StopSylviaBrowne - Montel: Jamie Barker Reading

Browne goes on to stress that too much emphasis is placed on recovering missing bodies for proper burials.

"Honey, please take my word for it, they don't care," she says.

I think she has said things like this before? Well, it's such a cynic thing to say. We know that the deceased will not care, he or she will not be able to care, but how can she be so cold and indifferent about the fact that the deceased's near and dear obviously will care?

I guess I shouldn't be surprised that she is though :rolleyes:
 
RSL,

It's beginning to look that you've picked the best option on what to report.

If you were aiming to use all the cases where Saliva was correct, you'd have a very small website, I reckon! :)

It's good to see that you're not getting too tired of the whole affair!

I agree with what Fran wrote - I find it incredible that somebody as callous and uncaring - and so obviously so - can have got any following at all!

YBW
 
I agree with the excellence of RSL's site, and like most others here I think SB is repulsive in what she does.

That said, if there is anything at all positive about what she does, telling the grieving that the dead do not care is it. Funerals are for the living; when they feel they can't have them because the remains cannot be recovered, they are choosing not to have the closure they claim they want.

Were I to attempt comforting someone in such circumstances, I would say something similar. Grieve and let go. You owe the dead nothing and yourself everything.
 
I agree with the excellence of RSL's site, and like most others here I think SB is repulsive in what she does.

That said, if there is anything at all positive about what she does, telling the grieving that the dead do not care is it. Funerals are for the living; when they feel they can't have them because the remains cannot be recovered, they are choosing not to have the closure they claim they want.

Were I to attempt comforting someone in such circumstances, I would say something similar. Grieve and let go. You owe the dead nothing and yourself everything.

I would agree on that there might be a time to let go, but Sylvia Browne is hardly qualified to tell people when this time is. As you say, funerals are for the living, and it's important when it comes to closure, and yes, if it's clear beyond any reasonable doubt that the body can not be found then the grieving relatives might need help to find closure in some other way. But SB is obviously not any help in this. Besides, she is most of the times also wrong about if the body can be found. In the example of the linked article above her cynic words followed a claim that the husband's body would never be found, but a few months later it was!

No matter if there is a time to let go... Sylvia isn't helping. It's pretty clear that that isn't her intention either. No matter if, in a rare case, words of hers, like the above quote, accidentally would be a help to someone, it isn't her intention - she is simply just dismissing these people and their grief. "Don't bother, honey, body's gone forever!" And then it turns up after all? How is this helping the grieving?

No, I see your point, and I agree with it to a certain extent, but I don't agree that this is one of the few good things SB does.
 
No, I see your point, and I agree with it to a certain extent, but I don't agree that this is one of the few good things SB does.
I don't want to argue as I think we pretty much agree, so this is my last post on the topic.

I do not think it is one of the good things SB "does."

I think it is one of the possibly good unintended consequences of her actions.
 
I don't want to argue as I think we pretty much agree, so this is my last post on the topic.

I do not think it is one of the good things SB "does."

I think it is one of the possibly good unintended consequences of her actions.

Yes, I do agree with you in most parts, and didn't mean to start an argument. I see what you meant better now as well. I just think that a possible good unintended consequence is unlikely, and isn't worth all the damage she will do with words like this. Just had to say that.

But I didn't think you were supportive of her or anything. :)
 
Last edited:
And Garette,

Never argue with anybody holding a meat-cleaver - if that's what it is. :)

YBW

*LOL* It is a meat cleaver, but it's just for decorative purposes ;)

It wasn't an argument though, just me misunderstanding what Garette was getting at :)
 
I think she has said things like this before? Well, it's such a cynic thing to say. We know that the deceased will not care, he or she will not be able to care, but how can she be so cold and indifferent about the fact that the deceased's near and dear obviously will care?

I guess I shouldn't be surprised that she is though :rolleyes:

She's usually so callous and uncaring to all of the people who appear on Montel that this almost seems warm, coming from her.

Too bad the transcript isn't on Lexis Nexis for this one. I suppose Robert could have ordered the episode to make his case stronger but I understand not wanting to put more money in Montel's pocket.
 
To the subject at hand:
Browne goes on to stress that too much emphasis is placed on recovering missing bodies for proper burials.

"Honey, please take my word for it, they don't care," she says.
A lot of believers in ghosts do say that the ghost is deeply concerned about the disposition of their mortal body. In some cases, that's the reason for the ghost to exist (here and not to have "moved on" or whatever).

Anyone familiar with the SB canon know if she's consistent on this point? Does she always say that the dead never care about what happens to their body?

Even if so, it seems odd that the dead would worry about some of the other things I'm pretty sure she has said--like the disposition of a piece of jewelry or fate of some other favorite object.
 
Anyone familiar with the SB canon know if she's consistent on this point? Does she always say that the dead never care about what happens to their body?

Even if so, it seems odd that the dead would worry about some of the other things I'm pretty sure she has said--like the disposition of a piece of jewelry or fate of some other favorite object.

That's a good point! If the dead are so uncaring about that their loved ones gets some answers about their deaths, and some closure and a grave to visit... Then wouldn't they really be too uncaring to make contact AT ALL!? :confused:
 
Yeah, I guess you're right :( What a despicable person

The "trust me, they don't care" comment is nothing compared to a cringe inducing reading she and Montel gave to a guy when I was there.

Sorry for repeating this story again but there was a man who wanted to contact his brother from whom he was apparently estranged when the brother died 12 years ago. He wanted to know if his brother forgave him, didn't say for what.

Sylvia either didn't bother to even listen to what he was saying or didn't understand what he was saying because of his accent and as a result, totally botched the reading. Montel jumped in the second she started floundering but he apparently didn't get it either and when after a very long while it finally dawned on Sylvia what he was asking, she coldly and abruptly told the guy that people on the Other Side don't care about what's going on down here cause they're way over it.

She turned to Montel and said something to the effect that on the Other Side, they're way past all that and we're the only ones worrying about it. Think she actually said at one point, to the man's face, "They're dead, they don't care."

When the man was still really confused and still didn't understand what she was talking about, Montel tried to lighten the mood with jokey lighthearted levity about how the man's brother's spirit doesn't care, with Sylvia interjecting. Something along the lines of "He ain't up there for 12 years going 'Man..!', screwing up about something that happened down here! You're the one that's messing up about it, they up there partying. That would be hell if you're worrying about it every day for 12 years!"

The guy replied "It has been hell! I think about it every day of my life, every day for the last 12 years."

I don't think I've ever cringed so hard in my life.
 
Last edited:
Unknown? That's far too generous.

[He won't surface] unless they dig and I don't think they will.

Wrong and wrong. They didn't dig, and he was found.

Then again, I don't care as much about objectivity as RSL. And, as usual, great job!
 
I agree. It's much too generous.

Robert, if I provide you with articles with more information on the scaffold collapse, the disappearance of Jamie Barker, the recovery of his body and the inquests and lawsuits that followed (I checked and this case was pretty heavily covered in Canada and Michigan) that confirm her story is bs, will you change the ratings to "wrong"?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom