StopSylviaBrowne - Montel: Psychic Show Participation Release

I still say at least some of the release is an attempt to hype up her abilities.

"Wow, she must be a real psychic because they give us all sorts of warnings about how powerful the experience might be!"

Sort of like the old-time side-show barker telling people that what's inside the tent is not for the squeamish. "Are you man enough? It's so astounding, we've been banned in 4 counties in this very state. I dunno, kid, you might be too young to go in there. You've got 25 cents? Well, don't tell anyone that I let you in. . . ."

And inside it's just lame and disappointing.
 
I guess I can't say it surprises me that Montel and Sylvia cover their keisters. Very nice to have those documents presented for all to see, too.

I'm no lawyer but I did find one thing interesting with the wording (though, may not have any legal bearing, I admit). In the release forms, multiple times they say they can't be held liable for "information" but yet, doesn't information imply truth or facts? Lies or wild guesses wouldn't seem to be "information". Part 4 just addresses information, though part 5 has something about the appearance and/or information (perhaps that's an out right there).

In any event, interesting read and my thanks to EMM too. (The analysis was a good reminder, too, of her terrible lies.)
 
You're very welcome. :blush:

What I'd like to find out is if the studio guests sign the same document. Too bad we never asked thought to ask Misty Robbins or any other past guests.

Oh, one mistake: the caption under the first photo is wrong.
 
In your "Analysis" section you have:

"Apparently, clauses 4 and 5 of the Release are to protect Sylvia Browne, Montel Williams and others from a lawsuit in cases such as when Browne told Shawn Hornbeck's parents that their missing son was dead when was alive..."

I think you mean "when he was alive".
 
Except for the specific references to Browne and her act, the rest seems pretty standard I would imagine. There may also be more documents involved that have not been posted, since section 5 says:

5. For good and valuable consideration (the receipt and sufficiency of which I hereby acknowledge)


This "consideration" is most likely payment of some kind. And so there could still be non-disclosure or other documents associated with that.
 
Except for the specific references to Browne and her act, the rest seems pretty standard I would imagine. There may also be more documents involved that have not been posted, since section 5 says:

5. For good and valuable consideration (the receipt and sufficiency of which I hereby acknowledge)


This "consideration" is most likely payment of some kind. And so there could still be non-disclosure or other documents associated with that.
I highly doubt that there is any payment flowing to the sitters in the audience. The consideration is just the opportunity to be read by SB, and to appear on national television. The reason this line is here is that a contract without any consideration is not a contract. If you sign a release for something but don't get anything in return, it is arguable that it is not an enforceable contract and therefore not binding.
 
I still say at least some of the release is an attempt to hype up her abilities.
Interesting take on it. I didn't get that at all.

I guess I can't say it surprises me that Montel and Sylvia cover their keisters. Very nice to have those documents presented for all to see, too.
Courtesy of EMM!

In the release forms, multiple times they say they can't be held liable for "information" but yet, doesn't information imply truth or facts?
I don't think so. There is good information and there is bad information. A lie is information. An innocently incorrect statement is information.

What I'd like to find out is if the studio guests sign the same document. Too bad we never asked thought to ask Misty Robbins or any other past guests.
I will try to remember to ask this question of the next guest I communicate with.

Oh, one mistake: the caption under the first photo is wrong.
I'll take a look, thanks!

I think you mean "when he was alive".
Thanks boojum, I'll take a look at that, too.

The reason this line is here is that a contract without any consideration is not a contract.
And the consideration in this case is being allowed to attend the taping, I assume.
 
It's really a pretty tame contract. Penn and Teller on one of their shows claimed that John Edward's release contract effectively bound the audience to secrecy; but to me this just looks like your standard "shall not be held liable" contract.
 
I wonder, could you sign the document with a pseudonym, and still be held accountable? Especially if they didn't check it too closely.
 
In the release forms, multiple times they say they can't be held liable for "information" but yet, doesn't information imply truth or facts?
I don't think so. There is good information and there is bad information. A lie is information. An innocently incorrect statement is information.


To me, it is the word "reveal" which is understood to mean truth (albeit including "divinely inspired" and perceived truth). It would require convincing evidence that she knows what she is saying is false/made-up and not from a supernatural being or real-world source (which I understand to be the case), but one could certainly argue that she is knowingly not "revealing" anything. To "reveal" knowingly false information is an absurd/nonsense statement.

eta: Of course, if there was evidence of her knowingly making up stuff, I would hope it would be used to prove criminal fraud. However, for the paid readings, she similarly makes no promises and people can get "compensated" by just getting their money back.
 
Last edited:
so this would not account for the lack of reports of bad readings from those who have attended tapings. I would imagine this lack can mostly be accounted for by the fact that most people who attend such tapings are fans of Browne.

This is speculation. You do not have any evidence to back this statement up. Any other explanation would be equally valid.

Difficult but possible, how about you go after the people who have appeared on the show, interview them and then put the results on your web site? Problem - how do you find them?
 
I don't think so. There is good information and there is bad information. A lie is information. An innocently incorrect statement is information.
I had checked a couple online dictionaries, and here and there "fact" and "knowledge" is peppered in a few entries, that sort of thing. I'd also just read an article in which Richard Dawkins talks about information reducing what was previously unknown or something along those lines (and following that, I was thinking the Sylvia does nothing to achieve that; her guesses don't convey any sort of fact or anything like that...) But anyways, I do agree that as far as trying to get legal about the release form, it's probably a big dead end.
 
It's really a pretty tame contract. Penn and Teller on one of their shows claimed that John Edward's release contract effectively bound the audience to secrecy; but to me this just looks like your standard "shall not be held liable" contract.
Links to the John Edward four-page release form are in the "Related Links" section of the article. I didn't notice the non-disclosure stuff, but I couldn't read more than a couple of paragraphs in it without falling asleep...

I wonder, could you sign the document with a pseudonym, and still be held accountable? Especially if they didn't check it too closely.
I don't know. I would think a judge would frown on that as having been done in bad faith. Is there a lawyer in the thread?

To "reveal" knowingly false nformation is an absurd/nonsense statement.
Perhaps so. I would givce it a thought, but my head is getting ready to explode...

This is speculation. You do not have any evidence to back this statement up.
Yes, which is why I said "I would imagine that..." rather than "It must be that..."

Difficult but possible, how about you go after the people who have appeared on the show, interview them and then put the results on your web site? Problem - how do you find them?
If I knew how, I would have done so months ago.

But anyways, I do agree that as far as trying to get legal about the release form, it's probably a big dead end.
Probably so.
 
I highly doubt that there is any payment flowing to the sitters in the audience. The consideration is just the opportunity to be read by SB, and to appear on national television. The reason this line is here is that a contract without any consideration is not a contract. If you sign a release for something but don't get anything in return, it is arguable that it is not an enforceable contract and therefore not binding.


It's possible.

When I went through training as a video production assistant, our instructor would get paid a certain amount per person for putting our bodies in studio seats. It seems the studios do not want empty seats to be seen on camera. They do this for the Emmy and Oscar Awards shows, as well.

You may have seen me in the audience on "Funniest Home Videos" and "Wheel of Fortune." (Did you know that none of those stars is taller than 5'6"? I'm 6'0", and the top of Vanna's head only came up to my nose, and she was in heels!)

When I found out that he was being paid for our services, and passing none of it along to his students ... well, the school administrators weren't pleased at all, to say the least.
 
This is speculation. You do not have any evidence to back this statement up. Any other explanation would be equally valid.

Difficult but possible, how about you go after the people who have appeared on the show, interview them and then put the results on your web site? Problem - how do you find them?

Take the A train to Columbus Circle and 59th Street and walk a few avenues over and a few blocks down.

There are a-plenty of them lining up every day of the week every few weeks or so outside a cheapie TV studio in Hell's Kitchen, waiting for hours to talk to a cold-reader. :mad:

The problem isn't finding them, because I could do that in 25 minutes, it's finding an appropriate way and time to talk to them about it. Assaulting them as they are leave the studio obviously isn't the right way to go.

Edit: I'm also pretty surprised we haven't had any former audience members come forward, with Robert's site up for so long and all. I agree that the majority must have been SB fans to start with and remained so even after seeing her.

It was very sad how many of "my" audience seemed disappointed but accepting. The most depressing part was as we were filing out. No one seemed happy at all, just downcast and downbeat and as soon as they could, they began discussing their readings among themselves and were already shoehorning and retrofitting. Which is, of course, how cold-reading works if you are not aware there is such a thing.

I wonder, could you sign the document with a pseudonym, and still be held accountable? Especially if they didn't check it too closely.

Drat, why didn't I think of signing it "Anna Banana"? :D. Now that I've violated number 2 and the form's on the site, Montel has a case for suing me!

It's possible.

When I went through training as a video production assistant, our instructor would get paid a certain amount per person for putting our bodies in studio seats. It seems the studios do not want empty seats to be seen on camera. They do this for the Emmy and Oscar Awards shows, as well.

You may have seen me in the audience on "Funniest Home Videos" and "Wheel of Fortune." (Did you know that none of those stars is taller than 5'6"? I'm 6'0", and the top of Vanna's head only came up to my nose, and she was in heels!)

When I found out that he was being paid for our services, and passing none of it along to his students ... well, the school administrators weren't pleased at all, to say the least.

Sadly, that's not the case with Sylvia Browne shows. The problem isn't filling seats, it's keeping the studio from imploding.

The other Montel shows I've been to delibrately overbook to have full capacity and call you a dozen times beforehand to make sure you're coming but for the Sylvia Browne ones, they have to add extra rows of seats and cram audience members onto the floor and stage to fit everyone into the studio.

They have plenty of audience members to choose from, too. :(
 
Last edited:
I'm also pretty surprised we haven't had any former audience members come forward, with Robert's site up for so long and all.

Actually, I did hear from an audience member a month or two ago.

She described the studio as filthy, most of the audience as looking homeless, and most of the people working the show as looking little better than that.

She wasn't happy with the experience, and the friend she had convinced to come with her was disgusted and furious to have wasted a day sitting in a disgusting room, with digusting people, in a seedy neighborhood.

But I paraphrase.
 
Mhhmm, I think that person's guilty of hyperbole. :confused:

That stretch of Hell's Kitchen is pretty seedy and disgusting and I was very surprisedat where the studio was located and what it looked like the first time I went to a taping- you should see it, it looks like an abandoned warehouse from the outside, you'd never guess it was Montel's studio- but then again, The Daily Show and The Colbert Report both have their studios a few blocks away. Same neighborhood and they look almost as shabby from the outside. You'd never think two of the most popular shows on cable were taped there if it wasn't for the three story ads out front. So go figure.

The studio's not too impressive on the inside, either, but not filthy at all and the staff looked perfectly presentable to me. There were a few first-class weirdos in the audience, to be sure, but I really don't know what she's talking about. Unless the disgusting homeless person she had to sit in a room with for hours was Sylvia Browne :D.

All in all, though, it is a very depressing, time-wasting and unpleasant experience I'm very sorry I spent so much time on.
 
Last edited:
Actually, I did hear from an audience member a month or two ago.

She described the studio as filthy, most of the audience as looking homeless, and most of the people working the show as looking little better than that.

She wasn't happy with the experience, and the friend she had convinced to come with her was disgusted and furious to have wasted a day sitting in a disgusting room, with digusting people, in a seedy neighborhood.

But I paraphrase.

As EMM said, the building itself you wouldn't recognize as a TV studio from the outside. It looks like a storefront and it's on a narrow side street. When you walk in, the waiting area is small and most of the people have to stand until they're allowed into the studio. There are a few wooden benches for the first 30 or so people into the room. After that, we all stood in a line for a very long time. It wasn't dirty - just small and crowded.

On the day that I went, the people were nicely dressed and were a friendly group of people (you have a lot of time to talk to each other while you're waiting in the line). The bathrooms are a joke though. There are only 2 so you can imagine the line to use it. Knowing that once you've gone through the metal detector and entered the studio, if you have to leave to go to the bathroom, you won't be allowed to return, most of the line is attempting to get into the bathroom.

I've been a couple of times and the studio was never dirty - and while cramped in the waiting area, that area wasn't dirty either. The benches were very old and the room could have used some painting or sprucing up which certainly gives a less than favorable impression.

ST
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom