Evolution/Religion (Origins of Life) [Was: Can we calm down in this section please?]

Apollo20

Banned
Joined
Mar 28, 2007
Messages
1,425
Cuddles:

Religion is not a theory.

Civilized Worm:

I am certainly not the only scientist who believes that the theory of evolution totally fails to explain the origin of life. That hardly makes me a pseudoscientist.

Isaac Newton is generally acknowledged to be one of the greatest scientists who ever lived, yet he believed in and studied alchemy.
 
Where does the Theory of Evolution actually try to tackle the origin of life???

TAM:)
 
Cuddles:

Religion is not a theory.

Civilized Worm:

I am certainly not the only scientist who believes that the theory of evolution totally fails to explain the origin of life. That hardly makes me a pseudoscientist.
Just as NIST had its charter to investigate the cause of collapse, not the actual collapse and post-collapse of the towers, Evolution does NOT, repeat, does NOT even attempt to address origins of life. It does address what happens to that life, once formed, over eons of environmental changes and other factors...
Why misrepresent stuff when you should know better? Do you not feel any duty to squelch fuzzy thinking?

Isaac Newton is generally acknowledged to be one of the greatest scientists who ever lived, yet he believed in and studied alchemy.
 
TAM:

What does the theory of evolution cover? I would say worms, fish, ammonites, stromatolites, all the way to prokaryotic and eukarotic cells?

My son has the Usborne Young Scientist's Guide to Evolution. It is a very good book. The first section is "Creation Myths and Religion"; the second section is "Darwin's Theory"; the third section is "The Chemical Code of Life"; then we have a section "What are Species"; next we have "The Origin of Life" followed by "The Fossil Record".

Perhaps you should write to the authors and complain about a book on "Evolution" having a section on the origin of life....
 
We are talking strictly about the theory.

Of course, an individual authoring of biological subjects around this topic will likely include theories on the origin of life.

Now if you want to get into what "Evolutionists" promote, then I would say that they do try to address the origins of life, often in terms of some form of electomagnetic stimulus to the Hydrocarbon/Protein soup.

TAM:)
 
The "origin of life" is essentially how life on Earth might have emerged from non-life, biological evolution does not depend on understanding how life began. Evolution is the understanding of what happened once life appeared, from the common ancestor or ancestral gene pool onwards.

The origin of life is a very interesting topic and nobody truly knows how it began, for example recently there was a discovery of inorganic dust with life-like qualities...

http://physorg.com/news105869123.html
 
We are talking strictly about the theory.

Of course, an individual authoring of biological subjects around this topic will likely include theories on the origin of life.

Now if you want to get into what "Evolutionists" promote, then I would say that they do try to address the origins of life, often in terms of some form of electomagnetic stimulus to the Hydrocarbon/Protein soup.

TAM:)
Absorootly!
One must separate the "Theory" (supported by scientific observation and correlation) as opposed to "Theorists" who may be looney as the day is long.
We see much of the latter in regard to 9/11 (or 11/9)
 
Spins:

You claim that: "Evolution is the understanding of what happened once life appeared". Well, this requires a definition of "life"... and this necessitates a consideration of the origin of life.
 
No it doesn't. The study of the stars, Astonomy, didn't NEED a theory on how the universe began in order to study the stars themselves. Observations of how the stars behave, how they move, how they glow, how long, etc, does not REQUIRE the big bang. Granted it helps us speculate, but it is not REQUIRED.

Like wise, the observations of the fossil record, the observations of closely linked species, the examination of DNA similarities does not REQUIRE a theory on the origin of life, in order to prove that the "Theory of Evolution" is the MOST LIKELY answer to how living beings evolved on earth.

TAM:)
 
TAM:

What does the theory of evolution cover? I would say worms, fish, ammonites, stromatolites, all the way to prokaryotic and eukarotic cells?

My son has the Usborne Young Scientist's Guide to Evolution. It is a very good book. The first section is "Creation Myths and Religion"; the second section is "Darwin's Theory"; the third section is "The Chemical Code of Life"; then we have a section "What are Species"; next we have "The Origin of Life" followed by "The Fossil Record".

Perhaps you should write to the authors and complain about a book on "Evolution" having a section on the origin of life....
Can we drop the theory of evolution bs please. There is another forum if you guys want to get into a debate about evolution.
 
No it doesn't. The study of the stars, Astonomy, didn't NEED a theory on how the universe began in order to study the stars themselves. Observations of how the stars behave, how they move, how they glow, how long, etc, does not REQUIRE the big bang. Granted it helps us speculate, but it is not REQUIRED.

Like wise, the observations of the fossil record, the observations of closely linked species, the examination of DNA similarities does not REQUIRE a theory on the origin of life, in order to prove that the "Theory of Evolution" is the MOST LIKELY answer to how living beings evolved on earth.

TAM:)
Please guys pay attention to the new rules. Evolution belongs in a different forum.
 
ok...I am done with it...I was merely trying to clarify...makes no odds to me as I am a firm believer in the theory. As to the origin of life, the jury is still out, and so am I.

TAM:)
 
Well, this requires a definition of "life"... and this necessitates a consideration of the origin of life.
These are incredibly difficult questions to answer scientifically, especially that last one, all we can do is speculate about life's origin at the moment.

On the other hand I'm perfectly comfortable with the theory of evolution, in fact you can see it happen, for example I thought this was an interesting observation...

As the weather gets hotter so the sheep are getting smaller

Anyways I'd better stop talking about evolution before ~enigma~ sends me to the sin bin.
 
Can we drop the theory of evolution bs please. There is another forum if you guys want to get into a debate about evolution.

Actually, the discussion is appropriate here.
It shows how people who should know better, who are involved in science, and who know the scientific method as it pertains to their field, can-and do- forget all about it when professing expertise in other fields.
They "assume", from "the popular press", or from people with axes to grind, or from the totally misinformed, or liars out to make a buck, that "this is the troof" about _______ (insert favorite misrepresented theory here)--simply because one cannot read everything there is.It is difficult enough keeping up with one field, however narrow it may bee--and something as diverse as evolution, too? Not sure it can be done...
This is why we are posting in the CT forum, right? To counter the misinformed, folks with axes to grind, liars, etc?
 
Posts must be on topic to the thread subject. On this Forum thread drift is expected but must follow from the discussion.
No rules broken I'm afraid, I believe we merely experienced a little thread drift ... may I suggest letting the mods do their job. ;)

Taxi for ~enigma~ please. :p
 
Cuddles:

Religion is not a theory.

Civilized Worm:

I am certainly not the only scientist who believes that the theory of evolution totally fails to explain the origin of life. That hardly makes me a pseudoscientist.


We've already explained to you how the theory of evolution isn't supposed to explain the origin so stop with the strawmen. I have already stated that I don't consider you a pseudoscientist. Nevertheless you do endorse pseudoscience and conspiracy theories.


Isaac Newton is generally acknowledged to be one of the greatest scientists who ever lived, yet he believed in and studied alchemy.


So? Newton lived in the 17th century, and given how ahead of his time he was in other respects I think we can forgive him for the alchemy. You on the other hand should know better.
 
No rules broken I'm afraid, I believe we merely experienced a little thread drift ... may I suggest letting the mods do their job. ;)

Taxi for ~enigma~ please. :p
Oh it drifted and it appeared that this thread was going to take a swerve into evolution land. That according to rule 11 is just as bad as cat pictures and recepies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom