latent aaaack
Muse
- Joined
- Aug 4, 2006
- Messages
- 926
If one believes that:
1. America's democratic process is deteriorating,
2. the US is slowly turning authoritarian,
3. the quality of presidential candidates is getting worse, producing presidents who are increasingly extreme, damaging, and less and less law abiding,
4. that there is no foreseeable event or trend which will cause major change to the election process and will save America's democracy
5. and at a certain point sometime in the not too distant future the country will be stuck with a permanent leader who will be more evil and damaging than the current leaders are
then would the best way to maintain the country's system of government, ability of it's leadership, and potential to change, be to halt the democratic process making a dictator out of whoever's in charge?
That leadership would then either attempt to slowly restore the health of the democratic process or would be fought against in a revolution by rebels who wanted to restore a functioning democracy. In the latter scenario it would be easier to fight against a less evil dictatorship so it would be better if that conflict happened sooner rather than later.
The same reason why it would've been a good thing if Hindenburg turned Germany into a dictatorship before the 1930s and the same reason why it's a good thing Musharraf keeps Pakistan from getting more extreme under an Islamist form of government is increasingly applicable to the US too if the momentum of current politics isn't reversed.
The point of contention I allow is that there's uncertainty about #4, but if the probability of #4 being true is over 60% then my opinion would be not to rely and act on it.
1. America's democratic process is deteriorating,
2. the US is slowly turning authoritarian,
3. the quality of presidential candidates is getting worse, producing presidents who are increasingly extreme, damaging, and less and less law abiding,
4. that there is no foreseeable event or trend which will cause major change to the election process and will save America's democracy
5. and at a certain point sometime in the not too distant future the country will be stuck with a permanent leader who will be more evil and damaging than the current leaders are
then would the best way to maintain the country's system of government, ability of it's leadership, and potential to change, be to halt the democratic process making a dictator out of whoever's in charge?
That leadership would then either attempt to slowly restore the health of the democratic process or would be fought against in a revolution by rebels who wanted to restore a functioning democracy. In the latter scenario it would be easier to fight against a less evil dictatorship so it would be better if that conflict happened sooner rather than later.
The same reason why it would've been a good thing if Hindenburg turned Germany into a dictatorship before the 1930s and the same reason why it's a good thing Musharraf keeps Pakistan from getting more extreme under an Islamist form of government is increasingly applicable to the US too if the momentum of current politics isn't reversed.
The point of contention I allow is that there's uncertainty about #4, but if the probability of #4 being true is over 60% then my opinion would be not to rely and act on it.
Last edited: