Self Contradiction Anthropogenic Global Warming Denier Arguments

a_unique_person

Director of Hatcheries and Conditioning
Joined
Jul 19, 2002
Messages
50,806
Location
Waiting for the pod bay door to open.
The arguments often remind me of the phrase "doth protest too much".

One contradiction that comes to mind, is the earth warming or not.

Evidence against from the deniers, temperature records are incorrect, it is not warming.

Evidence for, Mars and other solar bodies are warming, it's warming, but it's all due to the sun.
 
I tried to find the most basic data. "Like how hot is it now?", and I got a two degree range. With all the themometers in the world, and satellite and other hi-tech gismos.

I tired to find the acuity of the ancient proxies, and got a +/- two degree range.

Soo, all of the data is within normal historic variation, as far as the basic data goes. Yes, there are trends within that range. But all is within the normla range.

So I stopped discussing it. Too much religious fanaticism on both sides. Name calling and gratuitous debating gambits abound. Don't expect me to respond here either.
 
I don't think you're going to get too much action on this thread. The title itself is a thread-killer. I'll give you one post though.

I created this chart from Giss data. According to Hansen they don't know what the true global temperature is within even 1/2 a degree. So I just used his best guess as a starting point and added his anomalies.

Where in this chart do you see the unprecedented warming that worries you so much?


Edit to add: Also, what part of that temperature is due to CO2? What part is the Sun?
 
Last edited:
The graph is an excellent reason of why sensitivity is so important to the earth ecosystem. An ice age hardly puts a dent in the temperature record when it's in Kelvin, either, but it covers the earth in ice.
 
Can I expect an answer to my queries to be forth-coming? Especially the last two.

edit to add: I'm glad you now seem to agree that warmer will keep us away from having an ice age anytime soon.
 
Last edited:
Edit to add: Also, what part of that temperature is due to CO2? What part is the Sun?

A very small part, but it only takes a small change to take us out of our 'comfort zone'.

The issue is also rapid change, in natural terms. That is, how much time does the natural world need to adapt to change? The prediction is mass extinctions due to what is, in natural terms, rapid change, faster than evolution can cope with. In human terms, there is also the issue of rapid change. Can our economic and social systems cope with what will happen?
 
Climate models are accurate predictors of global warming.
The North pole is melting faster than predicted.


Oops. Wrong thread.
 
Correct, wrong thread.

In this case, I don't see what the problem is. If the models are underestimating the extent and rate of change, it's actually worse for us, not something we can just ignore.

The IPCC and researchers have also stated right from the start, the models will not be able to predict the changes with great accuracy.
 
Correct, wrong thread.

In this case, I don't see what the problem is. If the models are underestimating the extent and rate of change, it's actually worse for us, not something we can just ignore.

The IPCC and researchers have also stated right from the start, the models will not be able to predict the changes with great accuracy.

So the news stories are wrong, and the arctic melting is not happening faster than predicted, simply because the error range is so large?

Is there any size error on the warm side that would indicate an error in the model?
 
So the news stories are wrong, and the arctic melting is not happening faster than predicted, simply because the error range is so large?

Is there any size error on the warm side that would indicate an error in the model?

All the models have errors, that has never been an issue. The IPCC has never claimed they are pefect and error free.
 
All the models have errors, that has never been an issue. The IPCC has never claimed they are pefect and error free.
Yes, I know. That's why I didn't ask if they were perfect. I asked if there was any limit to their imperfection that would show they were wrong. You didn't answer. Which is an answer, in a way.
 
I don't think you're going to get too much action on this thread. The title itself is a thread-killer. I'll give you one post though.

I created this chart from Giss data. According to Hansen they don't know what the true global temperature is within even 1/2 a degree. So I just used his best guess as a starting point and added his anomalies.

Where in this chart do you see the unprecedented warming that worries you so much?
[qimg]http://img179.imageshack.us/img179/2764/globaltemperatureif0.gif[/qimg]

Edit to add: Also, what part of that temperature is due to CO2? What part is the Sun?

Can we get a usable scale, or would that make you seem to much of an [rule 8]
 
So the news stories are wrong, and the arctic melting is not happening faster than predicted, simply because the error range is so large?

Is there any size error on the warm side that would indicate an error in the model?
Yep- if it weren't getting warmer. But it is.
 
Yep- if it weren't getting warmer. But it is.

I'm rather disappointed. You generally read more closely than that. Of course it's getting warmer.
But if it is getting warmer at a rate that is not predicted by the model(s), then perhaps a model that failed to predict is not a good predictor. That doesn't say anything one way or the other about GW, or even AGW, really. It says something about the accuracy of the model, though.

Using a failure of the model to predict as evidence for the conclusions of the model is amusing. It reminds me of Calvin and Hobbes:
"You know how Einstein got poor grades when he was a kid?"
"Yes?"
"Well, mine are even worse!"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom