stanleywinthrop
Scholar
- Joined
- Aug 21, 2007
- Messages
- 121
Been done here before.
There is no gain in breaking water down into it's components just to burn it again. It will take more energy to break it down than it puts out as fuel, no matter the frequency- microwave or infra-red.
What I find odd is the guy Rustom Roy. He's a woo woo wooooo with a degree. It did confound me for a minute until I read his wikipedia article.The thing that cracks me up is that time and time again so-called journalists fall for these claims as being the panacea.
What I find odd is the guy Rustom Roy. He's a woo woo wooooo with a degree. It did confound me for a minute until I read his wikipedia article.
http://blog.wired.com/wiredscience/2007/09/pennsylvania-ma.htmlRustum Roy, a Penn State University chemist, has held demonstrations at his State College lab to confirm his own observations.
The radio frequencies act to weaken the bonds between the elements that make up salt water, releasing the hydrogen, Roy said. Once ignited, the hydrogen will burn as long as it is exposed to the frequencies, he said.
The discovery is "the most remarkable in water science in 100 years," Roy said.
Rustum Roy, a Penn State University (my alma mater!) chemist and expert in water structure, tells the Post-Gazette the guy is not just a nut bar. He says he recreated the phenomenon last week at the university's Materials Research Laboratory in State College.
"It's true, it works," Dr. Roy said. "Everyone told me, 'Rustum, don't be fooled. He put electrodes in there.' "
But there are no electrodes and no gimmicks, he said.
No, we don’t believe it either, but a Penn State chemist found the science to in fact be true; the water itself isn’t burning, just the hydrogen that’s released from it using the radio wave emitter. It’s a pretty crazy notion, we agree, but when you see the simple engine moving at the end of the video below — just from the flame coming from a single test tube of saltwater — you’ll be stunned.
PITTSBURGH — A recent discovery by an Erie, PA, man that saltwater can be "ignited" with a radio-frequency generator has sparked interest in scientific communities, including Penn State University.
Rustum Roy, Ph.D., a chemist at the university and a founding member of its Materials Research Institute, is an expert in water structure.
He tested John Kanzius’ finding, that saltwater will “burn” as long as it is exposed to radio frequencies, and found it to hold true, reported the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on September 9.
Roy said the saltwater does not burn, per se, but as it is exposed to the radio frequency, the bond that holds together its key constituents — such as sodium, chlorine, hydrogen and oxygen — weakens. As this happens, hydrogen is released, and once ignited, burns continuously when exposed to the radio frequency field.
The flame’s temperature was measured at 3,000 F, and is considered an enormous energy output, the article said.
I confess I read the same article (on a comic book forum of all places) today and showed up here to see what you guys thought about it. Can anyone give a more detailed answer as to why they think this won't work?
Is there a detailed analysis out there for me to read about the energy required to break it down contrasted with the energy net gains?
Well, casebro had it in a nutshell.
what's happening here is that water molecules are being broken up into hyrdogen and oxygen which are then re-combining. Breaking up the water molecules takes exactly the same amount of energy as you get back from them reacting (burning) to form water again.
But of course you can never actually break even because you'll always be losing energy in creating the radio waves only a fraction of the energy of which will actually go into breaking the hydrogen-oxygen bonds in the water. And then you can only get a bit of the energy back if you were to try and run a generator off the burning hydrogen. In short, it's a big waste of energy.
Of course if you could break up the water using energy you didn't have to pay the electricity company (solar power, for instance, or microwave energy beamed down from satellites, for a more futuristic option) then you have a ready supply of hydrogen which can be used as fuel.
You might think so, but on FoxNews right now, the article has this little addendum:It's amazing how the story is being reported as if there were free energy via this process. Science just doesn't lend itself to contemporary journalism, it seems.
A correction like that is nearly as remarkable as a working perpetual motion device.[Internet commentary upon Kanzius and Roy's assertion points out that creating fire from salt water is possible by first separating it into hydrogen, oxygen, sodium and chloride, then burning the sodium. However, such a process would consume much more energy than it produces.]