Financing terrorism: Split from: Truthers: what if you are wrong?

TC329

Banned
Joined
Oct 18, 2006
Messages
1,453
No use beating a dead horse. We don't need a new investigation, the current one proves truthers wrong quite sufficiently.

Why don't you answer the question?


To date, the US government has not been able to determine the origin of the money used for the 911 attacks. Ultimately the question is of little practical significance.

page 172 - The 9/11 Commission Report.


You agree with the above statement that identifying the people who financed the 3,000+ dead of 9/11 is insignificant?



YES OR NO
 
To date, the US government has not been able to determine the origin of the money used for the 911 attacks. Ultimately the question is of little practical significance.

page 172 - The 9/11 Commission Report.


You agree with the above statement that identifying the people who financed the 3,000+ dead of 9/11 is insignificant?



YES OR NO
Why can't you answer this question and not try to derail this thread?
Why don't you start a new thread with your question?
 
To date, the US government has not been able to determine the origin of the money used for the 911 attacks. Ultimately the question is of little practical significance. Al Qaeda had many avenues of funding. If a particular funding source had dried up, al Qaeda could have easily tapped a different source or diverted funds from another project to fund an operation that cost $400,000-$500,000 over nearly two years.

page 172 - The 9/11 Commission Report.


You agree with the above statement that identifying the people who financed the 3,000+ dead of 9/11 is insignificant?



YES OR NO

Put the quote back in context for you. I know you wouldn't have done that on purpose.
 
yes


i just did, how much were we betting again?


So let me get this straight - You don't think the people who financed the actions and needs of the 19 men you believe murdered over 3,000 people on 9/11 should be identified and prosecuted for murder??? :jaw-dropp
 
Your questions a cherry pick and you know it. I agree that the terrorists had more than one source like the commission concluded.

Do you think those people should be identified and prosecuted for their involvement in the murder of over 3,000 people on 9/11 or do you think much like Zelikow's 9/11 Commission that is insignificant?

I don't care if you think 1 man financed it or 1 million people making donations in Osama Bin Laden's secret Mosque donations program.
 
Put the quote back in context for you. I know you wouldn't have done that on purpose.

Ok.

Now that you added more to it :


Do you think tracing down the sources of those who paid for 9/11 is insignificant?

Yes or No
 
So let me get this straight - You don't think the people who financed the actions and needs of the 19 men you believe murdered over 3,000 people on 9/11 should be identified and prosecuted for murder??? :jaw-dropp
no more than anyone who paid pogo the clown to appear at their kids birthday party should be charged with murder
 
Ok.

Now that you added more to it :


Do you think tracing down the sources of those who paid for 9/11 is insignificant?

Yes or No

That's the wrong question TC. The report said "of little practical significance".

Do you understand the difference? It is not a trivial one.

The report was stating that even if there source of funding for 9/11 were tracked down and stopped, it would not help prevent any future attacks. I agree.
 
Last edited:
So let me get this straight - You don't think the people who financed the actions and needs of the 19 men you believe murdered over 3,000 people on 9/11 should be identified and prosecuted for murder??? :jaw-dropp


If I loan you $75 which you use to buy a gun to commit a murder (that I have no knowledge of), am I complicit in your crime?
 
Last edited:
TC, aren't you supposed to be one of the best and brightest of the debaters over in never-never-land?

Your total miscomprehension of the question that you yourself have raised is just plain awe-inspiring! Read the entire statement. Take away a couple of the big words and put in a few full stops (periods), and what they are saying is exactly what qarnos is pointing out.

EVEN IF they had stopped the source of funding via one channel, AQ had other channels. Terrorist cells are kinda like that! They don't have a board of directors meeting and get budgetary approval and then go to the shareholders. They have source channels all over the world if they're large organizations.

And, Yes (Happy???!!!!), it would be very important to find those sources and hold them responsible for their actions. Can they be considered guilty of murders in which they had no direct part or knew nothing of? No! Could they be proven to be funding terrorist anti-humanist groups and be outed for the creeps they are? Yes.

Your trap didn't work. We were supposed to:
A) disagree with you, thus allowing you to run around waving your black t-shirt in the air, saying, "See!?? JREFers don't want to get to the money men behind the attacks!"
B) agree with you, and then you could go, 'Ah ha! So you agree that we have to go after the Pope, Illuminati, Jooz, NWO, Bildebergers, Masons, (or other target group of your choice)"!

It's no phone when we don't play your little games, but you really have to make the challenge less transparent.

On the whole, I'd give it a 63. I like the lyrics, but my girlfriend didn't like the beat and you can't dance to it.
 
That's the wrong question TC. The report said "of little practical significance".

Do you understand the difference? It is not a trivial one.

The report was stating that even if there source of funding for 9/11 were tracked down and stopped, it would not help prevent any future attacks. I agree.


I understand the difference and the difference doesn't exist to me. If someone financed the cold blooded murder of a family member, think of it as a contract killing, then they are of equal guilt.

How can you agree with this? I don't care if you don't believe the WTC was blown up, I don't care that you believe every single aspect of the official story. But how can you sit here and say that the people who MADE IT ALL POSSIBLE BY FUNDING IT are of "little significance"?

What if it's 3 people? What if it's 30? How many rich evil men does it take to orchestrate 9/11 regardless of which side of the fence you are on?

Do you think you erase them from the equation and their is an endless supply of millionaires and billionaires who have nothing better to do than to fund WWIII because it was their agenda all along they were just waiting for the right opportunity?
 
If I loan you $75 which you use to buy a gun to commit a murder (that I have no knowledge of), am I complicit in your crime?

Mohammed Atta didn't give someone a sob story about needing rent money in order to get the cash for the box cutters. The ignorance in your comment is astounding.
 
And, Yes (Happy???!!!!), it would be very important to find those sources and hold them responsible for their actions. Can they be considered guilty of murders in which they had no direct part or knew nothing of? No! Could they be proven to be funding terrorist anti-humanist groups and be outed for the creeps they are? Yes.

Don't act like the guy wiring Atta the hundred grand shortly before the attacks thought it was to pay for his college tuition.

Your trap didn't work. We were supposed to:
A) disagree with you, thus allowing you to run around waving your black t-shirt in the air, saying, "See!?? JREFers don't want to get to the money men behind the attacks!"
B) agree with you, and then you could go, 'Ah ha! So you agree that we have to go after the Pope, Illuminati, Jooz, NWO, Bildebergers, Masons, (or other target group of your choice)"!

It's no phone when we don't play your little games, but you really have to make the challenge less transparent.

On the whole, I'd give it a 63. I like the lyrics, but my girlfriend didn't like the beat and you can't dance to it.
It's not a trap. This is not some game. This is real life. Real people. Real murders and real financiers of those murders.

They should be brought to justice. They should be tracked down in whatever mansio, I mean spider holes they crawled down into and brought to trial. Not deemed 'of little significance'.

3,000+ lives on 9/11 and hundreds of thousands of lifes afterwards in BS wars is not 'of little significance'.
 
You keep missing the word 'practical'.

And you keep making these appeals to emotion.

However, to answer your point: While I agree they should be traced down as part of a trial to bring the terrorists to justice, the commission is quite correct in stating that it won't help prevent further attacks. That simple.
 
<snip>I understand the difference and the difference doesn't exist to me.

No, I don't think you do understand the difference, because you persist in misquoting the report, you persist in omitting the important word, "practical", and you persist in ignoring the meaning of the word in the context in which it was written.

Your silly tactics might work on your fellow conspiracy fantasists but they won't work on skeptics.
 
I understand the difference and the difference doesn't exist to me. If someone financed the cold blooded murder of a family member, think of it as a contract killing, then they are of equal guilt.

How can you agree with this? I don't care if you don't believe the WTC was blown up, I don't care that you believe every single aspect of the official story. But how can you sit here and say that the people who MADE IT ALL POSSIBLE BY FUNDING IT are of "little significance"?

What if it's 3 people? What if it's 30? How many rich evil men does it take to orchestrate 9/11 regardless of which side of the fence you are on?

Do you think you erase them from the equation and their is an endless supply of millionaires and billionaires who have nothing better to do than to fund WWIII because it was their agenda all along they were just waiting for the right opportunity?

Tokorona beat me to it. You keep ignoring the word "practical"!

The 9/11 Commission was mandated to make recommendations to changes in security protocols, etc, which could help prevent 9/11 ever happening again. In this regard, the source of funding is of little practical significance.

The keyword here, Practical, means that even if we found out who provided the money and locked them away for life, it would have no impact on preventing any future attacks.
 
Is it possible to put both your feet in your mouth at one time?

I think I have just seen someone try:D
 
The 9/11 Commission was mandated to make recommendations to changes in security protocols, etc, which could help prevent 9/11 ever happening again. In this regard, the source of funding is of little practical significance.

The keyword here, Practical, means that even if we found out who provided the money and locked them away for life, it would have no impact on preventing any future attacks.

My compliments on the thread split, it's an interesting topic.

I understand for whom it wouldn't have an impact; on Al Qaeda, is the suggestion. But on our national consciousness? Our sense of closure, justice, etc.? It's one thing to say "that wasn't in the scope of the Commission's mandate", so when they write it's of little practical significance, they are implying "to this report".

The line in the Commission report looks like they can point to specific "sources" and "projects" and I do remember news reports of freezing bank accounts and attacking “terrorist financing”. "Follow the money" is the mantra of investigation.

I met someone once who had been paid a visit by the FBI. Apparently his mother had worked for and donated to a charity that turned out to be fraudulent, and was funneling money towards something sinister enough to warrant attention. I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of "terrorist" funding comes from the Muslim tradition of tithe, where you give some percent of your income to charity every year. It's one of the five pillars, even. It's entirely possible the money trail wouldn't lead to 'evil mansion dwellers' or whoever the OP is insinuating. Would it be worse news if it was pensioner grandmas donating to fraudulent charities to have prayers said in their name that paid for it? Or a relief that it wasn't something intentional?

A tenuous parallel; how much impact has the Michael Vick story had on people’s ability to bankroll animal blood sports? Probably not a huge impact, all things being equal. That doesn’t make it less news-worthy or criminal. Not to mention, bringing something to the forefront through the media means it’s being talked about, and who is to say it hasn’t turned a future potential dogfighter off of the idea entirely, if only for fear of exposure?
 
Do you think tracing down the sources of those who paid for 9/11 is insignificant?

Who says this isn't being done right now, or an attempt to locate funding sources wasn't made? You don't know everything that goes on behind the scenes of a criminal investigation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom