Cont: The One Covid-19 Science and Medicine Thread Part 5

Ok, that's a start - ONS are reliable.

It doesn't show what I'm after but it does at least show some actual numbers. Next would be who they are and why they're not working, that's a significant percentage of Poms.



Thanks - that makes your position much more understandable.

I don't doubt some cases of long-lasting effects happen - they happen with other viruses as well and I personally know a guy of 50 who's so debilitated by post-covid infection problems that he's spent many months in hospital long after his covid infection finished. I doubt he'll live more than another few years and he was also fit and healthy previously.

The only part I doubt is the extent of it.

That sounds like a change, since before you were saying it was the same as FM, which you appeared to think doesn't actually exists.
 
The only part I doubt is the extent of it.

Two things I see people struggle with is -

(a) 20% of people who get Covid getting Long Covid does not mean 20% of people who have had Covid *still* have Long Covid - people recover, or at least think they do. One of the top researchers in the field says than when he actually enquires, virtually everyone still has something hanging around. Like me and the new food problems. I say I recovered, but in reality while I mostly have, I've also moved my baseline to accommodate new health issues.

(b) Only a subset of people who get Long Covid are significantly debilitated by it

Too many people think "20% of people get Long Covid" means that 20% of the population is supposedly home in bed unable to function, which quite obviously isn't the case, so they reject the whole premise.
 
Do not personalise your posts. Address the arguments.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Agatha
 
The WHO definition, and that used by the Household Pulse survey cited in that link, is 3 months, not 6 weeks.



Sure, like being off work for 3 months isn't a burden to individuals or society at all, so let's try 6 months. If that has too many sufferers, shall we try 1 year or 2 years instead?

The Household Pulse survey's most recent data (US, October 2023) has more than 1 in 20 adults currently suffering Long Covid 1.6% of all adults in the country having "significant activity limitations" due to Long Covid.

And that's just the people who acknowledge having had covid - only 57% of the population, when we know it's much higher. There are likely many people with long covid who do not know it. I meet them all the time.

[qimg]https://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_2482765a38cc3029be.png[/qimg]

Re people not knowing that they have it.

I once went to my Doctor in dismay. I thought I had FM completely beat but was suddenly too tired to do anything.

To my relief, he told me that there was some kind of mild virus circulating in the community, that had very little symptoms, but was causing 'post viral fatigue'. At the time he reported that roughly 1/3 to 1/2 of his patients were turning up with the same 'ailment'.

I bounced back to normal levels of alertness and energy in just over a week.

My bet is that people with long Covid will have symptoms that range between 'a bit tired all the time' to 'completely unable to do anything'.

And of course, we don't know yet what the maximum length of the symptoms will be.
 
That sounds like a change, since before you were saying it was the same as FM, which you appeared to think doesn't actually exists.

Where in my post do I give that impression?

I want to start exploring "long covid", so if anyone thinks it deserves its own thread, feel free to ask the mods to split it off, but as there isn'y much happening on the covid front I thought it may as well go here.

I said many months ago I was disturbed by the similarity between long covid and ME/CFS, a disease with only symptoms that no test can identify. As time has gone on, I'm sure the two diseases are in fact the same thing.

Some people, for unknown reasons, develop a range of symptoms after a viral infection. No treatments exist for either syndrome, and in the case of long covid, I believe the numbers have been wildly overstated.

Claims around the number of long covid cases aren't borne out by reality. We're surrounded by claims that somewhere between 3 and 20% of covid cases result in long covid, yet if that were the case, we'd be seeing vast increases in sick leave and absenteeism, along with corresponding pressure on health systems, because pretty well everyone has had covid.

I participated in a study of sick leave for one of my customers recently, and it was starkly noticeable that sick leave and absenteeism hasn't increased at all. If a significant percentage of people were suffering from long covid, we would have seen an increase, yet there is none.

I was compelled to talk to doctors to see if I was missing something, and while they all mentioned having patients with long covid, it didn't appear to be any more then they were already seeing with ME/CFS.
 
Where in my post do I give that impression?

In this post:
Dear old Warren Tate. I referenced him in my ME/CFS thread a few years back. Warren has been the leading voice in ME research, which is appropriate since it was known as Tapanui 'Flu for a while, and that's just down the road from him.

The whole thing smacks of a medical "god of the gaps" attempt to find an answer in the only place we can't discount.

The conclusion gives the game away:



It looks more and more to me like both ME/CFS and long covid should be returned to the DSM until an actual physical mechanism is found.
 
Two things I see people struggle with is -

(a) 20% of people who get Covid getting Long Covid does not mean 20% of people who have had Covid *still* have Long Covid - people recover, or at least think they do. One of the top researchers in the field says than when he actually enquires, virtually everyone still has something hanging around. Like me and the new food problems. I say I recovered, but in reality while I mostly have, I've also moved my baseline to accommodate new health issues.

That's probably fair, but I still don't see any evidence that the incidence of long covid is anywhere near 20%. Some of that may be the criteria used, some of it may be malingering. I'd buy 5% but 20% doesn't appear to well supported by facts.

Just on personal anecdote, I know a hell of a lot of people who have had covid, including multiple bouts, and I know exactly one with anything you could class as long covid, and the people I know are a wide cross-section, from antivax loons to doctors. Add to that the workforce of 1000 I'm involved with and I want to see some very hard evidence of 20% being true.

(b) Only a subset of people who get Long Covid are significantly debilitated by it.

That's probably the real problem right there - we need to stop counting people who have a sore knee* for three months after. We live in a world where even fat ***** can claim to be disabled and we should maybe all just harden the **** up. People with genuine disabilities are disadvantaged by fat pricks using their car parks and health dollars and you can't diet out of spina bifida.

If someone has anosmia, I don't see it as any kind of long covid, it's just a change they can with, just as people live minus a kidney or tonsils.

I would have thought it was to the benefit of people with genuine long term harm not to let their needs be overshadowed by a huge number of snowflakes who can't smell the roses.


*I know that's not a symptom, but I'm sure you get my point.
 
If someone has anosmia, I don't see it as any kind of long covid, it's just a change they can with, just as people live minus a kidney or tonsils.

Long covid is literally ongoing symptoms from a covid infection. Whether you can "live with it" or not has nothing to do with it.
 
Full Committee Hearing, Thursday, Jan 18, 2024.
Hearing Title: Addressing Long COVID: Advancing Research and Improving Patient Care
Panel 2
1. Michelle Harkins, M.D., Professor of Medicine, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, NM
2. Ziyad Al-Aly, M.D., Clinical Epidemiologist, Washington University in St. Louis, St. Louis, MO
3. Charisse Madlock-Brown, Ph.D., Associate Professor of Health Informatics, University of Iowa, Iowa City, IA
4. Tiffany Walker, M.D., Assistant Professor, Emory University School of Medicine, Atlanta, GA
Addressing Long COVID: Advancing Research and Improving Patient Care (U.S. Committee on Health, Education, Labor & Pensions)
Medical experts. As far as I can see, not a single psychologist among the experts invited to speak!

SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, can damage the lungs, heart, brain, kidneys, and blood vessels. Inflammation was first thought to be the main source of this damage. As it became clear that parts of the virus bind to proteins in the mitochondria — the parts of the cell that produce most cellular energy — researchers realized that compromised mitochondria may also play a role in organ damage from SARS-CoV-2 infection.
In a study supported by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), researchers found that SARS-CoV-2 can cause lasting damage to the energy production of mitochondria in many organs of the body.
The Long-Term Effects of SARS-CoV-2 on Organs and Energy (National Institutes of Health, Oct 18, 2023)


Almost 2 years ago in Italy, pediatric infectious disease doctor Danilo Buonsenso, who works at Gemelli University Hospital, started to see children who, months after mild infections with SARS-CoV-2, were still short of breath and had crushing fatigue and other symptoms. He now suspects that, in some of them, the cells and tissues that control blood flow are damaged and the blood’s tendency to clot is amplified. Minute blood clots, leftover from the viral assault or fueled by its aftermath, might be gumming up the body’s circulation, to disastrous effect from the brain to joints. “In some patients we have specific areas where no blood flow comes in” or the flow is reduced, Buonsenso says. Is that driving their lingering symptoms? “I can’t say this is the truth, of course. But this makes sense.”
Meanwhile, in the United States, microbiologist Amy Proal can’t stop thinking about a second leading Long Covid theory: that the coronavirus keeps hurting people by stubbornly enduring in the body, even after acute infection passes. Studies have shown “the virus is capable of persistence in a wide range of body sites,” especially nerves and other tissues, says Proal, who works at the PolyBio Research Foundation, a nonprofit in Washington state. She recently caught COVID-19 for the third time.
Down under in Australia, immunologist Chansavath Phetsouphanh of the University of New South Wales, Sydney, is chasing a third lead, motivated by what the blood of Long Covid patients has divulged: an immune system gone haywire even 8 months after they’d first tested positive. He had assumed that immune cells galvanized to fight off infection would have calmed down over that time span. So, “It was a surprise that these cells did not recover,” says Phetsouphanh, who is working to set up an international Long Covid collaboration.
What causes Long Covid? Here are the three leading theories (Science)


The short version for people who can't be bothered to read:
Between 10% and 30% of people are estimated to have experienced some form of long COVID after recovering from a COVID-19 infection, and scientists still don’t yet know what causes it. Dr. Purvi Parikh, an immunologist and long COVID specialist at NYU Langone in New York, joins "CUOMO" to discuss the three prevailing theories about a cause.
Long COVID cause: Doctor explains three prevailing theories | CUOMO (NewsNation on YouTube, Jan 9, 2024 - 5:23 min.)

Spoiler: Not quite the same three theories. And yet, psychogenesis is not any one of them.

In a small study supported by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), researchers found that chronic viral infections may influence the likelihood of someone developing Long COVID. They also found that different chronic infections were associated with the development of different Long COVID symptoms.
The Relationship Between Chronic Viral Infection and Long COVID (National Institutes of Health, Nov 22, 2022)
 
... And yet, psychogenesis is not any one of them.
Having a difficult to diagnose disease myself, I can tell you when all the tests the doctors know to order turn up nothing, they always blame someting like it's all in your head. In my case years of complaining I was short of breath they kept saying it must be I'm not exercising enough. :mad:

You can't exercise much if you get short of breath just walking.

Then the autoimmune disease I had flared up and attacked my lungs in a bigger way. No more denying it was in my head when my lung scan was almost a total white out.

Now they think it's a rare disease called shrinking lung syndrome. Rare as in there are maybe 100 cases in the whole country.

Claiming people with chronic energy draining conditions are just imagining it becomes really frustrating for the person who knows it isn't psychogenic.
 
Last edited:
I have a somewhat similar horror story from back in the '80s. The disease wasn't as rare as yours, and I was not the victim.

My girlfriend had a student job in the summer holidays, working at a computer for a postal order company. Towards the end of the summer holidays, she got back pain, which was blamed on sitting at a desk all day for two months. She was treated with steroid blockers, but the pain returned when the blockers stopped working, so she got blockers repeatedly.
However, the pain returned, got worse, along with new symptoms: She could no longer sleep lying down, only in a sitting position. By December, she was told to see a psychiatrist.

At that point, I noticed the veins in her neck were standing out in a way I had never seen before - something she hadn't noticed herself - and I told her to see her doctor again the next day, which she did. She was taken directly from the doctor's office to a hospital to be x-rayed and then immediately after the x rays were processed to a cancer hospital. She had lymphoma, probably Hodgkin's, described as a grapefruit-sized lump between the stomach and her lungs. She had chemo therapy beginning that same afternoon.

She was cured by the chemo in combination with radiation therapy, but didn't trust MDs after that experience.

It makes me empathize with the 'Havana syndrome' and/or EHS sufferers when they tell their stories about not being listened to by doctors. After having read Baloh and Bartholomew's book about the 'syndrome, I recently read Baloh's book, Medically Unexplained Symptoms: A Brain-Centered Approach (GoodReads), in which he blames doctors for (some) of the problems with patients' neurological complaints. MDs don't take (have?) the time to listen to patients' stories or to explain their conditions to them properly, which confirms the (sometimes delusional) idea that they have diseases they don't have. It makes others go to the alt.med. practitioners.

But on the other hand, the abundance of delusional patients probably also makes MDs prone to dismiss patients with rare diseases like yours as delusional when they aren't.
 
A youtuber, aka Physics Girl, I had watched a few times in the past got Covid right after getting married in 2022. Mild case but towards the end of 2022 she got severe ME/CFS. And since has been bedridden with inability to focus or do much of anything. Quite the contrast to her earlier state.

Here's a recent description from a visit by a good friend:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xbcjf-hrOAs

Here's a video she did on a submarine under the Artic posted just before she got ME/CFS. Appears to have been from earlier in 2022.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JRQSbK4Krg0

Anecdote, of course, and possibly not related to getting C19 but damn, what a tough thing to go through.
 
Last edited:
One does need to be careful thinking every ill person is right about the cause. Symptoms are real (almost all the time) but conclusions may not be. For example, when I was working as the employee health nurse at a hospital >30 yrs ago we had a number of employees in the ED who were having symptoms and all thought they had the same work related chemical exposure. When I took a symptom profile of each one they all complained of a rash and this was one of the things that made them think they all had the same thing. Not a single one had the same rash as any other one. One person even pointed to normal skin and said there was a rash there.

Peter Sandman is a recognized expert in this field. I went to a lecture of his when this area was going bonkers over supposed sick-building syndrome. But that's for another thread.

So believe the patient, yes definitely. But you have to approach carefully when they are convinced of the cause. By the same token, just because a doctor can't find any tests that fit a diagnosis is no reason to turn to meaningless diagnoses like not exercising enough or it's psychogenic. There are a gazillion diagnoses no commercial tests have been developed to find.

Some of this stuff scares me to death. I've watched Physics Girl's videos. It's a shock to see her bedridden like that. The fact these are autoimmune disorders is what makes it especially scary. I have no idea what my immune system is going to attack next.

At least I'm 70, own a house and won't end up living out of my car or anything. It would be so awful to have something like this happen before I'd had a chance to do all the things I'd already done in my life.

Seems like a promising avenue looking at similar proteins on the surfaces of pathogens that are close in structure to proteins on the surfaces of organs and organelles. Maybe long COVID research will benefit people with a number of autoimmune diseases.
 
Last edited:
Seems like a promising avenue looking at similar proteins on the surfaces of pathogens that are close in structure to proteins on the surfaces of organs and organelles. Maybe long COVID research will benefit people with a number of autoimmune diseases.

So true. And I've been thinking the same thing. Autoimmune diseases are getting a lot more looking at as a result of Covid-19. And such is how science advances.
 
Similar story:

Back in the eighties, when I was in Sydney, I knew a young woman.

She was a medical student, towards the end of her training and a kung-fu instructor.

I've never met someone who was more full of life, until the last time I saw her, a shadow of her former self, bedridden, so weak she couldn't even raise her hand from the bed.

At the time, she was diagnosed with CFS, and I have no idea how the story ends.

The contrast was incredible, young, fit, vibrant, intelligent, to a husk.

Terrifying.
 
Oh, Physics Girl, I've seen her vids. May have come across it/them right here, in this forum, maybe. Either way, she's cool. And what a shame.

icerat's thing as well. Horrific. I've seen lives and families devastated by this infernal virus; and I've seen instances of Long Covid, including a cousin who, although young and formerly remarkably, exceptionally healthy, has now become hugely obese, and gone bald, and loads of et ceteras as well, all due to Long Covid, and symptoms still persist. But still, this (icerat's) is by far the worst instance of Long Covid I've seen, both he and his son, and a life completely torn apart like that. My sympathies, for what that's worth, and glad things are looking up now.

We clearly don't understand the half of this yet. This strengthens my resolve, this discussion on Long Covid, to continue to mask and distance etc as much as possible. Even if a year or three later it turns out that was unnecessary, that one was being overly cautious, paranoid even. I mean, whats the downside? Better safe than sorry (within reason, to the extent one's circumstances allow).
 
Senate Health Committee holds hearing on long COVID

Bernie Sanders about Long Covid:
"Each reinfection increases the risk of developing Long COVID. If you are under the impression that once you've gotten COVID you never need to worry about it again, you are mistaken." - @BernieSanders
And here's what far too many do not know:
Long Covid - and we will hear more about this this morning - can affect anybody who has had COVID-19, from those who experienced mild symptoms to those who were severely ill.
Further, although you may not have Long Covid after your first infection, each reinfection can increase the risk of developing it.
In other words, if you are under the impression that once you got COVID you don't need to worry about it ever again, you are mistaken.
Sawyer (X, Jan 18, 2024)
With short video clip, 28 sec.

The US Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) committee announced yesterday that it will hold a full committee hearing at 9:00 am (EST) tomorrow on addressing long COVID, focusing on advancing research and improving patient care. In a statement, Sen. Bernie Sanders, (I.-Vt.) said that the impact of the pandemic is still felt by millions of families. "Lives are at stake. I look forward to hearing from patients, experts, and researchers about what we must do to address this crisis, including the advanced research and patient care that so many Americans desperately need," he said. The committee will hear testimony from two panels, one a group of long-COVID patients and the other comprising medical doctors and researchers.
Quick takes: Ninth measles case in Philly, upcoming Senate hearing on long COVID, Brazil details dengue vaccine plan (CIDRAP, Jan 17, 2024)


WATCH LIVE: Senate Health Committee holds hearing on long COVID patients, research
(PBS NewsHour on YouTube, Jan 18, 2024 - 2:46:25)
 
From the Senate Hearing on Long Covid:
Senators push for more investment in long COVID research (TheHill, Jan 19, 2024)
Patients struck by long COVID plead with U.S. Senate panel for more research funding (MissouryIndependent, Jan 19, 2024)
Long COVID specialist tells US Senate that “the best way to prevent Long COVID is to prevent COVID in the first place!” (WSWS.org, Jan 19, 2024)
Long Covid patients, advocates push for more NIH oversight (PoliticoPro, Jan 18, 2024)

Blood test for Long Covid?
Stat: Test For Long Covid? Researchers Find New Clue In Blood Samples
Long Covid has long eluded scientists looking for its cause. Not knowing what triggers its persistent and distressing symptoms makes the condition challenging to treat; it’s hard to even say definitively who has it. New research published Thursday in Science has identified proteins present in the blood of people with long Covid that could point the way to a much-needed diagnostic test and possibly to future therapeutic targets. (Cooney, 1/18)

The Mercury News: Long Covid Creates Changes In The Blood, Aiding Detection: New Study
An international team of scientists has found distinct changes in the blood of people with long COVID, suggesting a potential strategy to diagnose and perhaps treat a mysterious condition that takes many forms. The study, published on Thursday in the journal Science, adds to our understanding of long COVID, the lingering and often debilitating symptoms experienced by some people. One significant finding revealed shifts in proteins the body produces in response to inflammation that may persist months after infection. Another detected blood clots and tissue injury. (Krieger, 1/18)
Researchers Find Protein Clues In Blood Samples Of Long Covid Sufferers (KFF Health News, Jan 19, 2024)
Test for Long Covid? Researchers find new clue in blood samples (StatNews, Jan 18, 2024)
Long COVID creates changes in the blood, aiding detection, reports new study (MercuryNews, Jan 18, 2024)
 
Last edited:
The mother of an 11-year-old Aberdeenshire girl with long Covid has launched a legal action against their health board, in what lawyers claim is the first case of its kind in Scotland.
(...)
The action claims the health board is responsible for "multiple failings" in Anna's treatment and care.
NHS Grampian said it would not comment on individual patient cases.
The claim alleges failings were avoidable, that they caused Anna "injury and damage", and led to her condition worsening.
(...)
She has not been able to return to school, needs the use of a wheelchair, and is often confined to her bed.
The action alleges a number of failings by the health board.
These include claims that requests for Anna to be referred to the specialist paediatric services of immunology and neurology were refused.
It also claims no further help was offered after Anna was diagnosed with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS) and Paediatric Acute-onset Neuropsychiatric Syndrome (PANS).
Long Covid: NHS legal action launched by family of girl (BBC News, Jan 19, 2024)


It doesn't seem to be about not protecting her from the infection in the first place. She was infected in 2020.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom