Have you changed any major belief as an adult?

Skeptic Ginger

Nasty Woman
Joined
Feb 14, 2005
Messages
96,955
I try to go by the evidence. A lot of people who don't agree with my political views wrongly accuse me of not being skeptical in politics and I accuse a lot of them of the same. So just to change the subject to a lighter fare (;) not necessarily) and discuss changing long held views when the evidence mounted against your belief, I thought I'd see what major long held beliefs other people have changed after holding those beliefs for a while.

I saw the movie, "The God Who Wasn't There", and it convinced me there is a case to be made that there never was an historical figure which resulted in the Jesus beliefs.

I don't want this thread to wander off on the question of whether Jesus ever existed. But if you want to discuss what kinds of evidence led you to change a major belief, then that's fine.

So I was wondering, what beliefs have you changed and can you say it was a single revelation or something that grew over time? A major science theory or part of a theory is OK. There's no restriction on what kind of belief it was you changed.
 
The end of woo for me: Oft repeated on these forums, a skeptical friend asked me to video and audio tape readings I gave people. Then we would follow up with the folks after a couple of weeks, and compare my memories, their memories, and the truth. I pretty much abandoned all woo and sought evidence to prove any outrageous claims after that.

Christianity: I always believed in evolution. I went to college, took plenty of science. My first year major was Physics (Laughing hysterically at the thought--I wisely switched over to business). The biblical account of creation and history did not sit well with me. I'd sit in there trying to believe with all my heart, but I kept reading the bible. The doubt grew until I could no longer lie to myself.

Politically, well, I serve no party or single ideology. It was mostly swinging from center, left, right over and over again that led me to see how blinding partisanship can be (this is not directed at you). Hardcore democrats taught me that they could be zealots on par in hostility and one sidedness as any religious fundamentalist. Hardcore republicans, even the non-religious ones, taught me that there was no amount of spin they wouldn't stoop to in order to engineer an issue into some kind of cultural battle. Hardcore Greens and Libertarians taught me that there is no true green or libertarian, just folks vacillating around their particular pet issues.

Leaving me no affiliation or "in group" to identify with, I learned to think for myself. I learned that I could examine an issue without histrionics and judge it on merit. You know---critical thinking and skepticism. I also decided that I would not judge all republicans evil fundies or all democrats as screaming liberal loonies. I would take them on a case by case basis. Sometimes they are right, and sometimes they are wrong. But I only truly learned to examine an issue with a clear head by stepping away and sorting through all the BS.
 
Last edited:
I was a "Good Christian" until I was 18 when I saw one of the deacons of my church pull a pistol on my Dad because of a petty argument. That was that. (though I still believe that there may be a "god" )

As far as political, I was a democrat until I was 22. I saw (like miss) that there were psyco zealots on both sides and went Indy voting with whomever I agreed with most.

Lastly I now believe that for the most part my parents were right.:D
 
As far as political, I was a democrat until I was 22. I saw (like miss) that there were psyco zealots on both sides and went Indy voting with whomever I agreed with most.

That's pretty much what happened to me.

Used to be Christian until I started studying science and learned about the Creationism movement. Now I am agnostic.
 
In my young years I was a firm believer in UFOs as ships from other worlds. But I've changed my mind, nowadays I still believe in UFOs, but as objects/phenomena from "this world" that can't be identified due to insufficient information.

As for other paranormal "phenomena", none!, never paid much attention nor have had interest in any other form of "beyond the normal" stuff.
 
Growing up in the hey days of post-WWII Western capitalism, I assumed that our political institutions were inviolably right, sacrosanct, and completely safe from any political skullduggery, as if it was a natural law.

Yeah, right.
 
Major beliefs? I don't have so many of those. A big one, though:

1. For a long time I semi-believed in god. I didn't really know what I thought this god was like or what it wanted or whatever, but I imagined some intelligent being at least had a good chance of existing, that it was interested in me in some way, and that I could influence it through my thoughts an actions. It took me a while to admit that that was what I meant when I refered to god, and then to actually think about whether that may or may not exist. When I finally faced the idea as it was, I started moving toward atheism.

2. I used to think that my thoughts and actions could influence the world through more than physical means. So that by wishing for something to happen, that might make it more likely to happen. My problem was that I actually looked at the consequences of this being true, found out that they weren't despite what it seemed anecdotally, and was forced to amend my beliefs to reality. One of the more influential things to force me to come to terms with this, however, was reading sagan's "Demon Haunted World". More than anything else it convinced me of the importance of intellectual courage.

3. Not so major, but to go in with the above, I thought that practicing yoga would give me semi-mystical powers. That went out the window too when I started to understand the world as it is rather than as I and others want it to be.

Some smaller things:

I used to think that using water couldn't strain water resources unless the water itself was contaminated in the process. Nevermind why... I just hadn't really thought about it since my dad had made the point when I was ten and at the time his argument seemed convincing. Eventually somoene else challenged me on it, and when I thought about it, I realised she had a point.

I'm sure there are more. I'll be back another time when I can think of them. :)
 
Bigfoot and ghosts were a big favourite of mine as a teenager. I use to read every book on the subjects as though they were gospel. Somewhere along the line i developed some critical thinking. I cant remember a specific turning point.
 
I can't really think of anything... I mean, I learn new things all the time, and have to reconsider what I knew, or thought I knew before. But one big, really major thing, something that really played a big part in my life... I don't think so, really. It has more been a life of numerous and continous smaller changes.

I just saw that film yesterday actually. I liked it, it was interesting. Many smart people speaking very well of very interesting things. But there was nothing major that was really groundbreakingly new to me, though there were many minor facts that were new to me.
 
Until 4 or 5 years ago I believed I was a psychic healer, and believed all kinds of other strange things.

I hold some in a kind of reserve, for when any evidence might be forthcoming, but I have rejected most of the things I believed in a decade ago.
 
I used to think it was acceptable to keep your mouth shut and your head down to get along. I used to be politically not-so-savvy. I really used to think that violence was a good answer to a lot of problems.

I grew up. Can't say I'm thrilled about it.
 
I didn't know what homoeopathy actually advocated - until I knew, I just assumed it was a synonym for "natural". Once the evidence was presented, I was pretty dumb-struck...
 
My belief in God slowly fell away in my 30's.

Reading Peter McWilliams's Ain't Nobody's Business if You Do: The Absurdity of Consensual Crimes in a Free Society completely changed my views on drug legalization.

I've always had a skeptical bent. When I was around 12 or so, I remember seeing books on dowsing in the public library and was nonplussed.
 
Last edited:
A big one for me was false memories, especially as they related to the day-care abuse scandals of the 1980's and 90's. At the time I totally believed the children, and couldn't imagine why or how they would make up stuff like this. I thought the people accused were the worst sort of scum who ever slithered the face of earth, and couldn't even conceive of how any jury could let any of these vermin off.

But as I learned more, I discovered how the children's testimony was coached and coerced, how false memories could be so easily planted, how so much contradictory evidence was simply ignored to make for a "cleaner" case for the prosecution. The horrifying realization came over me that I was almost certainly totally wrong, that the real victims were the day-care workers, and that political motivations were keeping innocent people in jail. Suddenly woo wasn't harmless or goofy anymore, it was something that needed to be fought.
 
I didn't know what homoeopathy actually advocated - until I knew, I just assumed it was a synonym for "natural". Once the evidence was presented, I was pretty dumb-struck...

Same here, and that was just a few months ago too, on this very forum. I used to see no real harm in this industry, since most "natural" stuff has at least some effect on the body, but now I am disgusted.

A turning point in my life was when I took an optionnal Rhetorics class at University. I had planned to take one optionnal class per semester on a topic I hated or was completely alien to me, to broaden my horizon and break the monotony. I had no idea what rhetorics was about, and it set me on my way to become a good debater, spotting logical fallacies to avoid them myself and to point them out in other people's arguments. I still have quite a way to go compared to many people on this forum, but I've successfully trumped many people's arguments in real life (including my parents', a particularly defining moment). (ETA: what this has to do with the OP is that this was the moment where I realized all arguments are not equal, far from it, while I used to hold a belief closer to "everybody opinion is worthy").
 
In some ways I have, in others I haven't. I've always had the same religious views (agnostic/weak atheism), always believed in evolution, etc.

I would say I used to be more interested in animals rights than I am now. I'm still a vegetarian and I still don't wear any animal products, and I'm still against cosmetic testing on animals, but I have shifted some in my views on animal research for medical purposes. I was never involved with PETA or any such organization (even in my most gung ho phase, probably when I was about 18, they rubbed me the wrong way). I think I did fall victim to some misinformation, such as the "no useful medical knowledge has ever resulted from animal testing", and the "humans have none of the physical features that other carnivores have, therefore were weren't 'made' to eat meat" arguments, which becoming more educated have led me away from.

I would still love to imagine there would come a day when technology would make it possible to do away with all animal testing, but I'm not as naive anymore to say "modern technology makes animal research completely unnecessary" (which is another one I believed at some point in my life).

As a small disclaimer, I was NEVER one of those annoying, preachy types who got in people's faces about what they ate. It was always simply a personal choice to me that I could elimate a certain amount of suffering by changing my own practices that I couldn't ethically justify.

Anyway, to a lesser extent, when I was younger I was certainly more willing to accept crazy conspiracy theories, and I guess I used to hold out hope that the Loch Ness Monster would turn up. I still am always skeptical of government actions, and I'll even admit the first time I saw a clip of Loose Chance online one morning before leaving for work, I thought about it a lot on the way there... sort of a "hrmm, that IS odd..." type thinking. That lasted about 20 minutes, until I got to work and looked up some of the claims and found a lot of important info they were conveniently leaving out.
 
I used to believe in the Tooth Fairy, Santa, the Easter Bunny and Jesus. They all turned out to be my parents.
 
I went from pro-life to pro-choice (to use the common, if not the accurate euphemisms). I'm not sure if that was a major change or just the natural consequence of following a materialist philosophy to its natural conclusion.
 
I,ve pretty much dropped my religion. One thing is hard to let go of though. Many of my beloved relatives and friends are deceased. Its hard to believe that I'll never see them again. My friends don't like me anymore because they're dead. My Grandmother doesn't love me anymore because she's dead, etc. Things like that are hard (not impossible) to think about.
 
I've dropped religion completely, moderated on animal issues (medical research), got slightly more moderated on economic issues (I'm only far left on those now, not distant left), swung back and forth on abortion and try not to think about it too much, gotten more into gay activism, and given up on the plausibility of many conspiracies (no I was never a troofer, but if I were younger I might have been).
That's what jumps immediately to mind.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom