were not.

This thread should clarify that.

To avoid us from further using the fallacious, strawman tactic of only targeting the most ridiculous 9/11 theories, can someone who believes 9/11 is an inside job, and who is well read on the subject, inform us of what is the "mainstream" theory among the members of the movement, and which are considered the fringe?

For instance, I understand that "no plane" theories are banned on the Loose Change forums... but I have further been told, repeatedly, that the Loose Change film itself is a frivolous and easy target and does not at all represent what the truther mainstream believes.

So what would that be?
 
My feeling is that a "mainstream" truther is one who hasn't attracted enough critical attention to have his/her claims utterly destroyed. These are getting fewer and farther between. Fetzer, Wood, Reynolds, S. Jones.. all big wheels in Twoof at one time, all reduced to rubble.

Now they're pushing people like the Jersey Girls and Sofia as "mainstream", maybe feeling that it's harder to attack women and family members. Their claims are no more valid than Fetzer's, Wood's or the Loose Change boys', but they haven't yet gotten raked over the coals by the mainstream debunking community (JREF is, as always, ahead of the curve on debunking).

As far as what the "mainstream" Twoofer, actually believes, I don't think you can pin it down, except to say that they feel "something" is wrong with the investigation that was done and that a "new investigation" should be launched. What they hope to accomplish by this, I don't know. They want people in the US government to be held accountable for their failures on 9/11. That's something I wouldn't mind, myself. There certainly were failures of communication and errors of commission and omission, and people should be accountable for them. The shrillest of the Twoofers, though, want Cheney and Bush and the whole leadership of the free world to be thrown in prison.

Ain't gonna happen, folks.
 
Would it be more helpful if I could list some common theories, and let them check off which ones are rejected/fringe claims, and which are valid?

First item:

No plane hit the Pentagon. Fringe theory? Or mainstream?
 
No plane hit the Pentagon. Fringe theory? Or mainstream?

Rejected by Dylan Avery. Verboten subject on LCF.

Most "prominent" advocates are probably Lyte Trip/CIT and Ace Baker/PFT.

Pretty fringy even amongst the Troothers, but not as far out there as Killtown.

ETA: Or is Mr. Wong's post #6 right? Is "No WTC planes" the only NPT banned at LCF? I thought Merc/Lyte/Pentacon were on the outs over there now.
 
Last edited:
Who are the legitimate members of the 9/11 Truth Movement?

Mavis Micklethwaite.

Mavis Micklethwaite had lived an unremarkable life. Born in 1946 to a family of rastafarian welsh soap miners, she had never even travelled outside of the familys one bed hovel until that fateful day one week in may 1972 when she discovered true love, though at first she had just thought her incontinence problem had returned, in the unshapely form of Brian, a pig sexer and part time revolutionary fighter for the truth, from Bollockwick, North Yorkshire.

Mavis racalled later that it was his flat cap and the way he adjusted himself when speaking with ladies, that first caught her attention.

Mavis and Brian were soon married and settled down to a peaceful married life as a married couple.

Together they discovered the heady delights of long nights drinking and discussing children, holidays, macrame and violent revolution.

Then on 9/11/2001 they watched in horror as their television was repossesed.

This was the final straw for Mavis, who had long suspected that Brian wasn't really jewish, and she left him.

Back out in the world, alone and with no friends, Mavis became addicted to sucking Fishermans Friends instead, and it was during one of her many trips to Boots that she discovered the difference between 9/11 and 11/9.

From that day forth, Mavis devoted herself and her cardigans, to spreading the truth about 9/11.

The truth that 9/11 was the wrong date, and that the horrorific terrorist attack on the US in 2001, actually occured on 11/9.

Mavis is also working on putting the record straight about the london attacks of 7/7.
 
Wait, I thought the "no plane" theory as banned at LCF was purely the "no plane at WTC, they were holograms" theories. I thought "no plane at the Pentagon" was in the most recent edition of Loose Change itself.

See? I can't keep it straight.
 
Would it be more helpful if I could list some common theories, and let them check off which ones are rejected/fringe claims, and which are valid?

First item:

No plane hit the Pentagon. Fringe theory? Or mainstream?

I'd say that one was mainstream at one time, but is moving towards the fringe.

Things I'd say are already on the fringe:

No plane at Shanksville/Delta 1989 switch

Beam weapons

Pods/no planes/holograms at WTC

The PentaCon

Pilots for Twoof

Anything involving Killtown

It seems to me that the Twoofers are increasingly focusing their energies on the idea that the WTC buildings were CD, and leaving everything else pretty much alone. You hardly hear anything about Shanksville any more, and most of the chirping about the Pentagon is coming from Lyte shilling his video. The rest of the chirping is coming from the crickets waiting for Lyte's reply to our brutal debunking.
 
Is the mini-nukes at the WTC theory currently "in" or is it fringe / disinfo?
defiantely fringe

i think the only "real" theories these days are thermite and/or standard demolition at the WTC (and WTC7) and anything LIHOP
 
I think the current widely accepted theories in the CT world have reduced to these few topics:

WTC controlled demolition
NORAD stand-down
Foreknowledge
Osama CIA link
ISI link

Anything outsides these is getting less and less interest even among truthers. Pentagon still gets some truther following. Shanksville not much.
 
Who are the legitimate members of the 9/11 Truth Movement?

Mavis Micklethwaite.

Mavis Micklethwaite had lived an unremarkable life. Born in 1946 to a family of rastafarian welsh soap miners, she had never even travelled outside of the familys one bed hovel until that fateful day one week in may 1972 when she discovered true love, though at first she had just thought her incontinence problem had returned, in the unshapely form of Brian, a pig sexer and part time revolutionary fighter for the truth, from Bollockwick, North Yorkshire.

... snip ...

The truth that 9/11 was the wrong date, and that the horrorific terrorist attack on the US in 2001, actually occured on 11/9.

Mavis is also working on putting the record straight about the london attacks of 7/7.
:D
I can just see the late, great Les Dawson reading that.
 
defiantely fringe

i think the only "real" theories these days are thermite and/or standard demolition at the WTC (and WTC7) and anything LIHOP

I dunno, No Plane at the Pentagon (and Shanksville) still seems to be right up there with thermate. If DU is anything to go by. :rolleyes:
 
This is one of the real benefits of a diverse group pretending to be a movement; whenever anybody says something stupid that can be used against the group, they just say, "Nobody believes him," and go on as before. There is no one theory that unifies the movement; CD at the WTC is about as close as you get, but there are plenty of Deniers who don't agree on that.
 
Much like the Idiot Movement refuses to give us an alternate theory on what happened, they also refuse to give us any answer as to who their leaders are. Without leaders there is no definition, and no way to "legitimize" membership in the Movement.

Anything specific they say will be rapidly found wrong. They know this. This is why the entire Movement isn't about finding a better theory, but instead focuses on tearing down anybody else's theory. They require the freedom to let their minds fill in the blanks in private, without fear of ridicule. This is also why the Idiot Movement tears into each other's theories as savagely as they attack the 9/11 Commission hypothesis.

Because they know anything they state will be refuted, they also will not identify leaders. At best you will get a spectrum of "thinkers," a shotgun approach of inconsistent positions, much like the scatter of random ideas they harbor.

As evidence, not one of the Idiot Movement answered my long and winding Victory Thread, except for a half-hearted attempt by legendary scalawag pdoherty. You will get no answer from them either.
 
Perhaps we should all go to our respective battlegrounds and ask the horse's mouths?
 
Reading the first post it comes off like I'm being sarcastic, or laying a trap. But I'm really not. After all, Lyte is a fun target but I fully admit that even among Truthers nobody buys into what he's saying. Same with that guy who thinks fighter jets fired missiles into WTC 7.

If we could boil down what are the "core" or mainstream beliefs of the movement, that would actually help the debunking. It's fun to prod somebody like Christophera but really, it's useful only in its entertainment value. If there are a few strong, well-researched pillars holding up the movement, I'd rather focus on those.

Okay, so we've said the No Plane at the Pentagon was NOT part of the mainstream any longer. So do they believe the plane was hijacked by terrorists, secretly hire by our government? Or flown by remote control with the passengers safely offloaded elsewhere?
 
So do they believe the plane was hijacked by terrorists, secretly hire by our government? Or flown by remote control with the passengers safely offloaded elsewhere?
this is somethign that doesnt seem to come up much, they dont want to say hijacked because its too close to the governemnt story, but i think remote control has gone by the wayside as well, they usually just respond with something like "we dont know, thats why we need another investigation"

rather than form a theory they try to focus on picking a few nits to try to convince people the questions need answers (similar to creationists)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom