Why I despise the Truthers

NYCEMT86

Graduate Poster
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
1,091
It was only in April when I started researching more into the truth movement to better understand what their "evidence" is. As most of you have come to the same conclusion as I have, they are full of [rule8].

What makes me despise the Truthers more is the fact that they call the FDNY, NYPD, and PAPD murders. They claim that they were involved with the horrible acts of 9/11.

As a New Yorker and a City Employee I find this sickening. I have friends and family who serve in both the FDNY and NYPD, as most New Yorkers do. You call my friends and my cousins murders it gets personal, especially since they worked against the odds that morning. They did their job with pride and committed themselves to that site months after the attack.

Most of you Truthers will never understand the sacrifice and pain they went through, what their family and friends went through. The FDNY suffered a huge loss, lost over 50% of their most experienced Firefighters. They still haven't fully recovered from that.

I have talked to my co-workers, friends, and cousins who where there that morning and I tell them about this b/s idea that they are murders and 9/11 was an inside job. They called it Bull**** and said you are all sick for thinking that. Its a slap in the face to them to hear this.

This city takes pride in our Firefighters and Police Officers. You will never understand how hard they work everyday for the Millions of people who work and live here.

We lost over 400 Uniformed Firefighters and Police Officers that day. They did their jobs the best they could and you call them murders, you make me sick. I became an EMT and I am working on becoming a FDNY Firefighter because of the actions of those brave men and women.

I hope you truthers can sleep at night for stepping on the honor and memory that these men and women have about their job.
 
I appreciate the post.

People like me who look at debunking as an intellectual excercise need to an occasional reminder as to how vile and depraved truther ranting really is. Not that I haven't noticed this before, or many times before, but that it is alwasy good to step back and really get the implications of what these yahoos claim. Also, does it sicken you as much as me when you realize that the worst of them make money off this?

Kage
 
It was only in April when I started researching more into the truth movement to better understand what their "evidence" is. As most of you have come to the same conclusion as I have, they are full of [rule8].

What makes me despise the Truthers more is the fact that they call the FDNY, NYPD, and PAPD murders. They claim that they were involved with the horrible acts of 9/11.

As a New Yorker and a City Employee I find this sickening. I have friends and family who serve in both the FDNY and NYPD, as most New Yorkers do. You call my friends and my cousins murders it gets personal, especially since they worked against the odds that morning. They did their job with pride and committed themselves to that site months after the attack.

Most of you Truthers will never understand the sacrifice and pain they went through, what their family and friends went through. The FDNY suffered a huge loss, lost over 50% of their most experienced Firefighters. They still haven't fully recovered from that.

I have talked to my co-workers, friends, and cousins who where there that morning and I tell them about this b/s idea that they are murders and 9/11 was an inside job. They called it Bull**** and said you are all sick for thinking that. Its a slap in the face to them to hear this.

This city takes pride in our Firefighters and Police Officers. You will never understand how hard they work everyday for the Millions of people who work and live here.

We lost over 400 Uniformed Firefighters and Police Officers that day. They did their jobs the best they could and you call them murders, you make me sick. I became an EMT and I am working on becoming a FDNY Firefighter because of the actions of those brave men and women.

I hope you truthers can sleep at night for stepping on the honor and memory that these men and women have about their job.


Ahhh, but you see they are sly about this. Look at Dylan and LC:FC. It will have a long segment about the hardships of those who worked at GZ, and breathed in the air...why? I do not think it has anything to do with them actually giving a rats ass about the topic, but rather it is to (A) gain sympathy from the audience, and in so doing expand their viewership, and (B) to use the "untouchable" factor to make the movie harder to slam.

Look at all the truthers who will come in here, and in one post claim that WTC7 was due to a planned CD, and to accuse the FDNY and others of foreknowledge, allowing them to get out in time, and then in the next post/breath claim that they are in full support of the first responders.

I would rather they simply came out and spoke the truth, which is that they do consider the 1st responders part of the cover up, rather than lie, and try to fall on both sides of the fence.

TAM:)
 
Ahhh, but you see they are sly about this. Look at Dylan and LC:FC. It will have a long segment about the hardships of those who worked at GZ, and breathed in the air...why? I do not think it has anything to do with them actually giving a rats ass about the topic, but rather it is to (A) gain sympathy from the audience, and in so doing expand their viewership, and (B) to use the "untouchable" factor to make the movie harder to slam.

Look at all the truthers who will come in here, and in one post claim that WTC7 was due to a planned CD, and to accuse the FDNY and others of foreknowledge, allowing them to get out in time, and then in the next post/breath claim that they are in full support of the first responders.

I would rather they simply came out and spoke the truth, which is that they do consider the 1st responders part of the cover up, rather than lie, and try to fall on both sides of the fence.

TAM:)
Dancing on a razor's edge often leads to getting cut. Easier to be on one side. Unfortunately they choose the wrong one :)
 
I also notice that the twoofers are generally not credible military veterans. (A few exceptions, mostly on P4T, but even some of them seem to have a screw or two that needs to be checked for torque.)

And look at the sites they link to. Lots of subtle white nationalist sites in there, a lot of blatant Holocaust-denier sites.

They don't want truth, they want a revolution.

Given the reception that Rudy gets now when he shows up at a fire fighters' gathering of any sort, I have a hard time imagining that any fire fighter who had any evidence that it was an inside job would keep his mouth shut when he could blow one of the least qualified GOP candidates out of the water.

They would not lie for rotten Rudy.
 
I appreciate the post.

People like me who look at debunking as an intellectual excercise need to an occasional reminder as to how vile and depraved truther ranting really is. Not that I haven't noticed this before, or many times before, but that it is alwasy good to step back and really get the implications of what these yahoos claim. Also, does it sicken you as much as me when you realize that the worst of them make money off this?

Kage

I make a point of reminding various loons that theirs is an "evil" movement. The sheer rock-headed stupidity is the first twoofer characteristic most observers notice, but all the irrationality and dishonesty is in the service of pure evil.
 
I make a point of reminding various loons that theirs is an "evil" movement. The sheer rock-headed stupidity is the first twoofer characteristic most observers notice, but all the irrationality and dishonesty is in the service of pure evil.

Well said Ron. Well said.
 
It was only in April when I started researching more into the truth movement to better understand what their "evidence" is. As most of you have come to the same conclusion as I have, they are full of [rule8].

What makes me despise the Truthers more is the fact that they call the FDNY, NYPD, and PAPD murders. They claim that they were involved with the horrible acts of 9/11.


Amen, brother.

I joined my combination FD as a volunteer a few months after 9/11. A lot of the guys I ride with today were at the Pentagon that day, pulling pieces of airliner, and passengers, and Pentagon workers out of the wreckage.

Now, I quite literally trust these guys with my life. How do you think I feel when someone says they were "in on it", lying about what they saw and did at the Pentagon? Over on the Bad Astronomy and apollohoax forums, one "truther" did exactly that.

I extended him an invitation to make that claim to my face. And that invitation stands for any other "truther" who believes that the cops and firefighters were "in on it". Anytime, anywhere.

So, NYCEMT86, I know how you feel. FTM.
 
Can you back this up with some examples?

Rev...do you believe that WTC7 was a CD? If so, do you believe that Silverstein was involved? If so, do you believe he used the words "pull it" to give the command to have the building demolished?
 
Rev...do you believe that WTC7 was a CD? If so, do you believe that Silverstein was involved? If so, do you believe he used the words "pull it" to give the command to have the building demolished?

Nobody died in building 7. I asked for examples of truthers calling FDNY, PAPD and NYPD murderers. Do you have any examples?
 
Can you back this up with some examples?

The problem is that the conspiracy theorists hold two mutually exclusive positions.

One is that there was a vast government conspiracy to murder thousands of innocent people, and an even bigger coverup. All those in the coverup are equally guilty of murder, as they are, at best, accessories after the fact. The absence of any physical evidence of explosives in the WTC towers - which must have been present, it is impossible for such a huge demolition to leave no physical evidence - implies that this coverup operation involved the complicity of all the first responders at the site, none of whom reported any such evidence. This therefore implicates those first responders - specifically, the FDNY, PAPD and NYPD. Furthermore, it is at least implied that the physical evidence collected (for example, victim DNA or aircraft debris) was falsified, again implicating the first responders; this is, for example, a necessary corrolory of all no-plane or substitute plane theories, whether at the WTC towers or the Pentagon.

The other is that the NYPD, PAPD and FDNY are unfortunate victims of the conspiracy. This is generally put forward because of the unpopularity of suggesting anything else. However, it is logically inconsistent with the first position, so the only ways to hold both views at once are cognitive dissonance or intellectual dishonesty.

A good example of the mental gymnastics required is given by our regular contributor Lyte Trip, who believes that:
(a) Government agents planted huge quantities of fake physical evidence around the Pentagon.
(b) Pentagon cops, themselves agents of the government, are above suspicion of dishonesty and cannot possibly be in error when testifying regarding the flight path of AA77.
(c) Anyone testifying otherwise as to the flight path of AA77 is automatically suspect because they might be in the pay of the government.
(d) Pentagon cops cannot be trusted when they say that they saw AA77 hit the pentagon because they could have been fooled by misdirection.
In Lyte Trip's world, therefore, government employees are automatically suspect, beyond suspicion, utterly reliable witnesses and easily misled; in many cases, these contradictions are true of the same specific individuals.

The same tactics are used by those who argue for CD of the towers and, in particular, WTC7; they argue that the PAPD, NYPD and FDNY were not complicit in the conspiracy, while outlining a scenario in which they cannot possibly have been anything but complicit.

To take the usual analogy: Suppose I claimed that your wife suffered serious blunt force trauma at a time when you were the only person in the house with her, argued that her injuries could not have been accidental or self-inflicted, pointed out that you were in posession of a baseball bat at the time, but claimed I was not accusing you of beating your wife - would you feel that I was accusing you anyway?

Dave
 
Nobody died in 7. I want examples of CTs calling those agencies murderers, as stated in the opening post.

People died before WTC 7 collapsed, ok?

Griffin says the fire chiefs knew there were explosives inside WTC 7, ok?

Griffin is accusing the fire chiefs of covering up the demolition of WTC 7, ok?

Griffin is accusing the fire chiefs of not being truthful about the day’s events, ok?

Griffins is accusing the fire chiefs are being complacent in mass murder, ok?

Incidentally ……………….

33-year FDNY veteran Chief of Department Peter Ganci,

42-year FDNY veteran First Deputy Commissioner Bill Feehan,

40-year FDNY veteran Chief of Special Operations Command Ray Downey (the most decorated man in the history of the FDNY),

Head Fire Marshal Ronald Bucca,

31-year FDNY veteran Assistant Chief Gerard Barbara,

39-year FDNY veteran Assistant Chief Donald Burns,

and 18 Battalion Chiefs,

all of whom died on 9/11, along with 23 Captains, 46 Lieutenants, two Paramedics, and 251 firefighters (some of whom were in retirement and volunteered).

Maybe you would be so kind as to point out which fire chiefs he is talking about, ok?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom