StopSylviaBrowne - Email: "Not a Good Woman"

Devastating, simply devastating. Not only does that piece of filth do all she can to ruin a marriage, but she may have been instrumental in a premature death. I truly hope Greg is in a position to sue her.

If the Hornbeck and Sago mine cases weren't bad enough, I'd like to know how her fans could still justify believing she's not a nasty crook after this story.
 
Oh good grief. I feel so choked and angry for that poor man after reading this...

It's the sort of thing that should go on the old "Where's the Harm?" thread (probably archived by now?). A direct impact on a person's life (and death).

RSL, further vindication, if any were necessary, that what you are doing is important and laudable.
 
Is there a law against practising medicine without a licence in the USA? If so why has she not been prosecuted for it?

I've often wondered this myself. As Robert points out in his article, a case could be made that she was speaking metaphorically and that the wife misunderstood. But why didn't she "see" that the woman was suffering from cancer? She frequently gives specific medical advice on Montel, is there a disclaimer after the show that says she may be wrong and that the victi...er, subject should seek qualified medical advice?

I also wonder about her "help" with investigating crimes and missing persons; isn't there a law about providing false evidence in these situations?

Many kudos, Robert. I don't see how any of her followers could still believe in her after reading your website. I'm sure there must be many who don't that you never hear about.

Sasha
 
I don't think this poor fellow could sue SB. He doesn't have a recording of the reading. It's all hearsay. It just makes me cry.
 
I don't think this poor fellow could sue SB. He doesn't have a recording of the reading. It's all hearsay. It just makes me cry.

Like she said. This is one of those major mess-ups like the Seco or Hornback stories that make good soundbites when talking with people we know.

I think it is great that Dr. Dean told this man to get a hold of SSB. I have always loved Dr. Dean, he is a fellow for CSI and gives such good common sense advise.

Good job by the way Lancaster

Susan
 
Oh, that was horrible. The reading, that is. I am sitting here with tears in my eyes. That story is so sad and is one more powerful reason that monsters like Sylvia must be stopped.
I hope Montel reads this. I guess for me hope springs eternal that he will wake up and see the harm his "good friend" is doing.
 
One of the first things Greg's wife must have said to SB was that her marriage was faltering. Maybe asked for advice about her marital problems.

She must have immediatly latched onto that and connected it to the woman's health problems.
 
If Browne had not "diagnosed" the woman's symptoms as from being poisoned by her husband (literally or metaphorically), would the wife have sought medical attention earlier, resulting in an earlier diagnosis of the cancer?

Well said. If she did know, maybe would have gotten treatment sooner. She certainly wouldn't have died under the paranoid delusion that her husband is killing her.

Medical people, could her belief in this delusion, though originating with SB, be partly attributed to liver failure? (I know the accumulated ammonia can cause encephalopathy, but delusions?)

My understanding on the practicing medicine without a license is that she's not prosecuted because authorities don't generally see what she's doing as a big deal. Technically, I suppose offering diagnoses and suggesting treatment with OTC stuff is practicing medicine (don't most OTC adverts do that?), but it's not the same as someone setting up shop in the U.S. to do cosmetic surgery with insufficient credentials from an un-accredited medical school.
 
Disgusting.

So not content to just take this woman's money, Sylvia also ruined her marriage, falsely accused the husband of attempted murder, and possibly delayed or hampered the medical care she needed. That's not just some 13% can't-always-be-right, but absolute contempt and malice for someone she's never even met.

But, it was nice for Dr. Edell to refer Greg to the www.stopsylviabrowne.com site.
 
Unbelievable. I can't imagine the pain and suffering. And it's even more tragic, knowing how she repeats things on her readings, how many more times she might have done the same thing.

This kind of stuff needs to get out for the public to see. Keep it up, Robert!
 
Good article, Robert. And just a horrible story. I plan on pointing to it when believers or fence-sitters ask the old question, "Well, what's the harm?"
 
I can only agree with the earlier posters, it's just horrible! Those poor people, Her believing her husband was poisoning her, and him being accused...And their sons, it must have been very difficult for them too.

I'm so glad they were reconnected before the wifes death, but still, for them to suffer so much...all because of this vile woman.
 
My understanding on the practicing medicine without a license is that she's not prosecuted because authorities don't generally see what she's doing as a big deal. Technically, I suppose offering diagnoses and suggesting treatment with OTC stuff is practicing medicine (don't most OTC adverts do that?), but it's not the same as someone setting up shop in the U.S. to do cosmetic surgery with insufficient credentials from an un-accredited medical school.

It seems like, in general, offering medical advice isn't illegal; if my neighbor complains of a back-ache and I tell him that Aleve works better for me than Tylenol, that's medical advice.

But, "diagnosing or treating" illnesses without a license IS illegal in the state of California. If Sylvia Browne tells someone that they have IBS based on stomach problems, that sounds like a diagnosis to me.

Edited to add: Yes, this situation is absolutely horrible. And the fact that Browne profited off the whole situation makes it even worse.
 
If the Hornbeck and Sago mine cases weren't bad enough, I'd like to know how her fans could still justify believing she's not a nasty crook after this story.
Some will have their eyes opened. Others will simply interpret it as "negativity" which should be ignored.

Oh good grief. I feel so choked and angry for that poor man after reading this...
Same here.

RSL, further vindication, if any were necessary, that what you are doing is important and laudable.
Thanks, DeVega.

Is there a law against practising medicine without a licence in the USA? If so why has she not been prosecuted for it?
There is, and I am pursuing that angle. There are plenty of examples of it on Montel transcripts and clips.

She frequently gives specific medical advice on Montel, is there a disclaimer after the show that says she may be wrong and that the victi...er, subject should seek qualified medical advice?
I don't know if one appears on the show, but there is no such disclaimer on the release form which audience members must sign. There is, however, a clause exonerating Browne, Montel, the producers (etc) from any harm which may befall the audience member as a result of being on the show or getting a reading with Browne.

I also wonder about her "help" with investigating crimes and missing persons; isn't there a law about providing false evidence in these situations?
I believe there is a law against lying in such a report. But, if you tell the police that you have psychically determined something, how can they prove you were just making it up? Besides, prosecuting someone for providing false information may have a chilling effect on other people coming forward with legitimate information.

Many kudos, Robert.
Thanks, Sasha.

I don't think this poor fellow could sue SB. He doesn't have a recording of the reading. It's all hearsay. It just makes me cry.
:(

I think it is great that Dr. Dean told this man to get a hold of SSB. I have always loved Dr. Dean, he is a fellow for CSI and gives such good common sense advise.
I've been a fan of Dr. Dean for years. It really was a thrill for me to hear that he had recommended the site. I first heard about it in an email I received when I was at TAM5, and it was pretty exciting.

Good job by the way Lancaster
Thanks, Susan.

I hope Montel reads this. I guess for me hope springs eternal that he will wake up and see the harm his "good friend" is doing.
I hoipe so too, Minarvia. But I'm not holding my breath.

One of the first things Greg's wife must have said to SB was that her marriage was faltering. Maybe asked for advice about her marital problems.

She must have immediatly latched onto that and connected it to the woman's health problems.
Quite probable.

And as others have mentioned in emails to me today, Browne's attitude towards her ex-husbands makes you wonder if she takes her anger at them out on the husbands of women who come to her for readings...

Well said. If she did know, maybe would have gotten treatment sooner. She certainly wouldn't have died under the paranoid delusion that her husband is killing her.
Well, as Greg said in the email, they were able to reconcile it all in her final days.

Is there a link to the audio/interview?
I hope to put together an audio clip and add it to the site in the coming days.

That's not just some 13% can't-always-be-right, but absolute contempt and malice for someone she's never even met.
Agreed.

This kind of stuff needs to get out for the public to see. Keep it up, Robert!
Thanks, M9B.

Good article, Robert.
Thanks, ORM.

I plan on pointing to it when believers or fence-sitters ask the old question, "Well, what's the harm?"
Indeed.

I'm so glad they were reconnected before the wifes death, but still, for them to suffer so much...all because of this vile woman.
Agreed. It's beyond disgusting.
 
How horrible.

I know of other stories like that too and have heard even more since I left the ministry. For example, a nice man whose wife had been told in a SB lecture 15 years ago that he was a dark entity. Then she filed for divorce. He said to this day he still watches SB on Montel just to try to figure out what kind of person could do something like that. To this day his wife still believes he's evil and his kids sided with their mom until just recently. He believes Sylvia Browne ruined his life because once his wife was convinced he was evil, she refused to even talk to him. It makes me sick.

The only positive part of this is that people like Dean Edell know about Robert's site and are recommending people talk to him.
 
I don't know whether Browne ever puts forth a disclaimer, as many other self-proclaimed soothsayers do, that her pronouncements are "for entertainment purposes only." If she does, one would have to wonder under what circumstances the assertion "Your husband is poisoning you"--whether offered in a literal sense or a figurative sense--could possibly be deemed entertainment.
 
I don't know whether Browne ever puts forth a disclaimer, as many other self-proclaimed soothsayers do, that her pronouncements are "for entertainment purposes only." If she does, one would have to wonder under what circumstances the assertion "Your husband is poisoning you"--whether offered in a literal sense or a figurative sense--could possibly be deemed entertainment.
Sorry, I repeated myself. From an earlier post, which I remembered existed when I was once again tempted to quote from the movie "Gladiator":
I was hoping that there would be a little more discussion about the meaning of "For Entertainment Purposes Only," which some self-proclaimed psychics use as a disclaimer.

Now, in the USA, it is absolutely astonishing what passes for "entertainment." There are live stage shows where ugly men pass themselves off as ugly women, and this is deemed "entertainment" in some circles. There are movies that graphically depict torture, and some folks deem this to be "entertainment." There are television shows that depict genuine footage of people being killed, maimed or seriously hurt, and these are deemed "entertainment" (and footage depicting groin strikes is deemed especially entertaining). There are popular books on the shelves that are written at a fourth-grade level and appeal only to pea-brains, yet they are deemed "entertainment."

So what does it mean, then, for a puffing psychic to say that his blather is for "entertainment purposes only?"

Imagine a doctor or an engineer or an auto mechanic or a baker or a hair stylist trying to qualify his/her work with the words "For Entertainment Purposes Only." What would it mean? For starters, it would clearly be an admission that the opinions provided or the work performed were not reliable.

In the real world, people have to stand behind their work. If they make a mistake, they have to own up to it. If they make a gross blunder that causes serious harm, they have to pay for it. But self-proclaimed psychics, seers and soothsayers demand that they be given a "pass" from the rules by which everyone else has to play. After all, what they said was only "entertainment." It wasn't genuine. It wasn't reliable. It wasn't really informational.

Even so, one has to wonder where the entertainment value lies in a so-called psychic pronouncement that a loved one is dead.

Your child is dead. Your beloved fathers's body is rotting in a ditch. Your dear daughter is overseas and in slavery. Are you not entertained? ARE YOU NOT ENTERTAINED???
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom