Science journalism at its best!

Mojo

Mostly harmless
Joined
Jul 22, 2004
Messages
47,083
Location
Nor Flanden
Astonishing article from the Independent (UK):

My war on electrosmog: Julia Stephenson sets out to clear the airwaves

Highlights include:

A claim that cordless phones make you radioactive:
Even cordless hands-free home telephones - such a boon to multitaskers, enabling one to patiently listen to friends and family for hours while cleaning cupboards, re-potting house plants and reorganising the CD collection - are now off-limits. Their electrical force-field is nearly as powerful as that of a mobile phone. Since I'm now chained to a phone on a lead, my cupboards are filthy and my friends are neglected. But at least I'm less radioactive.


A plug for the Q-Link pendant

Naturopaths, homoeopaths, a device that "offers unlimited protection from any negative electromagnetic emissions in a 700-square metre radius [sic]", and an admission that she's tapping into her neighbour's wi-fi.​

Amazing!
 
Lovely, amulets and potions. Next thing you know they'll be taking her out and dunking her to see if she's a witch or not. Electronic superstitions.
 
Nothing but advertisement, this 'article'.

What a smart closing sentence:

As yet, no one knows what price we will pay for our dependence on modern technology.

No, Julia, but at least you know the price for a silly 'Q-Link' quack item. They start at £70 as you advertise point out in the next paragraph. Naturopath my a$$.
 
Julia Stephenson is a silly bint....not to mention rather pretentious - as her self proclaimed title the "Green Goddess" might suggest.


she's opposed to animal testing too...


Testing on animals slows down medical progress because it tells us about animals, not people. Animals are biologically and physiologically different to humans and react differently to many substances. It's no surprise that prescription drugs tested on animals are the fourth leading cause of death in the Western world. The question is, why do animal experiments continue if they are so inaccurate and given that there are more efficient alternatives such as human DNA chips, human tissues, computer programmes that predict human metabolism, and micro-dose studies that reveal the fate of drugs in the human body?

The tradition of animal experiments is so deeply ingrained that the whole medical system is based on it. Researchers attract grants based on how many papers they publish. It's much easier to publish papers using animals than by doing human-based research. Animal breeders, cage and equipment manufacturers and the pharmaceutical industry are multi-billion pound industries. Animal tests help them speed new drugs to market and give them liability protection when their drugs kill or injure.
http://www.independent.co.uk/environment/lifestyle/article308759.ece
 
Last edited:
she's opposed to animal testing too...
Sorry, derail.

I just moved house, and I find my local convenience store provides plastic shopping bags - that have the approval of the British Association for the Abolition of Vivisection loudly emblazoned on both sides. Quite why I'm not sure.

I asked rather pointedly if they had any bags that didn't advertise the Animal Liberation Front, before leaving with my shopping in my arms to decant directly into my bicycle basket. I can see I'm going to be going very green on the subject of carrier bags, whether I like it or not. Which means I'll have to buy some bin liners. Rats.

Now this village is an easy commute from the main biotechnology centre of Scotland, just south of Edinburgh, home of Dolly the sheep and so on. That's why I moved there. I'm pretty certain a lot of people in the village work in biotechnology of one sort or another.

Am I the only person who sees the irony?

Rolfe.
 
...I can see I'm going to be going very green on the subject of carrier bags, whether I like it or not. Which means I'll have to buy some bin liners...

Bin liners? Why? Are you some sort of "new age traveller"? Why not just
get a proper shopping bag? I've reused the same placcy-covered canvas
one now for nearly a decade for my weekly provision run. It only cost me a
couple of guilders (in the pre-Euro days). I have almost never had to use
a "carrier bag".
 
Point being, I reuse all my carrier bags as bin liners. If I go down the proper shopping bag route (as it seems I'll be forced to), I need something else to line my kitchen bin.

Now going to Ben G's site, honest.

Rolfe.
 
Naturopaths, homoeopaths, a device that "offers unlimited protection from any negative electromagnetic emissions in a 700-square metre radius [sic]", and an admission that she's tapping into her neighbour's wi-fi.

Amazing!

I like the bolded part.

700 square meters. Not cubic.

So if you want protection, it seems you have to buy 6 of these to form a cube around you.
 
This article is one of the biggest loads of tripe I've waded through for a long time.

She admits to being obsessed with her health i.e. she's a hypochondriac.

She claims she was diagnosed by a naturopath. Thought that was a posh name for a herbalist. Why would one such have special knowledge of EMR not known to specialists.

She believes microwaves make you radioactive. And thinks that homeopathic and flower remedies remove "radiation" from the body. If she means "radioactivity" then that is complete rubbish. If she means microwave radiation, which the article is allegedly about, I for one wasn't aware that the human body could store microwaves.

Then there's the homeopathic engineer and his holograph generation field thingie which sounds like something out of Star Trek.

And the "Independent" is supposed to be a "quality" newspaper. This is tabloid <deleted> of the worst kind.
 
Julia Stephenson is a silly bint....not to mention rather pretentious - as her self proclaimed title the "Green Goddess" might suggest.


she's opposed to animal testing too...


http://www.independent.co.uk/environment/lifestyle/article308759.ece


Is this point wrong (the parts you quoted)?

I'd like to see much of the regulations against human testing/clinical trials lifted. It does seem like a lot of time and resources would be saved if medical scientists were able to go straight to human testing, for the most part.
 
AAAIIIIEEEEE!! The Stupid, it burns!

Cripes, I'm sorry, but this woman is suffering from an almost critical lack of intelligent thought. Where's JimBenArm's avatar when you need him?

Cheers,
TGHO
 
She must fall for every scam going. In the article she approvingly referred to homeopathy, flower remedies, Q-link pendants (Go to www.badscience.net to see these things literally taken apart), and some technowoo operating on a basis unknown to science.
 
Is this point wrong (the parts you quoted)?

I'd like to see much of the regulations against human testing/clinical trials lifted. It does seem like a lot of time and resources would be saved if medical scientists were able to go straight to human testing, for the most part.

lifting of some restrictions re human testing may be viable, but given the scale of animal testing [tens of millions of animals used annually] coupled with the non-transferability of a good deal of the research [say genetic engineering] means that this can't be an either/or issue. I'm not suggesting that you view it as such - but Julia certainly does.

The fight to abolish animal testing is not a cause the glossies generally race to take up. So I was delighted when, a while back, Vogue featured me in a photo shoot about green activists and invited me to plug my favourite cause.

I jumped at the chance to give some puff to BUAV (the British Union for Abolition of Vivisection) which campaigns tirelessly to let the public know the truth behind animal testing – not only that it is inhumane but also ineffective. A drug that works on animals will not necessarily work on humans, as we are so different. Just as an example, there are the 80 Aids vaccines successful in primates, which failed in human trials.

I’m against vivisection because I abhor the wanton cruelty involved, but the great thing about Europeans for Medical Progress Trust is that it represents the scientific establishment of doctors and scientists who mistrust animal-testing because it is ineffective and puts people in danger. Benn recounted that his wife had been offered thalidomide and, thank heavens, refused it, producing a healthy son, Hilary. Many mothers weren’t so lucky. Thalidomide, like so many drugs tested on animals, went on to have devastating effects on humans.

This happens again and again. Recently, there was the Northwick Park Hospital trial disaster, when six men nearly died when given the drug TGN1412, because it was shown to be safe in monkeys at 500 times the dose. And the arthritis drug Vioxx, which appeared to protect the heart in mice and monkeys, but may have contributed to 320,000 heart attacks and strokes in people, killing up to 140,000: the biggest drug disaster in history.
http://www.curedisease.net/articles/070510.shtml

you can read the BUAV arguments here
 
Hey if I have to beta test supposedly "done" software, PETA members should have to beta test drugs on themselves.
 
Hey if I have to beta test supposedly "done" software, PETA members should have to beta test drugs on themselves.
Not to mention "Save a cow, eat a vegetarian" - it's the least they could do, if they really believe what they say.

Yuri
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom