Cont: The One Covid-19 Science and Medicine Thread Part 5

Going to a vacation ? Wear a mask. Covid on a hotel sucks. Airplane is relatively well ventilated though, and there is only a handful of people sitting around you. Visit to a shopping mall is probably worse.
Define the highlighted.

From memory, don't hold me to it. Typically planes exchange half of the air that circulates (per hour I believe). For comparison hospital EDs typically have 10 air exchanges/hour in the US. Planes have an issue keeping the plane warm at high altitude. It's common they run the reused air through HEPA filters as well. It's unclear what that does do the risk of spreading viral pathogens.
 
Last edited:
Define the highlighted.

From memory, don't hold me to it. Typically planes exchange half of the air that circulates (per hour I believe). For comparison hospital EDs typically have 10 air exchanges/hour in the US. Planes have an issue keeping the plane warm at high altitude. It's common they run the reused air through HEPA filters as well. It's unclear what that does do the risk of spreading viral pathogens.

I think you are about right. That's what I mean by "relatively". It certainly not better then hospital ED. Why would it be ? But I hear it's better than busses or trains, which might turn off ventilation completely in cold weather.

As for traveling, I'd be more afraid of crowded departure and arrival halls, where you can get stuck for hours, with people from all over the world.
 
17 million people died of Covid vaccine according to anti-vaxx crank, Bret Weinstein, talking to Tucker Carlson about a "conference" he attended in Romania. The conference was full of fellow cranks such as Robert Malone, Pier Kory, and a bunch of disgraced doctors, academics and alternative medicine grifters.

 
Going to a vacation ? Wear a mask. Covid on a hotel sucks. Airplane is relatively well ventilated though, and there is only a handful of people sitting around you. Visit to a shopping mall is probably worse.
I think you are about right. That's what I mean by "relatively". It certainly not better then hospital ED. Why would it be ? But I hear it's better than busses or trains, which might turn off ventilation completely in cold weather.

As for traveling, I'd be more afraid of crowded departure and arrival halls, where you can get stuck for hours, with people from all over the world.


This is the Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology sub-forum, and Paul2 asked for "authoritative information" not hearsay. And don't mention being afraid! The panicking minimizers will accuse you of panicking.

As for airplanes:
The study estimates that from mid-2020 through early 2021, the probability of getting Covid-19 on an airplane surpassed 1 in 1,000 on a totally full flight lasting two hours at the height of the early pandemic, roughly December 2020 and January 2021. It dropped to about 1 in 6,000 on a half-full two-hour flight when the pandemic was at its least severe, in the summer of 2020. The overall risk of transmission from June 2020 through February 2021 was about 1 in 2,000, with a mean of 1 in 1,400 and a median of 1 in 2,250.
Friendly skies? Study charts Covid-19 odds for plane flights (MIT News, July 28, 2022)
However:
As Barnett readily notes, pandemic circumstances and airline policies keep evolving, meaning that their estimates for the 2020-2021 period in the study may not translate precisely to the summer of 2022. Even despite the availability of vaccines, he believes the reduced amount of masking, the more-crowded flights, and easy transmissibility of current variants all mean that risks could have increased.
“If we were to do an estimate of the chances of infection now, it could be considerably higher,” Barnett says.


This article from Reader's Digest was better than I expected and refers to experts and studies and links to sources:
In a study published in Environmental Science & Technology, Zhe Peng and other researchers at the University of Colorado at Boulder developed a mathematical model calculating the different factors that contribute to the level of risk for COVID-19 in different settings. These included:
Viral factors: transmissibility and prevalence
Human factors: mask use, movement and conversation level
Air-quality factors: room size, occupancy and ventilation levels
8 Places You’re Most Likely to Catch Coronavirus (Mar 14, 2023)


The 8 places mentioned are:
Bars and restaurants
Gyms and fitness centers
Places with high air pollution
Schools
Planes, trains and cruises
Crowded beaches and pools
Sporting events, festivals and religious services
Indoor social gatherings

The article also offers advice about protection.

My reservations:
Public pools may also be more problematic than people realize, says Dr. Horovitz. “When you are swimming, you are often breathing heavily, and your risk of catching COVID-19 depends on how close you are to someone who is not vaccinated,” he explains.


Dr. Horovitz doesn't seem to be aware that vaccination only to some degree protects against transmitting and getting infected by the virus.
I don't think that you are likely to get infected at beaches. The risk will be bigger at beach-adjacent restaurants or on public transport to and from the beach. After a large BLM demonstration (15,000) in Copenhagen, people were encouraged to get tested because one participant had been tested positive immediately after.
Four other protesters turned out to be positive, but the infections might have occurred somewhere else.
Since such protests are more crowded than beaches and since participants usually sing and yell a lot, I don't think beaches and other outdoor places are the venues of super-spreader events.
I don't think actual studies have been made of those places.

As for outdoor sporting events, I would also be more concerned about public transport to and from those places, but I also haven't seen any actual studies of the risk of transmission at those venues.
 
17 million people died of Covid vaccine according to anti-vaxx crank, Bret Weinstein, talking to Tucker Carlson about a "conference" he attended in Romania. The conference was full of fellow cranks such as Robert Malone, Pier Kory, and a bunch of disgraced doctors, academics and alternative medicine grifters.



David Pakman is usually reliable, but in this video the mentions that the the total C19 death toll is 6-7 million. However, that is the confirmed death toll. There is reason to assume that the actual death toll is much higher. (It's 1.2 million in the USA alone!)

This is from 2022:
We estimate 14.83 million excess deaths globally, 2.74 times more deaths than the 5.42 million reported as due to COVID-19 for the period.
The WHO estimates of excess mortality associated with the COVID-19 pandemic (PubMed)


It's probably where the covidiots in the Pakman video get their 17 million alleged vaccine deaths from: Excess deaths all caused by the vaccines!
 
This is the Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology sub-forum, and Paul2 asked for "authoritative information" not hearsay. And don't mention being afraid! The panicking minimizers will accuse you of panicking.

Yeah, and I added my 2 cents. Does it offend you ? Good.
 
The effect of Pfizer-BioNTech's C19 BNT162b2 on children and teens

High vaccine protection against moderate and severe Covid in children and teens throughout the pandemic
https://acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326...240109_1&utm_content=1&cmp=1&utm_medium=email @chenyong1203
And lower risk of cardiac complications among the vaccinated group during Omicron periods
The analysis showed a lower risk for cardiac complications in the vaccinated group during the Omicron variant period.
(...)
Conclusion: The study suggests that BNT162b2 was effective for various COVID-19-related outcomes in children and adolescents during the Delta and Omicron periods, and there is some evidence of waning effectiveness over time.
Eric Topol (X, Jan 8, 2024)

BNT162b2 was Pfizer-BioNTech's first COVID-19 vaccine.

X thread:
Annals of Internal Medicine just published our epidemiological study of vaccine effectiveness in children and teens during the delta and omicron waves based on large USA pediatric cohorts accounting for nearly 4% of the USA pediatric population.
The study found strong vaccine effectiveness vs. infection, severe disease, and ICU during the delta wave for adolescents and the omicron wave for children and adolescents, with no evidence of increased risk of cardiac outcomes.
Senior authors are Yong Chen, Christopher Forrest, and Jeffrey S Morris, and Lead authors are Qiong Wu and Jiayi (Jesse) Tong.
#PEDSNet #COVID_19 #COVIDVaccine @ChildrensPhila @UPennDBEI @PennMedicine
https://acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M23-1754
Prof Jeffrey S Morris (X, Jan 8, 2024)


They study:
Results:
During the Delta period, the estimated effectiveness of the BNT162b2 vaccine was 98.4% (95% CI, 98.1% to 98.7%) against documented infection among adolescents, with no statistically significant waning after receipt of the first dose. An analysis of cardiac complications did not suggest a statistically significant difference between vaccinated and unvaccinated groups. During the Omicron period, the effectiveness against documented infection among children was estimated to be 74.3% (CI, 72.2% to 76.2%). Higher levels of effectiveness were seen against moderate or severe COVID-19 (75.5% [CI, 69.0% to 81.0%]) and ICU admission with COVID-19 (84.9% [CI, 64.8% to 93.5%]). Among adolescents, the effectiveness against documented Omicron infection was 85.5% (CI, 83.8% to 87.1%), with 84.8% (CI, 77.3% to 89.9%) against moderate or severe COVID-19, and 91.5% (CI, 69.5% to 97.6%) against ICU admission with COVID-19. The effectiveness of the BNT162b2 vaccine against the Omicron variant declined 4 months after the first dose and then stabilized. The analysis showed a lower risk for cardiac complications in the vaccinated group during the Omicron variant period.
Real-World Effectiveness of BNT162b2 against Infection and Severe Diseases in Children and Adolescents (Annals of Internal Medicine, Jan 9, 2024)
 
I want to start exploring "long covid", so if anyone thinks it deserves its own thread, feel free to ask the mods to split it off, but as there isn'y much happening on the covid front I thought it may as well go here.

I said many months ago I was disturbed by the similarity between long covid and ME/CFS, a disease with only symptoms that no test can identify. As time has gone on, I'm sure the two diseases are in fact the same thing.

Some people, for unknown reasons, develop a range of symptoms after a viral infection. No treatments exist for either syndrome, and in the case of long covid, I believe the numbers have been wildly overstated.

Claims around the number of long covid cases aren't borne out by reality. We're surrounded by claims that somewhere between 3 and 20% of covid cases result in long covid, yet if that were the case, we'd be seeing vast increases in sick leave and absenteeism, along with corresponding pressure on health systems, because pretty well everyone has had covid.

I participated in a study of sick leave for one of my customers recently, and it was starkly noticeable that sick leave and absenteeism hasn't increased at all. If a significant percentage of people were suffering from long covid, we would have seen an increase, yet there is none.

I was compelled to talk to doctors to see if I was missing something, and while they all mentioned having patients with long covid, it didn't appear to be any more then they were already seeing with ME/CFS.
 
BNT162b2 was Pfizer-BioNTech's first COVID-19 vaccine.
... https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M23-1754

During the Delta period, the estimated effectiveness of the BNT162b2 vaccine was 98.4% (95% CI, 98.1% to 98.7%) against documented infection among adolescents...

Huh! In the 2021 summer P-Town Delta breakout, 75% were vaccinated. And the median time since their vaccination was just under 3 months. And that clarified the need for boosters which came out a few months later.

Really hard to believe there is such a fundamental difference between adolescents and middle aged men. But if so, this really needs to be looked into.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
No idea. It’s probably useless for us to just spit-ball our opinions. What does the research into Long Covid say? Is there much research into it? I wanted to hear what they said about it on The Studies Show which is, in my useless opinion, a usually pretty entertaining examination of the evidence for a number of scientific issues. But apart from the opening 11 minutes, it is paywalled.

https://www.thestudiesshowpod.com/p/paid-only-episode-2-long-covid
 
Planigale probably knows more about long covid than anybody else in this thread:
FWIW my personal experience of assessing patients with long covid is most have a syndrome that is either due to mitochondrial dysfunction or autonomic neuropathy (the two aren't mutually exclusive). I slightly favour autonomic neuropathy as the predominant lesion in most people I have assessed, but except in a research situation we don't have the tests to distinguish the two in routine clinical practice*. To some extent it is irrelevant because we don't have treatments for either syndrome.

*The consequence of either are quite similar, decreased muscle efficiency, i.e. muscles do less work than you would expect for delivered oxygen.


I hope that most people reading this are aware that neither mitochondrial dysfunction nor autonomic neuropathy is psychogenic or just 'in the head' as The Atheist implies.
 
Last edited:
Claims around the number of long covid cases aren't borne out by reality. We're surrounded by claims that somewhere between 3 and 20% of covid cases result in long covid, yet if that were the case, we'd be seeing vast increases in sick leave and absenteeism, along with corresponding pressure on health systems, because pretty well everyone has had covid.

(a) we are seeing increases in sick leave and absenteeism. Define "large"?
(b) most long covid doesn't lead to illness severe enough to require sick leave and absenteeism

I participated in a study of sick leave for one of my customers recently, and it was starkly noticeable that sick leave and absenteeism hasn't increased at all. If a significant percentage of people were suffering from long covid, we would have seen an increase, yet there is none.

Doesn't match with data I've seen (for example), got a source? Note however that many governments have actively changed requirements and definitions to qualify in the data in recent years.
 
Last edited:
I want to start exploring "long covid", so if anyone thinks it deserves its own thread, feel free to ask the mods to split it off, but as there isn'y much happening on the covid front I thought it may as well go here.

I said many months ago I was disturbed by the similarity between long covid and ME/CFS, a disease with only symptoms that no test can identify. As time has gone on, I'm sure the two diseases are in fact the same thing.

Some people, for unknown reasons, develop a range of symptoms after a viral infection. No treatments exist for either syndrome, and in the case of long covid, I believe the numbers have been wildly overstated.

Claims around the number of long covid cases aren't borne out by reality. We're surrounded by claims that somewhere between 3 and 20% of covid cases result in long covid, yet if that were the case, we'd be seeing vast increases in sick leave and absenteeism, along with corresponding pressure on health systems, because pretty well everyone has had covid.

I participated in a study of sick leave for one of my customers recently, and it was starkly noticeable that sick leave and absenteeism hasn't increased at all. If a significant percentage of people were suffering from long covid, we would have seen an increase, yet there is none.

I was compelled to talk to doctors to see if I was missing something, and while they all mentioned having patients with long covid, it didn't appear to be any more then they were already seeing with ME/CFS.


In a thread in Science, Mathematics, Medicine, and Technology, it is entirely irrelevant what The Atheist believes since he has already filled several threads with his obviously biased views in his attempts to minimize the pandemic. He doesn't actually "want to start exploring "long covid"", which is the reason why he writes Long Covid as "long covid." On the issue of Long Covid, it is thus no surprise that he would "believe the numbers have been wildly overstated."

That Atheist's claim that no test can identify ME/CFS is false:
A new blood test is highly accurate at diagnosing chronic fatigue syndrome, offering for the first time an objective way to identify the sometimes disabling condition that is estimated to affect up to 2.5 million people in the U.S.
A University of Oxford-led research team compared test results among 61 people with chronic fatigue syndrome, 21 people with multiple sclerosis, and 16 people who had no known health problems. They found that the new test is 91% accurate, according to findings published in the journal Advanced Science. The test can also differentiate between mild, moderate, and severe cases of the illness 84% of the time.
Scientists develop blood test for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (Sep 11, 2023)

The Atheist's post doesn't have one single reference to actual facts, and it is obvious that his only interest in the theme of Long Covid is to dismiss it as an actual physiological ailment, so there is really no reason whatsoever to do anything other with the post than ignore this new attempt to minimize the pandemic.

Let us instead look at some facts:

A survey from Statens Serum Institut showed that people who were infected with SARS-CoV-2 early on during the pandemic took substantially more sick leave over a long period of time compared to those who were not infected.
Increased sick leave over a long period after covid-19 infection (SSI.dk, April 19, 2023)


According to a recent Gusto survey of over 300,000 small and midsize businesses, 30 percent of all employees in the professional services industries who get paid time off (PTO) have taken sick leave so far this year, an increase of 42 percent from 2019.
The average amount of sick time these workers have taken has increased by 15 percent since 2019 and is now 15.5 hours per year. The largest increase is among workers ages 25-34: Nearly a third (32 percent) of them have taken sick leave in 2023, compared to 28 percent of workers ages 35-54.
Post-Pandemic, Employees Are Taking More Sick Days. How Are Employers Responding (SHRM, Nov 1, 2023)


This study aimed to investigate the patterns of sick leave, as well as factors associated with sick leave due to COVID-19 during one year after the COVID-19 diagnosis, and sex-related aspects on sick leave. This nationwide study involved 11,902 individuals who received sickness benefits for COVID-19 during the first wave of the pandemic. Data from three Swedish registries were analyzed for sick leave that commenced between March 1 and August 31, 2020, with a follow-up period of 12 months. Sick leave due to COVID-19 was counted as the number of days with sickness benefits and required to include at least one registered COVID-19 diagnosis. The median duration of sick leave was 35 days, and 347 (2.9%) individuals continued their sick leave during the entire follow-up period. Furthermore, 1 year later, the cumulative incidence of sick leave was slightly higher in males (3.5%) compared to females (2.7%). Older age, being single with no children, diagnosed with the virus, medium income level, history of sick leave, and need for inpatient care were significantly associated with a higher duration of sick leave due to COVID-19, both in the total population and when stratified by sex. These results indicated that three out of 100 (3%) patients were still on sick leave 1 year after their COVID-19 diagnosis. Aspects regarding the importance of sick leave duration differed between males and females and comprised sociodemographic characteristics and need for inpatient care. The results indicated the complexity of sick leave due to COVID-19.
(...)
It was possible that sick leaves were underestimated in this study. In this cohort, we previously showed that recurrent sick leave was present in 2.0% individuals within the first four months of sick leave (10). This may indicate that the number of people with longer sick leave due to COVID-19 may be higher than that in the present study.
Data from individuals who died during the first four months were not analyzed, which indicated that individuals with the most severe outcomes due to COVID-19 may not have been covered.
Sick leave one year after COVID-19 infection: a nationwide cohort study during the first wave in Sweden (Nature, Jan 5, 2024)


In January 2022, Brookings Metro published a report that assessed the impact of long Covid on the labor market. Data on the condition’s prevalence was limited, so the report used various studies to make a conservative estimate: 1.6 million full-time equivalent workers could be out of work due to long Covid. With 10.6 million unfilled jobs at the time, long Covid potentially accounted for 15% of the labor shortage.
This June, the Census Bureau finally added four questions about long Covid to its Household Pulse Survey (HPS), giving researchers a better understanding of the condition’s prevalence. This report uses the new data to assess the labor market impact and economic burden of long Covid, and finds that:
* Around 16 million working-age Americans (those aged 18 to 65) have long Covid today. * Of those, 2 to 4 million are out of work due to long Covid.
* The annual cost of those lost wages alone is around $170 billion a year (and potentially as high as $230 billion).
New data shows long Covid is keeping as many as 4 million people out of work (Brookings.edu, Aug 4, 2022)
 
Last edited:
(a) we are seeing increases in sick leave and absenteeism. Define "large"?

If 3-20% of people are suffering from it, I'd expect to see 3-20% increases.

Where are you seeing increases in sick leave? We did a study of a company with just over 1000 employees and there was zero increase, but if you have other data, show it.

(b) most long covid doesn't lead to illness severe enough to require sick leave and absenteeism

If that's true, why should anyone care about those cases, and why are they being counted? If they're not sick, then they not sick.

Let us instead look at some facts...

... from 2022.

Nah. Let's find something more recent and relevant, eh?
 
If 3-20% of people are suffering from it, I'd expect to see 3-20% increases.

Then I'm not sure you understand what Long Covid is.

Why would, say erectile dysfunction, or anosmia, or even a 10% drop in aerobic capacity lead to work or school absenteeism?

Where are you seeing increases in sick leave? We did a study of a company with just over 1000 employees and there was zero increase, but if you have other data, show it.

Some has already been posted.

If that's true, why should anyone care about those cases, and why are they being counted? If they're not sick, then they not sick.

You don't think erectile dysfunction or anosmia affect peoples lives?

Nah. Let's find something more recent and relevant, eh?

How is it not relevant? Data takes time. The virus is still here.

Here's a recent article in Harvard Business Manager, Germany - Long Covid and the Economy - There Is Money in Prevention
 
Hey hey! Looks like Robert Malone is at war with the rest of the anti-vaxx Covid cranks.

Gorski writes about how Robert Malone is now reaping the backlash for his claim to have invented the mRNA vaccine as the anti-vaxxers have finally rubbed their two brain cells together and worked out that it makes Malone a mass murderer.

You do love to see it.

Link
 
I know two people who suffered from Long Covid. One lost his sense of smell and taste, and it took half a year before it had returned fully. The loss of taste was particularly bad for his quality of life. The only taste that he could sense, was salty. But it did not affect his work, or his study, so he had no sick leave after the Covid.

The other person had a loss of breath, that prevented him cycling, or running for about three months after Covid, but as he worked as a lawyer, he did not take any sick leave for this.

None of this would appear sick leave statistics.
 
Then I'm not sure you understand what Long Covid is.

]Why would, say erectile dysfunction, or anosmia, or even a 10% drop in aerobic capacity lead to work or school absenteeism?


He doesn't want to understand what Long Covid is. He wants to have his bias confirmed, i.e. that most people with Long Covid aren't really sick.

Some has already been posted.


The Atheist ignores data that doesn't confirm what he wants data to confirm. Anecdotal data serves that purpose much better than actual data.

You don't think erectile dysfunction or anosmia affect peoples lives?


It no doubt does, and so do the well-documented microclots that cause the erectile dysfunction and other ailments, including the ones that require amputations. There is hard physiological evidence for those microclots, så The Atheist will continue to pretend they don't exist.

How is it not relevant? Data takes time. The virus is still here.


To The Atheist, unless it's his own family, only disease that affects the market economy is of concern. Disease that affects people's health but doesn't lead to sick leave, i.e. time off from making money for rich people, is the only one of concern.

Here's a recent article in Harvard Business Manager, Germany - Long Covid and the Economy - There Is Money in Prevention


Yes, but how does it affect stocks and bonds here and now?!
 
I know two people who suffered from Long Covid. One lost his sense of smell and taste, and it took half a year before it had returned fully. The loss of taste was particularly bad for his quality of life. The only taste that he could sense, was salty. But it did not affect his work, or his study, so he had no sick leave after the Covid.

The other person had a loss of breath, that prevented him cycling, or running for about three months after Covid, but as he worked as a lawyer, he did not take any sick leave for this.

None of this would appear sick leave statistics.


And there are all those people with other ailments that may be caused by C19 but also may have other causes. In December, one of my friends was rushed to hospital in an ambulance because of heart palpitations. She'll probably have to take blood thinners for the rest of her life. Another one is currently being tested for symptoms that may be Parkinson's.
We know C19 may cause both of those things.

Palpitations (YourCOVIDRecovery.nhs.uk)
An announcement made from the conference reports that researchers looked at the health records of people in Denmark. They found that those who had tested positive for COVID-19 were at an increased risk of being diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease, Parkinson's disease, and ischaemic stroke.
Increased Risk of Alzheimer's Disease Post COVID-19, Danish Researcher Suggests (Alzheimer's Research UK, June 24, 2022)


Long Covid wasn't mentioned by the doctors in those two cases. I was the one who pointed out the possible connection to them. Cases like these also won't be registered as Long Covid.

As for the sense of taste and smell. I remember that some people whose professions depend on that (chefs, for instance) chose to get the J&J vaccine back in 2021 instead of waiting for one of the mRNA vaccines.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom