How the tower did not fell

tabouere

Thinker
Joined
Apr 29, 2007
Messages
131
Sorry, i'll start this thread with a Bob's post in another thread.

Read the damn NIST report. Their FAQ shows you where to look:


Those kind of temperatures are normal for hydrocarbon fires and office fires. NIST recreated offices from the World Trade Center and set them on fire, and the temperatures reached 1,000°C




[qimg]http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/photos/docs/wp_wtc29.jpg[/qimg]

There are plenty of other images out there that show an even bleaker outlook that that one.



I am having trouble understanding what you are asking. Are you saying that the lower part of the building could not have collapsed because the top part had disintegrated?



Good.
http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-5.pdf


Sleep well.


First of all Bob, I must admit I don'read the NIST report interely, for one big reason, they speculate fire intensity with the color of the flame, that's could be accurate but I don't have the image to take a look by myself, but à KNOW one thing, theres is one photo of the fire in the WTC 1 here it is

wtc1fireyk7.jpg


And it's absolutely nothing in comparison of THIS

Madrid_Windsor.jpg


This is the Windsor Madrid et the fire reach 800 degrees C

MADRID, Spain -- The area surrounding a burned-out Madrid skyscraper remained cordoned off Monday amid concern the blackened hulk of wreckage could collapse.

As many as 100 firefighters worked 24 hours to extinguish the blaze in the city's eighth-tallest building, the 32-story Windsor Tower. The fire was said to be the worst in Madrid's history.

"Don't Fall Down," read Monday's front-page headline on the free newspaper Que given to morning subway and bus commuters.

The office tower was heavily damaged but did not collapse as feared.

"The situation is still critical," Madrid Mayor Alberto Ruiz-Gallardon told The Associated Press.

Officials say the building is unstable and have closed the area surrounding it, in a move that could affect several thousand employees in the city's financial district.

Cars will be routed to neighboring streets, subway lines under or near the damaged building will remain shut down, and adjacent office towers will remain closed by order of the mayor, AP reported.

El Corte Ingles, Spain's signature department store, remained closed Monday and told its 2,000 employees to stay home.

"What worries us now is its structural state because of the high temperatures it was subjected to," Merardo Tudelo, director of the Madrid Municipal Firefighters, told reporters shortly before 9 p.m. Sunday (2000 GMT).

By Sunday evening, flames were no longer visible, though gray smoke and ash stoked by gusts of wind continued to pour from the blackened shell of the building.

Hours earlier, several top floors collapsed onto lower ones. Firefighter official Fernando Munilla expressed concern that the entire building -- which at about 106 meters (350 feet) high is among the 10 tallest in Madrid -- could collapse.

"If the partial collapses keep happening, it would be lying to say it's impossible that the whole building couldn't fall down," he said.

Emergency crews at the scene said firefighters were waiting for the temperature inside the building to drop, which they said would lessen the danger of collapse.

At their peak, temperatures reached 800 degrees Celsius (1,472 Fahrenheit), said Javier Sanz, head of Madrid's firefighters.

http://www.cnn.com/2005/WORLD/europe/02/14/spain.block.fire/


And now, I'll answer that.

I am having trouble understanding what you are asking. Are you saying that the lower part of the building could not have collapsed because the top part had disintegrated?

All so call scientific theory consider that the upper floors blow the lower floors.

But all consider the upper floors are still a compact solid mass, just do a simple test. Ask someone to go 8 feet over your head, bring a brick with him and let it go in free fall straight to your head. If you are still alive, stay there, ask him the break the brick in many parts, put the brick in a pot and let it go from the same distance on your head....

The same material, the same quantity but different damage.

It's magic!

15 floors won't break the 95 floors below, especially if they are stronger as you go down.

The Greening paper about momentum is laughable, there is a energy lost at all impact and it's seem your are not able to understand his paper, because he write :

Consider now the newly formed mass of (14 + 1) floors of WTC 1, and (29 + 1) floors of WTC 2, impacting on the floor below. Because of momentum transfer, the impact velocities are slightly lower than the 8.6 m/s impact speed for the first floors hit: 8.1 m/s for WTC 1, and 8.3 m/s for WTC 2. The maximum kinetic energy prior to impact is ½ × 15 × (510,000,000/110) × (8.1)2 joules = 2.3 × 109 J for WTC 1, and ½ × 30 ×
(510,000,000/110) × (8.3)2 joules = 4.8 × 109 J for WTC 2. This is essentially the same result as the previous impact calculation and the kinetic energy released is therefore also sufficient to crush the concrete on the impacted floor to 175 μm particles.

http://www.nistreview.org/WTC-REPORT-GREENING.pdf

In your movies, you say the fall accelerated but Greening don't say that.

But Greening forgot a lot stuff too, don't worry.
 
Last edited:
First of all Bob, I must admit I don'read the NIST report interely, for one big reason, they speculate fire intensity with the color of the flame, that's could be accurate but I don't have the image to take a look by myself, but à KNOW one thing, theres is one photo of the fire in the WTC 1 here it is
You need to read the report you're criticizing, before you criticize it. NIST's results are based on far, far more evidence than you suppose here. Heck, you even admit you could be wrong... you are.

And it's absolutely nothing in comparison of THIS

This is the Windsor Madrid et the fire reach 800 degrees C
Ah, yeah. The latter picture was taken at night, so naturally it would be brighter...

...and the portions of the Windsor Madrid that were comparable to the WTC towers collapsed. You're not helping your case here one bit.

All so call scientific theory consider that the upper floors blow the lower floors.

But all consider the upper floors are still a compact solid mass, just do a simple test. Ask someone to go 8 feet over your head, bring a brick with him and let it go in free fall straight to your head. If you are still alive, stay there, ask him the break the brick in many parts, put the brick in a pot and let it go from the same distance on your head....

The same material, the same quantity but different damage.

It's magic!
It's a fundamental misconception about the nature of momentum. The small pieces of brick bounce off your head. The bounce will still hurt, but it dissipates much of the energy. In the WTC case, the "small pieces," which by the way are not small pieces until long after it starts moving, have nowhere to go but down. The total momentum transfer is the issue, and it doesn't matter whether the upper block is intact or not.

If I drop a one ton anvil on your head, or a one ton bag of flour, you're dead in both cases.

15 floors won't break the 95 floors below, especially if they are stronger as you go down.

The Greening paper about momentum is laughable, there is a energy lost at all impact and it's seem your are not able to understand his paper, because he write :

But Greening forgot a lot stuff too, don't worry.
You obviously haven't read Greening's paper either. He accounts for the energy loss at impact, and also shows that the timing of global collapse is insensitive to corrections such as loss of material over the sides. Go back and try to find anything he "forgot."

Oh, and welcome to the JREF forum.
 
Last edited:
The Greening paper about momentum is laughable, there is a energy lost at all impact and it's seem your are not able to understand his paper, because he write :

In your movies, you say the fall accelerated but Greening don't say that.

But Greening forgot a lot stuff too, don't worry.
what greening is saying is that the speed immediately after the impact is slower then the speed immediately before, this has no bearing on the acceleration on the way to the next impact

the impact slows it down maybe .1 m/s

the fall to the next floor accelerations it 4-5 m/s, resulting in a net acceleration

i think you are confusing first and second derivatives
 
Sorry, i'll start this thread with a Bob's post in another thread.




First of all Bob, I must admit I don'read the NIST report interely, for one big reason, they speculate fire intensity with the color of the flame, that's could be accurate but I don't have the image to take a look by myself, but à KNOW one thing, theres is one photo of the fire in the WTC 1 here it is



And it's absolutely nothing in comparison of THIS



This is the Windsor Madrid et the fire reach 800 degrees C



[



All so call scientific theory consider that the upper floors blow the lower floors.

But all consider the upper floors are still a compact solid mass, just do a simple test. Ask someone to go 8 feet over your head, bring a brick with him and let it go in free fall straight to your head. If you are still alive, stay there, ask him the break the brick in many parts, put the brick in a pot and let it go from the same distance on your head....

The same material, the same quantity but different damage.

It's magic!

15 floors won't break the 95 floors below, especially if they are stronger as you go down.

The Greening paper about momentum is laughable, there is a energy lost at all impact and it's seem your are not able to understand his paper, because he write :





In your movies, you say the fall accelerated but Greening don't say that.

But Greening forgot a lot stuff too, don't worry.
Is English your first/primary language? I do not ask this to be offensive, but if it is, the odds are good you do not have the background to follow the physics of most of the elements of this material.
That does not preclude your disagreement with it, but it would preclude your ability to back your disagreement with factual material.
 
You need to read the report you're criticizing, before you criticize it. NIST's results are based on far, far more evidence than you suppose here. Heck, you even admit you could be wrong... you are.


Ah, yeah. The latter picture was taken at night, so naturally it would be brighter...

...and the portions of the Windsor Madrid that were comparable to the WTC towers collapsed. You're not helping your case here one bit.


It's a fundamental misconception about the nature of momentum. The small pieces of brick bounce off your head. The bounce will still hurt, but it dissipates much of the energy. In the WTC case, the "small pieces," which by the way are not small pieces until long after it starts moving, have nowhere to go but down. The total momentum transfer is the issue, and it doesn't matter whether the upper block is intact or not.

If I drop a one ton anvil on your head, or a one ton bag of flour, you're dead in both cases.


You obviously haven't read Greening's paper either. He accounts for the energy loss at impact, and also shows that the timing of global collapse is insensitive to corrections such as loss of material over the sides. Go back and try to find anything he "forgot."

Oh, and welcome to the JREF forum.

Thanx

A ton of flour in a bag that keep the floor in a kind of one piece solid state, yes, it will kill me, but remove it from the bag

And yes I read the Greening paper and I notice by myself that he does a lot of mistake.... Then I found that

MOMENTUM TRANSFER ANALYSIS

OF THE COLLAPSE OF THE UPPER STOREYS OF WTC1


Author:
The author of this work, Gordon Ross, was born in Dundee, Scotland. He holds degrees in both Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering, graduating from Liverpool John Moores University, in 1984. He can be contacted at [email protected].

Summary:

This paper examines the elastic loading and plastic shortening phases of the columns of WTC 1 after impact of the upper 16 storeys of the building upon the lower storeys and its effect on the momentum transfer after the collision. An energy balance is derived showing that there is an energy deficit before completion of the plastic shortening phase that would not allow the collapse to continue under the constraints of this paper.

Introduction:

Previous analysis of the momentum transfer in the collapse of the towers has viewed them as being floors suspended in space and have examined the momentum transfer as a series of elastic or inelastic collisions, which are independent of each other. This type of analysis takes the momentum transfer out of the context given by the other effects of the collisions. This is because this type of analysis assumes that the impacts have an effect upon only the topmost storey of the impacted section. The reality of the situation is that the impacts would have an effect upon several storeys in the lower section and for a valid analysis all of these momentum transfers must be included.
.....

Conclusion:

The energy balance of the collapse moves into deficit during the plastic shortening phase of the first impacted columns showing that there would be insufficient energy available from the released potential energy of the upper section to satisfy all of the energy demands of the collision. The analysis shows that despite the assumptions made in favour of collapse continuation, vertical movement of the falling section would be arrested prior to completion of the 3% shortening phase of the impacted columns, and within 0.02 secondsafter impact.

A collapse driven only by gravity would not continue to progress beyond that point.

The analysis shows that the energies expended during the time period of the plastic shortening of the first storey height of the vertical columns is sufficient to exhaust the energy of the falling section and thereby arrest collapse. This however is not the full extent of the plastic strain energy demand which exists. The next immediate task for the falling mass to continue in its descent would be the plastic shortening within the remainder of the buckle length. As has already been stated a buckling failure mode has a minimum length over which it can act and in the case of the towers would be several storey lengths. Each additional storey length involved in the buckle would add a further demand of about 450MJ for a further downward movement of 0.111metres. This also shows that collapse arrest is not dependent upon an expenditure of energy in concrete pulverisation, since even if this expenditure were disregarded the input energy would be exhausted during plastic shortening of the second storeys affected.

http://gordonssite.tripod.com/id1.html

It's call sorry mister Greening.

Debris don't act like a solid mass, when a solid mass hit another with one surface or corner, it will hurt the other mass with all is mass, but if this solid block is broke in pieces, all pieces will no hit the mass below at the very same moment, that's why it's a much smaller impact and don't forget, a big part of the concrete is completly reduce to dust that FLY in the air.

And for the NIST evidences of the temperature of the fire is null, or maybe there was another document, because in this document I see no evidence of a fire that reach 1000 degrees C

http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-5.pdf

And for sure, the Windsor Madrid was an inferno in comparison with the WTC fire.

windsor-corte-ingles.jpg
 
wtc1fireyk7.jpg


And it's absolutely nothing in comparison of THIS

Madrid_Windsor.jpg


This is the Windsor Madrid et the fire reach 800 degrees C
Yes one photo is at night and one is in the day. Do you understand the WTC would be the same or bigger than your Madrid building which the steel only portions fell in a couple of hours.

Where is the Madrid building today? Where is the Madrid building which firemen fought. Remember great researchers all over 9/11, WTC 1,2,7 fires were NOT fought. Madrid was fought by hundreds of firemen. BIG difference, just like your photo, NIGHT and DAY. Why are 9/11 truthers so research and knowledge limited?

Tell my why truthers have not had physics and do not understand gravity, velocity squared, and other facts about energy?

Why are the biggest heroes in the 9/11 movement high school dropouts and failed PhDs?
 
A ton of flour in a bag that keep the floor in a kind of one piece solid state, yes, it will kill me, but remove it from the bag

... and it will still kill you.

Don't ever lie down behind the back of a dump truck full of sand. You'll die.

Would you leap out of an airplane into a lake, expecting to live to tell about it? It's the same principle. Newton will certify that it doesn't matter who's moving, you or the other mass, the effect at impact is the same.

I don't know where you folks grew up, but you seem to be divorced from reality.

And yes I read the Greening paper and I notice by myself that he does a lot of mistake.... Then I found that

MOMENTUM TRANSFER ANALYSIS

OF THE COLLAPSE OF THE UPPER STOREYS OF WTC1

http://gordonssite.tripod.com/id1.html

Gordon's papers are a sham. I dismantled it personally here on the JREF forum, Gordon knows about it, and all he did was whine. Read all about it here.

It's call sorry mister Greening.

Debris don't act like a solid mass, when a solid mass hit another with one surface or corner, it will hurt the other mass with all is mass, but if this solid block is broke in pieces, all pieces will no hit the mass below at the very same moment, that's why it's a much smaller impact and don't forget, a big part of the concrete is completly reduce to dust that FLY in the air.
Complete and utter crap.

The upper stories are not in small pieces until after they've crashed through several of the lower floors!

The upper stories after being smashed into small pieces have the same mass, and deposit the same momentum upon impact as though they were solid!

Because the collisions are almost purely inelastic, the material strength of the impacting pieces makes no difference!

You are simply and utterly wrong, that's all there is to it.

And for the NIST evidences of the temperature of the fire is null, or maybe there was another document, because in this document I see no evidence of a fire that reach 1000 degrees C

http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-5.pdf
The very first figure of NIST NCSTAR1-5, that you linked yourself, shows their prediction exceeding 1000 oC only fifteen minutes after impact. Figure E-1, page xlv. That's some whopper of a mistake you've made here.

And for sure, the Windsor Madrid was an inferno in comparison with the WTC fire.

[qimg]http://eurotrip.com.ar/windsor-corte-ingles.jpg[/qimg]
Your saying "for sure" doesn't make it true.
 
tabouere,

the tower in Madrid had a concrete core and the steel portion DID collapse.

That was the 5,957th time this has been pointed out to the truthers.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/member.php?u=16632

ROFL DUDE, that's not the point, the point is the FIRE IN THE WINDSOR MADRID BUILDING REACH AT MAX 800 degrees C and IT WAS A REAL INFERNO IN COMPARISON WITH THE FIRE IN THE WTC.

And the NIST is telling us without evidence the fire reach 1000 degrees C in the WTC.

And you poor believer, you believe it and you are so convinced that your a unable to understand what I just said. I've never said the Windsor stay in place and perfectly intact, no, I've said the Windor Madrid's fire reach a peak temp of 800 degrees C and the fire was a lot stronger, it pass trough windows and raise along the wall, the windows are big and all broken, that's why the fire have orange flame because there was a lot of oxygene so the temperature is rising.... But in the WTC the flame is more red than orange and the windows are tiny because the main architech have the fear of height......
 
Last edited:
Yes one photo is at night and one is in the day. Do you understand the WTC would be the same or bigger than your Madrid building which the steel only portions fell in a couple of hours.

Where is the Madrid building today? Where is the Madrid building which firemen fought. Remember great researchers all over 9/11, WTC 1,2,7 fires were NOT fought. Madrid was fought by hundreds of firemen. BIG difference, just like your photo, NIGHT and DAY. Why are 9/11 truthers so research and knowledge limited?

Tell my why truthers have not had physics and do not understand gravity, velocity squared, and other facts about energy?

Why are the biggest heroes in the 9/11 movement high school dropouts and failed PhDs?

It is all you can do?

Your post is full of insult and have no argument at all, see the answer above to understand my point, because you don't.
 
Comparing the WTC to the Windsor Tower fire is stupid.

To begin with, the WTC towers were steel-framed buildings, whereas the Windsor Tower was a steel and concrete building with a thick concrete core. Concrete is far less susceptible to heat than steel.

Secondly, there is the issue of scale.

The entire floor area of the 32-storey Windsor Tower was 20,000m2. In contrast a single floor of the WTC measured 3,900m2. The impact area ALONE for WTC1 was about the same area as the ENTIRE Windsor Tower, and the impact area ALONE for WTC2 was almost half again the area of the ENTIRE Windsor Tower.

The Windsor Tower had a volume in the vicinity of 70,000m3. Each WTC tower had a volume of 1,600,000m3. The above-impact volume (a critical factor in the collapse) of WTC1 would have been roughly 180,000m3 (2.5 times the volume of the entire Windsor Tower) and the volume above impact of WTC2 would have been roughly 390,000m3 (5.5 times the volume of the entire Windsor Tower).

In order to realistically compare the Windsor Tower to one of the WTC towers, one would have to ensure certain unique events:

1) Totally remove the concrete structural elements from the Windsor Tower including its massive concrete core and mechanical floors
2) Cause severe structural damage to every single floor of the building
3) Flood every single floor with jet fuel and ignite it simultaneously.

Even then, in a scenario where most would agree the Windsor Tower would totally collapse in a matter of minutes, the scenario would not accurately reflect the WTC as the building would also need 2.5 and 5.5 entirely intact versions of itself stacked on top of it.

Then we can begin to compare them.

-Gumboot
 
ROFL DUDE, that's not the point, the point is the FIRE IN THE WINDSOR MADRID BUILDING REACH AT MAX 800 degrees C and IT WAS A REAL INFERNO IN COMPARISON WITH THE FIRE IN THE WTC.

And the NIST is telling us without evidence the fire reach 1000 degrees C in the WTC.

And you poor believer, you believe it and you are so convinced that your a unable to understand what I just said. I've never said the Windsor stay in place and perfectly intact, no, I've said the Windor Madrid's fire reach a peak temp of 800 degrees C and the fire was a lot stronger, it pass trough windows and raise along the wall, the windows are big and all broken, that's why the fire have orange flame because there was a lot of oxygene so the temperature is rising.... But in the WTC the flame is more red than orange and the windows are tiny because the main architech have the fear of height......


Have you ever noticed that firewalking demonstrations are always done at night, never in the daytime? Can you think of a reason why?
 
I hate to respond to the woo woos, but I guess I have to.

ROFL DUDE, that's not the point, the point is the FIRE IN THE WINDSOR MADRID BUILDING REACH AT MAX 800 degrees C and IT WAS A REAL INFERNO IN COMPARISON WITH THE FIRE IN THE WTC.

Listen, I was there, looking at the INFERNO. the pictures DO NOT at all do justice to the actual experience of being there and seeing and feeling the fire.

I was a couple of blocks away, on the street, and the heat was so intense on my face that it felt like opening up a hot oven.

The fire was RAGING like nothing I have ever seen, even in the movies.

What you are saying is not only completely wrong, it is insulting.
 
ROFL DUDE, that's not the point, the point is the FIRE IN THE WINDSOR MADRID BUILDING REACH AT MAX 800 degrees C and IT WAS A REAL INFERNO IN COMPARISON WITH THE FIRE IN THE WTC.

So people jumped out of the buildings despite the lack of heat, and the steel structureof the building collapsed. WTC was an inferno, denying that makes you look foolish.

And the NIST is telling us without evidence the fire reach 1000 degrees C in the WTC.

This is a rather brassy thing to say for someone who admits they did not read the report.

There was plenty of evidence. You might want to read it some time.

And you poor believer, you believe it and you are so convinced that your a unable to understand what I just said. I've never said the Windsor stay in place and perfectly intact, no, I've said the Windor Madrid's fire reach a peak temp of 800 degrees C and the fire was a lot stronger,

It was not stronger. It looked brighter because your photo was taken at night and is a close up of the structure. Wheras the WTC photo was taken during the day and covers more of the side of a much larger structure

it pass trough windows and raise along the wall,

Look at your WTC photo, it is doing much the same thing. The building is bigger is all.

the windows are big and all broken, that's why the fire have orange flame because there was a lot of oxygene so the temperature is rising.... But in the WTC the flame is more red than orange and the windows are tiny because the main architech have the fear of height......

This is reading way too much into apparent color of a photograph. It is nonsense as far as evidence. Colors can appear different.

Here is an example: http://www.michaelbach.de/ot/lum_adelson_check_shadow/index.html
 
... and it will still kill you.

Don't ever lie down behind the back of a dump truck full of sand. You'll die.

That's why people can survive of an avalanche of many ton of SNOW?

Throw dust and you will notice something strange, it's called air resistance.

Throw a rock of 1 KG from a 8 foot height and notice the damage, do the same thing but with a bucket 1 KG of the same rock but in smaller pieces and notice what happen. Why?

Simple, when the rock hit, it hit with all is mass, but when the litle rock hit, they will not hit all at the very same moment, that's why the damage are different




Would you leap out of an airplane into a lake, expecting to live to tell about it? It's the same principle. Newton will certify that it doesn't matter who's moving, you or the other mass, the effect at impact is the same.

I don't know where you folks grew up, but you seem to be divorced from reality.

Ok so if I follow you, it doesn't matter if it's the lower or the upper part of the building that is moving? Strange, because the mass and speed is two data required in momentum calcul.

So it doesn't matter if I hit a stopped truck at 20 miles/h or if the truck hit me at a speed of 20 miles per hour while i'm stopped. Oh I see.



Gordon's papers are a sham. I dismantled it personally here on the JREF forum, Gordon knows about it, and all he did was whine. Read all about it here.


Complete and utter crap.

The upper stories are not in small pieces until after they've crashed through several of the lower floors!

The upper stories after being smashed into small pieces have the same mass, and deposit the same momentum upon impact as though they were solid!

Because the collisions are almost purely inelastic, the material strength of the impacting pieces makes no difference!

You are simply and utterly wrong, that's all there is to it.

ROFL, it's seem that your are the one who don't know what your are talking about.

see the quote at the bottom.

Gordon is right for that and debris and solid block don't have the same momentum for a simple reason the solid block hit with all his mass, the debris hit only with the mass of the debris and they don't hit at the same moment the floor below.



The very first figure of NIST NCSTAR1-5, that you linked yourself, shows their prediction exceeding 1000 oC only fifteen minutes after impact. Figure E-1, page xlv. That's some whopper of a mistake you've made here.


Your saying "for sure" doesn't make it true.

Here a resume of what Greening paper forgot :



An initiation mechanism involving a total and instantaneous loss of all load bearing ability on one storey, sufficient to cause a 3.7m drop under full gravitational acceleration followed by a neat impact is not credible. This is presented to show the relative sizes of the energies involved. This analysis underestimates the energy demands by using a constant value of velocity, equal to the velocity at impact, 8.5 m/sec. This is an assumption made in favour of collapse continuation.
This analysis also assumes that each storey had the same mass. The effect that this assumption has, is to underestimate the energy losses at collision. No account has been taken of the mass which falls outside the tower perimeter, and most notably neither of the expulsion of large amounts of dust early in the collapse, nor of the energy requirement to cause these masses to move outside the perimeter.

This analysis takes no regard of the energy consumed in damage caused to spandrel plates or other structural elements, nor disconnection of the floor to column connections, crushing of floor contents, nor of any other energies expended. No account is taken of any strain energy consumption during the initial fall through the height of one full storey, though this would be a substantial proportion of the initial energy input.


http://gordonssite.tripod.com/id1.html
 
Last edited:
Buster, I've read it. I already told you that. I knocked out Gordon's paper here.

You are not bringing new information to the table.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom