Sorry, i'll start this thread with a Bob's post in another thread.
First of all Bob, I must admit I don'read the NIST report interely, for one big reason, they speculate fire intensity with the color of the flame, that's could be accurate but I don't have the image to take a look by myself, but à KNOW one thing, theres is one photo of the fire in the WTC 1 here it is
And it's absolutely nothing in comparison of THIS
This is the Windsor Madrid et the fire reach 800 degrees C
http://www.cnn.com/2005/WORLD/europe/02/14/spain.block.fire/
And now, I'll answer that.
All so call scientific theory consider that the upper floors blow the lower floors.
But all consider the upper floors are still a compact solid mass, just do a simple test. Ask someone to go 8 feet over your head, bring a brick with him and let it go in free fall straight to your head. If you are still alive, stay there, ask him the break the brick in many parts, put the brick in a pot and let it go from the same distance on your head....
The same material, the same quantity but different damage.
It's magic!
15 floors won't break the 95 floors below, especially if they are stronger as you go down.
The Greening paper about momentum is laughable, there is a energy lost at all impact and it's seem your are not able to understand his paper, because he write :
http://www.nistreview.org/WTC-REPORT-GREENING.pdf
In your movies, you say the fall accelerated but Greening don't say that.
But Greening forgot a lot stuff too, don't worry.
Read the damn NIST report. Their FAQ shows you where to look:
Those kind of temperatures are normal for hydrocarbon fires and office fires. NIST recreated offices from the World Trade Center and set them on fire, and the temperatures reached 1,000°C
[qimg]http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/photos/docs/wp_wtc29.jpg[/qimg]
There are plenty of other images out there that show an even bleaker outlook that that one.
I am having trouble understanding what you are asking. Are you saying that the lower part of the building could not have collapsed because the top part had disintegrated?
Good.
http://wtc.nist.gov/NISTNCSTAR1-5.pdf
Sleep well.
First of all Bob, I must admit I don'read the NIST report interely, for one big reason, they speculate fire intensity with the color of the flame, that's could be accurate but I don't have the image to take a look by myself, but à KNOW one thing, theres is one photo of the fire in the WTC 1 here it is
And it's absolutely nothing in comparison of THIS
This is the Windsor Madrid et the fire reach 800 degrees C
MADRID, Spain -- The area surrounding a burned-out Madrid skyscraper remained cordoned off Monday amid concern the blackened hulk of wreckage could collapse.
As many as 100 firefighters worked 24 hours to extinguish the blaze in the city's eighth-tallest building, the 32-story Windsor Tower. The fire was said to be the worst in Madrid's history.
"Don't Fall Down," read Monday's front-page headline on the free newspaper Que given to morning subway and bus commuters.
The office tower was heavily damaged but did not collapse as feared.
"The situation is still critical," Madrid Mayor Alberto Ruiz-Gallardon told The Associated Press.
Officials say the building is unstable and have closed the area surrounding it, in a move that could affect several thousand employees in the city's financial district.
Cars will be routed to neighboring streets, subway lines under or near the damaged building will remain shut down, and adjacent office towers will remain closed by order of the mayor, AP reported.
El Corte Ingles, Spain's signature department store, remained closed Monday and told its 2,000 employees to stay home.
"What worries us now is its structural state because of the high temperatures it was subjected to," Merardo Tudelo, director of the Madrid Municipal Firefighters, told reporters shortly before 9 p.m. Sunday (2000 GMT).
By Sunday evening, flames were no longer visible, though gray smoke and ash stoked by gusts of wind continued to pour from the blackened shell of the building.
Hours earlier, several top floors collapsed onto lower ones. Firefighter official Fernando Munilla expressed concern that the entire building -- which at about 106 meters (350 feet) high is among the 10 tallest in Madrid -- could collapse.
"If the partial collapses keep happening, it would be lying to say it's impossible that the whole building couldn't fall down," he said.
Emergency crews at the scene said firefighters were waiting for the temperature inside the building to drop, which they said would lessen the danger of collapse.
At their peak, temperatures reached 800 degrees Celsius (1,472 Fahrenheit), said Javier Sanz, head of Madrid's firefighters.
http://www.cnn.com/2005/WORLD/europe/02/14/spain.block.fire/
And now, I'll answer that.
I am having trouble understanding what you are asking. Are you saying that the lower part of the building could not have collapsed because the top part had disintegrated?
All so call scientific theory consider that the upper floors blow the lower floors.
But all consider the upper floors are still a compact solid mass, just do a simple test. Ask someone to go 8 feet over your head, bring a brick with him and let it go in free fall straight to your head. If you are still alive, stay there, ask him the break the brick in many parts, put the brick in a pot and let it go from the same distance on your head....
The same material, the same quantity but different damage.
It's magic!
15 floors won't break the 95 floors below, especially if they are stronger as you go down.
The Greening paper about momentum is laughable, there is a energy lost at all impact and it's seem your are not able to understand his paper, because he write :
Consider now the newly formed mass of (14 + 1) floors of WTC 1, and (29 + 1) floors of WTC 2, impacting on the floor below. Because of momentum transfer, the impact velocities are slightly lower than the 8.6 m/s impact speed for the first floors hit: 8.1 m/s for WTC 1, and 8.3 m/s for WTC 2. The maximum kinetic energy prior to impact is ½ × 15 × (510,000,000/110) × (8.1)2 joules = 2.3 × 109 J for WTC 1, and ½ × 30 ×
(510,000,000/110) × (8.3)2 joules = 4.8 × 109 J for WTC 2. This is essentially the same result as the previous impact calculation and the kinetic energy released is therefore also sufficient to crush the concrete on the impacted floor to 175 μm particles.
http://www.nistreview.org/WTC-REPORT-GREENING.pdf
In your movies, you say the fall accelerated but Greening don't say that.
But Greening forgot a lot stuff too, don't worry.
Last edited: