In terms of doubt about their statements about where they were and what they were doing during the tragic events of the 11th of September 2001, I can offer no opinion as I live in another Continent and have never been to New York.
My only source is “Giulianai - Leadership” which he describes the attacks in Part 1 of the book, I therefore can make no comment on Mr Rodreguez.
With regard to the ‘profit’ gained. It comes down to the definition of profit.
I would suggest that prior to those tragic events there was little knowledge outside the U.S. as to the name or political stance of the Mayor of New York however that does not mean he was unknown in Business Circles.
Due to the massive amounts of media exposure generated as a result of the human tragedy that unfolded on that day the mayor gained public recognition but he would already have been guaranteed lecture work and as a speaker at Management and Leadership events because he had been successful in introducing change into complex management systems.
I would argue that his participation in these types of events is based on the leadership skills he displayed over the whole period of his time in office (introducing change into the Police Force for example) not just as a result of the human tragedy of the day. It is, however, inevitable that he would be questioned and asked for his opinions of what happened on that day.
If someone is arguing that there has been financial gain, specifically from 9/11 itself, then that is a job for a Certified Fraud Examiner.