Amateur Hour, Continued
Continued: Havana syndrome: Sonic attacks or all in the mind? (The Sunday Times, Jan 22, 2023)
Robert Bartholomew needs no introduction to people who have been following this thread:
That is true, at first sight - pun not intended - and the article has already mentioned typical MPI symptoms:
So why aren't bleeding eyes mentioned in this context? The question is important because the case of one agent/diplomat, Karen Coats, who was mentioned yesterday (see previous post), suffered from retinal hemorrhage and this one case appears to be Nicky Woolf's argument for dismissing MPI:
But what she was allegedly told was a lie. And a very obvious one:
Now, I can't say who's lying: Karen Coats, "they" (the medical research team, I assume), or Nicky Woolf, but it would have been as easy for Woolf, the author of this piece, to look it up as it was for me.
But that's just one thing. The other thing is the question of mass psychogenic illness: Hypertension may have a psychological component, but I seriously doubt that "retinal vein occlusion (a blockage of a retinal vein), anemia, leukemia or diabetes" are psychosomatic.
So it does seem unlikely that her retinal bleeding was caused by mass psychogenic illness.
But it's not at all unlikely that some of the 'Havana Syndrome' sufferers had other ailments that were in no way due to MPI.
I have mentioned the very serious widespread case of MPI in Denmark that took place in 2015 in girls who had been vaccinated against HPV. What convinced the Danish doctor Jesper Mehlsen that the girls' problems were something other than MPI was the fact that some of them had real physiological symptoms, e.g. mitochondrial dysfunction, but he was criticized for lacking a control group in his studies.
Mehlsen never succeeded in documenting that the ailments that the girls complained about had anything to do with the vaccines. It was sometimes difficult to find a group of unvaccinated girls in Denmark large enough to make a proper comparison of vaccinated and unvaccinated girls, but whenever other medical research teams carried out studies, there was no difference in the percentage of reported ailments in the two groups.
Besides, many of the 'HPV girls' turned out to have visited doctors before they had actually been vaccinated complaining about the same symptoms that they later ascribed to the vaccines.
In a group of people suffering from the same symptoms, it is highly likely that one or more of them may suffer from other things completely unrelated to whatever they may have in common. That individuals in the 'Havana Syndrome' group ascribe each and every one of their symptoms to having been attacked doesn't prove their point. And I haven't seen Baloh, Bartholomew or anybody else advocating the MPI explanation claim that retinal bleeding was caused by MPI.
I don't know how long it takes to edit a podcast series - the next episode will appear on Monday, I assume - but Nicky Woolf's article in The Sunday Times based on his investigations for the podcast - leaves a lot to be desired.
I assume that he still has time to make up for it, and I think that he should.
Continued: Havana syndrome: Sonic attacks or all in the mind? (The Sunday Times, Jan 22, 2023)
Robert Bartholomew needs no introduction to people who have been following this thread:
Havana syndrome is “a classic outbreak of mass psychogenic illness. Standard. Textbook,” says Robert Bartholomew, a medical sociologist at Auckland University and one of the world’s leading experts on mass delusions. Suggestibility can cause powerful physical symptoms.
(...)
On closer scrutiny, it was clear there were parts of the story the psychogenic hypothesis could not explain. Yes, the power of suggestion could feasibly be responsible for headaches, nausea and dizziness — but it can’t make you bleed inside your eyes.
That is true, at first sight - pun not intended - and the article has already mentioned typical MPI symptoms:
Diplomats, not just CIA agents, started to have the same symptoms. Nausea, dizziness, cognitive issues and insomnia.
So why aren't bleeding eyes mentioned in this context? The question is important because the case of one agent/diplomat, Karen Coats, who was mentioned yesterday (see previous post), suffered from retinal hemorrhage and this one case appears to be Nicky Woolf's argument for dismissing MPI:
That afternoon Karen Coats started seeing black spots. She was sent to Miami, where a doctor found that her retina was bleeding. She was told they’d “only ever seen this when somebody has a trauma to their head, like a car accident”.
But what she was allegedly told was a lie. And a very obvious one:
In older children and adults, retinal hemorrhage can be caused by several medical conditions such as hypertension, retinal vein occlusion (a blockage of a retinal vein), anemia, leukemia or diabetes.
(...)
In adults, retinal hemorrhages are largely spontaneous, secondary to chronic medical conditions such as hypertension.
Retinal hemorrhage (Wikipedia)
Now, I can't say who's lying: Karen Coats, "they" (the medical research team, I assume), or Nicky Woolf, but it would have been as easy for Woolf, the author of this piece, to look it up as it was for me.
But that's just one thing. The other thing is the question of mass psychogenic illness: Hypertension may have a psychological component, but I seriously doubt that "retinal vein occlusion (a blockage of a retinal vein), anemia, leukemia or diabetes" are psychosomatic.
So it does seem unlikely that her retinal bleeding was caused by mass psychogenic illness.
But it's not at all unlikely that some of the 'Havana Syndrome' sufferers had other ailments that were in no way due to MPI.
I have mentioned the very serious widespread case of MPI in Denmark that took place in 2015 in girls who had been vaccinated against HPV. What convinced the Danish doctor Jesper Mehlsen that the girls' problems were something other than MPI was the fact that some of them had real physiological symptoms, e.g. mitochondrial dysfunction, but he was criticized for lacking a control group in his studies.
Mehlsen never succeeded in documenting that the ailments that the girls complained about had anything to do with the vaccines. It was sometimes difficult to find a group of unvaccinated girls in Denmark large enough to make a proper comparison of vaccinated and unvaccinated girls, but whenever other medical research teams carried out studies, there was no difference in the percentage of reported ailments in the two groups.
Besides, many of the 'HPV girls' turned out to have visited doctors before they had actually been vaccinated complaining about the same symptoms that they later ascribed to the vaccines.
In a group of people suffering from the same symptoms, it is highly likely that one or more of them may suffer from other things completely unrelated to whatever they may have in common. That individuals in the 'Havana Syndrome' group ascribe each and every one of their symptoms to having been attacked doesn't prove their point. And I haven't seen Baloh, Bartholomew or anybody else advocating the MPI explanation claim that retinal bleeding was caused by MPI.
I don't know how long it takes to edit a podcast series - the next episode will appear on Monday, I assume - but Nicky Woolf's article in The Sunday Times based on his investigations for the podcast - leaves a lot to be desired.
I assume that he still has time to make up for it, and I think that he should.