In all fairness, I think these questions needed to be asked.
One who authentically has a successful record can always support it with specifics. Atheletes do it. Professionals such as doctors and lawyers do it. Building contractors do it. Salesmen do it. They don't just have testimonials from satisfied clients; they also have objective records, statistics, profits or other documentation to back up their claims.
A baseball player can show how many base hits he got. A surgeon can discuss documented morbidity and mortality figures. A sales representative can show how many sales were made and how many commissions were earned. Shoot, I can point to cases I've won, patents I've drafted, articles I've authored, grades I received, crosswords I've constructed. It is not difficult for me to substantiate any of my claimed accomplishments with objective evidence.
Those who claim to be psychic ought to be able to do something comparable.
Indeed, if they really were instrumental in breaking open a particular case, you'd expect them to not let the public forget it. They'd trumpet their specific or objective successes (especially if they had a lot of them), and wouldn't speak in generalities, unverifiable puffery or shameless doubletalk.
For goodness's sake, when I was very successful as a psychic in 2002 (
correctly predicting, for example, that the Washington DC sniper would be "a perpetrator found asleep," which was exactly how he was caught),
and by golly, I'm going to trumpet that success!
Certainly anyone who authentically had extensive experience and a long and distinguished record of success as a psychic could provide comparable verifiable details.