StopSylviaBrowne - Scorecard: Missing/Homicide Readings & Open Letter to Browne

RSLancastr

www.StopSylvia.com
Joined
Sep 7, 2001
Messages
17,135
Location
Salem, Oregon
Just keeps getting better and better!

Excellent summary. Excellent challenge!

(Minor typo in the note to Linda before the letter to SB where you said "Thanks you". Since you're quoting a letter you sent out, probably best to leave it as is with a [sic] lest you be accused of posting a different e-mail than what you sent.)
 
Ouch!

I doubt you're expecting a reply from SB to your open letter.
 
Just keeps getting better and better!

Excellent summary. Excellent challenge!
Thanks, Joe!

(Minor typo in the note to Linda before the letter to SB where you said "Thanks you". Since you're quoting a letter you sent out, probably best to leave it as is with a [sic] lest you be accused of posting a different e-mail than what you sent.)
Yes, I noticed it, but in keeping with my policy of publishing emails as-is, I left it in. I also have made it a policy to not use "sic", as it is easily misinterpreted as mocking the author. Since I do this with incoming emails I publish, I also feel I have to do so with the outgoing.
 
Robert: maybe you should consider sending a new open letter to Montel...formally pointing out this record of achievement and asking him whether there is something missing in his opinion and if not, why he continues to support this liar and fraud.
 
Minor typo in the Scorecard page - "If you are aware of any missing person of murder case ...".
 
I wonder if there is a way you could extend the same invitation to Montel or his managers? Perhaps they would be interested in knowing about the effort that your web site will be hosting?
 
I think the letter to the ministers is a brilliant idea. If only this makes one of them think about where the evidence is, it's been worthwhile.
 
Two more excellent articles - the "score card" in particular is absolutely devastating. It doesn't matter how often I read Browne's sickening Opal Jo Jennings fantasy, it still makes my blood boil. :mad:

And I agree with the other posters that an open letter should be sent to Montel Williams, without whose collusion Sylvia would be a much poorer woman.
 
In the year this site has been open to the public, I have made that invitation multiple times on this site, as well as in Sylvia Browne-friendly web forums, and in replies to dozens of people who have emailed me and accused me of ignoring "all the cases she got right."

I am not ignoring them. I cannot find any.

The format, succinctness, and implication of the last two lines is the best thing I've read on SSB all year.
 
Last edited:
I'd be shocked if Sylvia responded, especially since all of their previous responses have been dismal.

Should they respond, it will be to the effect that she has to keep everthing confidential since she is dealing with sensitive information that is given only to her clients. Or they will send unverifiable cases.

One must smile when they realize that not even Sylvia Browne or her staff will be able to produce cases that she got right :)
 
In all fairness, I think these questions needed to be asked.

One who authentically has a successful record can always support it with specifics. Atheletes do it. Professionals such as doctors and lawyers do it. Building contractors do it. Salesmen do it. They don't just have testimonials from satisfied clients; they also have objective records, statistics, profits or other documentation to back up their claims.

A baseball player can show how many base hits he got. A surgeon can discuss documented morbidity and mortality figures. A sales representative can show how many sales were made and how many commissions were earned. Shoot, I can point to cases I've won, patents I've drafted, articles I've authored, grades I received, crosswords I've constructed. It is not difficult for me to substantiate any of my claimed accomplishments with objective evidence.

Those who claim to be psychic ought to be able to do something comparable.

Indeed, if they really were instrumental in breaking open a particular case, you'd expect them to not let the public forget it. They'd trumpet their specific or objective successes (especially if they had a lot of them), and wouldn't speak in generalities, unverifiable puffery or shameless doubletalk.

For goodness's sake, when I was very successful as a psychic in 2002 (correctly predicting, for example, that the Washington DC sniper would be "a perpetrator found asleep," which was exactly how he was caught), and by golly, I'm going to trumpet that success!

Certainly anyone who authentically had extensive experience and a long and distinguished record of success as a psychic could provide comparable verifiable details.
 
Last edited:
Great articles, Robert! Will be interesting to see what happens, although I have a feeling this can only go the way of the master's degree in English that wasn't.
 
Just repeating what everyone else has already said. Great article. Keep up the good work.
 
Maybe all those posters on GSB who said that all the cases are she's solved that are too numerous to list will actually step up and produce one. Or two.

Or not. :D

Great letter! I'll bet her circle are cringing as we post.
 
Robert, I hate to add just another ditto to what everyone else is saying, but...

Outstanding work! You do a fabulous job of maintaining a climate of fairness, objectivity and civility on SSB. It must be tough, considering that Sylvia is, well, Sylvia.
 
Last edited:
Yes! Just the article I've been waiting for. :)

If I have one complaint, it's that after all my hard work and countless hours, you didn't use my list of homicide/ missing persons case that have never been solved. :(

I believe publishing the full list (which I believe would come out to over a hundred cases, actually) under the "Unknown" heading would be absolutely devastating, even more so than the ones she got hopeless wrong.

Also, I think it would be fair to list Terrence Farrell as a missing person. And update the Weyman Robbins article with what Mrs. Robbins told us.

Edit: Thank you for giving QG and me and the others credit. I really appreciate it.
 
Last edited:
Will you be organizing your articles on the "articles page" according to subject rather than date? The "articles page" is really long and reorganizing it might make it easier to read.

Also you might consider putting the two Hornbeck articles together on your "scorecard". You listed the two articles separately, thereby counting one case twice.
 
Last edited:
Great article! Perhaps you could print a copies of your open letters and send them by registered mail. Either you get a receipt signed by Sylvia Browne, or a 'refused' receipt from her office. Either way, you'll get an interesting item for your files.
 
Richard Kneebone

If anyone has access to the Mercury News archive, I did a key word search and came up with the following abstract:

TITLE: NO CLUES IN HOLLISTER MAN'S DISAPPEARANCE
AUTHOR: JACK FOLEY
SOURCE: San Jose Mercury News
DATE: July 6, 1990

ABSTRACT:
The disappearance of a 26-year-old Hollister man two weeks ago has police and relatives worried and baffled. Richard Kneebone was last seen leaving Don Pedro's tavern around midnight June 22, several hours after telling his wife and sister he was going for a walk. He had suffered a concussion and neck sprain earlier in the day and was on medication, according to his family and authorities.

[FROM THE SEARCH]
... they consulted well-known psychic Sylvia Brown for help. ...

The next day on July 7th:

TITLE: BODY FOUND IN HOLLISTER IS IDENTIFIED CORONER SAYS MAN DIED OF BROKEN NECK, INJURIES TO HEAD
AUTHOR: JACK FOLEY
SOURCE: San Jose Mercury News
PUBLISHED: July 11, 1990, Page 1B,

A body discovered in a vacant Hollister lot July 7 has been identified as that of Richard Kneebone, who was reported missing June 22 by his family.
...

Search: http://www.mercurynews.com/archivesearch

I don't know if/or how this might be linked to Sylvia Browne, just something I found.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom