StopSylviabrowne - Browne and the Pomeroy-Mason Bridge

Hmmm. Perhaps someone is checking up on you.
 
Interesting article, Robert.

I have always been fascinated yet bothered by"urban legends". Fascinated by the psychology of the people that pass them along, and bothered that they insist on doing so.

And as always, Robert, you prove yourself to be above the fray by asking for and publishing the input of Sylvia's office. This is a case where you seem to exonerate Sylvia of this false prediction. Class act Robert.
 
Lesson: never repeat that something is true unless you really know it's true.

Sounds like this one originated in a chat room.
 
Fair and balanced reporting. Well done.

If Snopes doesn't have a link to your site, they should (IMHO).
 
A bit anticlimactic, but worthwhile to publish all the same. If the trail stopped with just the email, perhaps it's phony, but with other people that had heard that same story it seems well worth the time to research and include on the site.

Also, a typo: 'January f 2004' probably ought to be 'January of 2004'

ETA: I did enjoy the "idiots who watch Montel" quote by the librarian.
 
Another typo: caption for the film poster reads:

Poster for he film "The Mothman Prophecies".

Um, he film? Something for the male audience? :D
 
Hmmm. Perhaps someone is checking up on you.
:boxedin:

I have always been fascinated yet bothered by"urban legends". Fascinated by the psychology of the people that pass them along, and bothered that they insist on doing so.
It's definitely an interesting process.

And as always, Robert, you prove yourself to be above the fray by asking for and publishing the input of Sylvia's office. This is a case where you seem to exonerate Sylvia of this false prediction. Class act Robert.
Thanks, Gray.

Sounds like this one originated in a chat room.
Or while doing some smoking out behind the gym at Pomeroy High...

Fair and balanced reporting. Well done.
Thanks, Fnord.

If Snopes doesn't have a link to your site, they should (IMHO).
The site has been mentioned in the message boards there, but that's it as far as I know.

A bit anticlimactic, but worthwhile to publish all the same.
I know what youmean. I was hoping it would end with a climactic battle between Browne and The Mothman, where we learn that he is in fact a force for good, but I had to go where the evidence took me. :(

Also, a typo: 'January f 2004' probably ought to be 'January of 2004'
Gah! Evidently my spell checker ignores lone letters. Thanks, I will correct it tonight.

ETA: I did enjoy the "idiots who watch Montel" quote by the librarian.
:)

Is it just me, or does the StopSylviaBrowne site just drip with honesty?!
Thanks, Wow.

Poster for he film "The Mothman Prophecies".

Um, he film? Something for the male audience? :D
Double gah! When will someone invent a said-what-I meant-checker? Thanks, will correct it tonight.
 
Great article Robert!

A small thing; the name of the friendly librarian is spelled in two different ways in the article: First as Elita Heighton, and then in her e-mail and subsequently as Olita Heighton.

Also quite fascinating that Linda Rossi still reply to your e-mails! :D
 
That stupid bridge caused me more aggrevation than some of the murder cases. Talk about anticlimactic, there's not even a concrete explanation to be found of how this bizzarre urban legend even started. :(

I almost wished she had predicted a bridge collapse so that I could have at least gotten to the bottom of it and had something to show for digging through those transcripts for about forever.
 
Last edited:
That stupid bridge caused me more aggrevation than some of the murder cases.

Well your aggravation is appreciated. :)

I think that the research done by you, the librarian, not to mention RSL following up to get to the bottom of the rumor adds credibility to the article. And the article itself is good for the site; it helps to address those that might want to attack RSL for not following up on different things.

Getting one email from a crack pot doesn't deserve hours of research, but this one did have something behind it -- though it wasn't Sylvia this time.
 
This then raises a question -- does SB's office retain a record of every single prediction she's ever made? (or at least, in the last several years). Otherwise, how could Rossi unequivocally state that "Sylvia Browne did not make any prediction concerning the bridge over the Ohio River at Pomeroy"?
 
This then raises a question -- does SB's office retain a record of every single prediction she's ever made? (or at least, in the last several years). Otherwise, how could Rossi unequivocally state that "Sylvia Browne did not make any prediction concerning the bridge over the Ohio River at Pomeroy"?

Easy, something that specific would be far to easy to monitor, so she wouldn't make it. She may be scary but I don't think she's that stupid.
 
A bit anticlimactic, but worthwhile to publish all the same. If the trail stopped with just the email, perhaps it's phony, but with other people that had heard that same story it seems well worth the time to research and include on the site.

Also, a typo: 'January f 2004' probably ought to be 'January of 2004'

ETA: I did enjoy the "idiots who watch Montel" quote by the librarian.

On the other hand, librarians really shouldn't express opinions* when answering reference questions.

But I totally agree with her.
 
Great article Robert!
Thanks, chran!

A small thing; the name of the friendly librarian is spelled in two different ways in the article:
Thanks, will correct it tonight.

Also quite fascinating that Linda Rossi still reply to your e-mails! :D
Although this article came out weeks after the previous one quoting Rossi, I believe that the emails I quoted were both sent at about the same time.

I almost wished she had predicted a bridge collapse so that I could have at least gotten to the bottom of it and had something to show for digging through those transcripts for about forever.
The lack of evidence is meaningful as well. Just like the lack of correct missing-persons readings.

Getting one email from a crack pot doesn't deserve hours of research, but this one did have something behind it -- though it wasn't Sylvia this time.
The email wasn't from a crackpot, but from someone who had fallen for a rumor, that's all.

This then raises a question -- does SB's office retain a record of every single prediction she's ever made? (or at least, in the last several years). Otherwise, how could Rossi unequivocally state that "Sylvia Browne did not make any prediction concerning the bridge over the Ohio River at Pomeroy"?
If the rumor was popular enough that Browne's office got multiple calls on it, then Rossi might remember it.
 
This then raises a question -- does SB's office retain a record of every single prediction she's ever made? (or at least, in the last several years). Otherwise, how could Rossi unequivocally state that "Sylvia Browne did not make any prediction concerning the bridge over the Ohio River at Pomeroy"?

Yes, everything she says is catalogued. But, it can also be edited, as one particluar Cardinal in Novus could tell you (he would edit the copies of her Lectures that they sold).
 
The email wasn't from a crackpot, but from someone who had fallen for a rumor, that's all.

Oh, I didn't mean it was. Sorry I wasn't clear.

I was envisioning you getting oddball emails that tell you about some isolated incident, and I wouldn't expect you to follow up on each and every thing. If someone wrote in to tell you that they heard Sylvia has OCD and has to put on her left shoe first, it wouldn't make for a good article; having a couple people point out she has someone put her shoes on for her, might -- even if you find out she flies into a rage when they put on her right shoe first.

In the article you say it wasn't the first time you'd been informed of the bridge prediction and because of that it warrants some investigation, in my opinion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom